Scouts consider oath for atheists

  • Thread starter Thread starter Digitonomy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am proud to say that the Boy Scouts of America has staunchly defended “Duty to God”. Of course, it helps that the majority of troops are sponsored by churches of various sorts.

I don’t know if scouting in England is similarly organized by by local community groups as done in the United States.
Won’t happen. They aren’t going to destroy 100 years of tradition for a few discontent loudmouths. If they don’t want to have a duty to God, they can look at another club to join.
 
Speaking as a Scouter myself, I would not be in favor of altering it from the historical one.

It starts the BSA down the path that the Girl Scouts went, making their Oath more of a statement of the times.

And as far as the current one, there are already Jewish and Muslim troops. They use the current Oath. The word ‘God’ has the same meaning ( the single Holy Divine Being) as it does for us.,
 
That is not true in the UK, the oath has been changed to allow Hindus, Moslems and Buddhists to join.

rossum
Yes, I am aware of that.

A Muslim, Hindu or Buddhist boy is allowed to join, there is no bar to their membership. They just use the same Oath that we do.

If a family chooses not to participate, they are welcome to form up their own organization that carries their own values.

An example are the SpiralScouts, a Wiccan based organization.

archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2002/10/31/70432.shtml
 
This is actually something that seems reasonable. I could understand Atheists or their parents feelings uncomfortable taking an oath to God. Theres little reason to oppose this.
Since a Scout is supposed to be Reverent, why would an Atheist parent enroll their child in a monotheist organization. Or expect the monotheist, private org to change to accommodate them
That is not true in the UK, the oath has been changed to allow Hindus, Moslems and Buddhists to join.

rossum
IIRC, current rules say any religion may join. In other words, you have to believe in a higher power (as some troops need to learn)
 
There really isn’t a reason necessary. The Oath has been unchanged for 100 years. The burden for giving reasons for any change to the Oath should fall on those who wish to change it.
That is not true in the UK, the oath has been changed to allow Hindus, Moslems and Buddhists to join.

rossum
The UK organization is a totally separate corporation from the Boy Scouts of America. The BSA has used always used the same oath, changing only “duty to my Queen” to “duty to my country”. The BSA does not need to justify not changing the oath.

However, changing the oath would weaken the values it wishes to teach. Boy Scouts have a duty to God, first and foremost, however God is understood. Scouts that have professed Atheism have had been denied the Eagle Scout Award in some cases, because of the importance of the duty to God.

As an aside, I’d also like to point out that the main program, Boy Scouting, is still only open to young men ages 11-18, unlike many other scouting programs worldwide, however there are coed program available to older young adults ages 14-21. The BSA is a very traditional organization throughout.
 
The UK organization is a totally separate corporation from the Boy Scouts of America. The BSA has used always used the same oath, changing only “duty to my Queen” to “duty to my country”. The BSA does not need to justify not changing the oath.
Do you read what you post? You tell us that the BSA changed the oath and then say that they don’t need to justify not changing it.

They obviously thought there was good reason to change it from King/Queen to country. There is no reason in principle why they could not think there was a good reason to change it in future.

Maybe not in this particular case, but you are making a very weak argument here.

rossum
 
Do you read what you post? You tell us that the BSA changed the oath and then say that they don’t need to justify not changing it.

They obviously thought there was good reason to change it from King/Queen to country. There is no reason in principle why they could not think there was a good reason to change it in future.

Maybe not in this particular case, but you are making a very weak argument here.

rossum
Do you read what you post? You address the least important point of my argument, and only manage to point out a superficial flaw.

“Duty to Queen” was never in the BSA oath. The BSA adapted Lord Baden Powell’s oath for the United States circa 1910. However, “Duty to God” is a core value, and will not be removed or diluted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top