"All bodily mortifications and other exercises are useless, save that they serve to arrive at the union with God by love. He had well considered this, and found it the shortest way to go straight to Him by a continual exercise of love, and doing all things for His sake."
Brother Lawrence
(1611-1691)
Why is there such an overwhelming aversion to bodily mortification throughout this thread?? Have we really become so placated?
Whilst I would advise against ‘pain’ in the strict sense, I would be very quick to suggest and defend that you look for some form of bodily mortification.
In this day and age people have become so uncomfortable with the idea of any bodily mortification or ‘pain’ for penance sake and have absolutely no problem with bodily modification which puts the human body through a hell of a lot more in the name of vanity.
(I am not including here necessary reconstruction surgery but surgery done for the sake of vanity)
I would suggest that you speak to your confessor about this and explain fully the desire you have to look into some form of bodily mortification.
It can be as little as kneeling without support or sitting without using the back rest for a short amount of time. It does not have to include gouging ones eyes out or sticking hot pins in ourselves!!!
Do some research yourself and you may find something that suits.
PS There is nothing wrong with a good cold shower either