Sen. Jay Rockefeller: Study video-game violence

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
In the wake of the Newtown shootings, Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Jay Rockefeller introduced a bill Tuesday night that would have the National Academy of Sciences examine any link between violent games and media and violent acts by children, industry sources say.

According to a copy of the “discussion draft” obtained by POLITICO, the legislation directs the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Communications Commission to make “appropriate arrangements” with the NAS to enable the study.

Read more: politico.com/story/2012/12/sen-jay-rockefeller-wants-shooter-games-and-violence-studied-85298.html#ixzz2FWZZ7LPp
 
there are a TON of violent video games out there…and why? I’ve never understood why someone would want to play a video game where you KILL SOMEONE! And movies are becoming more and more violent as well…and I am not talking about the one based on the true historical fact of the Religious war in Mexico…I am talking about violent movies like Natural Born Killers (which is mentioned with Columbine shooting).

However, there are other problems in society - broken homes, mental illness that goes undiagnosed, etc

The shooter in Oregon had just quit his job, supposedly. The shooter in Conn - his mother reportedly was going to institutionalize him. There was a young man in Omaha, Nebraska who shot a few people at his high school…he had been suspended for trespassing with his car during the winter holidays break - he had just transferred from a school in LINCOLN to the one in Omaha. a few months before. He took his father’s police gun that was in a closet, while his father was out doing an errand. The shooter of Von Maur (can’t believe that it has been 5 years already) had some issues as well (and came from a broken home).

I’d love to see an end to extremely violent video games. Its one thing to play a game where you are a war hero, its another to play a first person shooter where you just kill people for the fun of it.
 
I’m sorry, but this concept is absolute nonsense. I, and many of my friends, have spent many an hour playing violent video games; from FPS’s like Call of Duty and Unreal tournament, to game like GTA and Saint’s Row. None of us has felt the need to go out and shoot up a school or run people down.

The problem widespread is the destruction of the family unit throughout our civilization. I’d lay heavy odds that if we fixed that problem, most of the other problems in society would start to vanish, including mass killings.

I will say though, that when parents let their young children play these games, it definitely has an affect on them, my wife has seen it first hand in he sister’s step-son… er… ex-step son… He changed drastically over the course of a year or so because of the influence of the father and violent games. This, incidentally, is why those games are rated mature,and the problem then returns to the families, and the parents for allowing their young children to play them.
 
Yeah, I don’t know if this means anything. This is another band aid.
 
There’s certainly a correlation (if you love violence enough to kill people you probably play violent video games and/or watch violent movies) but causation is more difficult to establish. Rather, the playing of violent video games should be evaluated as a possible symptom of certain illnesses, at least among adults. We won’t end violence by shredding every copy of Call of Duty.

At the same time, I don’t think we can say that violent video games don’t negatively impact young players’ attitudes towards violence, problem resolution, and personal interaction. I don’t mean the kid who gets to play Halo for an hour on Saturday because he finished all his homework and chores that week. It’s hard to say that there’s not such an impact when that play is for such extended periods (6, 8 hours a day, 30 hours a week, etc) that it supplants normal social interaction. I suspect if we evaluated it, we’d find a difference in behavior between kids whose video game time is limited - especially of violent video games - and those whose video game time is extensive. Even if that behavior is a matter of diminished social interaction it can still be destructive, making it difficult to feel accepted and entrenching antisocial behaviors.

We may find less of a difference between extended players of non-violent games (thinking of my wife’s friend who plays Sims Online nonstop) and extended players of violent games than we do between extended players of any games with casual, limited players of any games. That would be an interesting, and probably fruitful, research question.

I think it’s also telling that kids who are innately socially awkward, even to the point of having anxiety around peers, are more likely drawn to video games as an escape, and therefore entrenched in less healthy behaviors than their shy peers of 70 or 80 years ago who instead likely delved into books. I was a very shy kid around other kids (for some reason, I never had problems around adults), and I had little involvement with anyone else in school. I played Nintendo (dating myself here) often, to the point that my mother stepped in and got me reading, which I took to very strongly, and I still devour books. I have to wonder how I would’ve ended up if she hadn’t done so - after recent events, I remembered again being in 6th grade, and before leaving for the day (I always hid in the library while everyone else went home, then left so I wouldn’t run into anyone) I would walk around and, like in the NES Metal Gear game pretended to plant bombs on the walls, then exited and ran home before the building blew up, in my imagination. If someone saw me doing that today, instead of 20 years ago, I’d be in counseling at the very least. Back then, I was just this wierd antisocial kid who liked anything with “Star” in the title, got into fights all the time, and ate lunch by myself (which I still do, sadly, I’m very uncomfortable in a small group but I’ve learned to do fine one-on-one).

A related thought: we can’t say that social media doesn’t negatively impact the communication capabilities of young people. At my workplace, some of the newest hires are among the first who used social media during formative high school years, and it really shows. They’re less involved in meetings, less able to follow, more often checking email (not that all of us who have blackberries don’t do that - one reason I’ve always told my work I do not want a company phone), and their IM and email abilities need a remedial class in the English language. We expect to have to train these kids up in research methods, project management, etc, but now we’re seeing we have to toss in business communication skills.

Bottom line: our kids are less connected to other kids now than they were. The paradox of mediated communications is that you’re not as close to the person you send 50 text messages to daily as you are to the person who you sit with for 10 minutes at lunch.
 
if what one views doesn’t affect one,i guess pornography is ok 🤷
 
I agree with the consensus here that rational, well-adjusted adults playing video games is an acceptable form of leisure (though we should probably watch, out of a sense of charity, how much leisure time is spent - I beat the PC sim Freelancer after 60 hours and thought “oh my … I’ve wasted a week and a half of work-time on this stupid game”), but with kids or persons who aren’t mature enough to delineate healthy alone time from unhealthy alone time, or violence from reality:
The problem widespread is the destruction of the family unit throughout our civilization. I’d lay heavy odds that if we fixed that problem, most of the other problems in society would start to vanish, including mass killings.
I would think so, as well. If you take a kid who has problems coping with other people, with stress, etc, because of a weak home or even because of a medical or psychological condition within a strong and healthy home, which is worse for him (and it’s most often him): That the majority of waking time is spent in isolation, or that the majority of waking time is spent immersed in violence? I know a cousin who dropped out of college because of constant gaming (he paints cars at his uncle’s dealership now, brilliant), and I myself blew much of a semester because of Populous (again, dating myself).

Maybe we’ve gotten too leisurely, in addition to too violent, too disconnected, too unhealthy, too self-centered…
 
and I myself blew much of a semester because of Populous (again, dating myself).
.
Fun game. Peter Molyneux is working on a “Spiritual successor” to it now, I can’t wait. ^^
 
It always has to be someone or something elses fault, never the person who actually committed the crime. Now they are blaming video games. Normal mentally healthy people are not turned into mass murderers because they play video games or watch Tarantino movies ( I personally don’t like his movies but whatever).
 
Normal person + violent video games = normal

Crazy person + violent video games = crazy
 
Normal person + violent video games = normal

Crazy person + violent video games = crazy
Normal person + violent video games = normal

Crazy person + violent video games = crazy and acts on his craziness (at times)
 
I’m sorry, but this concept is absolute nonsense. I, and many of my friends, have spent many an hour playing violent video games; from FPS’s like Call of Duty and Unreal tournament, to game like GTA and Saint’s Row. None of us has felt the need to go out and shoot up a school or run people down.
Dear M.A.D.D.,
I’m sorry, but this concept is absolute nonsense. I, and many of my friends, have spent many an hour drinking beer, from early evening to last call, driving from one bar to the next with a designated driver. None of us has felt the need to go out, get in our own cars and run people down.

How many tragedies must one have before there are tougher laws?

(I’m playing devil’s advocate here. I’m not in favor of yet another government sponsored study.)
 
Dear M.A.D.D.,
I’m sorry, but this concept is absolute nonsense. I, and many of my friends, have spent many an hour drinking beer, from early evening to last call, driving from one bar to the next with a designated driver. None of us has felt the need to go out, get in our own cars and run people down.

How many tragedies must one have before there are tougher laws?

(I’m playing devil’s advocate here. I’m not in favor of yet another government sponsored study.)
There is a distinct difference here. Alcohol impedes the senses, and impairs judgment. It has a demonstrable affect on the brain. Video games, do not. It is true that they can affect the psychology of young, impressionable children, no one is questioning that. What we are questioning is what is the root cause of violent behavior. Video games are not to blame, it is the fault of the parents who do not keep a watchful eye on what their children are playing, and who do not go to the lengths necessary to ensure that their children are raised properly. In all of these cases (at least the ones I’m aware of), the person performing the killing was mentally unstable. Their instability is primarily to blame, not whatever video games they may play.
 
There is a distinct difference here. Alcohol impedes the senses, and impairs judgment. It has a demonstrable affect on the brain. Video games, do not. It is true that they can affect the psychology of young, impressionable children, no one is questioning that. What we are questioning is what is the root cause of violent behavior. Video games are not to blame, it is the fault of the parents who do not keep a watchful eye on what their children are playing, and who do not go to the lengths necessary to ensure that their children are raised properly. In all of these cases (at least the ones I’m aware of), the person performing the killing was mentally unstable. Their instability is primarily to blame, not whatever video games they may play.
I agree with all you say here. And what you say shows to some degree the aptness of the analogy. In the M.A.D.D. analysis, one of the outcomes was a greater awareness that the hosts providing the entertainment (in this case, liquor) share responsibility for the behavior of their guests. In the same vein, parents share responsibility for the action of their children if they see that video games are affecting them adversely. No matter what the subject is where there is a weakness in an individual, but people around them make no concessions for that weakness … well, don’t be surprised at the results. Bad behavior is often a product of making the near occasions of sin something that is simply very hard to avoid.
 
I have to disagree with who ever said that video games do not change decision making. That is a popular myth.

Indiana University did a brain scan study in regards to video game violence. Large amounts of video games DO change the way the brain processes information. Here is the article with brain scans:

killology.com/new_media_vio.htm

Viewing violence = behaving more violently.

So to redo a previously stated error, to fit scientific evidence:

Normal person + small amount of violent video games = normal person

Normal person + Large amount of violent video games = more violent person
 
I have to disagree with who ever said that video games do not change decision making. That is a popular myth.

Indiana University did a brain scan study in regards to video game violence. Large amounts of video games DO change the way the brain processes information. Here is the article with brain scans:

killology.com/new_media_vio.htm

Viewing violence = behaving more violently.

So to redo a previously stated error, to fit scientific evidence:

Normal person + small amount of violent video games = normal person

Normal person + Large amount of violent video games = more violent person
If you note, that study is specifically talking about children, which we have all agreed can be influenced by excessive violence. What we are contesting, however, is that this is not the fault of the video games, but rather the parents who chose not to keep track of their children’s habits / deny them access to the violent games. While it is true that the violence seen is what actually affects the child, it is the parent’s negligence that makes it available to them.

I’m not saying violent video games are a good thing, no matter how much I personally have enjoyed them in my life I recognize that they aren’t really good; I just don’t believe them to be “evil” like the people conducting these studies would suggest. Apathy is the evil here.
 
Rasmussen poll

Does the United States need to place limits on violent movies and video games?

Yes 49%

No 37%

Not sure 13%

Note: Most adults under 40 oppose limits on violent video games and movies. Most older adults are in favor of such limits
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top