There’s certainly a correlation (if you love violence enough to kill people you probably play violent video games and/or watch violent movies) but causation is more difficult to establish. Rather, the playing of violent video games should be evaluated as a possible symptom of certain illnesses, at least among adults. We won’t end violence by shredding every copy of Call of Duty.
At the same time, I don’t think we can say that violent video games don’t negatively impact young players’ attitudes towards violence, problem resolution, and personal interaction. I don’t mean the kid who gets to play Halo for an hour on Saturday because he finished all his homework and chores that week. It’s hard to say that there’s not such an impact when that play is for such extended periods (6, 8 hours a day, 30 hours a week, etc) that it supplants normal social interaction. I suspect if we evaluated it, we’d find a difference in behavior between kids whose video game time is limited - especially of violent video games - and those whose video game time is extensive. Even if that behavior is a matter of diminished social interaction it can still be destructive, making it difficult to feel accepted and entrenching antisocial behaviors.
We may find less of a difference between extended players of non-violent games (thinking of my wife’s friend who plays Sims Online nonstop) and extended players of violent games than we do between extended players of any games with casual, limited players of any games. That would be an interesting, and probably fruitful, research question.
I think it’s also telling that kids who are innately socially awkward, even to the point of having anxiety around peers, are more likely drawn to video games as an escape, and therefore entrenched in less healthy behaviors than their shy peers of 70 or 80 years ago who instead likely delved into books. I was a very shy kid around other kids (for some reason, I never had problems around adults), and I had little involvement with anyone else in school. I played Nintendo (dating myself here) often, to the point that my mother stepped in and got me reading, which I took to very strongly, and I still devour books. I have to wonder how I would’ve ended up if she hadn’t done so - after recent events, I remembered again being in 6th grade, and before leaving for the day (I always hid in the library while everyone else went home, then left so I wouldn’t run into anyone) I would walk around and, like in the NES Metal Gear game pretended to plant bombs on the walls, then exited and ran home before the building blew up, in my imagination. If someone saw me doing that today, instead of 20 years ago, I’d be in counseling at the very least. Back then, I was just this wierd antisocial kid who liked anything with “Star” in the title, got into fights all the time, and ate lunch by myself (which I still do, sadly, I’m very uncomfortable in a small group but I’ve learned to do fine one-on-one).
A related thought: we can’t say that social media doesn’t negatively impact the communication capabilities of young people. At my workplace, some of the newest hires are among the first who used social media during formative high school years, and it really shows. They’re less involved in meetings, less able to follow, more often checking email (not that all of us who have blackberries don’t do that - one reason I’ve always told my work I do not want a company phone), and their IM and email abilities need a remedial class in the English language. We expect to have to train these kids up in research methods, project management, etc, but now we’re seeing we have to toss in business communication skills.
Bottom line: our kids are less connected to other kids now than they were. The paradox of mediated communications is that you’re not as close to the person you send 50 text messages to daily as you are to the person who you sit with for 10 minutes at lunch.