Sen. Jay Rockefeller: Study video-game violence

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not saying violent video games are a good thing, no matter how much I personally have enjoyed them in my life I recognize that they aren’t really good; I just don’t believe them to be “evil” like the people conducting these studies would suggest. Apathy is the evil here.
In these video games, there is a definite “we the good guys, they the bad guys” premise in the role playing part. If someone has a beef with real life people perceived as “bad guys”, then the player may project his frustration and fantasize about taking it out on real people. This is not necessarily a conscious act, but a subconscious satisfaction in getting revenge for a general feeling of frustration. With the decline of the traditional family, one has to recognize that many kids are granted whatever they desire, almost as a consolation prize to make up for the broken family situation. Parental apathy is not so much the case, as intentionally spoiling the kid with any video game desired.

Fantasizing revenge for a general sense of frustration in society is quite normal. Else, why would violent movies - the “Dirty Harry”, “Death Wish”, or Batman types - have such box office appeal.

Why can’t they come out with a first person shooter snowball fight where the action is role playing a team sport, rather than a simulation combat scenario?
 
Rasmussen poll

Does the United States need to place limits on violent movies and video games?

Yes 49%

No 37%

Not sure 13%

Note: Most adults under 40 oppose limits on violent video games and movies. Most older adults are in favor of such limits
I’m over 40 and I don’t favor them. We already have a ratings system. Besides, Lanza was 20 years old. An adult. Not a child. So unless you want to ban violence in video games any other limits would not be applicable to an adult.
 
So everyone is against the level of sexual indecency in media because it normalizes immoral sexual values, but no one is against the way violence is used in media to normalize anti-heroic attitudes? :confused:
 
Not to defend overly-violent video games or to say that they have zero impact on people, but it really irks me when they try to make video games the scapegoat for these types of horrors.

The Call of Duty franchise alone has sold about 100 million copies. Millions of people play these games.

So let’s just say that, conservatively speaking (since there is more than one Call of Duty game), 5 million people play these games or even games like it. If these games caused even one tenth of one percent of those who played it to go on a murderous rampage, we should expect to see 5000 such cases.

I get it. It’s natural in the face of tragedy to want to try to do something to prevent such a thing from happening again. I have little confidence that any legislation related to video games is going to be the answer.
 
Not to defend overly-violent video games or to say that they have zero impact on people, but it really irks me when they try to make video games the scapegoat for these types of horrors.

The Call of Duty franchise alone has sold about 100 million copies. Millions of people play these games.

So let’s just say that, conservatively speaking (since there is more than one Call of Duty game), 5 million people play these games or even games like it. If these games caused even one tenth of one percent of those who played it to go on a murderous rampage, we should expect to see 5000 such cases.

I get it. It’s natural in the face of tragedy to want to try to do something to prevent such a thing from happening again. I have little confidence that any legislation related to video games is going to be the answer.
Agree 100%. When my character in Skyrim is slaying a bandit with a big honkin’ sword, my mind is a million miles away from actually doing violence to anyone or anything in the real world.
 
They went through these games on O’Reilly last night. Some of those games are outrageously violent. At a minimum, they need to enforce the ratings system.
 
I find it interesting that some on the Right are suddenly interested in violence in video games and even more so in mental health issues- hardly a historical interest of the Right.

It seems to me that some want to talk about anything BUT how increased gun regulation could affect change in the issue of such egregious violence.

Guns are the holy grail to some on the Right.
 
Normal person + violent video games = normal

Crazy person + violent video games = crazy
That’s it in a nutshell. Same goes for TV, movies, guns, divorce and all the other excuses people are coming up with to run from the real issue of mental health and how poorly it is dealt with in our society. Between the ridiculous stigmas people have about it and the fear that some of their “hard earned money” might go to treat someone that they consider unworthy of assistance we’re never going to see the end of these kind of violent acts.
 
You wouldn’t allow your kids to play video games where the action was simulated sex, so why would you allow them to play video games where they simulate committing other mortal sins like killing?
 
You wouldn’t allow your kids to play video games where the action was simulated sex, so why would you allow them to play video games where they simulate committing other mortal sins like killing?
If the game has killing in it it would be rated M and could only be sold to 18 year-olds.
 
:nunchuk: Time to issue bullet proof book bags and have mandatory civil defense drills in school.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top