Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lisa, I don’t think that enhanced background checks would have much of an impact on criminals…as has been said…they’ll get them one way or the other. Where I think it could have at least a modest impact is the area of unstable people.
This proposal was worked out between tow gun-owners, and I don’t think that anyone would describe either as anti-gun. My read on the situation is that the senators who opposed this compromise position have placed themselves in a very difficult position. Many are already seeing their approval ratings tank because a sizable majority of people in this country view this as a reasonable effort.
I completely agree that current laws should be more rigorously enforced…and that the proposal is not a panacea…but I don’t see where it will do any harm.
Again, as a reasonable man, what is the POINT of adding another layer on laws that are not being enforced already? What is the point of adding a law that will not address the problem?

I see the reason for this sudden interest in piling on more laws as strictly political…do something-itis which our Congress suffers from frequently. I agree some of the negative reaction or no votes are also politically motivated. But not all of them and my opinion is that the Senate would have voted for a well written bill that actually addressed the problems.

As I said previously, I heard a lobbyist for gun owners (National Shooting Sports Assn or something like that) who explained a number of elements of the bill that they really liked. But they said with the good stuff came a bunch of bad stuff, notably the extremely confusing list of exceptions…like you can sell a gun to your wife’s brother in law’s uncle…there were SO many and they were so convoluted that it would make the law very hard to understand or enforce, particularly as these provisions were intended NOT for gun dealers but for ordinary folks. The real death knell though was that gun show background checks would effectively stop store checks during the period a gun show was open. Most of the sellers at gun shows are dealers who have stores as well. So as the lobbyist explained it, with the gun show checks taking precedance, the store sales would be halted during that time period. I don’t know the point of this portion of the law. I think there is the illusion that criminals are buying guns at gun shows…not likely.

Toomey and Mancion are gun owners and as such they got a LOT further than would DiFi or any of the the others in the Senate who are notoriusly anti-gun. Had they carefully crafted the bill, the result might have been different.

Lisa
 
If you look at the background check not from a criminal standpoint, but from a mental stability standpoint, who would determine and track who is on the “no gun list” and once on , would that be forever? What about people on anti depressant drugs that are known to intensify suicidal tenancies? Is everyone on these also on the list? Will one psychologist have a different interpretation of mental instability then another and will all of them report their suspicions to the state? And will the state follow through and report to the feds? I remember reading that only a small number of states are doing so now and those that are have reported less then 100 cases leaving the NICIS database nearly useless. And the biggest question would be what other purpose would this database be used for? As far as the criminal element, they very seldom purchase a firearm. In gangs, they’re usually handed down so a background check would be useless.
 
Since it was never passed…your statement begs the question…how do you know?

A bit of inconvenience for law-biding citizens seems like a good trade-off to me…that spoken as a lawful gun owner.
I truly have no respect people who would give away my rights.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top