Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So I assume because you think an air rifle is off topic, it’s not a gun :confused:
Virginia classifies an air rifle or bb gun as a firearm, and they were previously banned in San Francisco. It’s closer to the topic than the Franco back and forth.
 
Franco was a Fascist thug dressed up in a fancy uniform like his fellow Fascist soulmates Hitler and Mussolini.
Franco wasn’t a fascist and he wasn’t “soulmates” with Hitler and Mussolini.
His evil treatment of the Jews in Spain
Wow. Letting them flee through his country, how horrible.
his anti-Catholicism.
If you really believe that Franco was anti-Catholic then I have a bridge from manhattan to brooklyn that I’d like to sell you.
Oh my goodness. You mean Franco shook Hitler’s hand, that’s horrible, you know he probably even ate with sinners if he was willing to do a thing like that.
 
the bottom line is that Obama, in the aftermath of these shootings, with the PR machine in high gear and with control of the Senate, was unable get even minimal reforms on gun control. the country has definitely turned on him, and with the election cycle coming up, gun control is dead.
…Oh my goodness. You mean Franco shook Hitler’s hand, that’s horrible, you know he probably even ate with sinners if he was willing to do a thing like that.
he probably talking about those Catholic priests Franco shot.
A memorial service was held on Sunday, for 14 priests executed by Franco’s forces in the Basque Country during the Spanish Civil War.
The bishops of the Basque Country have issued an apology for the Church’s silence over the episode. None of the priests was given a proper funeral, nor did most of them have their deaths registered.
indcatholicnews.com/news.php?viewStory=14603
 
the bottom line is that Obama, in the aftermath of these shootings, with the PR machine in high gear and with control of the Senate, was unable get even minimal reforms on gun control. the country has definitely turned on him, and with the election cycle coming up, gun control is dead.

he probably talking about those Catholic priests Franco shot.

indcatholicnews.com/news.php?viewStory=14603
But why was Obama unable to get, as you put it, “even minimal reforms” in gun control? It’s not the COUNTRY that has turned against him, but the Republican Congress influenced by the NRA leadership. Further, I don’t agree that the gun control issue is dead in the 2016 election cycle. Some of those who voted it down, OTOH, may very well be.
 
But why was Obama unable to get, as you put it, “even minimal reforms” in gun control? It’s not the COUNTRY that has turned against him, but the Republican Congress influenced by the NRA leadership. Further, I don’t agree that the gun control issue is dead in the 2016 election cycle. Some of those who voted it down, OTOH, may very well be.
the issue is dead. the NRA doesn’t control congress anymore than the gun grabbers and their lobby and the president and their shills in the media do.

gun control won’t fly with the public from this president. a GOP president would have been able to get background checks passed, but not Obama.

F/
 
But why was Obama unable to get, as you put it, “even minimal reforms” in gun control? It’s not the COUNTRY that has turned against him, but the Republican Congress influenced by the NRA leadership. Further, I don’t agree that the gun control issue is dead in the 2016 election cycle. Some of those who voted it down, OTOH, may very well be.
Senators turned on a BAD gun bill, plain and simple, not due to some NRA influence (if you missed it, they supported background checks in the past).

washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-rush-to-a-bad-gun-control-law/2013/04/15/af89abb4-a5ff-11e2-a8e2-5b98cb59187f_story.html?wpisrc=nl_opinions

The issue is legislatively dead, and fortunately for the rest of the country, there is a political world outside of New York. Just ask Bill Clinton about the 1994 elections.
 
Senators turned on a BAD gun bill, plain and simple, not due to some NRA influence (if you missed it, they supported background checks in the past).

washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-rush-to-a-bad-gun-control-law/2013/04/15/af89abb4-a5ff-11e2-a8e2-5b98cb59187f_story.html?wpisrc=nl_opinions

The issue is legislatively dead, and fortunately for the rest of the country, there is a political world outside of New York. Just ask Bill Clinton about the 1994 elections.
Pat Toomey and others would disagree with you on the dead issue. This whole discussion may well shift to the state and local level.
 
Senators turned on a BAD gun bill, plain and simple, not due to some NRA influence (if you missed it, they supported background checks in the past).

washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-rush-to-a-bad-gun-control-law/2013/04/15/af89abb4-a5ff-11e2-a8e2-5b98cb59187f_story.html?wpisrc=nl_opinions

The issue is legislatively dead, and fortunately for the rest of the country, there is a political world outside of New York. Just ask Bill Clinton about the 1994 elections.
The NRA supported background checks in the past.
 
Pat Toomey and others would disagree with you on the dead issue. This whole discussion may well shift to the state and local level.
As it should. Do you really think the issues are the same for rural Wyoming and Manhattan? The whole “one size fits all” approach is a disaster in a large and diverse country.

As to the bill introduced, as usual with “do something-itis” it was rushed in and while there were some good provisions that would have been supported by the Senate as well as the American people. However the exclusions were not only extensive but mindnumbingly cumbersome. Read it and you’ll see what I mean…The buyer’s second cousin twice removed and his or her spouse and that spouse’s third cousin…

It also failed to note the reality that NOTHING in the bill would have stopped any of the mass shooters whose evil acts inspired the rush to take actions. Oh and the complete and utter failure of the Obama Justice department to follow up on CURRENT violations of background checks was not addressed either.

Bad law is bad law and thankfully enough Senators voted it down. If a well thought out and effective approach is proposed you will see support.

Lisa
 
As it should. Do you really think the issues are the same for rural Wyoming and Manhattan? The whole “one size fits all” approach is a disaster in a large and diverse country.

As to the bill introduced, as usual with “do something-itis” it was rushed in and while there were some good provisions that would have been supported by the Senate as well as the American people. However the exclusions were not only extensive but mindnumbingly cumbersome. Read it and you’ll see what I mean…The buyer’s second cousin twice removed and his or her spouse and that spouse’s third cousin…

It also failed to note the reality that NOTHING in the bill would have stopped any of the mass shooters whose evil acts inspired the rush to take actions. Oh and the complete and utter failure of the Obama Justice department to follow up on CURRENT violations of background checks was not addressed either.

Bad law is bad law and thankfully enough Senators voted it down. If a well thought out and effective approach is proposed you will see support.

Lisa
one size doesn’t fit all with one major exception. as the USSC ruled, because gun ownership is a constitutional right, there are some control options that are off the table and the most gungrabtastic city can’t repeal the second amendment.

F/
 
one size doesn’t fit all with one major exception. as the USSC ruled, because gun ownership is a constitutional right, there are some control options that are off the table and the most gungrabtastic city can’t repeal the second amendment.

F/
Huh? I have no idea what you are talking about. Having detailed national regulations on gun use and ownership makes no sense as well as violating the 2nd Amendment. It’s a non-starter

Lisa
 
Huh? I have no idea what you are talking about. Having detailed national regulations on gun use and ownership makes no sense as well as violating the 2nd Amendment. It’s a non-starter

Lisa
gun control can be greater in DC or NYC than it is in Montana. but it cannot go past a certain constitutional threshold. DC could ban 30 rd magazines, it cannot ban pistols for home defense.

F/
 
The NRA supported background checks in the past.
Didn’t I mention that in my post? Several of the Senators who voted against the bill have also supported background checks in the past.

Fact is, this was a poorly thought out bill, however well intentioned. By bringing it up in a special procedure vote (and failing to get cloture), the supporters of the bill just wanted to prevent any more amendments, rather than keep it in ordinary Senate rules.

The gun-control bill died because the White House and the Senate leadership would not entertain any such amendments.

Obama FAIL>
 
Didn’t I mention that in my post? Several of the Senators who voted against the bill have also supported background checks in the past.

Fact is, this was a poorly thought out bill, however well intentioned. By bringing it up in a special procedure vote (and failing to get cloture), the supporters of the bill just wanted to prevent any more amendments, rather than keep it in ordinary Senate rules.

The gun-control bill died because the White House and the Senate leadership would not entertain any such amendments.

Obama FAIL>
Senate and Party leadership behind the scenes probably didn’t want this bill to pass because of the coming election cycle. Obama certainly did, but he’s a lame duck.

F/
 
Virginia classifies an air rifle or bb gun as a firearm, and they were previously banned in San Francisco. It’s closer to the topic than the Franco back and forth.
Sale and possession of air guns are not regulated federally, nor are they regulated by most state and local governments. A few States and municipalities which do restrict or prohibit air gun sales or possession in some manner are San Francisco, New York City, Camden, New Jersey and Newark, New Jersey. Johnson City, Tennessee; Massachusetts, Chicago, Philadelphia, and the States of Illinois, Michigan[27] and California. Additionally, ordinances in many cities prohibit the discharge of air guns outdoors outside of an approved range.
Some states, such as Virginia, classify a pellet gun or BB gun as a firearm. In Virginia, certain case law has determined that, during certain criminal conduct, air guns are firearms.
Air guns were banned in San Francisco, but a state preemption statue struck down the ban, and the San Francisco District Attorney declared them legal as long as in compliance with state law.
Seems as nobody can agree on anything. I wonder how many young kids are criminals for possessing a Red Ryder BB gun (with a compass in the stock and this thing that tells time) without the proper permits and licensing. And when Dad or Grandpa gave it, was he sure to have a background check run? :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top