Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We have limitations and restrictions to the First Amendment regarding freedom of speech and freedom of the press. What makes the Second Amendment holier than the First?
Exactly Meltzerboy. We don’t yell “fire” in a crowded bldg when there is none or publicly display child porn just because we have freedom of speech. Amendments have restrictions and limitations. And there is nothing to make the 2nd amendment holier than any other except in the minds of gun proponents who want to be able to own any weapon, including such deadly assault weapons made in the 21st century which were unheard of in the18th century when the 2nd amendment was written.
 
Exactly Meltzerboy. We don’t yell “fire” in a crowded bldg when there is none or publicly display child porn just because we have freedom of speech. Amendments have restrictions and limitations. And there is nothing to make the 2nd amendment holier than any other except in the minds of gun proponents who want to be able to own any weapon, including such deadly assault weapons made in the 21st century which were unheard of in the18th century when the 2nd amendment was written.
Protecting the right to own guns isn’t the equivalent to “yelling fire in a crowded bldg.” Disappointed in your flippant remarks on the constitution. The right to own guns is a safeguard against tyranny. If you think a central, activist govt. which controls more and more of our lives is a good thing then perhaps you could move to a country that doesn’t have a constitution like ours that values freedom and liberty.

Ishii
 
Protecting the right to own guns isn’t the equivalent to “yelling fire in a crowded bldg.” Disappointed in your flippant remarks on the constitution. The right to own guns is a safeguard against tyranny. If you think a central, activist govt. which controls more and more of our lives is a good thing then perhaps you could move to a country that doesn’t have a constitution like ours that values freedom and liberty.

Ishii
The old love it or leave it. Haven’t heard that golden oldie in a while.
Gun control already exists to varying degrees across the country and generally always has. Old west towns would require people to surrender their weapons for the duration of their stay, I can’t legally own an operational M-50 machine gun, or a grenade launcher or…This vote was about background checks and is far from dead.
Phase two will see who is more effective at beating their opponent over the head with their own words and proposals, or lack thereof. The Gang of 45 has to hope fervently that there isn’t another mass killing.
 
The old love it or leave it. Haven’t heard that golden oldie in a while.
Gun control already exists to varying degrees across the country and generally always has. Old west towns would require people to surrender their weapons for the duration of their stay, I can’t legally own an operational M-50 machine gun, or a grenade launcher or…This vote was about background checks and is far from dead.
Phase two will see who is more effective at beating their opponent over the head with their own words and proposals, or lack thereof. The Gang of 45 has to hope fervently that there isn’t another mass killing.
Yes, I agree. However, let’s all hope and pray that there are no more mass killings.
 
Most of the parents who lost their children in Newtown probably don’t think that gun control is the ONLY answer, but most also no doubt believe it’s at least a start. According to what I heard, the proposed, now defeated, bill was revised by a conservative Democrat and a conservative Republican so that private gun sales would not be affected. (And there were even measures that loosened gun restrictions for law-abiding citizens.) That’s one of the problems with the Obama administration, in my view: such compromise measures often become too watered down to be very effective. I don’t know if the legislation would have helped in the specific case of Adam Lanza, but, weak as it was, it may have helped save lives in other situations, and even if only a few lives had been saved at virtually no cost to law-abiding gun owners, it would have been worth it.
Laws on the book are not being enforced adequately. Prosecutions are down over 45% under Obama:

washingtonexaminer.com/gun-prosecutions-under-obama-down-more-than-45-percent/article/2516175

If criminals think they can get away with gun crime they are more probably more likely to commit it. Obama admin should urgently address the decline in prosecutions under their administration
 
Laws on the book are not being enforced adequately. Prosecutions are down over 45% under Obama:

washingtonexaminer.com/gun-prosecutions-under-obama-down-more-than-45-percent/article/2516175

If criminals think they can get away with gun crime they are more probably more likely to commit it. Obama admin should urgently address the decline in prosecutions under their administration
Exactly and I’ve now said the same thing three times. All of you “gun grabbers” conveniently ignore that we HAVE background checks already. They are not being used to catch criminals who seem to violate them with impunity. What say you about that? How can any administration demand further background checks when they prosecuted 44 of 44000 violations? Of COURSE 90% of Americans are for background checks. WE HAVE THEM. Now if we don’t enforce them, is that the fault of Congress?

A background check would NOT have stopped the majority, if not all of these mass shootings that have ginned up the howls to “do something.” Even the expanded background checks proposed would have done nothing to stop Adam Lanza from using his mother’s legally obtained guns in a state that has among the toughest of laws.

Further cities with the strongest of gun control laws are awash in gun violence. Obama has very little to say about his hometown where there are dozens of gun crimes every weekend with numerous fatalities. There are cries of protest about the “gun show loophole” but again the facts are ignored. One of them is that even at gun shows, dealers must still provide background checks and does anyone know of one of these mass shooters who used a gun purchased at a gun show where he was able to avoid background checks?

Guns used in crimes tend to be those owned by criminals…who do not buy their guns at Cabelas.

Facts are inconvenient things aren’t they? Ya’ll might use them now and then to make an effective argument.

Lisa
 
. I don’t know if the legislation would have helped in the specific case of Adam Lanza, but, weak as it was, it may have helped save lives in other situations, and even if only a few lives had been saved at virtually no cost to law-abiding gun owners, it would have been worth it.
So without knowing if it would help at all you are for it?

Sounds logical…:hmmm:
 
Exactly and I’ve now said the same thing three times. All of you “gun grabbers” conveniently ignore that we HAVE background checks already. They are not being used to catch criminals who seem to violate them with impunity. What say you about that? How can any administration demand further background checks when they prosecuted 44 of 44000 violations? Of COURSE 90% of Americans are for background checks. WE HAVE THEM. Now if we don’t enforce them, is that the fault of Congress?

A background check would NOT have stopped the majority, if not all of these mass shootings that have ginned up the howls to “do something.” Even the expanded background checks proposed would have done nothing to stop Adam Lanza from using his mother’s legally obtained guns in a state that has among the toughest of laws.

Further cities with the strongest of gun control laws are awash in gun violence. Obama has very little to say about his hometown where there are dozens of gun crimes every weekend with numerous fatalities. There are cries of protest about the “gun show loophole” but again the facts are ignored. One of them is that even at gun shows, dealers must still provide background checks and does anyone know of one of these mass shooters who used a gun purchased at a gun show where he was able to avoid background checks?

Guns used in crimes tend to be those owned by criminals…who do not buy their guns at Cabelas.

Facts are inconvenient things aren’t they? Ya’ll might use them now and then to make an effective argument.

Lisa
What WOULD have stopped those mass shootings would have been taking down those ridiculous “Gun Free Zone” signs.

The nutjobs spent years preparing their attacks. And making sure there would be NO opposition was a key factor.

The “gun free zone” signs were perfect for their evil purposes.

Take down those signs!!
 
What WOULD have stopped those mass shootings would have been taking down those ridiculous “Gun Free Zone” signs.

The nutjobs spent years preparing their attacks. And making sure there would be NO opposition was a key factor.

The “gun free zone” signs were perfect for their evil purposes.

Take down those signs!!
You might have to do more than take down the signs - you have to make it known that someone (people) in the school are armed. You just don’t have to say who.

Our school board recently considered allowing one or two people in each building to be armed (must have CCW class and further training) and they would draw extra duty pay. They hope to have the program in place starting next school year.
 
You might have to do more than take down the signs - you have to make it known that someone (people) in the school are armed. You just don’t have to say who.

Our school board recently considered allowing one or two people in each building to be armed (must have CCW class and further training) and they would draw extra duty pay. They hope to have the program in place starting next school year.
And put up signs that say “Everyone in this building is armed to the teeth”.

Everyone should have a sign like that.

With a picture of a guard dog.
 
And put up signs that say “Everyone in this building is armed to the teeth”.

Everyone should have a sign like that.

With a picture of a guard dog.
I hate the fact that we are in this situation…where schools are basically like medium security prisons. But, the realist in me says that these actions are needed. Having several responsible, willing and well-trained staff armed…and making it known…is a good approach in my opinion. Where the funds allow I would also support hiring full-time security…we are going to have a lot of combat vets in need of employment.
All this makes me wistful. All I had to worry about when I was a kid was whether or not so and so liked me.
 
I hate the fact that we are in this situation…where schools are basically like medium security prisons. But, the realist in me says that these actions are needed. Having several responsible, willing and well-trained staff armed…and making it known…is a good approach in my opinion. Where the funds allow I would also support hiring full-time security…we are going to have a lot of combat vets in need of employment.
All this makes me wistful. All I had to worry about when I was a kid was whether or not so and so liked me.
The question is - how did we get there?

When I was in highschool I parked an old Ford 4X4 in the school lot with a 30-30 and a shotgun hanging in the back window. The violent crime rate was much higher in 1986 that it is now. Now the crime rate is lower but parking my pickup with a visible firearm in the back window on school property is a felony. 30 years ago school shootings were mostly unheard of and “mass” school shooting never happened. Today you get at least one mass school shooting a year - what changed?
 
What WOULD have stopped those mass shootings would have been taking down those ridiculous “Gun Free Zone” signs.

The nutjobs spent years preparing their attacks. And making sure there would be NO opposition was a key factor.

The “gun free zone” signs were perfect for their evil purposes.

Take down those signs!!
Another fact that is lost in translation…many of the mass shootings were at known “gun free zones.” Putting up these signs is laughable at best, and tragic in some cases. The Batman Shooter picked a theater that was a “gun free” zone. The Portland Mall shooter picked a “gun free” mall…but was stopped by someone who violated the law with his legal concealed carry. The college subject to a mass killer was also a “gun free” zone.

What is it about lawmakers that they think signs do anything but restrict otherwise law abiding citizens? Do they REALLY think these work? In our city, in one of the worst areas for drug sales is a sign “Drug Free Zone.” Again, it’s laughable as various shady characters literally hang out under the signs selling drugs.

A couple of other common factors in these mass killings, psychotropic drugs and mental health issues. The Batman Shooter was reported as being homocidal but was not stopped or even questioned. Gabby Giffords’ shooter was known to be extremely disturbed and had been thrown off the campus where he had been attending classes.

It’s so odd to me that the signs and issues related to the SHOOTERS, rather than their choice of weapon, are ignored by Congress with all focus being on restricting gun ownership by law abiding citizens.

Lisa
 
The question is - how did we get there?

When I was in highschool I parked an old Ford 4X4 in the school lot with a 30-30 and a shotgun hanging in the back window. The violent crime rate was much higher in 1986 that it is now. Now the crime rate is lower but parking my pickup with a visible firearm in the back window on school property is a felony. 30 years ago school shootings were mostly unheard of and “mass” school shooting never happened. Today you get at least one mass school shooting a year - what changed?
Sam, maybe police have realized that some criminals who see a shotgun in a pickup might try to break in and steal the weapon, and that’s why it’s not such a good idea to leave it there in plain sight.
 
I hate the fact that we are in this situation…where schools are basically like medium security prisons. But, the realist in me says that these actions are needed. Having several responsible, willing and well-trained staff armed…and making it known…is a good approach in my opinion. Where the funds allow I would also support hiring full-time security…we are going to have a lot of combat vets in need of employment.
All this makes me wistful. All I had to worry about when I was a kid was whether or not so and so liked me.
Well, get with the program, oldcelt. More guns in schools is what we need, as well as in malls, movie theaters, restaurants, hospitals, nursing homes, and churches. Let’s all be armed to the teeth, I say!
 
Another fact that is lost in translation…many of the mass shootings were at known “gun free zones.” Putting up these signs is laughable at best, and tragic in some cases. The Batman Shooter picked a theater that was a “gun free” zone. The Portland Mall shooter picked a “gun free” mall…but was stopped by someone who violated the law with his legal concealed carry. The college subject to a mass killer was also a “gun free” zone.

What is it about lawmakers that they think signs do anything but restrict otherwise law abiding citizens? Do they REALLY think these work? In our city, in one of the worst areas for drug sales is a sign “Drug Free Zone.” Again, it’s laughable as various shady characters literally hang out under the signs selling drugs.

A couple of other common factors in these mass killings, psychotropic drugs and mental health issues. The Batman Shooter was reported as being homocidal but was not stopped or even questioned. Gabby Giffords’ shooter was known to be extremely disturbed and had been thrown off the campus where he had been attending classes.

It’s so odd to me that the signs and issues related to the SHOOTERS, rather than their choice of weapon, are ignored by Congress with all focus being on restricting gun ownership by law abiding citizens.

Lisa
BTW, Lisa, Gabby Giffords and her husband have guns which they use for recreational purposes and hunting (I believe), but they are nonetheless in favor of gun control. Imagine that!
 
Maybe police have realized that some criminals who see a shotgun in a pickup might try to break in and steal the weapon, and that’s why it’s not such a good idea to leave it there in plain sight.
Should we lock women up for the same reason? A rapist might see them and want to rape them?

Its all for the public good after all.
 
Well, get with the program, oldcelt. More guns in schools is what we need, as well as in malls, movie theaters, restaurants, hospitals, nursing homes, and churches. Let’s all be armed to the teeth, I say!
Because the crimnals are following the law and you’ll never encounter one in such a situation…:rolleyes:
 
Well, get with the program, oldcelt. More guns in schools is what we need, as well as in malls, movie theaters, restaurants, hospitals, nursing homes, and churches. Let’s all be armed to the teeth, I say!
I don’t like it…I just can’t stand the thought of another Newtown. Truly, I wish I had a better solution.
 
Should we lock women up for the same reason? A man might see them and want to rape them?

Its all for the public good after all.
Yes, of course. Women should be locked up because they are just as dangerous as guns or, as you say, liable to be raped. It’s for their own safety as well as the public good. And household utensils (i.e. knives) should also be locked up because they may be stolen. Apples and oranges are both fruits; therefore apples ARE oranges.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top