Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MattinTex

Guest
I wanted those gun laws to be passed. It would not have prevented responsible citizens who were not criminals from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun. I have nothing against responsible, law-abiding citizens owning guns and this law would not have prevented responsible, law-abiding citizens from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of the hands of criminals or at least it would have helped to do so. What is so wrong with that?
 
Holly,

How effective have the mass of gun control laws passed in the last fifty years in the US been?

Has gun crime gone down or up (dramatically)?
 
I agree. People need to understand that when everyone buys a gun, everyone is a good citizen. After a deadly shooting, facts come up. Mental illnesses, the person being isolated, with having tougher laws it would eliminate those individuals who cause these bad things.
 
Holly,

How effective have the mass of gun control laws passed in the last fifty years in the US been?

Has gun crime gone down or up (dramatically)?
The effectiveness of past gun control laws is no indicator of how effective future gun control laws will be. I mean, maybe if the past gun control laws really did fail then we have learned something and have now come up with better and more effective gun control laws.
I agree. People need to understand that when everyone buys a gun, everyone is a good citizen. After a deadly shooting, facts come up. Mental illnesses, the person being isolated, with having tougher laws it would eliminate those individuals who cause these bad things.
Exactly. I have no issue with responsible, law-abiding citizens owning a gun. What I have a problem with is irresponsible citizens, citizens who are criminals, and citizens with serious mental illnesses owning or being able to purchase a gun. I have a serious mental illness and I would be perfectly fine with my mental illness precluding me from owning a gun.
 
If only our society could realize that “heaven on earth” is not possible. It sounds beautiful to talk about ending all gun violence, but what we are going to inevitably end up with is an Orwellian government that surpresses both the good and the bad… If left to its own devices, the State would eventually seek to take away our God-given free-will to create a Eutopia… And in so doing move us further away from heaven then we would ever be, otherwise.

If you want to make the world a better place, seek first the kingdom of God. And please, don’t put your trust in princes… No matter how strong the horse is, it cannot save.
 
Exactly. I have no issue with responsible, law-abiding citizens owning a gun. What I have a problem with is irresponsible citizens, citizens who are criminals, and citizens with serious mental illnesses owning or being able to purchase a gun. I have a serious mental illness and I would be perfectly fine with my mental illness precluding me from owning a gun.
This is, of course, eminently sensible; how anyone could object to requiring background checks at gun shows and for internet sales is beyond me. But then again, you and I aren’t lily-livered politicians.
 
I hate to tell you pro-gun control people that the legislation just defeated in the Senate would have been worthless because there was no provision for making the reporting of mental cases manditory for the states.
Until all 50 states have to report the names of all the people in public as well as private mental institutions, the screening process is useless.
If the Government was serious about gun violence, all they have to do is strictly enforce the Federal laws already on the books…that goes not only for arresting and prosecuting people, it goes for the judges who sentance the perps.
Unfortunately, if that was done, it would triple the prison population and we would have to build labor camps similar to those in the old USSR. Then the liberals would scream that the camps are filled with minorities.
 
Gun registration = gun confiscation. To the poster near the beginning of the thread who thinks ‘law abiding’ people would be able to keep their guns, nope. The government wants us DISARMED. Only the criminals and the criminal government would be allowed to carry them, and of course all the people wealthy enough to pay for armed body guards.
Second amendment had to do with protection against the government. Our laws are based on the laws in Switzerland, those which have prevented invasion for many centuries in Switzerland, from what I understand. Laws there include the following:
  1. mandatory annual inspection of Each and Every Home by ‘officials’ who, if they can LOCATE YOUR GUNS, WEAPONS, whatever, will arrange for you to pay a fine.
  2. Structures along hiking trails hold various kinds of weapons. Structures along highways are for snipers.
  3. Every resident of the country is trained to shoot, including the elderly if they have not learned early.
Switzerland has a lot to protect; we, arguably, no longer do. HOWEVER: we have a consumately evil government headed by a consumately evil man and his view of our future is radically opposed to what would be comfortable for those who appreciate freedom, entrepreneurialism, individualism on all sorts of levels, etc. The agenda is unbelievable; unfortunately, many many people are naive and asleep, or drugged.

More drugs are pharmaceutically recommended in the US than anywhere in the world. The antidepressants people are taking NUMBS THEM emotionally, and that is just the tip of the iceberg.

Postulating that either we NEED a change to the Second Amendment, or that we need to abolish it alogether is gravely incorrect.

I wish people would do the research and learn a little about history, and stop trusting the people who have gotten control in this country.

Look around: look at WHO most loudly supports gun “control” - they are the dual citizens, whose primary loyalty is NOT TO THE UNITED STATES. Why would they want to disarm the dominant culture?
 
The effectiveness of past gun control laws is no indicator of how effective future gun control laws will be. I mean, maybe if the past gun control laws really did fail then we have learned something and have now come up with better and more effective gun control laws.

Exactly. I have no issue with responsible, law-abiding citizens owning a gun. What I have a problem with is irresponsible citizens, citizens who are criminals, and citizens with serious mental illnesses owning or being able to purchase a gun. I have a serious mental illness and I would be perfectly fine with my mental illness precluding me from owning a gun.
Holly I suspect you mean well but you are living in dreamland if you think that the laws being proposed will do anything to combat the kind of mass shootings that make the news or even the more mundane gun crimes that plague POTUS’s adopted hometown of Chicago.

All they seem to propose are laws that do little more than harrass law abiding citizens. This will not stop one single criminal from buying a gun…they aren’t going through the regular channels, gun dealers or even gun shows. They are obtaining stolen or illegally sold guns.

Here’s a little factoid, the Justice Department that wants to remove guns from law abiding citizens who WOULD pass a background check has almost totally failed to prosecute those who try to buy guns illegally. Apparently there were tens of thousands of such cases and the Justice Department prosecuted fewer than 50! Before we enact more laws, why not prosecute those on the books now? If felons or others who fail back ground checks are trying to get guns and failing the checks, why are they not at least being contacted?

Further nothing is being done to keep guns out of the hands of the mentally ill or even those on psychtropic drugs. All of the mass shooters from Sandy Hook to Colorado were on these drugs. Further in the case of the Colorado shooter, college security was warned by his doctor that he was homocidal! They either ignored it or thought she was overstating the case. Ditto with the shooter of Rep Gabriel Giffordss…many people said he was clearly disturbed and was threatening fellow students at his college.

So what is the reaction to all of these mass shootings? What is the reaction to some twenty shootings in Chicago on a single weekend? Oh yes let’s make it hard for Joe Smith to buy a rifle at a gun show…that ought to help.

If this logic were extended to the recent bombings we’d hear cries to outlaw pressure cookers!

Lisa
 
ALSO: Sandy Hook was three years at least in the planning. Look at the research about every mass shooting we have had - several in Colorado, the center of the “secret” “second” government, where very sophisticated resources of all types are located. Investigate Sandy Hook and see the primary source material. Understand that 911 was an inside job. Understand terrorism is a means of control deliberately used throughout history, and we in the United States are a victim of it. Understand what has happened since 911, and only because of it. The grip is tightening; China wants us disarmed and has directly encouraged our government in that. Why would China care?

Remember: they own our debt; they are buying our resources, own oil wells, and media centers in the United States and are increasingly present here. What is going on with all the strange weather? Consider the spraying of aluminum and barium salts, which is ruining farmland and destroying health. Understand it is deliberate. Undrestand that the United States is the BIG enchilada to be taken down.

Our population is already weakened by an assault of massive amounts of vaccines with destructive properties deliberately included. I teach in public school and see the results: great weakening of health, far more disability, lower IQ xcores.

An accident? Sandy Hook a random act? NO. It’s all part of the process of gradually destroying the one country that had a whiff of freedom and propsperity, for as long as it was allowed to have these.

People with enomous wealth want enormous control, and remain hidden. The middle class is the enemy; they want us below third world povery level, while they run things and reduce the population more and more overtly.

Give up guns at your own peril. Go right ahead.

For those who want concealed carry banned in Catholic churches, the idea is to have someone there who can shoot the person or persons who are mowing people down. It’s only a matter of time before a shooting is staged in a church IN THE UNITED STATES. I’m sure it’s included on the agenda of those who plan these attacks here.
 
A great victory for freedom loving men everywhere in the country. Now we in California have to deal with our proposed bills…
 
I support the constitution. We need to address the lack of mental health facilities in this country. Salem Oregon closed a large mental health facility and just let all the patient’s out into the streets. They now beg to get by on the street corners…so sad…this is what a Government is supposed to be addressing, not changing the constitution to erode our God given rights. :onpatrol:

The city of Chicago proves that gun restrictions have little to no effect.
 
WRT mental illness, which mental illnesses would have rendered someone unfit to own a gun? For how long?

And how would this be known to those who have the info for the background checks?

Would everyone who went to marital counseling be precluded from owning a gun for the rest of their lives?

Would counselors of all sorts be required to report all or just some of their patients’s medical histories?

Is this what we want?

I guess what I am saying is that yes, it would be a good idea to keep guns out of the hands of seriously mentally ill people. But until we have some *criteria *for that, this would not work–either because too many people would be reported or too few.

Additionally, we would probably be a lot better off if we could put people who are a damger to themselves or others into a safe situation, bit this has been deemed an unreasobe breach of people’s Constitutional rights. So instead we attempt to restrict other Constitutional rights…

Moreover, * A 1997 U.S. Justice Department survey of 14,285 state prison inmates found that among those inmates who carried a firearm during the offense for which they were sent to jail, 0.7% obtained the firearm at a gun show, 1% at a flea market, 3.8% from a pawn shop, 8.3% from a retail store, 39.2% through an illegal/street source, and 39.6% through family or friends.[94]Link

While I inderstand that the new law was supposed to capture some of that almost 40% of criminals who acquire guns from family or friends… how many people do you think who are currently willing to lend, give, or sell a gun to a criminal are likely to follow the law? And even among law-abiding citizens who lend, give, or sell guns to friends or relatives who they do not know are criminals, how many would lend a gun without a background check to someone who claimed to want to borrow it because there was a lot of crime in their area?

And this still leaves the official almost 40% completely uncovered by the law…

Just fyi: as I understand it, dealers at gun shows are still required to run background checks; it’s just private sales which do not.
 
This is, of course, eminently sensible; how anyone could object to requiring background checks at gun shows and for internet sales is beyond me. But then again, you and I aren’t lily-livered politicians.
I am curious about this calling those who voted against the bills cowardly–not just on your part, but that of others as well.

The idea seems to be that they bowed to the pressure of the NRA and voted against the bills for fear of losing in an upcoming election. But the advocates of the gun control bills also claimsd that 90% of Americans were for these bills… so why would they vote against the bills?

It just seems like this meme is illogical.
 
ALSO: Sandy Hook was three years at least in the planning. Look at the research about every mass shooting we have had - several in Colorado, the center of the “secret” “second” government, where very sophisticated resources of all types are located. Investigate Sandy Hook and see the primary source material. Understand that 911 was an inside job. Understand terrorism is a means of control deliberately used throughout history, and we in the United States are a victim of it. Understand what has happened since 911, and only because of it. The grip is tightening; China wants us disarmed and has directly encouraged our government in that. Why would China care?

Remember: they own our debt; they are buying our resources, own oil wells, and media centers in the United States and are increasingly present here. What is going on with all the strange weather? Consider the spraying of aluminum and barium salts, which is ruining farmland and destroying health. Understand it is deliberate. Undrestand that the United States is the BIG enchilada to be taken down.

Our population is already weakened by an assault of massive amounts of vaccines with destructive properties deliberately included. I teach in public school and see the results: great weakening of health, far more disability, lower IQ xcores.

An accident? Sandy Hook a random act? NO. It’s all part of the process of gradually destroying the one country that had a whiff of freedom and propsperity, for as long as it was allowed to have these.

People with enomous wealth want enormous control, and remain hidden. The middle class is the enemy; they want us below third world povery level, while they run things and reduce the population more and more overtly.

Give up guns at your own peril. Go right ahead.

For those who want concealed carry banned in Catholic churches, the idea is to have someone there who can shoot the person or persons who are mowing people down. It’s only a matter of time before a shooting is staged in a church IN THE UNITED STATES. I’m sure it’s included on the agenda of those who plan these attacks here.
No offense, but no one wants to hear that paranoid garbage here. There’s enough to be worried about without the phantom threats of a “secret” Nazi government, “chemtrails”, and the other stuff you read about from fear merchants like Alex Jones. Keep it on Prison Planet (In Alex’s Head) where it belongs.
 
You all realize of course, that background checks are required for gun purchases at gun shows and for online purchases now, right? You can’t buy a gun online without a NICS check. You can’t buy a gun from a dealer without a NICS check. This legislation was worthless and redundant. You realize Adam Lanza failed a background check when he tried to purchase a gun in Connecticut, which had the toughest laws in the country for gun ownership at the time?

This legislation was garbage, and I’m glad it failed. I oppose ALL legislation that limits my 2A rights, period. It does nothing but punish law abiding gun owners. There are laws on the books to punish those who buy guns illegally, or use them for crimes. Prosecute those laws before creating new laws that do nothing.

I think those who voted against this are patriots. Except Reid, that is.
 
I wanted those gun laws to be passed. It would not have prevented responsible citizens who were not criminals from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun. I have nothing against responsible, law-abiding citizens owning guns and this law would not have prevented responsible, law-abiding citizens from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of the hands of criminals or at least it would have helped to do so. What is so wrong with that?
There is nothing at all wrong with that. The slippery-slope argument is not applicable to everything. As President Obama said: “This is a pretty shameful day for Washington.” And, I might add, a bad day for our country.
 
You all realize of course, that background checks are required for gun purchases at gun shows and for online purchases now, right? You can’t buy a gun online without a NICS check. You can’t buy a gun from a dealer without a NICS check. This legislation was worthless and redundant. You realize Adam Lanza failed a background check when he tried to purchase a gun in Connecticut, which had the toughest laws in the country for gun ownership at the time?

This legislation was garbage, and I’m glad it failed. I oppose ALL legislation that limits my 2A rights, period. It does nothing but punish law abiding gun owners. There are laws on the books to punish those who buy guns illegally, or use them for crimes. Prosecute those laws before creating new laws that do nothing.

I think those who voted against this are patriots. Except Reid, that is.
I am glad it failed too
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top