WRT mental illness, which mental illnesses would have rendered someone unfit to own a gun? For how long?
And how would this be known to those who have the info for the background checks?
Would everyone who went to marital counseling be precluded from owning a gun for the rest of their lives?
Would counselors of all sorts be required to report all or just some of their patients’s medical histories?
Is this what we want?
I guess what I am saying is that yes, it would be a good idea to keep guns out of the hands of seriously mentally ill people. But until we have some *criteria *for that, this would not work–either because too many people would be reported or too few.
Additionally, we would probably be a lot better off if we could put people who are a damger to themselves or others into a safe situation, bit this has been deemed an unreasobe breach of people’s Constitutional rights. So instead we attempt to restrict other Constitutional rights…
Moreover, * A 1997 U.S. Justice Department survey of 14,285 state prison inmates found that among those inmates who carried a firearm during the offense for which they were sent to jail, 0.7% obtained the firearm at a gun show, 1% at a flea market, 3.8% from a pawn shop, 8.3% from a retail store, 39.2% through an illegal/street source, and 39.6% through family or friends.[94]
Link
While I inderstand that the new law was supposed to capture some of that almost 40% of criminals who acquire guns from family or friends… how many people do you think who are currently willing to lend, give, or sell a gun to a criminal are likely to follow the law? And even among law-abiding citizens who lend, give, or sell guns to friends or relatives who they do not know are criminals, how many would lend a gun without a background check to someone who claimed to want to borrow it because there was a lot of crime in their area?
And this still leaves the official almost 40% completely uncovered by the law…
Just fyi: as I understand it, dealers at gun shows are still required to run background checks; it’s just private sales which do not.