Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps Washington needs 20 more children to die. Shameful!
Mark Mattioli who lost his seven year old son in Newtown does not think more gun control is the answer:

google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CDsQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fvideo.foxnews.com%2Fv%2F2286893462001%2Fnewtown-parent-more-gun-control-is-not-the-answer%2F&ei=wJtvUeuZEOOl0AWM3YEI&usg=AFQjCNEkCi5wRRBXqWYARYggXHydG6Kltw&sig2=EDq8txxYjPOEuN_WEh_lmQ&bvm=bv.45368065,d.d2k

Question for you and all the other gun control advocates: What in the proposed bill would of stopped Adam Lanza, James Holmes or Seung-Hui Cho?
 
Thank Heaven that reason, decency and liberty have prevailed. Tonight, my family is a little bit safer.

If you want to be safe, take personal responsibility. Don’t rely on a bunch of Socialists to arrange it for you. They’ll either bungle it, or grind you up. They always do.
 
. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun.
It would not have even come close.

The DoJ did a study on where convicted criminals got their firearms. The majority of firearms came from illegal means ( which should surprise no body)

Street purchases, burglary and straw purchases.

So how exactly would a background check ensure that criminals didn’t acquire firearms by any of those means.

And for Sandy Hook, Lanza’s mom did go through a background check. So how would that have applied there.

In the Webster NY shooting, a felon got a firearm via his neighbor who did pass a background check. That transaction was already illegal, so how would this bill have prevented that.

The kids in the Columbine shooting got their firearms the same way. Again the original purchaser passed a background check.

The list goes on and on. So what proof can you offer to your statement “It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun”

How does it ensure what you claim it does?
 
This is definitely a good thing. If anything else, we all know that the Senate typically adds all sorts of onerous provisions to any variety of bills they pass. So if this did pass we would’ve ended-up with one of those “let’s pass this law to see what’s in it” type of situation.

Thank you to the six senators who stopped this bill!
 
blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/timstanley/100212724/barack-obama-cant-pass-gun-control-despite-90-per-cent-support-truly-he-is-a-lame-duck-president
Why did the no-brainer bill fail? Four reasons:
  1. It wasn’t the political priority that its supporters presumed it was. Yes, Newtown shocked the nation – but the top priority for the public remains the economy. According to Gallup, only 4 per cent of Americans think that gun control is the “most important problem facing the country today”.
  1. The National Rifle Association is smarter than we all thought. In the wake of Newtown it scored a number of own goals, including a disastrous press conference and floating the idea of armed guards in schools. But Blake Zeff argues that its extremism was calculated, that its goal was to shift the gravity of debate away from the centre ground and towards the Right – compelling Democrats to talk seriously about armed guards and stop talking about banning whole classes of weapons. The NRA, even by farce, transformed the discussion to its advantage.
  1. The Democrats are dumber that we all thought. Blake Zeff, again, makes a compelling case that the Dems screwed up when they declined to rally behind a more comprehensive gun control bill – conceding leadership of the debate to the Right within their party. This is a familiar story: liberals tend to be less ambitious and tenacious than their conservative rivals.
  1. Barack Obama is a lame duck president. Nobody listens to what he says anymore, nobody is interested in winning his approval and nobody much cares if he thinks they have “let the country down”. This is typical for a second-term president who has lost all their leverage because they’re no longer running for office and everybody is patiently waiting for the day when he quits the White House. But Obama’s difficult personality has doubled the size of the challenge. Gloating in victory, adolescent in defeat – the Prez doesn’t make it easy to work with him. Why should conservative senators give him a legislative victory after he has spent four years painting them as knuckle-dragging rednecks who hate women and the poor?
Whatever your position on gun control, yesterday’s events are a damning indictment of Obama’s presidency – a flash of style, lots of soaring rhetoric and, when the votes are actually counted, little show for any of it. America has four more years of this lame-duck president telling them that it has let him down. If only he could tear up the Constitution and rule by diktat he might save himself a little disappointment. Alas, American democracy is a stickler for rules.
 
Mark Mattioli who lost his seven year old son in Newtown does not think more gun control is the answer:

google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CDsQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fvideo.foxnews.com%2Fv%2F2286893462001%2Fnewtown-parent-more-gun-control-is-not-the-answer%2F&ei=wJtvUeuZEOOl0AWM3YEI&usg=AFQjCNEkCi5wRRBXqWYARYggXHydG6Kltw&sig2=EDq8txxYjPOEuN_WEh_lmQ&bvm=bv.45368065,d.d2k

Question for you and all the other gun control advocates: What in the proposed bill would of stopped Adam Lanza, James Holmes or Seung-Hui Cho?
Most of the parents who lost their children in Newtown probably don’t think that gun control is the ONLY answer, but most also no doubt believe it’s at least a start. According to what I heard, the proposed, now defeated, bill was revised by a conservative Democrat and a conservative Republican so that private gun sales would not be affected. (And there were even measures that loosened gun restrictions for law-abiding citizens.) That’s one of the problems with the Obama administration, in my view: such compromise measures often become too watered down to be very effective. I don’t know if the legislation would have helped in the specific case of Adam Lanza, but, weak as it was, it may have helped save lives in other situations, and even if only a few lives had been saved at virtually no cost to law-abiding gun owners, it would have been worth it.
 
I wanted those gun laws to be passed. It would not have prevented responsible citizens who were not criminals from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun. I have nothing against responsible, law-abiding citizens owning guns and this law would not have prevented responsible, law-abiding citizens from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of the hands of criminals or at least it would have helped to do so. What is so wrong with that?
What is wrong with that is these measures WOULD NOT stop criminals from getting guns…the criminals have many resources available for getting guns that skirt the legal routes. All these laws would have done is make it harder for law-abiding citizens to own guns.
 
The idea seems to be that they bowed to the pressure of the NRA and voted against the bills for fear of losing in an upcoming election. But the advocates of the gun control bills also claimsd that 90% of Americans were for these bills… so why would they vote against the bills?

It just seems like this meme is illogical.
Actually few people cared about this “gun control” bill.
Gallup: Only 4% of Americans Think Gun Control is an Important Problem
Only 4 percent of Americans think guns and gun control are an important problem facing the country, according to Gallup, and far more Americans are concerned about the economy, unemployment and the federal debt.

In its poll from Apr. 4-7, Gallup surveyed 1,005 adults by telephone and asked, “What do you think is the most important problem facing the country today?”

Respondents answered in the following order:

Economy in general 24%

Unemployment/Jobs 18%

Dissatisfaction with Government 16%

Federal budget deficit/Federal debt 11%

Healthcare 6%

Ethical/Moral/Family decline 5%

Immigration/Illegal aliens 4%

Education 4%

Guns/Gun control 4%

Situation with North Korea 4%

Lack of Money 3%

Welfare 2%

Lack of respect for each other 2%

Poverty/Hunger/Homelessness 2%

Foreign aid/Focus overseas 2%

Taxes 2%
That’s after the press spent months trying to convince people it was important.
 
Most of the parents who lost their children in Newtown probably don’t think that gun control is the ONLY answer, but most also no doubt believe it’s at least a start. According to what I heard, the proposed, now defeated, bill was revised by a conservative Democrat and a conservative Republican so that private gun sales would not be affected. (And there were even measures that loosened gun restrictions for law-abiding citizens.)
Source?

A measure was supposed to be added to make sales between family members exempt - but I don’t know if it ever made it into the bill.
 
Most of the parents who lost their children in Newtown probably don’t think that gun control is the ONLY answer, but most also no doubt believe it’s at least a start. According to what I heard, the proposed, now defeated, bill was revised by a conservative Democrat and a conservative Republican so that private gun sales would not be affected. (And there were even measures that loosened gun restrictions for law-abiding citizens.) That’s one of the problems with the Obama administration, in my view: such compromise measures often become too watered down to be very effective. I don’t know if the legislation would have helped in the specific case of Adam Lanza, but, weak as it was, it may have helped save lives in other situations, and even if only a few lives had been saved at virtually no cost to law-abiding gun owners, it would have been worth it.
The thing is, we *already have *background checks on what we can reasonably expect to be able to check. We will never be able to guarantee that any other than the law-abiding would not evade the new provisions.

This whole gun control thing has been nothing more than grandstanding that would have accomplished nothing other than to allow some politicians to show off their rhetorical skills and distract the government from issues which really are important.
 
This is, of course, eminently sensible; how anyone could object to requiring background checks at gun shows and for internet sales is beyond me. But then again, you and I aren’t lily-livered politicians.
Their already are background checks at gun shows and on internet sales. Only a small fraction of gun sales at gun shows are private sales, most go through a licensed dealer. I’ve bought a gun over the internet before and I had to find a local FFL to take possession of the delivery and have background check. What they are really talking about is banning all private sales of guns. So that my mom can’t sell me her gun. I can’t give my daughter my gun. It’s already illegal to privately sell a gun to someone you know can’t legally pass the background check.

This legislation would do nothing to stop criminals from getting guns.
 
The thing is, we *already have *background checks on what we can reasonably expect to be able to check. We will never be able to guarantee that any other than the law-abiding would not evade the new provisions.

This whole gun control thing has been nothing more than grandstanding that would have accomplished nothing other than to allow some politicians to show off their rhetorical skills and distract the government from issues which really are important.
Exactly, more bread and circuses to distract from the day to day misery of unemployment, no growth in the economy along with an unsuccessful foreign policy that seems to have emboldened the nut in NoKo and Assad who continues to slaughter his own people.

Honestly the last thing people want to do is abdicate even more control over their lives to the government that created this mess in the first place. The proposed law served only to harrass and annoy law abiding gun owners with more checks and delays while not stopping the major source of gun deaths, handguns in the possession of violent gang bangers in places like POTUS’ hometown.

The irony that states and cities with very restrictive gun laws have been the site of mass shootings and street violence seems totally lost on a group of politicians who have a bad case of “do something-itis.” What they need to do is enforce the laws on the books now, focus on the hotspots like Chicago which seems to be ignored by POTUS when trying to get Joe Smith’s magazine clip reduced. Further the complete ignorance of some of the lawmakers like that dingbat who thought once you shot all your bullets out of the clip that the clip evaporated or something…SHEESH!

It’s the straitjacket of ideology where the facts do not matter once again. And POTUS was in rare form, flanked by his “props” and scolding the American people like bratty children.

Lisa
 
blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/timstanley/100212724/barack-obama-cant-pass-gun-control-despite-90-per-cent-support-truly-he-is-a-lame-duck-president

Barack Obama is a lame duck president. Nobody listens to what he says anymore, nobody is interested in winning his approval and nobody much cares if he thinks they have “let the country down”. This is typical for a second-term president who has lost all their leverage because they’re no longer running for office and everybody is patiently waiting for the day when he quits the White House. But Obama’s difficult personality has doubled the size of the challenge. Gloating in victory, adolescent in defeat – the Prez doesn’t make it easy to work with him. Why should conservative senators give him a legislative victory after he has spent four years painting them as knuckle-dragging rednecks who hate women and the poor?

Whatever your position on gun control, yesterday’s events are a damning indictment of Obama’s presidency – a flash of style, lots of soaring rhetoric and, when the votes are actually counted, little show for any of it. America has four more years of this lame-duck president telling them that it has let him down. If only he could tear up the Constitution and rule by diktat he might save himself a little disappointment. Alas, American democracy is a stickler for rules.
My sentiments exactly. Obama should be embarrassed by his adolescent response to not getting his way. I’ve seen five year olds who showed more maturity.

Lisa
 
Exactly, more bread and circuses to distract from the day to day misery of unemployment, no growth in the economy along with an unsuccessful foreign policy that seems to have emboldened the nut in NoKo and Assad who continues to slaughter his own people.

Honestly the last thing people want to do is abdicate even more control over their lives to the government that created this mess in the first place. The proposed law served only to harrass and annoy law abiding gun owners with more checks and delays while not stopping the major source of gun deaths, handguns in the possession of violent gang bangers in places like POTUS’ hometown.

The irony that states and cities with very restrictive gun laws have been the site of mass shootings and street violence seems totally lost on a group of politicians who have a bad case of “do something-itis.” What they need to do is enforce the laws on the books now, focus on the hotspots like Chicago which seems to be ignored by POTUS when trying to get Joe Smith’s magazine clip reduced. Further the complete ignorance of some of the lawmakers like that dingbat who thought once you shot all your bullets out of the clip that the clip evaporated or something…SHEESH!

It’s the straitjacket of ideology where the facts do not matter once again. And POTUS was in rare form, flanked by his “props” and scolding the American people like bratty children.

Lisa
I thought the POTUS was scolding Washington, not the American people. And rightly so!
 
I thought the POTUS was scolding Washington, not the American people. And rightly so!
Why rightly so?

Because they wouldn’t pass a bad bill that would not accomplish anything? Even the supporters of the bill admitted would do nothing to prevent mass shootings and would do little or no good to prevent crime in general.
Well, this is odd. New York State Senator Ruben Diaz, Sr., while announcing that he had every intention of voting for S.2230, the draconian anti-gun “Democratic bill,” chided his fellow Democrats with a simple admonition: “It will not make a difference in the committing of crimes.”

“I assure you, nothing’s gonna change. We have lost respect for life, we have no respect and fear of God,” Diaz told the senate. “Not until we go back to those standards, nothing’s gonna control crime.”

“It’s the mind. It’s not the weapon, it’s not the revolver, it’s not the rifle. It’s the mind,” Diaz said as he concluded his remarks.
Well, this is odd. New York State Senator Ruben Diaz, Sr., while announcing that he had every intention of voting for S.2230, the draconian anti-gun “Democratic bill,” chided his fellow Democrats with a simple admonition: “It will not make a difference in the committing of crimes.”

“I assure you, nothing’s gonna change. We have lost respect for life, we have no respect and fear of God,” Diaz told the senate. “Not until we go back to those standards, nothing’s gonna control crime.”

“It’s the mind. It’s not the weapon, it’s not the revolver, it’s not the rifle. It’s the mind,” Diaz said as he concluded his remarks.
The study also concluded those weapons are not a major factor in deaths caused by firearms, nor would an “assault weapons” ban be effective.

“The existing stock of assault weapons is large, undercutting the effectiveness of bans with exemptions,” it said. “Therefore a complete elimination of assault weapons would not have a large impact on gun homicides.”

The report finds no significant link between “assault weapons” and murders.
 
Nice to see common sense in Washington. Who would’ve thunk it would come from the Democrat controled Senate?
 
I thought the POTUS was scolding Washington, not the American people. And rightly so!
It reminded me of how a father would talk to his child. Not how someone talks to a peer he is suppose to be trying to work with. As far as shameful, his record on protecting children born alive is what I’d call shameful.
 
It reminded me of how a father would talk to his child. Not how someone talks to a peer he is suppose to be trying to work with. As far as shameful, his record on protecting children born alive is what I’d call shameful.
Yes the irony of that reality seems to be lost on POTUS who lives in an ever shrinking bubble of pandering synchophants while the gun deaths in his adopted hometown provide a weekly Sandy Hook experience.

Lisa
 
I thought the POTUS was scolding Washington, not the American people. And rightly so!
meltzerboy are you in the straitjacket of ideology? Do you understand that the bill would not address the problems of a Sandy Hook? Do you realize that legislation would be an immediate target for the courts? What would be the point other than to pander to POTUS who thankfully is bleeding out influence?

Rep Diaz is right, we have no respect for life and this is manifested in many ways including gun violence. The turning needs to be of the mind and heart, not the choice of weapon.

Lisa
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top