Amazing, the flak that Della is receiving on this.
Great story about the Rosary, if indeed it is true. I, too, would like to see a past citation from the deceased Fr. Kerr. Shame on me!
Della is simply being prudent and just in an age of Internet easy believism. Might be good to review the cardinal virtures of Prudence and Justice (CCC 1806,1807).
The suggestion that Della “[q]uit raining on other people’s parades” is something I would expect from unbelievers who want to believe whatever truth is convenient for them. Truth does matter.
No, it doesn’t necessarily “hurt to believe that the Rosary might have saved the girl”.
But does it hurt to confirm the veracity of the story?
Personally, I tend to believe the report (though my own belief of course does not make the story true). The inclusion of the Rosary reference by blog editor Damian Thompson of The Telegraph is noteworthy, though even top editors of major news agency get things wrong on occassion.
Good thing the Bereans (Acts 17:10-12) didn’t live in today’s Internet age. Back in St. Paul’s time, their desire to “examine” and “see if these things were so” resulted in them being called “noble”. Today they might be called “party poopers”.
I think I’ll pray a Rosary now …