A
AlaricTeudisson
Guest
This is my first post. I would like to ask a basic question pertaining to how Catholics view those who call themselves Christians outside of the Catholic Church.
But first a little background. I was born into a Presbyterian church going family. I married and became a member of the Episcopal church. My wife has always leaned toward the Catholic church but she kind of defaulted to the Episcopal church since it had reformed theology (for my perceived comfort) and a liturgical worship practice which she liked. We periodically, maybe once or twice a year, attend Catholic mass on a Friday evening. I also have several close friends who are Catholic, via marrying Catholic girls, and we have had lots of discussions about faith issues. So, I am not completely ignorant about the Catholic Church.
After spending my first 36 years as a nominal Christian (i.e. in name only), the Holy Spirit finally got to me and convicted me about who Jesus was and what He did for me. I have always been an avid reader/researcher. After the call, I focused my energies on learning more about the Faith. I have read much of the Patristic writings, Catholic Catechism, Orthodox Catechism, later reformed theologians, Ray Brown, and NT Wright along with others. I consider myself a “conservative” “traditional” “creedal” Christian. We attend church regularly. I teach Sunday School and am involved in the leadership of my Parish. Also, I am not struggling with uniqueness of Christ, trinity issues, or anti-Catholic issues. Nor do I have problems with anything in the Creeds.
I do understand that these words don’t carry much weight with my Catholic brothers and sisters since calling yourself a Christian outside of the Catholic Church is perceived as problematic. But, I say this to point out that I am not a pro abortion, many paths to heaven type of protestant. I also acknowledge that my belief in the creeds does not hold a lot of water with Catholics either since you would most likely say (with validity) that I do not have the same meaning for some of the words. (For example, one holy Catholic and apostolic church means “Catholic Church” to you while I have always viewed that as the body of all believing Christians with Christ as the head.)
With the Episcopal Church falling into apostasy (I have Anglican in my moniker since saying your Episcopalian to most Catholics is like saying you’re Buddhist), my wife and I know that we will probably need to make a change soon. She is perfectly willing (and hoping) to go to the Catholic Church. Many of my fellow Episcopalians (Lay,Bishop, and Priest) have crossed over to the Catholic Church. Before my family makes such a move, I need to do some more investigating, so that is why I am here. I have been lurking for several weeks on the site and decided that it is time to participate a little more actively.
So much for the background….Now for my question. After reading many threads over the past few weeks, it seems that Protestants are held in less than high regard by many Catholics. In many cases it seems difficult for Catholics to acknowledge somebody outside the Church as Christian.
I realize that Catholics believe that they are members of the one true Church and only there do you find the fullness of truth in Christ. Here is my problem……I am reluctant to post in threads and participate if I am perceived by the majority of people here as non Christian. Am I no different to a Catholic than a Mormon or JW? I guess what I want to hear is this: Yes, we consider you a Christian, but you do not have the fullness or completeness of a relationship with Christ since you are not a member of the Catholic Church. I can deal with that. In other words, am I considered by the Catholic Church a wayward sheep or a goat?
Hopefully, this will not be an opinion thing, but a fact thing. The Church surely has a position on “outside” the Church Christians like me. Maybe the answer is…It depends on what you believe. Please don’t misunderstand me. I am not in search of affirmation. I really want to know how somebody like me is officially (and unofficially) viewed by the Church.
I appreciate all responses.
Jeff
But first a little background. I was born into a Presbyterian church going family. I married and became a member of the Episcopal church. My wife has always leaned toward the Catholic church but she kind of defaulted to the Episcopal church since it had reformed theology (for my perceived comfort) and a liturgical worship practice which she liked. We periodically, maybe once or twice a year, attend Catholic mass on a Friday evening. I also have several close friends who are Catholic, via marrying Catholic girls, and we have had lots of discussions about faith issues. So, I am not completely ignorant about the Catholic Church.
After spending my first 36 years as a nominal Christian (i.e. in name only), the Holy Spirit finally got to me and convicted me about who Jesus was and what He did for me. I have always been an avid reader/researcher. After the call, I focused my energies on learning more about the Faith. I have read much of the Patristic writings, Catholic Catechism, Orthodox Catechism, later reformed theologians, Ray Brown, and NT Wright along with others. I consider myself a “conservative” “traditional” “creedal” Christian. We attend church regularly. I teach Sunday School and am involved in the leadership of my Parish. Also, I am not struggling with uniqueness of Christ, trinity issues, or anti-Catholic issues. Nor do I have problems with anything in the Creeds.
I do understand that these words don’t carry much weight with my Catholic brothers and sisters since calling yourself a Christian outside of the Catholic Church is perceived as problematic. But, I say this to point out that I am not a pro abortion, many paths to heaven type of protestant. I also acknowledge that my belief in the creeds does not hold a lot of water with Catholics either since you would most likely say (with validity) that I do not have the same meaning for some of the words. (For example, one holy Catholic and apostolic church means “Catholic Church” to you while I have always viewed that as the body of all believing Christians with Christ as the head.)
With the Episcopal Church falling into apostasy (I have Anglican in my moniker since saying your Episcopalian to most Catholics is like saying you’re Buddhist), my wife and I know that we will probably need to make a change soon. She is perfectly willing (and hoping) to go to the Catholic Church. Many of my fellow Episcopalians (Lay,Bishop, and Priest) have crossed over to the Catholic Church. Before my family makes such a move, I need to do some more investigating, so that is why I am here. I have been lurking for several weeks on the site and decided that it is time to participate a little more actively.
So much for the background….Now for my question. After reading many threads over the past few weeks, it seems that Protestants are held in less than high regard by many Catholics. In many cases it seems difficult for Catholics to acknowledge somebody outside the Church as Christian.
I realize that Catholics believe that they are members of the one true Church and only there do you find the fullness of truth in Christ. Here is my problem……I am reluctant to post in threads and participate if I am perceived by the majority of people here as non Christian. Am I no different to a Catholic than a Mormon or JW? I guess what I want to hear is this: Yes, we consider you a Christian, but you do not have the fullness or completeness of a relationship with Christ since you are not a member of the Catholic Church. I can deal with that. In other words, am I considered by the Catholic Church a wayward sheep or a goat?
Hopefully, this will not be an opinion thing, but a fact thing. The Church surely has a position on “outside” the Church Christians like me. Maybe the answer is…It depends on what you believe. Please don’t misunderstand me. I am not in search of affirmation. I really want to know how somebody like me is officially (and unofficially) viewed by the Church.
I appreciate all responses.
Jeff