sex abuse

  • Thread starter Thread starter debraran
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ahhh.

Your preferred response is number 1:

“Protestants have molested kids too”

Like I said…

…
And you of course dodged the question.

Perhaps because your concern about the sex abuse scandal is precisely proportionate to how effective a vehicle it is for your anti-Catholicism?

Might want to check out those links, Atemi. A number of these cases occurred in Florida, you know.

It seems that such crimes are not the province of Catholicism alone, unfortunately.
 
I think what the poster meant, that any time you defer blame (“they do it too”) it seems like you are trying to diminish the sin. If a wayward spouse says, “A lot of guys cheat, look at the polls!” or “everyone takes something from work”, that makes it seem like you acknowledge it, but are trying to lessen it.

What angers me is that many bishops must have known, they talk and they pushed them around knowing they were not only hurting the children/teens, they were instilling lifelong memories. I was also surprised, even in cases where there wasn’t a lot of evidence, that many priests admitted it. Maybe a late conscience, but they did admit it. Most couldn’t deny it, although a few did. The ones that lied will pay the piper later, but if the iniital accusations weren’t filed, others wouldn’t follow.

The last thing that keeps me awake some nights, is that I know there were more that DIDN"T get caught. I have heard guys talk growing up about “funny brothers” and “funny priests” some very old now, some dead. I’m glad they didn’t get dragged into the mud, but it makes me wonder how much more worse it was maybe if caught earlier, it would have been even greater.
The only saving grace to me as a passionate “revert” is that they will be under a microscope now and children are much more savvy. Sure there are a lot of Catholic-bashers, but you have to admit, we give them a lot of fodder sometimes. Supporting the church is something I will continue doing, but if this happened again, I think I’d just support Jesus and leave the bureaucracy with the rest. : (
 
This is a Christian scandal, not simply a Catholic scandal. The common denominator seems to be America. Might be worth brooding over.

Now where may we find the evidence for Assertion # 3? I have yet to find any Catholic who would say such a thing, but perhaps I’m simply hanging with the wrong crowd.
 
All we can do is pay attention and make sure its not happening in our own parishes. I’m glad its out and those who were wronged have a voice and the Church is finally listening. I know I will never get the same.
We can pray and hope. I’m sorry to hear about your situation and commend your courage in sharing it. It’s important to note the very real human and spiritual cost of these crimes, and to keep that cost in mind as we punish those who perpetrate them and protect ourselves from them in the future.

May God bless and keep you always.
 
Sure there are a lot of Catholic-bashers, but you have to admit, we give them a lot of fodder sometimes. Supporting the church is something I will continue doing, but if this happened again, I think I’d just support Jesus and leave the bureaucracy with the rest. : (
True, but as we’ve seen with the ABCs (Anything But Catholics) even when the Church provides no fodder for their bigotry they simply make it up.

In every generation, the Church has had her challenges. It’s our lot to have this. May God help us to bear our cross as He bore His.
 
No, the response I chose happens to be factual.
Factual and irrelevant to the topic.

That is why it is so popular with too many Catholics. What better explanation and response than to point a finger? It is all too human.
This is a Christian scandal, not simply a Catholic scandal.
Yes and no.

Do all these events mar the reputation of the Christian faith? Yes.

Is it a scandal in the Catholic Church how many vile animals and child predators were protected, hidden, and empowered by those in the highest positions of authority in the RCC?

Yes.

That is not a scandal at my church. Sorry.

…
 
True, but as we’ve seen with the ABCs (Anything But Catholics) even when the Church provides no fodder for their bigotry they simply make it up.
Unfortunately, that is not the reality in this case.

I sincerely wish it was…but the lifelong suffering of who knows how many children and adults says my wish is not true.

…
 
Are you ignoring my question to you?
What question?

That there were multiple RC bishops responsible for the systematic protection, hiding, and empowerment of vile pedophiles within the RCC?

If we really have to go there, then yes, that can be wisely ignored. If not, please clarify your question.

…
 
I think what the poster meant, that any time you defer blame (“they do it too”) it seems like you are trying to diminish the sin. If a wayward spouse says, “A lot of guys cheat, look at the polls!” or “everyone takes something from work”, that makes it seem like you acknowledge it, but are trying to lessen it.
Yes.

These types of responses are all too common among too many Catholics. I do understand why, however. I am human, after all, and I’ve done the same myself on occasion.

But these types of replies and responses only further the damage done and further mar the Name of our Lord among the unbelievers.

They see right through all of this.
What angers me is that many bishops must have known, they talk and they pushed them around knowing they were not only hurting the children/teens, they were instilling lifelong memories.
Yes. Some knew.

Some probably didn’t care to know any more than the accusations before cleaning up.

“Reputation” and “face” are the key words here, IMO.
I was also surprised, even in cases where there wasn’t a lot of evidence, that many priests admitted it. Maybe a late conscience, but they did admit it. Most couldn’t deny it, although a few did. The ones that lied will pay the piper later, but if the iniital accusations weren’t filed, others wouldn’t follow.
God has a way of convicting us all.
The last thing that keeps me awake some nights, is that I know there were more that DIDN"T get caught. I have heard guys talk growing up about “funny brothers” and “funny priests” some very old now, some dead. I’m glad they didn’t get dragged into the mud, but it makes me wonder how much more worse it was maybe if caught earlier, it would have been even greater.
The problem here is that if it was not brought up and pursued by the secular world, we all probably would have never heard about it to this very day.

God has judged us with the world. That is a huge embarrassment from my perspective.

…
 
I do think also, as a Catholic that loves what our church can bring to an individual, that being “different” brings a lot of bad press if we fall. We say our priests are different, that they can change bread into the body and blood of Jesus (through the holy spirit and holy orders) we say, the priests can hear confession and absolve our sins, we say as Catholics, our priests are holier, not marrying and sacrificing that part of their humaness, the list can go on…the point is the higher you are, the harder you fall.
I think the maginifiying of the shame for me (also being human) was that “specialness” was tarnished. It made it seem like the priests didn’t believe in it either, the perpetrators or the enablers.

Again, like with any tragedy, diligence is required and having it known that forgiveness is there but you can’t hurt another and stay in your position. I try to mention the priests that are trying to do God’s work in my prayers under stress from the scandals…they need many prayers too not to get discouraged.
 
This was my question…

I would be interested in hearing more about your source on the accusations on the NUMBERS you call of it of the higher echelon. By numbers you seem to indicate quite a few…
Do you mean high percentage?
Do you have a specific number?
What source do you use for that?

Catholics here sure do defend the faith, but I don’t know one that does not also think the molestation and the cover up is a travesty.

But, please clarify what you mean by NUMBERS.
 
Derailing and off topic posts and responses have been edited or deleted. This is a discussion of how Catholics can and should respond to this issue and not a platform for debate or rhetoric.
MF
 
This was my question…

I would be interested in hearing more about your source on the accusations on the NUMBERS you call of it of the higher echelon. By numbers you seem to indicate quite a few…
Do you mean high percentage?
Do you have a specific number?
What source do you use for that?

Catholics here sure do defend the faith, but I don’t know one that does not also think the molestation and the cover up is a travesty.

But, please clarify what you mean by NUMBERS.
It seems every single one of my posts has been excised from this thread.

I am not at liberty to speak to your questions as it obviously would be a waste of my time if they will thus disappear and be edited out.

I obviously have to sit this one out, unfortunately.

…
 
This is not only a Catholic problem but a society problem. This problem is rampent in Protestent Churches and worse our public schools.

The Catholic Church gets all the attention naturally because of our special situation of how our Priests and the vows they take.
 
It seems every single one of my posts has been excised from this thread.

I am not at liberty to speak to your questions as it obviously would be a waste of my time if they will thus disappear and be edited out.

I obviously have to sit this one out, unfortunately.
I doubt that very seriously but I saw those posts and they actually did not even address the thread topic but you used them as a platform for another screed against the Catholic Church. When Catholics want to know how to respond to that topic, the last thing they need is just another such screed that has not even the integrity to address the same problem within n-C faith communities and society as a whole.

It’s called a balanced viewpoint. 🤷
This is not only a Catholic problem but a society problem. This problem is rampent in Protestent Churches and worse our public schools.

The Catholic Church gets all the attention naturally because of our special situation of how our Priests and the vows they take.
As well as the ever intrinsic a-C media bias.

If one is well read on this issue one can answer without having to be defensive, though in my experience, the only people who even bring this up are those already with some agenda to oppose or deride our Catholic faith. I cannot think of a single instance where this was not the case.
 
I agree that some people have an agenda, but there are quite a few that are just ignorant of the faith or the scandals and just repeat what they heard here and there. They are usually not very religious either, but I take it as an opportunity to try to educate when I can. Sometimes though, I am at a loss and I think the best thing I can do after reflecting on it, is to just say, Some bishops made a big mess of this, but hopefully in the future the church will have better responses and err on the side of caution. The gifts of the church aren’t the erring priests, but the wonderfuul ones that silently endured and gave us the sacraments.

I actually felt a little better hearing Fr. Corapi say he didn’t want to be a priest anymore when the scandals really hit the fan…the scorn and embarassment was great and he was humble enough to admit it mattered to him. Then he realized who his boss was and kept going. I guess I can say, "Jesus is the real boss, with very human workers, but nothing really explains the idiocy of the decisions made. I will try to always tell about the miracles though and the joy I receive from reading about the good things the church has done.
 
I doubt that very seriously but I saw those posts and they actually did not even address the thread topic but you used them as a platform for another screed against the Catholic Church. When Catholics want to know how to respond to that topic, the last thing they need is just another such screed that has not even the integrity to address the same problem within n-C faith communities and society as a whole.
Just about every post addressed the topic head on.

How Catholics should respond to these scandals is definitely not with finger pointing and excuses (which are the most poular retorts). If you want to continue to feed the flames of this issue, then you can keep on responding in that fashion if you like.

And why every idea that does not agree with your worldview is a “screed” is beyond me. You need to get over looking for “anti-Catholics” around every corner and in every bush. People do disagree with you, Michael, and when they say so, it does not automatically qualify as “screed.”

:rolleyes:

What is interesting is that I said nothing else other than what many wise Catholics have told me themselves. It seems that when a Protestant repeats Catholic sentiments it magically becomes “screed.”

What to do…
If one is well read on this issue one can answer without having to be defensive, though in my experience, the only people who even bring this up are those already with some agenda to oppose or deride our Catholic faith. I cannot think of a single instance where this was not the case.
Including those victims who keep coming out to report the abuse?

You do highlight the major problem in Catholicism today in regards to this issue:*** if you mention this at all with any critical aspect against the behavior of priests or bishops involved, then you are automatically an “anti-Catholic.”***

Like you said, only those who are anti-Catholics bring this up. This is the “don’t ask, don’t tell” mindset in too much of the Catholic world today, IMO.

If actual criticism of evil makes someone a bigot, what kind of world exactly is it that you seek?

…
 
[If actual **criticism of evil makes someone a bigot, what kind of world exactly is it that you seek?

…

I agree, you should be able to have criticism of the church without being “anti-catholic”. Even priests, if you ever catch them talking to each other, have their own criticisms, they discuss within their walls. We aren’t “stepford Catholics”.🙂 The fear of having their flock brought down from the too high platform they were put on, in part helped the bishops and other priests keep quiet. The same way a “funny uncle” was kept quiet even when abuse was happening in a home, they kept quiet, but they knew they were playing a chess game. There is a lot of shame associated with sexual abuse. In the 50’s and 60’s, if a child even alluded to abuse with a religious, he was probably told to shut up and maybe given a slap. I remember being told to just avoid so and so when I was a kid, rather than have to talk to anyone in question about it. Although our society is saturated in sex now, at least no one would feel as embarassed to tell earlier on.
Later, I think I can safely assume, the shortage played a big part in covering it up, but you still could have sent them away and doubled up, rather than have the abuse continue.I guess they prayed the victims would all just keep the secret and life would go on. As I said in another post, with all the teaching of “bad touch” with ANYONE, teachers, priests, coaches, etc. I hope this will not happen again or be addressed quickly.
I also think besides the emotional damage done to the victims and their families, much damage was done to some faithful that believed “they had a good one” when the scandals hit and then found out their priest was indicted too. That happened to my aunt…she was very hurt. He was their 20 years…what did that mean?
There was also a priest indicted this morning in my area for money embezzling. That wasn’t sexual, but still tests the trust you have for someone you thought was “above that”. Yesterday at work, someone told me a patient, Father “blank” tells the best dirty jokes…they loved him and there was a nice rapport going on. I asked if he was Catholic and they said Yes. Not a great thing, but you would think that wouldn’t be something a priest would want to be noted for. Nit-picking, maybe, but when you are listening to arrests and reading about them, you start to get depressed, especially if they are near you. I think I need to watch some good tapes, go on a nearby pilgrimage, something like that early next year. Sometimes you just need to get refreshed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top