Well, is it immoral?Wow, cutting off perfectly healthy body parts because you have a risk of them becoming cancerous is crazy IMO.
…] Except when performed for strictly therapeutic medical reasons, directly intended amputations, mutilations, and sterilizations performed on innocent persons are against the moral law.
I don’t think we know enough to say yes or no, and anyways even if we could, I don’t think we should say yes or no, because the next case is different from this one, and so onMerriam-Webster
Therapeutic
1: of or relating to the treatment of disease or disorders by remedial agents or methods
2: providing or assisting in a cure
I think this portion is regarding such procedures done against ones will or without the persons consent. IE infant and children, the mentally disabled or procedures enforced by the state.Except when performed for strictly therapeutic medical reasons, directly intended amputations, mutilations, and sterilizations performed on innocent persons are against the moral law.
Of course.prevention of cancer and ones life is justified
No, this applies to people doing it themselves voluntarily as well.I think this portion is regarding such procedures done against ones will or without the persons consent. IE infant and children, the mentally disabled or procedures enforced by the state.
to be fair, this is not the same as breast implants to give you more breasts, I cannot think of any woman that would have her breast and nipple cut off for any other reason…but u agree that it could be misunderstood in thinking getting a boob job was ok…Of course.
But we must be very careful, because such a statement can be taken very far into a very dangerous ground.
The end does not justify the means. Never.
For some women it is NOT crazy. I’m not being disrespectful but do some research on the issues here.Wow, cutting off perfectly healthy body parts because you have a risk of them becoming cancerous is crazy IMO. And I am a cancer survivor, it took 6 months of chemo to save my life. I still would never do what she did.
With all due respect, where did you get your medical degree? I think you are speaking about something of which you know nothing.Wow, cutting off perfectly healthy body parts because you have a risk of them becoming cancerous is crazy IMO. And I am a cancer survivor, it took 6 months of chemo to save my life. I still would never do what she did.
You are right. Mastectomy is the best course of action in some circumstances.With all due respect, where did you get your medical degree? I think you are speaking about something of which you know nothing.
Where did I make any medical claims. If you notice, I said IMO and said I wouldn’t do it myself.With all due respect, where did you get your medical degree? I think you are speaking about something of which you know nothing.
It’s not immoral, it’s just crazy. :whacky:Well, is it immoral?
Again, it’s not crazy in some circumstances. Look it up. A mastectomy is, sometimes, an appropriate route to take for a woman with the gene showing that she will very likely get cancer.It’s not immoral, it’s just crazy. :whacky:
Don’t know Sharon’s story, but often if a patient has had a previous malignant tumor removed from a breast and then later gets one in the second breast, double mastectomy is the course of treatment preferred by physicians. Perhaps this was true in her case. In any case, reconstructive surgery after mastectomy is a personal preference.Where did I make any medical claims. If you notice, I said IMO and said I wouldn’t do it myself.
I think you need to go back and reread my post. I’m not sure why you are the claiming I’m the one making medical claims when I didn’t at the same time you are the one making them. Are you unclear that IMO means in my opinion? And that I said I wouldn’t cut off HEALTHY body parts to prevent cancer? Your post here has nothing at all to do with what I said and additionally you are making assumptions about her supposed state of health.Don’t know Sharon’s story, but often if a patient has had a previous malignant tumor removed from a breast and then later gets one in the second breast, double mastectomy is the course of treatment preferred by physicians. Perhaps this was true in her case. In any case, reconstructive surgery after mastectomy is a personal preference.