Should I be okay with this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cojrio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For what it’s worth, this is problematic on many levels. To me this is almost as if you were walking past a bar, that a bunch of GUYS you both knew were going in, and she asked you if you didn’t mind waiting while she had a beer or two inside with those fellows AND didn’t wait to hear your answer. I mean she had to have those beers on that night when you couldn’t join in, on top of that it was agreed (from my understanding) that this was supposed to be an evening spent studying. Did you notice she had some kind of closer relationship/attraction with/to any of those guys? Let’s just say she’s not the most respectful and considerate person I’ve ever heard of. Of course my own judgement can be clouded by my insecurity and minimal self-esteem, I’ll grant you that. I hope you’re not passive aggressive, because if it were me, I’d find a way to subtly get back at her (overly complimenting/giving a shoulder massage to a girl she feels less beautiful than/intimidated by/in competition with and so on and so forth). Perhaps this is one isolated occurrence, but it would definitely stay in my mind for a considerable amount of time.
I didn’t read the part where the OP was not allowed to enter the drinking room. If you have insecurity and minimal self-esteem as well as a passive agressive personality, why are you giving people advice on whether his reaction is reasonable or not?
 
For what it’s worth, this is problematic on many levels. To me this is almost as if you were walking past a bar, that a bunch of GUYS you both knew were going in, and she asked you if you didn’t mind waiting while she had a beer or two inside with those fellows AND didn’t wait to hear your answer. I mean she had to have those beers on that night when you couldn’t join in, on top of that it was agreed (from my understanding) that this was supposed to be an evening spent studying. Did you notice she had some kind of closer relationship/attraction with/to any of those guys? Let’s just say she’s not the most respectful and considerate person I’ve ever heard of. Of course my own judgement can be clouded by my insecurity and minimal self-esteem, I’ll grant you that. I hope you’re not passive aggressive, because if it were me, I’d find a way to subtly get back at her (overly complimenting/giving a shoulder massage to a girl she feels less beautiful than/intimidated by/in competition with and so on and so forth). Perhaps this is one isolated occurrence, but it would definitely stay in my mind for a considerable amount of time.
That’s rude. It is much more rude than having a few beers with mutual friends when your boyfriend is studying. If any of my boyfriends massaged a girl for spite, they would have a black eye and be girlfriendless.
 
It isn’t uncommon in college for a group of people to be in the other room socializing while someone is in another room studying. I think you are upset for no reason. I met my husband in college and if he told me that he was upset because I had a few beers with his fraternity brothers while he was studying I would have gave him the I-think-you-are-being-ridiculous look. I also know that when boyfriends and girlfriends try to study together, they usually don’t. Not that you would do anything wrong, just studying isn’t always top priority.
I think you are either jealous because she was spending time with other boys or you are upset that you couldn’t have a beer when they could. Either way, I think you are upset for no reason.
I think this is a good summation.

I see no reason to be upset. Just sounds like a touch of jealousy I think. Sometimes when we get jealous, we need to ask ourselves “why am I jealous?” and “am I being reasonable?”. This happens to me (I married up, so to speak) and sometimes I determine that’s it’s something to discuss so my wife and I understand each other, and sometimes I work out that I’m just being unreasonable and letting jealousy get the better of me.

cojrio, any relationship worth having will encite some jealousy. It is up to you to be able to understand and control your own jealousy. Based on what you’ve described about this situation, I think you need to just acknowledge that you are jealous (which is natural), but not being reasonable.
 
We were planning on studying together, and instead she hung out with a group of guys in another room. Not sure why that one’s so hard to believe, or why everyone here is telling me that it’s super normal and shouldn’t upset me.
Well, you asked:
Should I be upset about this?
As well as:
How should I feel?
So, when you ask people whether they think you should/shouldn’t have been upset, and when you ask people how they think you should feel, they are going to, you know, tell you those things. I don’t think you wanted an honest answer to these questions so much as you wanted a little pat on the back that you were “right.”

I think I know how you feel, you want your feelings validated by us. Now, that is perfectly normal.

Look, I think it makes some sense that you felt this way, because you thought she backed out on plans that you made. Either she didn’t understand the plans, or she didn’t think they were that important, or she just got caught up in doing something else. That kind of stuff happens.

Either way, she apologized… that’s the key thing. She has said she’s sorry. Presumably this means, for your sake, that she doesn’t intend to do the same thing again, even if she didn’t see it as a big deal at the time. So she’s said she’s sorry. Why dwell on it? 🤷
 
Look, I think it makes some sense that you felt this way, because you thought she backed out on plans that you made. Either she didn’t understand the plans, or she didn’t think they were that important, or she just got caught up in doing something else. That kind of stuff happens.
If the “plan” was to study…well, she’s hardly the first student to find a convenient distraction from study! When I was at Uni, I found very creative ways to avoid study. If there are friends with beers nearby…that’s about as easy an excuse not to study as they come.

It’s the sort of “plan” a parent might get upset about their child breaking. I don’t think it’s the place of a boyfriend or girlfriend to police studying.

But as VeritasLuxMea notes, she apologised, so move on.
 
I didn’t read the part where the OP was not allowed to enter the drinking room. If you have insecurity and minimal self-esteem as well as a passive agressive personality, why are you giving people advice on whether his reaction is reasonable or not?
I didn’t read the part where it said I’m not allowed to post on CAF because I’m messed up, I bared it all for everyone to see, besides, being clueless and unable to read situations right is not reserved to people like me. AND, having gone in the room to enjoy a diet pop while the “adults” enjoyed adult drinks would have made the situation so much better and not the least awkward, I agree (not).
 
Thank you.

We’ve talked about it before, and **she has apologized **that my feelings got hurt, which is cool, but she doesn’t think she did anything wrong.

How would others feel about this? Should I be upset? What should I do to ease my own mind?
If the “plan” was to study…well, she’s hardly the first student to find a convenient distraction from study! When I was at Uni, I found very creative ways to avoid study. If there are friends with beers nearby…that’s about as easy an excuse not to study as they come.

It’s the sort of “plan” a parent might get upset about their child breaking. I don’t think it’s the place of a boyfriend or girlfriend to police studying.

But as VeritasLuxMea notes, she apologised, so move on.
Apologizing when you make it clear you don’t think you did anything wrong (and would likely do the same thing place in a similar situation) is worthless. It may have sounded like, “Look, I’m sorry if you have a thin skin, ok?” There is not an overflow of contrition involved here.
 
The reasons it made me feel bad:

We were planning on studying together, and instead she hung out with a group of guys in another room.
So she ditched you. Or that’s what it felt like, at least. I’d be upset too. I’ve had people give me the impression that they were going to spend time with me, and then not do it because seemingly something more fun came along. It hurts, and it’s unkind. Some people are more thoughtful about such things than others, though, and I know a number of social butterfly types who wouldn’t realize that they were doing something hurtful. When it’s a significant other, it is worse, because there is an expectation that you will be more mindful of each others interests and feelings than with friends.
She drank beer with them. I thought that was a pretty insensitive thing to do, considering her boyfriend, a minor, was in the other room. I think if she was even a little bit empathetic and respectful of my feelings, she would have realized that it was inappropriate, and that she would have hated it if the roles were reversed. Maybe I’m wrong in feeling like that.
I guess it depends on if you have been dying to drink beer, and she knows it. Then it would be like flaunting. But otherwise, the fact that she could drink and you couldn’t wouldn’t bother me. Are you upset/jealous/insecure because it was a bunch of guys? I can understand that. Beer can make people lower their inhibitions, and can make people be flirtatious. Is that a concern? Would it have been different if she was with a bunch of girls? These things would have made a difference to me. It is difficult to say, but she might understand better, if you explain how it mades you feel when this all happened (hurt, rejected, insecure about her caring about you, etc…).
 
Apologizing when you make it clear you don’t think you did anything wrong (and would likely do the same thing place in a similar situation) is worthless. It may have sounded like, “Look, I’m sorry if you have a thin skin, ok?” There is not an overflow of contrition involved here.
Perhaps this situation doesn’t require contrition. I don’t think she did anything “wrong” either. However, if she agreed to do something differently when she is clearly under no moral obligation to do so, than I would accept that and move on. Remember, these people aren’t married. She could just as easily dump him and look for someone better suited to her personality.
 
I didn’t read the part where it said I’m not allowed to post on CAF because I’m messed up, I bared it all for everyone to see, besides, being clueless and unable to read situations right is not reserved to people like me. AND, having gone in the room to enjoy a diet pop while the “adults” enjoyed adult drinks would have made the situation so much better and not the least awkward, I agree (not).
You can post all you want. I’m just saying, why would anyone consider it sound advice in the proper way to deal with the situation? The situation wouldn’t be awkward if one was less concerned about getting into the booze and more concerned about spending time conversing with friends. Mature people are able to center social interactions around friendship and mutual interests and not around getting sauced. That’s why you aren’t allowed to drink until you are 21. Theoretically, that’s the magic number where such maturity starts. Personally, I wouldn’t date a person who threw himself a pity party because he wasn’t 21 yet and had to drink soda, but it seems like the OP is less concerned about that and more concerned about the lack of attention he was getting. (Which is far more reasonable, in my opinion.)
 
It really wasn’t that I was dying for a beer. I’m 21 now and don’t really ever drink, even when I’m offered.

It was just the whole idea of “girlfriend having a beer with the guys in the other room” that really just made me uncomfortable. I thought it was inappropriate. Apparently that is not the case, which is fine, I just wanted to know whether it was something I should worry about, and I figured it wasn’t, so I wanted people to reaffirm that it isn’t something to worry about, which is what is happening. No I did not come here for a pat on the back, I did legitimately want to hear what other people thought about it, thank you.

I still think that it was a bit inconsiderate of my feelings, and if the roles were reversed, she would have been upset too. And yeah, y’all are probably right, jealousy does play into it. But honestly, I’m not controlling and don’t freak out every time she talks to another guy or anything like that. In this situation, is jealousy not at least mildly acceptable?

It’s true that she apologized but she didn’t think she did anything wrong. But she didn’t apologize for doing something wrong, she apologized for doing something that hurt my feelings. And it’s awesome of her to do so. And so of course I won’t dwell on it anymore.
 
It really wasn’t that I was dying for a beer. I’m 21 now and don’t really ever drink, even when I’m offered.

It was just the whole idea of “girlfriend having a beer with the guys in the other room” that really just made me uncomfortable. I thought it was inappropriate. Apparently that is not the case, which is fine, I just wanted to know whether it was something I should worry about, and I figured it wasn’t, so I wanted people to reaffirm that it isn’t something to worry about, which is what is happening. No I did not come here for a pat on the back, I did legitimately want to hear what other people thought about it, thank you.

I still think that it was a bit inconsiderate of my feelings, and if the roles were reversed, she would have been upset too. And yeah, y’all are probably right, jealousy does play into it. But honestly, I’m not controlling and don’t freak out every time she talks to another guy or anything like that. In this situation, is jealousy not at least mildly acceptable?

It’s true that she apologized but she didn’t think she did anything wrong. But she didn’t apologize for doing something wrong, she apologized for doing something that hurt my feelings. And it’s awesome of her to do so. And so of course I won’t dwell on it anymore.
That sounds very reasonable.
 
Really it depends in your girlfriend. If she’s the type to get flirty or touchy feely with or without alcohol then yes, I would be concerned. But if she’s that type of person why would you go through the headache of being with her anyway?

If she’s one of the guys it’s different. All of my close friends are male and I frequently hang out with a room full of them and drink beer and talk football and video games. My husband knew about this when we first started dating and it was one of the things he liked about me. If this is your girlfriend you should either move on if you can’t handle it, or try to embrace it. My husband loves that going out with my friends means beer, superhero movies, sports, and playing kickball or football in the park. He likes that I’m able to talk to his friends about genuine mutual interests. He isn’t jealous because he trusts and respects me and the guys I hang out with. It’s a pretty common joke when we go out that everyone must think that I’m the annoying girlfriend who tagged along for his guy time, when in reality he tagged along with me.
 
I still think that it was a bit inconsiderate of my feelings, and if the roles were reversed, she would have been upset too. And yeah, y’all are probably right, jealousy does play into it. But honestly, I’m not controlling and don’t freak out every time she talks to another guy or anything like that. In this situation, is jealousy not at least mildly acceptable?
Yes, those feelings are understandable and reasonable.

She has apologized, which is good. But she doesn’t think she did anything wrong. It seems that good people can disagree on whether or not her actions were objectively wrong. In such a case, where there is a grey area, and where it would have been very reasonable for her to say no to the guys with the beer and study with you in the other room like she said she would, then it was wrong because it was hurtful to you. You don’t want to beat this to death with her, but it might help her to see why she shouldn’t have a repeat of that night, if she sees how it was perceived, and how it affected your feelings. It is important in a relationship for people to be able to compromise based on care for the others feelings, even when you might have an objective disagreement. And assuming one’s significant other is not possessive and controlling (which I didn’t get from you at all), one should not want to do things that will evoke insecurity and jealousy in them.
 
But she doesn’t think she did anything wrong. It seems that good people can disagree on whether or not her actions were objectively wrong. In such a case, where there is a grey area, and where it would have been very reasonable for her to say no to the guys with the beer and study with you in the other room like she said she would, then it was wrong because it was hurtful to you.
I doubt that they had the conversation that night - or at least until the way home. So, I would agree with her - she has done nothing wrong - she didn’t realize that it would matter to him (and I wouldn’t have either).

But once she realized that it hurt his feelings - she apologized - not for doing something wrong - but for inadvertantly hurting him.
 
Yes, those feelings are understandable and reasonable.

And assuming one’s significant other is not possessive and controlling (which I didn’t get from you at all), one should not want to do things that will evoke insecurity and jealousy in them.
I just wanted to throw another perspective out there. Perhaps it is reasonable and understandable to feel jealous just because your girlfriend is hanging out with other guys, but it is also reasonable and understandable for a girl to be upset that her boyfriend doesn’t trust her enough to allow her to hang out with her friends just because they are guys. And, yes, I do realize the OP isn’t trying to be controlling, but if his jealousy is going to make it impossible for her to hang out with her guy friends just because they’re guys that will likely be felt as overly-restricting.

OP, I don’t at all think you are controlling, and obviously your gf should be considerate of your feelings, but I highly suggest you try to examine why you dislike your girlfriend hanging out with guys so much and see if you can’t work on changing that.
 
It really wasn’t that I was dying for a beer. I’m 21 now and don’t really ever drink, even when I’m offered.

It was just the whole idea of “girlfriend having a beer with the guys in the other room” that really just made me uncomfortable. I thought it was inappropriate. Apparently that is not the case, which is fine, I just wanted to know whether it was something I should worry about, and I figured it wasn’t, so I wanted people to reaffirm that it isn’t something to worry about, which is what is happening. No I did not come here for a pat on the back, I did legitimately want to hear what other people thought about it, thank you.

I still think that it was a bit inconsiderate of my feelings, and if the roles were reversed, she would have been upset too. And yeah, y’all are probably right, jealousy does play into it. But honestly, I’m not controlling and don’t freak out every time she talks to another guy or anything like that. In this situation, is jealousy not at least mildly acceptable?

It’s true that she apologized but she didn’t think she did anything wrong. But she didn’t apologize for doing something wrong, she apologized for doing something that hurt my feelings. And it’s awesome of her to do so. And so of course I won’t dwell on it anymore.
Jealousy is not something you can “decide”. You feel what you feel, and you decide what to do with your feelings. You can decide to look at other people in a different light or to distract yourself with other thoughts, but that sometimes doesn’t happen. Don’t punish yourself for your emotions, whatever the case. See your emotions as something you cope with, something you subordinate to your will in terms of how you act and what you’re going to allow, but not in terms of whether or not you will feel them.

If she told me she was going to study with me and then blew me off to socialize without asking if it was OK, that was not cool. If she said “I’ll help you if you want” and you only wanted her there when you saw she’d be doing something fun without you if she weren’t, well, that’s not quite fair of you, is it?

If she has a social gathering in a house and doesn’t arrange in advance for privacy when not everyone at the house is going to be welcome, that isn’t cool. (For instance, if you’re going to have some meeting at your house where your spouse is expected to wave “hi” and then make himself/herself scarce, then unless someone has asked for your private ear for serious reasons, that requires prior clearance or a serious and unforeseeable need for privacy, like a friend or family member in crisis who just dropped in on you.)

If she knows that it drives you nuts to be around people who are enjoying something you can’t have, it is not cool for her to spring that on you, especially in a place and at a time where you really aren’t free to go elsewhere. Still, it is more mature to give others the freedom to enjoy legitimate pleasures that aren’t available to you. Not everyone should be expected to refrain from eating bread just because you’ve been put on a gluten-free diet, for instance, and not everyone ought to go to bed early just because you have to get to work at dawn the next day.

Generally speaking, the spouse or maybe-spouse-to-be is always included in mixed-gender social gatherings, or at least invited. Opinions vary wildly about whether or not it is to be expected that such a gathering will or won’t bother one’s spouse. Although there are mixed-gender social situations that wise married people stay out of–never presume that you can’t possibly develop sexual feelings for someone who seemed in the past to be more like a sibling or become the object of romantic affection for them!–there isn’t really a single right answer, I’d advocate avoiding marriage to someone who has wildly different views than you do.
 
It really wasn’t that I was dying for a beer. I’m 21 now and don’t really ever drink, even when I’m offered.

It was just the whole idea of “girlfriend having a beer with the guys in the other room” that really just made me uncomfortable. I thought it was inappropriate. Apparently that is not the case, which is fine, I just wanted to know whether it was something I should worry about, and I figured it wasn’t, so I wanted people to reaffirm that it isn’t something to worry about, which is what is happening. No I did not come here for a pat on the back, I did legitimately want to hear what other people thought about it, thank you.

I still think that it was a bit inconsiderate of my feelings, and if the roles were reversed, she would have been upset too. And yeah, y’all are probably right, jealousy does play into it. But honestly, I’m not controlling and don’t freak out every time she talks to another guy or anything like that. In this situation, is jealousy not at least mildly acceptable?

It’s true that she apologized but she didn’t think she did anything wrong. But she didn’t apologize for doing something wrong, she apologized for doing something that hurt my feelings. And it’s awesome of her to do so. And so of course I won’t dwell on it anymore.
Actually, do. Is she the kind of person to dump you at the last minute because she found something more fun to do, I think we all know people who aren’t the least reliable, you can rely on them as long as nothing more exciting comes up. You expect them at 2h00, you’ll get a call at 2h15 saying they can’t make it for x reason. I may be off, but if it’s not a one-time occurrence, I’d ask myself if I’d be ok committing to such a person. I try to think of very confident guys who’d find themselves in the situation you were in, I can’t imagine how any of those guys could not feel some kind of rightful jealousy or resentment. Call off a candle light dinner at the last minute when she’s 8 months pregnant and go to an activity she can’t do with a bunch of girls that you both know. And text her throughout the evening to tell her what she’s missing out on. And give a half-as*ed apology afterwards. “I’m sorry you felt that way” is a way to not apologize while trying to make it sound like one does. So what she did do and the unsincere apologies are pale red flags to me. You wanted opinions, you’ve got a whole bunch of 'em.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top