should i bow to a Buddha image?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tractarian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
space ghost:
I can see you saluting the flag, i can see you bowing to the Queen of England given the opportunity to meet her…
Space Ghost, you’ve found the one extreme for me.

I would rather take a bullet in the head than bow to the Queen of England. I would bow to the Queen of Thailand, though…
 
Also, if you walked into a church in Thailand, you may find people there taking off their shoes before entering. In the United States, we would never think of taking off our shoes. It’s a cultural practice. Here, we show respect with proper shoes, there, we show respect by taking them off.
 
I am originally from South Dakota. In some of the very small town churches there it is customary to take of your shoes but that is because many of them are coming from the farm. Very muddy – amongst other things.

My Grandfather used to talk about it. He got upset because he felt that people should have their chores done the night before so that they need to work on the Sabbath.
 
40.png
Shibboleth:
…a difficult question that all comes to the intent of the bow…

…as long as you are not doing the bowing as an act of worship you are not doing anything wrong.
It is my understanding that Buddhists do not worship Buddha as a deity. When they bow, it is out of respect for Buddha. Had Buddhism developed in the West, they likely would salute Buddha instead of bowing.

Buddhists do not answer the question of whether God exists or not. Therefore they do not worship any being.
 
40.png
tractarian:
… I do not regard Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, as any kind of religious figure per se. I see him as a philosopher, on par with Plato and Aristotle, not with Jesus. Most Buddhists i’ve met would probably agree with that.
To answer your question, if you respect Buddha, bow. If not, don’t.

That’s sounds easier than it really is I suppose. If you do not respect what he stands for (it is not Catholic teaching) this is one reason not to bow.

If you respect Buddha for another reason (let’s say positive impact on people/society or historical reasons) then perhaps this is a reason to bow.

For myself, I do not think I would bow. Of course this would be consistent with my cultural understanding.
 
40.png
tractarian:
It’s odd how the Zen Buddhists and the Christian Fundamentalists have one random thing in common: shocking iconoclastic attitude.
I never thought about that before, but neither really seems to have much use for structure.
 
My Grandfather used to talk about it. He got upset because he felt that people should have their chores done the night before so that they need to work on the Sabbath.
He obviously didn’t milk cows. That has to be done twice daily 7 days a week come rain or shine.
 
40.png
Harland:
He obviously didn’t milk cows. That has to be done twice daily 7 days a week come rain or shine.
He had cows but I do not know if they were the milking kind. He could have almost been considered a Puritan. To him working on the Sabbath was a sin. He understood why people did it he just did not like it. From what I understand he did not consider Sunday into effect until the sun rose, so he would go out on the farm until sun up on Sunday.

He was a good man, just very strict in his beliefs. He also admitted many times that some of his morals and beliefs should only apply to him.
 
space ghost:
I can see you saluting the flag, i can see you bowing to the Queen of England given the opportunity to meet her…
being a republican mick, i’d never suggest bowing in front of that woman.

thanks for listening, love and peace, terry

(i hope everyone gets the irish humor.)
 
Auberon Quin:
Space Ghost, you’ve found the one extreme for me.

I would rather take a bullet in the head than bow to the Queen of England. I would bow to the Queen of Thailand, though…
Whoa, looks like we have anti-Brit in the house. Sounds distinctively… Irish. Am I correct?
 
Archbishop 10-K:
Whoa, looks like we have anti-Brit in the house. Sounds distinctively… Irish. Am I correct?
Me? IRISH? Nononononono. I’m, uh, Lithuanian. Every March 17th we get together and dye the river in our city emerald brown in honor of our patron saint, St. Patr… uh… Casimir. Then we drink lots of Lithuanian beverages such as beer, and we wear silly green hats in honor of the Battle of Fluxno, where we beat back the Tartar invaders in 1223.

I despise the queen for her corgis, silly hats, and support of the vile sport of horse racing. My purported ethnic origin has nothing to do with it. All Lithuanians love the Queen and pray daily that she, her family, and her loyal ministers may be gathered into the loving arms of almighty God.

Soon.
 
Don’t Japanese people bow when greeting each other? Which one is the pagan? (he who bows last???)

What is wrong with showing respect? Buddhists do not worship statues, why should you?

much lovingkindness,
Buddha-Full
 
Think about this really hard!! :hmmm: If you bow to Buddah, would they bow to any of your saints, or make the sign of the cross when passing by a Catholic Church? Your first instinct is usually right. :yup: You are being tested. Many people are afraid of what others might think of them if they do not do what is code. :getholy:
 
40.png
tractarian:
I am ambivalent about whether i should do the same when i make my trip and visit a temple.:o I do not regard Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, as any kind of religious figure per se. I see him as a philosopher, on par with Plato and Aristotle, not with Jesus. Most Buddhists i’ve met would probably agree with that
I think Shibboleth summed it up pretty well. And I think several others here have expounded very welll on this point. Thais bow to each other all the time as a sign of respect. Bowing to a statue of the Buddha should be taken as such as well. And as you said, the Buddha was a great man, a philosopher. So, you are not revering or worshiping him any more than any other living person you pay respect to.

I think you are very wise to examine the cultural practices of the land yuu plan to visit.
 
I think you are very wise to examine the cultural practices of the land yuu plan to visit.
If you’re sitting on the floor don’t point your feet at anyone.
Don’t touch anyone on the head.
Shorts and such are a no no when visiting temples.
 
I would never in a gazillion years bow down before a statue of Buddha - worship or no. He may have been a good man but Jesus said, “He who is not with me is against me.” Luke 11:23 and I’m on HIS side. <>< CM
 
I could see bowing to a Japanese person as a greeting but to bow to a statue is a form of worship.

I think to bow to a Bhuddist statue is to deny Jesus. Do not do it.
 
Tractarian…to bow or not to bow. Why would you bow? To show respect to this statue? To acknowledge that you understand the customs of the land you are visiting?

I grew up in Japan (honto! 🙂 ) and much of their culture has been ingrained in me. There are things I do that are Japanese in flair - like never counting change handed to me - and I did not know that it was considered a taboo thing (by Japanese standards) to do until I was an adult and read about it by a foreign writer writing about Japan.

If I were to revisit Japan and go to Mejii Shrine, which I used to visit as a child, I would probably bow to the statues there and say a silent prayer…but the prayer would not be to the statue, it would be to Our Lord, Jesus.

When I was a child we went to the Shrine like all good Japanese people do on New Years Day…it was just part of my growing up culture. We bowed then and so, in some respects, I think I would feel rather ‘rude’ not to bow now.

I am sure this has made things as clear as mud :whacky: …and I will bet that you will either bow or not bow…As for my recommendation - do what ever feel right at the moment. You know that Jesus is God - that is what is important.

God Bless - and have a wonderful trip!
 
40.png
Greg_McPherran:
I could see bowing to a Japanese person as a greeting but to bow to a statue is a form of worship.

I think to bow to a Bhuddist statue is to deny Jesus. Do not do it.
I bow, kneel and prostrate myself in front of statues and icons of Our Savior and Mary all the time. And I am not worshiping the statues at all. I am bowing to the divine nature of those who these objects represent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top