Show me where - Another Eucharist Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter guanophore
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Good for you Zundrah! And you used the relevant words, which are “Christ performed”…

Worship in Spirit and in Truth is worship as Christ performed it. The amanesis is a performance - a ritual - a “doing”.

This is one reason Catholics do not consider praise and sermons as True Worship. True Worship only occurs in Eucharist.
How can I just grasp the Eucharist? It’s too hard to just suddenly recognise it as a “must”, if I have already found Christ outside of the church!
 
Yes, here I am! :cool: Hello, my ‘little’ friend. 😛
Hahahaha I guess I am not as little as you think I am 😃
I see the act as a remembrance of Christ but not as an essencial sacrament.
Oh ok. Well anyways, I guess you have read the Gospel of St. John chapter 6 as well as the various commentaries about that, about how it supports the doctrine of the Holy Eucharist. I’ll let you read a guy named Socrates’ excellent website about this, but since the AOL Hometown has been down due to the economic recession, I have to point you to the webarchive of it:

1st part: web.archive.org/web/20080525210731/http://members.aol.com/SocratesMG/index10a.html

2nd part (the link in the webpage above does not work): web.archive.org/web/20080527034020/http://members.aol.com/SocratesMG/index10b.html

But briefly, the thing about John chapter 6 that convinced me long ago of the Holy Eucharist’s importance is the end of that chapter. For it says:

Jesus answered them, “Did I not choose you, the twelve, and one of you is a devil?” He spoke of Judas the son of Simon Iscariot, for he, one of the twelve, was to betray him.
John 6:70-71

Where will Judas be again associated with a devil/Satan in St. John’s Gospel? In the Last Supper, John chapter 13.

And during supper, when the devil had already put it into the heart of Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, to betray him (John 13:2)

…

[21]When Jesus had thus spoken, he was troubled in spirit, and testified, “Truly, truly, I say to you, one of you will betray me.”
[22] The disciples looked at one another, uncertain of whom he spoke.
[23] One of his disciples, whom Jesus loved, was lying close to the breast of Jesus;
[24] so Simon Peter beckoned to him and said, “Tell us who it is of whom he speaks.”
[25] So lying thus, close to the breast of Jesus, he said to him, “Lord, who is it?”
[26] Jesus answered, “It is he to whom I shall give this morsel when I have dipped it.” So when he had dipped the morsel, he gave it to Judas, the son of Simon Iscariot.
[27] Then after the morsel, Satan entered into him. Jesus said to him, “What you are going to do, do quickly.”
John 13:21-27 (RSV)

Curious, ain’t it?
 
Hahahaha I guess I am not as little as you think I am 😃
Well, I am most likely smaller than you! 😛
Oh ok. Well anyways, I guess you have read the Gospel of St. John chapter 6 as well as the various commentaries about that, about how it supports the doctrine of the Holy Eucharist. I’ll let you read a guy named Socrates’ excellent website about this, but since the AOL Hometown has been down due to the economic recession, I have to point you to the webarchive of it:

1st part: web.archive.org/web/20080525210731/http://members.aol.com/SocratesMG/index10a.html

2nd part (the link in the webpage above does not work): web.archive.org/web/20080527034020/http://members.aol.com/SocratesMG/index10b.html

But briefly, the thing about John chapter 6 that convinced me long ago of the Holy Eucharist’s importance is the end of that chapter. For it says:

Jesus answered them, “Did I not choose you, the twelve, and one of you is a devil?” He spoke of Judas the son of Simon Iscariot, for he, one of the twelve, was to betray him.
John 6:70-71

Where will Judas be again associated with a devil/Satan in St. John’s Gospel? In the Last Supper, John chapter 13.

And during supper, when the devil had already put it into the heart of Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, to betray him (John 13:2)

…

[21]When Jesus had thus spoken, he was troubled in spirit, and testified, “Truly, truly, I say to you, one of you will betray me.”
[22] The disciples looked at one another, uncertain of whom he spoke.
[23] One of his disciples, whom Jesus loved, was lying close to the breast of Jesus;
[24] so Simon Peter beckoned to him and said, “Tell us who it is of whom he speaks.”
[25] So lying thus, close to the breast of Jesus, he said to him, “Lord, who is it?”
[26] Jesus answered, “It is he to whom I shall give this morsel when I have dipped it.” So when he had dipped the morsel, he gave it to Judas, the son of Simon Iscariot.
[27] Then after the morsel, Satan entered into him. Jesus said to him, “What you are going to do, do quickly.”
John 13:21-27 (RSV)

Curious, ain’t it?
Ahh, see, didn’t Christ give his “communion/ Eucharist” also to Judas?
 
hmmm…

What do you think “no salvation oustide the Church” means?

It is true that it is the Sacrifice of Christ on the cross, made present to us in the celebration of the Eucharist, is the means by which we are saved. No one is saved outside of this sacrifice, and it is it’s essence, remememberd in the Catholic Mass that enables people everywhere to come to salvation.
Are you talking about the passover sacrifice! The lamb that HAD TO BE EATEN!?
 
Are you talking about the passover sacrifice! The lamb that HAD TO BE EATEN!?
…yes, yes, the meat had to be eaten in order for those Isrealites to survive, otherwise they would have lost their first born son’s too just like the Egyptians!?

They had to follow Moses’s instructions on how that years passover was to be done;

…if you didn’t eat the lambs meat then you died! So now catholics believe that if you do not eat of the meat of God’s lamb (Christ) then you also will be left for dead on the last day (the second coming)!? Is that accurate?

…see Guanpohre, I am not so ignorant after all!
 
Yes, the lamb had to be eaten.
But if the Eucharist is seen in the same light as that Egyptian passover (if you MUST do it), then surely those who did not have communion after that year in Egypt will go to hell? But communion was only done AFTER Christ’s coming… so there was no salvation between that point of Egypt and up to Christ appearance?
 
Well, I am most likely smaller than you! 😛
Ahehehe…but don’t worry I don’t mind someone calling me little 😃
Ahh, see, didn’t Christ give his “communion/ Eucharist” also to Judas?
Yep, Jesus gave the One Bread to Judas…but did Judas believe that what he was receiving in the Last Supper was the Bread of Life that Jesus said in chapter 6?

Jesus said: “But there are some of you that do not believe.” For Jesus knew from the first who those were that did not believe, and who it was that would betray him. (John 6:64)

Remember what St. Paul said:

[27] Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord** in an unworthy manner** will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord.
[28] Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup.
[29] For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment upon himself.
[30] That is why many of you are weak and ill, and some have died.
1 Corinthians 11:27-30 (RSV)

Now, if the Eucharist is not important, then why are the consequences of taking It in an unworthy manner so dire?
 
…yes, yes, the meat had to be eaten in order for those Isrealites to survive, otherwise they would have lost their first born son’s too just like the Egyptians!?

They had to follow Moses’s instructions on how that years passover was to be done;

…if you didn’t eat the lambs meat then you died! So now catholics believe that if you do not eat of the meat of God’s lamb (Christ) then you also will be left for dead on the last day (the second coming)!? Is that accurate?
More accurately, If you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Life in heaven requires the life-giving source of God in us, it is lost by sin, that is why were subject to death. “this day you shall die” said God to Adam, but Adam lived a long time after. It is the loss of God’s life in us. This life is called sanctifying grace. Without eating Jesus who calls himself “the life,” we have no life. He is our life.

**“For he is the life according to his nature as God, and when he became united to his flesh, he made it also to be life-giving”- **Letter of Cyril
 
How can I just grasp the Eucharist? It’s too hard to just suddenly recognise it as a “must”, if I have already found Christ outside of the church!
This is an excellent question, and one with which many of us have grappled over various doctrines. Our response should be the same as Peter’s in Jn. 6. He did not understand Jesus either (it was a mystery that had not yet been revealed) but Peter acted in faith. Jesus asked the Apostles “will you also walk away”? Peter said “to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life”. We walk by faith, not by sight, and since we know that Jesus has the words of eternal life, we cling to Him in faith, that all will be revealed in the proper time. It was quite some time before the Apostles were in the upper room, and finally understood what His sayings really meant.

Besides, what makes you think you have found Christ outside of the Church? You have found Christ THROUGH the Church. Those who are born again to a living hope introduced you to Him!
…yes, yes, the meat had to be eaten in order for those Isrealites to survive, otherwise they would have lost their first born son’s too just like the Egyptians!?

They had to follow Moses’s instructions on how that years passover was to be done;

…if you didn’t eat the lambs meat then you died! So now catholics believe that if you do not eat of the meat of God’s lamb (Christ) then you also will be left for dead on the last day (the second coming)!? Is that accurate?

…see Guanpohre, I am not so ignorant after all!
By golly, I think you got it!

All Catholics have believed this since the time of the Aposltes. We find this in the writings of the Early fathers.

During the Reformation, believers lost the Apostolic succession (valid priesthood) so they re-inventeed the meaning of the Lord’s Supper so they could still follow the form of Godliness.
 
Are you talking about the passover sacrifice! The lamb that HAD TO BE EATEN!?
Absolutely. One cannot understand the Passover meal where Eucharist was changed unless one first understands the sacrifice of the lamb. If you study this in the bk. of Genesis, it will help you understand.
 
Ahehehe…but don’t worry I don’t mind someone calling me little 😃

Yep, Jesus gave the One Bread to Judas…but did Judas believe that what he was receiving in the Last Supper was the Bread of Life that Jesus said in chapter 6?

Jesus said: “But there are some of you that do not believe.” For Jesus knew from the first who those were that did not believe, and who it was that would betray him. (John 6:64)

Remember what St. Paul said:

[27] Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord** in an unworthy manner** will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord.
[28] Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup.
[29] For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment upon himself.
[30] That is why many of you are weak and ill, and some have died.
1 Corinthians 11:27-30 (RSV)

Now, if the Eucharist is not important, then why are the consequences of taking It in an unworthy manner so dire?
…I don’t know how to refute that… other than to say this;

1 - Those who called them selves christians but did not fully recieve Christ.
2 - Those who done the “acts” but did not go in “spirit”.

…therefore the got ill or even died?
More accurately, If you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Life in heaven requires the life-giving source of God in us, it is lost by sin, that is why were subject to death. “this day you shall die” said God to Adam, but Adam lived a long time after. It is the loss of God’s life in us. This life is called sanctifying grace. Without eating Jesus who calls himself “the life,” we have no life. He is our life.

**“For he is the life according to his nature as God, and when he became united to his flesh, he made it also to be life-giving”- **Letter of Cyril
Once again, it sounds to me as though He was talking in spirit;

1 - Eat his flesh; Accept his death as a sacrifice for your sins. He was everybodies lamb.

2 - Drink his blood; Walk in the same suffering and persicution as he did, e.g. “Abba, Father, take this cup away from me…”
 
This is an excellent question, and one with which many of us have grappled over various doctrines. Our response should be the same as Peter’s in Jn. 6. He did not understand Jesus either (it was a mystery that had not yet been revealed) but Peter acted in faith. Jesus asked the Apostles “will you also walk away”? Peter said “to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life”. We walk by faith, not by sight, and since we know that Jesus has the words of eternal life, we cling to Him in faith, that all will be revealed in the proper time. It was quite some time before the Apostles were in the upper room, and finally understood what His sayings really meant.
This has some truth in it, and you are making me reconsider my doubts.
Besides, what makes you think you have found Christ outside of the Church? You have found Christ THROUGH the Church. Those who are born again to a living hope introduced you to Him!
But I became a christian before I was drawn towards the CC!?
 
Absolutely. One cannot understand the Passover meal where Eucharist was changed unless one first understands the sacrifice of the lamb. If you study this in the bk. of Genesis, it will help you understand.
I know that a lamb was used as sacrifice to pay for one person, or one families sins. Christ was the lamb for the world rather than just for one person or one family.

…unblemished lamb, with no broken bones and it had to be the first born = Christ 😃
 
it sounds to me as though He was talking in spirit;

1 - Eat his flesh; Accept his death as a sacrifice for your sins. He was everybodies lamb.

2 - Drink his blood; Walk in the same suffering and persicution as he did, e.g. “Abba, Father, take this cup away from me…”
If that is what he meant and he said “you must eat my flesh.” and thousands of disciples start walking away, he would be morally obligated to say “No wait! don’t leave, I’m speaking only figuratively.” But he didn’t do that.

I think you will be hard pressed to find one Christian before the 16th century who believed eating the Lamb means accepting his death on the cross in your mind. Even Luther, a reformation father, believed in the real presence of Christ’s flesh and blood. He showed us what he meant for us to do when he broke bread, and said eat. and they ate. He blessed the cup and said drink. this is what he meant.
 
If that is what he meant and he said “you must eat my flesh.” and thousands of disciples start walking away, he would be morally obligated to say “No wait! don’t leave, I’m speaking only figuratively.” But he didn’t do that.

I think you will be hard pressed to find one Christian before the 16th century who believed eating the Lamb means accepting his death on the cross in your mind. Even Luther, a reformation father, believed in the real presence of Christ’s flesh and blood. He showed us what he meant for us to do when he broke bread, and said eat. and they ate. He blessed the cup and said drink. this is what he meant.
…okay, I get it.

But until next time = I’ve gotta go now…

(thanks)
 
…I don’t know how to refute that… other than to say this;

1 - Those who called them selves christians but did not fully recieve Christ.
2 - Those who done the “acts” but did not go in “spirit”.

…therefore the got ill or even died?
Everyone eventually gets ill and die…what is important to note is that St. Paul says “many”: “many of you are weak and ill, and some have died.” A church in which many of its members becomes weak and ill at more or less the same time is a weak and ill church. In other words, a church which does not honor the Holy Eucharist in a worthy manner becomes weak and ill, and may even die.

Now, compare the Catholic Church and all the other Orthodox Churches with the Protestant Churches. The Catholic and Orthodox Churches have honored the Holy Eucharist much more than almost every Protestant Church. And the previous have endured for the past 2000 years, while the latter since almost 500 years ago have disintegrated into so many pieces…and it is not unusual to hear a Protestant Church even cease to exist because of various reasons.

The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread.
1 Corinthians 10:16-17
 
…I don’t know how to refute that… other than to say this;

1 - Those who called them selves christians but did not fully recieve Christ.
2 - Those who done the “acts” but did not go in “spirit”.

…therefore the got ill or even died?

Once again, it sounds to me as though He was talking in spirit;

1 - Eat his flesh; Accept his death as a sacrifice for your sins. He was everybodies lamb.

2 - Drink his blood; Walk in the same suffering and persicution as he did, e.g. “Abba, Father, take this cup away from me…”
These metaphors are certainly applicable. Yet He incorporated them into a ritual that was physical. He made the bread and wine into His Very Body and Blood. Only those persons who do your #'1 and 2 above can partake in a worthy manner.

Jesus used many metaphors about Himself. He referred to Himself as the Door, the Sheepgate, the Vine, etc. This is the only time He brought the metaphor into the physical realm. He is the Living Bread which came down from heaven.
 
The Eucharist is hard because we cannot see it’s reality with our eyes but just because
we can’t see it doesnt make it less real.

Look at us … we are embodied soul. We can see our bodies but not our souls
but that doesnt make our souls any less real or our bodies more real than our
souls. We, as Christians, take this by faith … even though we probably have never seen
a soul.

We are made up of natural and supernatural elements … since we are both
body and soul. That is what the Eucharist is … natural and supernatural.
We are able to see the natural … it looks like bread and wine but we are not able to
see the supernatural truth of what it really is.

You cannot make yourself see this supernatural element …it will never work if you
use your eyes or even your mind … it must be revealed by the Father.

I don’t know why some can “see” it and some cannot but we do know that “ask and you shall receive”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top