Sin to sleep with girlfriend?

  • Thread starter Thread starter thomasemmanuel
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
While it is a near occasion of sin and highly inadvisable to do such barring extreme circumstances it is not actually sinful.

For the people claim a near occasion is sin is sin read this:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=177586&highlight=near+occasion+of+sin
I am a little surprised by this answer.

In general, theologians draw a line between “remote occasions”, in which the danger of sin is slight, and “proximate occasions”, in which the danger is probable (for a typical person). Most theologians argue that there is a moral obligation to avoid proximate occasions and to deliberately/voluntarily put oneself in a proximate occasion of sin is in itself a sin.

For more, see here: newadvent.org/cathen/11196a.htm
 
I am a little surprised by this answer.

In general, theologians draw a line between “remote occasions”, in which the danger of sin is slight, and “proximate occasions”, in which the danger is probable (for a typical person). Most theologians argue that there is a moral obligation to avoid proximate occasions and to deliberately/voluntarily put oneself in a proximate occasion of sin is in itself a sin.

For more, see here: newadvent.org/cathen/11196a.htm
I too was surprised. I find it hard to believe that it’s not sinful to sleep in the same bed as a woman whom you are presumably attracted to.
 
Hi!

Let’s say that I slept over at my girlfriend’s room, in the same bed. We did nothing else except sleep. Have I committed a sin?

I’ve read various other threads about this topic, so I’d like to clarify:
  1. here, I’ve ALREADY slept in the same bed as her, and we did nothing except sleep.
  2. I am not asking about whether it is inappropriate, or whether it is a near occasion for sin. I am asking if it is an ACTUAL sin.
  3. No one else knew about us sleeping in the same bed, so there is no scandal.
Thank you, I await your answers.
Ask your confessor…

Peace
James
 
If, on the outside chance, you were only looking to “prove your point” to the members of this forum, I ask why is it important what we think?
I do not feel guilty, and I am not attempting to start an argument. My intention is (as is the purpose of a forum) to discuss. I am grateful for all answers.

I think there’s some confusion about “near occasion of sin”
A near occasion of sin isn’t a sin but an occasion where one may be tempted. To put oneself in such a situation is imprudent, but not sinful in itself. However, if one deliberately puts oneself in such a situation in the hope of sinning, one has already sinned by willing to sin. Sin begins with the will to sin.
Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.
As Fr Serpa says, the sin is putting oneself in a situation AND HOPING to sin. It is not simply deliberately putting oneself in a particular situation, there must be an INTENTION that sin occurs.

For example, deliberately holding a rifle in my hand might well be a near occasion to sin (because I might be tempted to shoot my enemies). But it is not a sin, unless I hold the rifle HOPING to shoot my enemy.

Likewise, deliberately sleeping in the same bed as my girlfriend might well be a near occasion to sin (because I might be tempted to have intercourse). But it is not a sin, unless I sleep in that bed HOPING to have intercourse.
 
While it is a near occasion of sin and highly inadvisable to do such barring extreme circumstances it is not actually sinful.

For the people claim a near occasion is sin is sin read this:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=177586&highlight=near+occasion+of+sin
This is what I thought too. It’s not a sin, per se, but it definitely puts you at risk. If you slept next to her with the intention of becoming aroused or hoping something more would happen, that would most definitely be a sin.

However, I find it very shocking that anyone could sleep in the same bed next to someone they are very attracted to and not be turned on…I certainly would not feel comfortable putting myself or my boyfriend in such a situation. Even if I wasn’t tempted or anything, how would I know he wasn’t. I care too much about him and his soul to do such a thing to him.

If you love her, you should sleep on the couch 😉
 
Hi!

Let’s say that I slept over at my girlfriend’s room, in the same bed. We did nothing else except sleep. Have I committed a sin?

I’ve read various other threads about this topic, so I’d like to clarify:
  1. here, I’ve ALREADY slept in the same bed as her, and we did nothing except sleep.
  2. I am not asking about whether it is inappropriate, or whether it is a near occasion for sin. I am asking if it is an ACTUAL sin.
  3. No one else knew about us sleeping in the same bed, so there is no scandal.
Thank you, I await your answers.
We do not know if you committed the sin of lust or if you caused her to lust?
 
For example, deliberately holding a rifle in my hand might well be a near occasion to sin (because I might be tempted to shoot my enemies). But it is not a sin, unless I hold the rifle HOPING to shoot my enemy.

Likewise, deliberately sleeping in the same bed as my girlfriend might well be a near occasion to sin (because I might be tempted to have intercourse). But it is not a sin, unless I sleep in that bed HOPING to have intercourse.
Or if you hold the rifle and fantasize about killing them…

It is also a sin to sleep next to her and think about sexual activity with her. Purity is not only in the body, but in the mind and heart as well. Be careful sweetie. Things can happen in the heat of the moment that you could really regret! :eek:
 
We do not know if you committed the sin of lust or if you caused her to lust?
It is also a sin to sleep next to her and think about sexual activity with her. Purity is not only in the body, but in the mind and heart as well. Be careful sweetie. Things can happen in the heat of the moment that you could really regret! :eek:
Indeed, this is not merely about having sex. The fact that you didnt have sex doesn’t mean other sins weren’t committed by you and/or her.
Question : and if there is no “near occasion of sin”??
Yes, as I alluded to earlier, if you are lying in bed with a girl, and you have no temptation to have sex with her, and you don’t even have lustful thoughts about her, then maybe this isn’t the right girl for you. 😉
 
Hi!

Let’s say that I slept over at my girlfriend’s room, in the same bed. We did nothing else except sleep. Have I committed a sin?

I’ve read various other threads about this topic, so I’d like to clarify:
  1. here, I’ve ALREADY slept in the same bed as her, and we did nothing except sleep.
  2. I am not asking about whether it is inappropriate, or whether it is a near occasion for sin. I am asking if it is an ACTUAL sin.
  3. No one else knew about us sleeping in the same bed, so there is no scandal.
Thank you, I await your answers.
You sound as if you want approval. It is a sin to do knowingly do what you know is putting yourself in a position of temptation. God knows this and so do you. It is wise to not put yourself in this situation.

My love and prayers,
mlz
 
It is a sin to do knowingly do what you know is putting yourself in a position of temptation.

mlz
You sure about this? I don’t think a near occasion of sin is actually a sin but rather a temptation that can easily lead to sin.
 
Yes, as I alluded to earlier, if you are lying in bed with a girl, and you have no temptation to have sex with her, and you don’t even have lustful thoughts about her, then maybe this isn’t the right girl for you.
Ding ding ding. This is why I’m not buying the situation.
 
Hi!

Let’s say that I slept over at my girlfriend’s room, in the same bed. We did nothing else except sleep. Have I committed a sin?
No, as long as there is no sex. But I think you know that the temptation to have sex could be too much for the both of you.

my 2 cents.
 
Since you did not sin sexually, there is no sexual sin.
Since you did not intend to sin sexually, there is no intent to sin.
However it sounds as if you risked scandal should you have been discovered, thus you may have sinned against her through a disregard for her reputation. Search your conscience and talk to a priest who knows your situation.

Since it sounds like you are not even mildly attracted to this girl, there is no reason to date her; Either you are called to celibacy or there is another woman for you. You obviously need to break up immediately before you scandalize her.
A man doesn’t need to really want to get into his girlfriend’s panties for it to be the right girl (there are lots of “the right girl”)
I am a little surprised by this answer.

In general, theologians draw a line between “remote occasions”, in which the danger of sin is slight, and “proximate occasions”, in which the danger is probable (for a typical person). Most theologians argue that there is a moral obligation to avoid proximate occasions and to deliberately/voluntarily put oneself in a proximate occasion of sin is in itself a sin.

For more, see here: newadvent.org/cathen/11196a.htm
It makes sense to those who have (formally) studied Catholic theology intensely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top