Just a clarification, the sacrament I think you intend to refer to here is Anointing of the Sick. It is not something only celebrated when a person is near death. There’s no sacrament called “last rites.”
One more clarification: The Church considers marriages between non-Catholics as valid (barring any impediments that would invalidate the marriage). If they are both Christians (i.e. baptized) then the marriages are also sacramental.
Yes,Greebus the Catholic church teaches that all sin is forgiven If we repent, turn to God for fiveness. Catholics do this through the Sacrament of reconcilliation, , (Sacramental confession.) Thank you Lord for your Mercy!
CarlanI undertake the training rule to abstain from fermented drink that causes heedlessness.I do not know what you are good at, if you are going to be a protestant I hope you make a good.smileI was responding to PJM’s post.
He said 5 of the 7 sacraments relate to salvation and were only validated by the catholic church.
I asked if baptism was one of the 5.
You need to ask PJM what 5 he/she was refering to.#
I was interested in baptism as the catholic church says christian baptism in other churchs is valid and they dont rebaptise if you have been baptised properly elsewhere.
That seems to contradict the claim that the sacrament of baptism is only valid if done in the catholic church.
Thats why I aked PJM if baptism was one of the 5 he was referring to.
If you read my post properly you would have seen that,
Do you still think I’ll make a good protestant
Fair enough, Guy but my point was that we are not dealing with deadly sin in this case. The mortal sin, and the real concern would be if a person delibertly did not attend Mass , on the vigil or Sunday.On the contrary.
I’m responding to an error.
I know when the sabbath is.
And I know what the catechism says about it.
Some catholics clearly don’t, and contradict their own catechism and claim to know better and tell others they are wrong, when they dont even know what their own church teaches.
They don’t represent the teaching of the catholic church.
If a non catholic didnt know better, they could be easily misled by these self professed catholics into error.
There was a reference to keeping holy the sabath day - which was pointed out as a saturday. As in a breach of the 10 commandments.
OTCA said the sabbath was a Sunday, and disparaged protestants for believing it was a saturday.
Several of us pointed out she is wrong (again
Readers should be clear about what the catechism of the catholic church says on the matter, and is crystal clear that the sabbath is NOT the same as the Lords Day, as claimed by OTCA.
When dealing with sin, it’s important to have the churchs teaching straight, dont you think!
CarlanI’d happily sink a beer or two with you too CarlanBTW, I realy like you and I think it is wonderful that you are being so thorough in your search for the whole truth.
Ha, thank you Guy, only this old girl doesn’t drink the stuff, could never stay with it long enough to like the taste.I’d happily sink a beer or two with you too Carlan
Carlan**GOTS,On the contrary.
I’m responding to an error.
I know when the sabbath is.
And I know what the catechism says about it.
Some catholics clearly don’t, and contradict their own catechism and claim to know better and tell others they are wrong, when they dont even know what their own church teaches.
They don’t represent the teaching of the catholic church.
If a non catholic didnt know better, they could be easily misled by these self professed catholics into error.
This thread is about sin.
There was a reference to keeping holy the sabath day - which was pointed out as a saturday. As in a breach of the 10 commandments.
OTCA said the sabbath was a Sunday, and disparaged protestants for believing it was a saturday.
Several of us pointed out she is wrong (again
Readers should be clear about what the catechism of the catholic church says on the matter, and is crystal clear that the sabbath is NOT the same as the Lords Day, as claimed by OTCA.
When dealing with sin, it’s important to have the churchs teaching straight, dont you think!
My oopsFirst you say the church accepts all christian baptisms done with water to the trinitarian formula, then you say the sacrament can only be validly administered and received in the catholic church
OTCA you said
That was not truth.
Isn’t the Sabbath sundown Friday to sundown Saturday? So that would be part of Friday and part of Saturday.
I went to school under Sisters of Loretta and they taught it was a mortal sin as it was. Eating meat on Fridays was and is still (during lent) a mortal sin. Let me add one more thing. Mortal sin requires three elements. 1) It has to be grave. It is indeed grave to disobey Church law. 2.) The person has to know it is grave. 3) The person has to do it anyway.
Yes. That’s by the Jewish reckoning of the day, which begins sundown the night before the calendar day. I wasn’t speaking in terms of the Jewish calendar. Whether one reckons “Saturday” as beginning at 12:00 a.m. or sundown the night before, it’s still the sabbath.
And I’d listen to them too before someone who says this:
See that. You said, and then repeated, the sabbath is a sunday.
Jewish sabbath begans at sunset the eve before.I’m not sure if the confusion is even a sin, BTW, I realy like you and I think it is wonderful that you are being so thorough in your search for the whole truth.
I think we should pose this question on the “Ask An Apologist” forum.
(#1)I doubt many people think eating meat on Friday is a grave matter.