Single Mom - What is my moral obligation to my daughter?

  • Thread starter Thread starter aggieints2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

aggieints2010

Guest
Hi all,

I’m a single mother of a beautiful toddler girl, who I love with all my heart. I’ll try to make a very long story as short as possible, but give enough details to allow some understanding of my situation.

Her father and I were in a long term relationship and engaged to be married when she was born. The original plan was for me to move back to my hometown so that I could be near my family once I had the baby, and after we were married a couple of months later, I would move back to his hometown. However, after a series of very stressful situations, my family convinced me to stay in my hometown and refuse to go back with him, for the sake of the baby. I tried to convince him that it was best for our family that we stay in my hometown for sometime, because there were a lot of very negative influences in his hometown at the time. He disagreed and decided to move back to his hometown to start a business, and promised he would move back once that was done, but never gave me a timeline of when that would be.

After a couple of more months of disagreeing, I broke off the engagement and relationship, and asked him to please let our daughter and myself go our separate ways. As we both believed this was in her best interest, he did as I asked and we didn’t see or talk with each other for almost a year.

For the entire year, however, I was never at peace with my decision and felt like I had made the wrong decision for us all, and that I was doing an injustice to my daughter by keeping her from her father. I prayed every day for a sign of which way to go, and ended up praying a novena, and asking for a sign as to whether or not I should contact my ex. After speaking with a priest various times as well as others who knew my situation, I decided to reach out to him and ask to try again. He agreed, and we had many discussions on how to resolve past issues, and were moving toward to getting married. However, after a disagreement I became worried and once again broke it off, thinking once again that I was doing what was best. Now, I am back to feeling the same way as I did last year, and praying for guidance as to what is best for my daughter and myself. My ex comes from a rough background and a different family environment than my own. He has a past, but now has a very close relationship with God and has a good heart.

Both of our families are no longer fond of us, and our attempt at resolving our issues brought about divisions between us and our own families. However, I still have a very strong feeling that God wants us together, and wants us both to work toward achieving a happy family environment. He, however, is very hurt and understandably tired of going back and forth between working things out and not, and believes that we are no longer meant to move forward.

With that said, my question is what would be my moral obligation to him and our daughter in this situation? Should I continue to fight as hard as possible to bring about a healthy family environment, or should I move forward and let him go his way and I go mine, and explain the circumstances to my daughter once she’s older? I feel like us breaking things off was the easy way out rather than facing our demons together and moving forward, but on the other hand, maybe it was a blessing in disguise and a means of me finding a better situation for my daughter. I’ve quickly learned that it’s hard enough to make decisions for someone’s well being other than your own, but when it comes to going against someone with whom you should be on the same page, it makes things even more confusing. Also, how should I handle the situation when I firmly believe that God is telling me one thing, and he firmly believes that He is telling him another? How can I determine who is right and wrong?

Apologies for an incredibly long post, and if you’ve made it this far, thank you. 🙂 Any advice, along with prayers for strength and clarity would be very much appreciated.
 
Neither of you should marry the other for the sake of your daughter–this is grounds for annulment and the Church discourages it.

How does he feel about being involved in his daughter’s life? How much does he want to be involved?

Overall, barring seriously bad things, your daughter should have as much of a relationship with her father and her father’s family as possible, just as she should have with you and your family. He is equally her parent; they are equally her family.

In your shoes, I would do everything I could reasonably do to make this happen.
 
I am sorry you are going through this-

You have to limit your families (both) influences and make this decision with your daughter’s father.

You don’t have to live in either hometown, just close to employer. People commute everyday if it’s a bit far. This is what’s best for your daughter.
 
Neither of you should marry the other for the sake of your daughter–this is grounds for annulment and the Church discourages it.

How does he feel about being involved in his daughter’s life? How much does he want to be involved?

Overall, barring seriously bad things, your daughter should have as much of a relationship with her father and her father’s family as possible, just as she should have with you and your family. He is equally her parent; they are equally her family.

In your shoes, I would do everything I could reasonably do to make this happen.
I agree. All things being equal, a child has a right to know both her mother and her father and have a relationship with them. And this is true regardless of whether the two parents are married to each other or not.

As to whether or not you two should work it out or not, I’m afraid I cannot answer that one. But the father should still have the opportunity to know his daughter and be a part of her life (“barring seriously bad things” as St Francis said, of course).
 
It would not be right to get married JUST because of your daughter. And it would not be right to avoid the marriage JUST because of some unresolved issues and potentially take away your daughter’s chance to grow up in an intact family.

Maybe the two of you could seek some counseling - a Catholic or Christian family counselor, or your pastor - who could help you sort out the emotions from the actual factual issues.
 
Maybe the two of you could seek some counseling - a Catholic or Christian family counselor, or your pastor - who could help you sort out the emotions from the actual factual issues.
On this note, I recommend looking up your local Catholic Charities office. They sometimes offer counseling services which are focused on care for the whole person, not just the mental and emotional, but also the spiritual.
 
Hi all,

I’m a single mother of a beautiful toddler girl, who I love with all my heart.

Should I continue to fight as hard as possible to bring about a healthy family environment, or should I move forward and let him go his way and I go mine, and explain the circumstances to my daughter once she’s older?
There is no going completely separate ways anymore because the child has two parents. If you keep her from her father, part of what you will have to explain is why her father isn’t in her life. What part did you play in keeping him away from her. Regardless of what you do in the future, she has a father. She may at some point have a step-father who loves her as his own, and that she loves in return. But you’ll find that human beings have a desire to know their origins. Whether adopted or a product of surrogacy or separated from biological parents by life circumstances- once she knows she’ll more than likely want some kind of relationship. There may be resentment against you from not ensuring she’d had him in her life.

The right thing for your daughter is to promote and support a relationship with her father, even if you two don’t end up getting back together.
 
Unless her father is a physical danger to her, it is your responsibility as her mother to do whatever you can to ensure she has a good relationship with him, regardless of how awkward it may be for you. As her father, he has the responsibility to do all he can to provide for and have a relationship with her.

How you go about this is entirely up to the two of you, no one here knows your exact circumstances.

Oh, and it really doesn’t matter what your family thinks of this or where they think you should live. Your responsibility is to your daughter, not them. In listening to them, you fail her.
 
Unless her father is a physical danger to her, it is your responsibility as her mother to do whatever you can to ensure she has a good relationship with him, regardless of how awkward it may be for you. As her father, he has the responsibility to do all he can to provide for and have a relationship with her.

How you go about this is entirely up to the two of you, no one here knows your exact circumstances.

Oh, and it really doesn’t matter what your family thinks of this or where they think you should live. Your responsibility is to your daughter, not them. In listening to them, you fail her.
I agree with your post. At some point in her life, the daughter would want to search for her father anyway and there would be those missing years. This should be between you and the father and your daughter as to the decisions that are made. Life is complicated. I will pray for you.
 
I am concerned about the integrity and maturity of a man who would not stay as close as possible to his baby and mother of baby despite family, work, etc. I realize we have a difficult economy and it’s tough starting out and all, but I sense that you are doing most of the work here and he gets led by the nose by everyone but can’t make the strong moves that would make him a good father and husband. You reach out, he comes close, but it doesn’t seem close enough.

Can you take a few steps back and realize that the discussions and interactions of who lives where and how we would raise a family used to come BEFORE people made babies? Well now, the world has gotten more lax and a woman like you who should be raising her child in a stable environment is still being tossed around emotionally. We love intact families but it’s usually best to start out on the right foot with the right person.

As for the “I feel God is telling me” stuff, get rooted in reality. God wants you and your daughter in a stable home. Where is this guy? What is he doing when he is not with you? Why are all the families so agitated? Who has been paying the bills?

Your daughter can see him in supervised settings if you think that is safe. Years from now she might ask: “Why didn’t you marry my father?” You answer that she is not a mistake but you made a mistake in thinking he was mature and ready for a family. Teach her the proper order of how to date a man in order to find out if he is ready and mature. And if you ever meet someone else who seems nice, CHECK IT OUT before you fall for him, before you have sex, before getting close. Show your daughter how to do this thing right.
 
It’s never in a child’s best interests to separate her from her father, unless he is violent or abusive in some way.

.
 
It’s never in a child’s best interests to separate her from her father, unless he is violent or abusive in some way.

.
Yes.

It’s also not in a child’s best interest to marry someone because it’s also in your child’s best interest.

Do not feel obligated to marry him. Your only obligation is to encourage and help develop a relationship between the two of them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top