So what's the Catholic position on what Roeder did?

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
GodIsGracious said:
Roeder is as much of a murderer as Tiller. He killed. Intentionally, and with premeditation. Look up the word murder.

Do all the word spin you want, but murder is murder. He took the life of another human being, innorcent or not.

Sorry, distracted, but I hate to inform you that Jesus did not die and leave you as God. YOU are doing the rationalizing and it is people with attitudes like yours and other fringe groups that give your cause a bad name.

By your rationalizations, people who kill people who perform abortions can in turn be killed since those killings can prevent the MURDER of someone else.

Murder is murder. Regardless of whether someone is innocent or not. When the state kills someone on death row, they commit murder. Period. Roeder is just as much a murderer as Tiller is. YOU are not to determine who is any better than anyone else.

But I suppose you’ll just “ignore me” because you think I’m promoting abortion because I don’t believe like you do. Go ahead and excommunicate me too, it won’t count. YOU are not the church. YOU are not God. YOU do not determine the value of each person’s life. And thank God you don’t.🤷
Click to expand...
not answering this…

alredy did for one thing…

and don’t associate with those who support abortion for another…
 
johngh said:
“unauthorized capital punishment” is the same thing as murder to the Catholic Church, since we see capital punishment as murder in itself.

What Roeder did was wrong, plain and simple. I do believe Tiller should have been punished for his crimes, but not by death.
Click to expand...
you think that tiller the mass baby killer had just as much a right to live as an innocent person

whoa… :confused:
 
as Ann coulter said about liberals… These people are literally insane…
 
johngh said:
"What Roeder did was wrong, plain and simple. I do believe Tiller should have been punished for his crimes, but not by death.
Click to expand...
i do believe those unborn children should be punished, but not by death
 
GodIsGracious said:
Nor by a vigilante.
Click to expand...
so here’s the logic… according to you who think Tiller is so great… no different from an unborn child… e tc…

if its legal to murder

no one should stop that murder except through legal means… but uh… the legal system is corrupt and murderous … The legal system is the what’s the problem in the first place… The legal system is what OK’d murder in the 1st place…

gee… no wonder abortion is still legal… What is legal is right…

no wonder we can’t do anything about it… except talk, talk, talk, while babies are being dismembered…

if it was YOU being dismembered, well… that would be different… THEN you would want someone to really do something effective… and IMMEDIATE… something a little faster than long, drawn - out court battles … You would want a pro-life “Rambo” to burst into the abortion clinic and rescue you… but instead all you can do as an unborn child is … well, put your hope in court battles… :rolleyes: which have now been going on now for 36 yrs… with no success in outlawing abortion…

whatever… :rolleyes:
 
distracted said:
i do believe those unborn children should be punished, but not by death
Click to expand...
What?? Not only do I fail to see how this relates to the thread, what a terrible thing to say imho (and of course completely contrary to anything the Catholic Church teaches).
 
diggerdomer said:
What?? Not only do I fail to see how this relates to the thread, what a terrible thing to say imho (and of course completely contrary to anything the Catholic Church teaches).
Click to expand...
not to mention making a point? :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top