Social Issues and the Santorum Surge

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bubba_Switzler

Guest
Mr. Bell, 68, is an unlikely tribune for social conservatism. His main interest has always been economics. He was “an early supply-sider” who worked on Ronald Reagan’s presidential campaigns of 1976 and 1980 and Jack Kemp’s in 1988. In 1978 he ran an anti-tax campaign for the U.S. Senate in New Jersey, defeating Republican incumbent Clifford Case in the primary but losing to Democrat Bill Bradley.
Even now his day job is to advocate for the gold standard at the American Principles Project. But he’s been interested in social issues since the 1980s, when “it became increasingly clear to me . . . that social issues were beginning to be very important in comparison to economic issues,” in part because “Reaganomics worked so well that the Democrats . . . kind of retired the economic issues.”
In Mr. Bell’s telling, social conservatism is both relatively new and uniquely American, and it is a response to aggression, not an initiation of it. The left has had “its center of gravity in social issues” since the French Revolution, he says. “Yes, the left at that time, with people like Robespierre, was interested in overthrowing the monarchy and the French aristocracy. But they were even more vehemently in favor of bringing down institutions like the family and organized religion. In that regard, the left has never changed. . . . I think we’ve had a good illustration of it in the last month or so.”
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204880404577227694132901090.html?mod=WSJ_article_MoreIn_Opinion
 
Some people have suggested that the HHS issue was a clever political play by the Obama administration. By pushing these social issues into the forefront of the national debate, they remind social conservatives that Santorum’s social positions are by far the most amenable to their way of thinking. By thus strengthening Santorum’s campaign, Obama increases the chance that he would run against Santorum in the general election, a very attractive option for Obama. Even if that does not happen, Romney still has to fight harder (i.e. he has to waste additional money) and the enthusiasm social conservatives have for Romney may ultimately be reduced in the general election.
 
Wow,do you really think they are that clever?:eek:
There certainly are other options. I believe it is most likely that whoever was in charge of the decision simply screwed up. They made the decision too hastily, out of misplaced idealism, unknowingly because it was obfuscated, on bad advice, or some combination thereof. The administration didn’t do a good enough job checking the decision and out the door it went. After a few days, they realized they had made a mistake and acted to correct it.

It could also be that they made it intentionally and had to withdraw after the backlash, but I suspect that is less likely. Their quick fix suggests that they were aware of the alternatives, so why risk that sort of bad press? They could have just proposed one of the alternatives and curried favor with religious organizations by pointing out how considerate they were.
 
The contraception thing was another example of evil. Whenever evil thrives and begins to dominate, as it does here in the US, these folks get very confident and even over eager. They begin to assume that because all these other moral things have gone by the wayside that one more step won’t be a big deal. They don’t want to wait another 5-10 years when it would likely pass with less opposition. Evil is ambitious and is often its own worst enemy.

Consider Obamacare as another example of this tendency. The left almost went bananas that Obama didn’t immediately institute a single payer system. They threatened to derail his plan. Obama and his surrogates had to actually go out and explain that this new system was really a 2-step plan to get to single payer. Obama was smart enough to realize that more time is needed to condition Americans to get used to the idea (just as we’ve become used to abortion, divorce, gay sex, social security, etc). Yet, evil wanted it all right now and almost jeopardized a long term victory.

In other words, evil often jumps the gun when it’s winning. And in this country, it is definitely winning. That’s all this contraception thing was about. Most “christians” will go back to doing whatever they were doing beforehand, and this will be chalked up as a bureaucratic snafu. And yes, Obama will win the election if any of the remaining 4 candidates are the opposition.
 
Santorum is going to need more than social issues to win. But, Obama is going to have a problem on his hands if prices keep rising and gas goes much higher. Not to mention the large corps laying off people.
 
Santorum is going to need more than social issues to win. But, Obama is going to have a problem on his hands if prices keep rising and gas goes much higher. Not to mention the large corps laying off people.
You underestimate the ignorance of the populace and the media/academia’s influence. They are already explaining the fuel prices by blaming the Middle East (Bush deceptively blamed supply and demand which is also nonsense). As for unemployment, they’ve jiggered the numbers to drop the rate by not counting over a million people who no longer can find work. And as for inflation, they don’t count food and energy prices.

And here’s the kicker, the people really do believe it. All of it.

About the only place you can get real info is on hard right websites (Drudge, townhall, renew america) and hard left websites (huffingtonpost, mother jones ,etc). They are definitely biased, but they are not homogenized, pasteurized, and celebritized like CNN, Fox, and all the rest. In fact, you might learn something from one of those websites because you know going in that there is a concrete bias in place.
 
You underestimate the ignorance of the populace and the media/academia’s influence. They are already explaining the fuel prices by blaming the Middle East (Bush deceptively blamed supply and demand which is also nonsense). As for unemployment, they’ve jiggered the numbers to drop the rate by not counting over a million people who no longer can find work. And as for inflation, they don’t count food and energy prices.

And here’s the kicker, the people really do believe it. All of it.

About the only place you can get real info is on hard right websites (Drudge, townhall, renew america) and hard left websites (huffingtonpost, mother jones ,etc). They are definitely biased, but they are not homogenized, pasteurized, and celebritized like CNN, Fox, and all the rest. In fact, you might learn something from one of those websites because you know going in that there is a concrete bias in place.
I am well aware of the ignorance of the general population. I also know that they tend to blame bad things happening to them on the current people in charge, whether it’s their fault or not.
 
Santorum is a standing affront to the sensibilities and assumptions of the media and political elite. That elite is constantly writing the obituary for social conservatism, which is supposed to wither away and leave a polite, undisturbed consensus in favor of social liberalism. Santorum not only defends beliefs that are looked down upon as dated and unrealistic; he does it with a passionate sincerity that opens him to mockery and attack.
As Jeffrey Bell, author of the new book The Case for Polarized Politics, notes in a Wall Street Journal interview, Santorum’s style of social conservatism is deeply American. No other Western country saw the rise of such a social-conservative movement after the social upheaval of the 1960s. Bell traces American social conservatism back ultimately to the God-given natural rights enunciated in the Declaration of Independence. Sure enough, Santorum is given to quoting the Declaration.
nationalreview.com/articles/291518/effrontery-rick-santorum-rich-lowry
 
When Barack Obama was campaigning for president in 2008, he declared that marriage is between a man and a woman. For the most part, his position was treated as a nonissue.
Now Rick Santorum is campaigning for president. He too says that marriage is between a man and a woman. What a different reaction he gets.
There’s no mystery why. Mr. Santorum is attacked because everyone understands that he means what he says.
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204909104577235471075318762.html
 
Drudge has turned into a pro-Romney site this cycle, but I am sure people will be discussing the following (maybe at the debate tomorrow night, which is probably why he put it up):
Provocative, indeed!

It looks like Santorum is doubling down on Christianity.
 
Wow,do you really think they are that clever?:eek:
They’re that sleazy anyway. 🤷 If they were clever [or at least acted upon their cleverness] they wouldn’t keep digging us into a hole that’s already above our heads.
 
They’re that sleazy anyway. 🤷 If they were clever [or at least acted upon their cleverness] they wouldn’t keep digging us into a hole that’s already above our heads.
They would if their aims were destructive.

I’m not sure if I’m ready to say that they are in league with Satan but I don’t dismiss the possibility that they mean to do what they are doing.
 
I like Santorum but am concerned if he is the nominee it be made all about his views on contraception etc. and not about Obama and his terrible polices. Discussion on the economy could be taken away and replaced with accusations that Santorum is a right wing extremist, with focus on contraception, and some of his other comments like about women in combat, and not on gas prices etc. were it is possible to win voters over.

I do not think you can win voters over on the issue of contraception say.
 
I like Santorum but am concerned if he is the nominee it be made all about his views on contraception etc. and not about Obama and his terrible polices. Discussion on the economy could be taken away and replaced with accusations that Santorum is a right wing extremist, with focus on contraception, and some of his other comments like about women in combat, and not on gas prices etc. were it is possible to win voters over.

I do not think you can win voters over on the issue of contraception say.
Agreed, but Santorum can win if he uses the HHS mandate to illustrate larger principles.

Of course, we all know how the media will treat him. But there is an empirical question at hand: can a Republican candidate win on a strong social issues platform? Obviously many Republicans believe not, or at least, prefer not to win that way. But there is reason to think that, in spite of how the media will treat him, that it could be a winning strategy.

What Santorum has not yet done to my satisfaction is tie the social and economic issues together into a coherent whole. That’s what Reagan accomplished.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top