T
tqualey
Guest
And a Joyous Greeting to you, Csobel! 
First let me welcome you to CAF - it is always good to get interested folks to place comments and respond to questions. I think you will find that CAF is both lively and informative - in addition to being a way to increase your understanding of the Faith.
Now, down to businessâŚ
Did you want to give a reference for this definition, or is it one you have developed?
I took the liberty of changing the pitch and bolding some of the words. I really have no honest idea what you mean by an ordinary believer. Really. While maybe a knowledge of Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek would be helpful, what constitutes âordinaryâ belief? The reason why I ask is there are about 30,000+ various competing Protestant denominations (philvaz.com/apologetics/a106.htm ) all claiming SS is true - and yet all arguing over what is said and how they interpret it. For example her are just four items where SS and the private interpretation that goes with it are floundering:
1.) Is Baptism necessary? Various groups claim it is just a symbol and an optional one at that.
2.) Is the manner of Baptism important? Those who can not be dunked have real problems
3.) Is the consecrated Bread and Wine really (as in Real Presence) the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, as He said?
4.) Can another human being have the power to forgive sin?
If Scripture can no âstand aloneâ. Unopened books do not do anything. Opened books that are not understood do not do much more - and books that are interpreted by 30,000+ different groups have conflicting meanings. The Scripture must be interpreted - and without a recognized authority being guided by the Holy Spirit - interpretations are all over the place. Here are some examples:
1.) Scripture condemns homosexual behavior - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the current agenda under the idea of âInclusienessâ and being ânon-judgmentalâ
2.) Gay clergy, gay bishops, gay marriages have been endorsed by various Protestant denominations - yet this behavior is strictly contrary to any literal meaning of the written Word.
3.) Scripture condemns killing the innocent - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the âpro-choiceâ movment and actively support groups like âPlanned Parenthoodâ in the bloody dismemberment of a living human being in its motherâs womb.
4.) Scripture condemns killing oneâs self - yet multiple Protestant denominations have endorsed assisted suicide, The Hemlock Society and other groups whose sole focus is ending another personâs life - by by their own hand.
Really, who is the âjudgeâ in this âCourt of Appealâ you have identified with Scripture? Courts of Appeal - at least as I am familiar with them are not temples of theory - but applications of judical principles to particular cases that have been previously decided and are now under review.
For example, The OT clearly identifies circumcision as the sign of the Covenant that God gave to Abraham - but, in the NT, this is done away with.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?
Christ clearly condemns divorce - but - St. Paul allows it if unequally yoked with a non-believer.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?
How does this Court of Appeal render a judgment? How is this judgment made know to other interested parties? Just what is the appeals process as far as it involves another human being?
Let me stop at your first paragraph.
I submit SS fails (and, fails in a most obvious manner) when those who claim to submit to it do not agree on how they will interpret matters. This inconsistency appears to be permanent state of affairs - in my own lifetime (Iâm 65) homosexuality was condemned by every church I was aware of in the US. Today, that is far from the case. Yet all are claiming that their new embrace is a manifestation of Godâs inclusive Love for all - and the previous condemnations ⌠well ⌠that was then and this is now⌠and that seems to end it.
SS has produced nothing but chaos and a contempt for Godâs Word - because, as I have demonstrated, it can be made to say anything you want it to say. Now, this is just a personal opinion - but the only justification I can see for SS is that unless you return to the Catholic Church and its teaching authority - there is no where else to go. There is no alternative choice. The Bible (even the abridged form you have) is from the Catholic Church.
I really am looking forward to hearing from you. Please note, there are no straw men in this argument and I certainly do not expect to see any from youâŚ
God bless
First let me welcome you to CAF - it is always good to get interested folks to place comments and respond to questions. I think you will find that CAF is both lively and informative - in addition to being a way to increase your understanding of the Faith.
Now, down to businessâŚ
At the risk of putting a match to some of the âstrawâ I found here ⌠let me get a good understanding of the definition you have offered.Greetings brethren,
I have read through some of the material on this thread and am quite shocked at the amount of straw men that are being set up to take down âsola scripturaâ!
First, let us clearly define the terms:
Sola Scriptura posits that all things necessary for salvation, and concerning faith and life are clearly laid down in the Scriptures so that any ordinary believer may understand them. Scripture stands alone as the highest authority on matters of faith and life for the believer, and is** the ultimate court of appeal**.
It does not posit that Scripture is the only authority that may bear on a persons life, or that the church (as in the gathered body of true believers) is not an authoritative interpreter of those Scriptures. But we deny that a specific church or see or progression of men has the sole authority of interpreting those very Scriptures.
Did you want to give a reference for this definition, or is it one you have developed?
I took the liberty of changing the pitch and bolding some of the words. I really have no honest idea what you mean by an ordinary believer. Really. While maybe a knowledge of Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek would be helpful, what constitutes âordinaryâ belief? The reason why I ask is there are about 30,000+ various competing Protestant denominations (philvaz.com/apologetics/a106.htm ) all claiming SS is true - and yet all arguing over what is said and how they interpret it. For example her are just four items where SS and the private interpretation that goes with it are floundering:
1.) Is Baptism necessary? Various groups claim it is just a symbol and an optional one at that.
2.) Is the manner of Baptism important? Those who can not be dunked have real problems
3.) Is the consecrated Bread and Wine really (as in Real Presence) the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, as He said?
4.) Can another human being have the power to forgive sin?
If Scripture can no âstand aloneâ. Unopened books do not do anything. Opened books that are not understood do not do much more - and books that are interpreted by 30,000+ different groups have conflicting meanings. The Scripture must be interpreted - and without a recognized authority being guided by the Holy Spirit - interpretations are all over the place. Here are some examples:
1.) Scripture condemns homosexual behavior - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the current agenda under the idea of âInclusienessâ and being ânon-judgmentalâ
2.) Gay clergy, gay bishops, gay marriages have been endorsed by various Protestant denominations - yet this behavior is strictly contrary to any literal meaning of the written Word.
3.) Scripture condemns killing the innocent - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the âpro-choiceâ movment and actively support groups like âPlanned Parenthoodâ in the bloody dismemberment of a living human being in its motherâs womb.
4.) Scripture condemns killing oneâs self - yet multiple Protestant denominations have endorsed assisted suicide, The Hemlock Society and other groups whose sole focus is ending another personâs life - by by their own hand.
Really, who is the âjudgeâ in this âCourt of Appealâ you have identified with Scripture? Courts of Appeal - at least as I am familiar with them are not temples of theory - but applications of judical principles to particular cases that have been previously decided and are now under review.
For example, The OT clearly identifies circumcision as the sign of the Covenant that God gave to Abraham - but, in the NT, this is done away with.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?
Christ clearly condemns divorce - but - St. Paul allows it if unequally yoked with a non-believer.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?
How does this Court of Appeal render a judgment? How is this judgment made know to other interested parties? Just what is the appeals process as far as it involves another human being?
Let me stop at your first paragraph.
I submit SS fails (and, fails in a most obvious manner) when those who claim to submit to it do not agree on how they will interpret matters. This inconsistency appears to be permanent state of affairs - in my own lifetime (Iâm 65) homosexuality was condemned by every church I was aware of in the US. Today, that is far from the case. Yet all are claiming that their new embrace is a manifestation of Godâs inclusive Love for all - and the previous condemnations ⌠well ⌠that was then and this is now⌠and that seems to end it.
SS has produced nothing but chaos and a contempt for Godâs Word - because, as I have demonstrated, it can be made to say anything you want it to say. Now, this is just a personal opinion - but the only justification I can see for SS is that unless you return to the Catholic Church and its teaching authority - there is no where else to go. There is no alternative choice. The Bible (even the abridged form you have) is from the Catholic Church.
I really am looking forward to hearing from you. Please note, there are no straw men in this argument and I certainly do not expect to see any from youâŚ
God bless