Sola Scriptura and why do Protestants like it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornAgain2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And a Joyous Greeting to you, Csobel! 🙂

First let me welcome you to CAF - it is always good to get interested folks to place comments and respond to questions. I think you will find that CAF is both lively and informative - in addition to being a way to increase your understanding of the Faith.

Now, down to business… 😃
Greetings brethren,

I have read through some of the material on this thread and am quite shocked at the amount of straw men that are being set up to take down ‘sola scriptura’!

First, let us clearly define the terms:

Sola Scriptura posits that all things necessary for salvation, and concerning faith and life are clearly laid down in the Scriptures so that any ordinary believer may understand them. Scripture stands alone as the highest authority on matters of faith and life for the believer, and is** the ultimate court of appeal**.

It does not posit that Scripture is the only authority that may bear on a persons life, or that the church (as in the gathered body of true believers) is not an authoritative interpreter of those Scriptures. But we deny that a specific church or see or progression of men has the sole authority of interpreting those very Scriptures.
At the risk of putting a match to some of the ‘straw’ I found here … let me get a good understanding of the definition you have offered.

Did you want to give a reference for this definition, or is it one you have developed?

I took the liberty of changing the pitch and bolding some of the words. I really have no honest idea what you mean by an ordinary believer. Really. While maybe a knowledge of Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek would be helpful, what constitutes ‘ordinary’ belief? The reason why I ask is there are about 30,000+ various competing Protestant denominations (philvaz.com/apologetics/a106.htm ) all claiming SS is true - and yet all arguing over what is said and how they interpret it. For example her are just four items where SS and the private interpretation that goes with it are floundering:

1.) Is Baptism necessary? Various groups claim it is just a symbol and an optional one at that.
2.) Is the manner of Baptism important? Those who can not be dunked have real problems
3.) Is the consecrated Bread and Wine really (as in Real Presence) the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, as He said?
4.) Can another human being have the power to forgive sin?

If Scripture can no ‘stand alone’. Unopened books do not do anything. Opened books that are not understood do not do much more - and books that are interpreted by 30,000+ different groups have conflicting meanings. The Scripture must be interpreted - and without a recognized authority being guided by the Holy Spirit - interpretations are all over the place. Here are some examples:

1.) Scripture condemns homosexual behavior - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the current agenda under the idea of ‘Inclusieness’ and being ‘non-judgmental’
2.) Gay clergy, gay bishops, gay marriages have been endorsed by various Protestant denominations - yet this behavior is strictly contrary to any literal meaning of the written Word.
3.) Scripture condemns killing the innocent - yet multiple Protestant denominations have embraced the ‘pro-choice’ movment and actively support groups like ‘Planned Parenthood’ in the bloody dismemberment of a living human being in its mother’s womb.
4.) Scripture condemns killing one’s self - yet multiple Protestant denominations have endorsed assisted suicide, The Hemlock Society and other groups whose sole focus is ending another person’s life - by by their own hand.

Really, who is the ‘judge’ in this ‘Court of Appeal’ you have identified with Scripture? Courts of Appeal - at least as I am familiar with them are not temples of theory - but applications of judical principles to particular cases that have been previously decided and are now under review.

For example, The OT clearly identifies circumcision as the sign of the Covenant that God gave to Abraham - but, in the NT, this is done away with.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?

Christ clearly condemns divorce - but - St. Paul allows it if unequally yoked with a non-believer.
What does the Court of Appeal have to say about that?

How does this Court of Appeal render a judgment? How is this judgment made know to other interested parties? Just what is the appeals process as far as it involves another human being?

Let me stop at your first paragraph.

I submit SS fails (and, fails in a most obvious manner) when those who claim to submit to it do not agree on how they will interpret matters. This inconsistency appears to be permanent state of affairs - in my own lifetime (I’m 65) homosexuality was condemned by every church I was aware of in the US. Today, that is far from the case. Yet all are claiming that their new embrace is a manifestation of God’s inclusive Love for all - and the previous condemnations … well … that was then and this is now… and that seems to end it.

SS has produced nothing but chaos and a contempt for God’s Word - because, as I have demonstrated, it can be made to say anything you want it to say. Now, this is just a personal opinion - but the only justification I can see for SS is that unless you return to the Catholic Church and its teaching authority - there is no where else to go. There is no alternative choice. The Bible (even the abridged form you have) is from the Catholic Church.

I really am looking forward to hearing from you. Please note, there are no straw men in this argument and I certainly do not expect to see any from you… 😃

God bless
 
Hi, Nikella,

I am so happy that you have a personal relationship with Christ.

I am also happy that you are getting so much out of the Bible. For most people it is not easy reading. Because there are differences in styles and word usages, it is easy to read a passage and wonder what is being said. If you have ever wondered what a particular passage meant, how do you resolve your question(s)?

God bless
Hello, and I beg your pardon, I must not have been very clear in explaining my perspective. In my KJV Bible, God’s Plan of Salvation is revealed to me personally, and I get to know my Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, who came in the flesh, personally. To me, Christ Jesus is a Living Person! In my Bible He says that He will come again a second time, the way He left, physically descending from Heaven.

When Jesus Christ walked the Earth, he was a Jew, and He is the foretold Messiah that Israel was waiting for. In the Last Supper, which was the passover meal that the jews celebrated in rememberance of the exodus from Egypt and the promise of a Priest-King, Jesus reveals to them that the second of the three unleavened matzo-bread they break symbolising the Messiah, was in fact Himself. In the Bible is explained that He was speaking figuratively, because he tells them to eat unleavened bread, and this is new doctrine, as leaven throughout the Bible is seen as traditions and teachings that corrupt the new covenant which is wholly spiritual and the work of God alone.

The real offering of flesh and blood was done once on the Cross when Jesus took upon his sinfree self all the sins of the world so that we might be saved through faith in Him. Jesus is no longer on the Cross because He is now in heaven with God, risen and alive. As a protestant with a personal relationship with and love for Jesus Christ who is the Lord of my life, I am so happy that He set me free from the bondage of works. I could just as well have been born Jewish and raised in the traditions of Pharisees who still wait for the Messiah and think they have anything to offer that could trump God’s work.

Lord Jesus Christ said on the Cross: It is finished. In the glorious Gospel God’s Plan of Salvation is crystal clear; remain in the Lord until the end, and suffer persecution from Pharisees gladly because the reward is worth it. Jesus Christ gives those who believe on Him, the Spirit of Truth, and thus we find all the answers in the Bible alone.

This is how I as a follower of my Lord Jesus Christ have found salvation, by reading the Gospel and asking Jesus to give me understanding and discernment so that no man may deceive me. I put all my trust and faith in Him alone.

I don’t understand the Catholic faith. I am trying to learn but I am struggling with the extra-biblical writings, trying to line them up with the Bible. It’s confusing to me.
 
Greetings brethren,
Welcome to CAF, csoble. 👋
Code:
I have read through some of the material on this thread and am quite shocked at the amount of straw men that are being set up to take down 'sola scriptura'!
Keep in mind that those of us that prefer dialogue with our separated brethren have heard maybe a dozen different definitions of it. That is why it is always useful to see which one is being used by which individual member.

Like bible based doctrines, it can have whatever meaning is assigned to it by the user.
Code:
 First, let us clearly define the terms:
Sola Scriptura posits that all things necessary for salvation, and concerning faith and life are clearly laid down in the Scriptures so that any ordinary believer may understand them. Scripture stands alone as the highest authority on matters of faith and life for the believer, and is the ultimate court of appeal.
Just so you are clear, from our point of view, Jesus did not leave the Scriptures in charge of the Church. Catholics believe that Jesus left the gifts and authority for the care of the Church to persons, not writings, however Holy.

Eph 4:10-14
11 And his gifts were that some should be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, some pastors and teachers, 12 to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, 13 until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ;

Scripture, as it states of itself, is “profitable” or “useful” in these tasks. We consider the Scriptures as authoritative, since their primary author is God. The scriptures are also clear that they can lead one to Christ (salvation). We call this material sufficiency, and it is a doctrine we share with our Reformed brethren.
Code:
It does not posit that Scripture is the only authority that may bear on a persons life, or that the church (as in the gathered body of true believers) is not an authoritative interpreter of those Scriptures.
The definition of the church as the gathered body of “true believers” (a distinction not found in Scripture) represents a significant departure from what the Apsotles believed and taught with regard to the nature of the Church. It must also be said that there are gatherings of “true believers” that intepret the Scriptures in opposition to one another.
But we deny that a specific church or see or progression of men has the sole authority of interpreting those very Scriptures.
Yes. Such a thing of necessity must be denied, or else a committed Christian would have to submit oneself to that authority. This was the whole point of the Reformation, to get out from under corrupt authority figures, claiming to be representing the Church.
Code:
 Here is the proof of this:
  1. This is the way that God has always worked
“this” being what, exactly?
Code:
a) The mosaic law is a prime example. The law stands on its own, and does not require a third party interpreter to infuse it with authority. It was written down (cf. Deut 31:9-12), the people listened to it, and it was in this very word that life was to be found. It was a common occurrence in the ministry of Jesus Christ that he strongly rebuked the traditions of the Pharisees in regards to the interpretation of the mosaic law: " You hypocrites, rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you:‘THIS PEOPLE HONORS ME WITH THEIR LIPS, BUT THEIR HEART IS FAR AWAY FROM ME. ‘BUT IN VAIN DO THEY WORSHIP ME, TEACHING AS DOCTRINES THE PRECEPTS OF MEN.' (Mt 15:7)
Much of the sermon on the mount is dedicated to the stripping away of these man made traditions that were polluting his Law (Mt 5-7).
The law clearly stood on its own; it was sufficient for salvation (Micah 5:8).
No Catholic is claiming (speaking of strawmen) that the Scriptures do not stand authoritatively on their own. But you are wrong, the Law of MOses was always read in an interpretive context, in community, under leadership. There have always been custodians of the Word. Although Jesus did rebuke the behavior of the pharisees, He did affirm that they sat on the Seat of Moses, and that the disciples should do what they said, but not what they do. In this way, He affirmed their position, if not their conduct in it.
Code:
b) This does not change with the glorious realization of the shadows and types of the mosaic economy in Christ, but rather finds its perfect fulfillment. Paul exhorts Timothy and reaffirms that the Scriptures (he’s probably talking about the OT here) are able to make him wise in salvation through Christ Jesus (2Tim3:15-17) and that they can equip the godly man for every good work.
No, it does not say this, csobel, though this is a common misperception of the verse. It says that the scriptures are useful and profitable in the equipping of the saints, but these tasks, as the NT clearly states, are given to persons.
 
I don’t understand the Catholic faith. I am trying to learn but I am struggling with the extra-biblical writings, trying to line them up with the Bible. It’s confusing to me.
Welcome to CAF, nikella. You have come to the right place for this. 👍
 
  1. The Scriptures must be read within the living tradition of the whole Church (CCC 113)
    This is a subtle way of saying that you can’t understand the Scriptures without the teaching of the Catholic church.
They can be understood, clearly, as all of our separated brethren now read them outside of the living tradition of the whole Church. The problem with that method is that they are removed from their context (the Catholic Church). When the Holy Writings are separated from the Sacred tradition that produced them, their meaning becomes distorted, just like reading any historic document outside of it’s cultural context.
  1. Essentially, that the authority of Scripture derives from the church. The appeal to the equal authority of the Word in written form as well as Tradition is often to 2 Thessalonians 2:15, 2 Timothy 2:2, and 1 Cor 11:2. But do these really teach an authoritative tradition equal to the word of God?
Obviously , Catholics receive the Apostolic Tradition that yes, the Word of God in the Church is just as authoritative and valid as the Word committed to writing.

But it is wrong to say that the “authority of Scripture derives from the Church”. If you keep reading that catechism, you will find that the CC teaches Scripture is authoritative because it’s primary author is God.
  1. Does Scripture contradict itself with stern warnings not to add to the written Word (Deut 4:2, Rev 22:18)?
    “So then, brothers, stand firm and hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter.” (2 Thes 2:15) Just to clarify, the Greek here for tradition is paradosis, which denotes authoritative doctrine.
Many of our separated brethern lose sight of the fact that the majority of the NT books had not yet been written when Paul commands “not to go beyone what is written”. 😉

Naturally, the command not to add to the written word is dispensed for the Church in the formation of the NT, otherwise, it would not exist.
  1. But context and the rest of Scripture, not the applying of Scripture to a pet doctrine, must be the rule of sound biblical exegesis. In this context, Pual is rebuking the Thessalonians for buying on to a phony doctrine in a false letter when they should have known better than to swallow, given his personal visit and earlier letter. We cannot say here that Paul established a (T)radition that was to be passed down and would be equal with the word, but rather that the Thessalonians were not to believe anything but the very words that came out of his mouth, or was not signed by his very pen. To say that this establishes a Tradition that is passed down through the Church and coequal with Scripture is an exegetical fallacy.
I agree, but then, the Church is not derived from the Scripture, and the Sacred Traditions passed on to them by Paul preceded the writing of the NT, and were not dependent upon it for validity. Scripture testifies that the Word of God was given to the Church. And we all know that God preserves His Word where it was placed.
  1. Paul contrasts the Thessalonians, who easily swallowed the traditions of man, over against the Bereans, who he commended in Acts 17:11 for submitting the Apostolic teaching to the Scriptures. Why? Because they are the highest authority in life and faith, and Paul knew that.
On the contrary, Paul commends the Bereans for their nobility. How was their noble character demonstrated?

Acts 17:11-12
11 Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessaloni’ca,** for they received the word with all eagerness, **examining the scriptures daily to see if these things were so.

They were more noble because they received the Word of God with all eagerness. They were receptive to the Apostolic instruction. Yes, they examined the Scriptures in the light of Apostolic teaching, and this is what was lost during the Reformation. Apostolic Teaching was replaced with modern methods of “exegesis” so that the Word of God was no longer handed down, through the paradosis,but extracted from the pages of the Scriptures. And each man extracts according to his own sensibilities, resulting in fragmentaiton of the Body.
Code:
2 Timothy 2:2—Nowhere in this verse would you take away that Paul was passing down an infallible tradition unless you tried to read it into the Scripture. This describes the process of discipleship, rather.
Catholics have no need to “read into Scripture”, csobel. The New Testament was written by,for, and about Catholics. Everything in it is Catholic, and there are no contradictions between the NT and the Catholic faith, since they came from the same Source.

We read the Scripture through the lens of Sacred Tradition, which means that we understand it from the point of view of those who wrote it. This is the perspective that was lost during the Reformation.
 
“Apostolic preaching was equally binding for those who heard it from the apostles’ own mouths. Beyond that, Scripture lays no burden on anyone’s shoulders.
The Scriptures cannot “lay a burden” anyway, not being a person… However, it is false to say that Apostolic authority does not exist in the bishops, the successors to the Apostles.
But, thank God, His own Word assures us that Scripture is fully sufficient to bring us to salvation and to equip us spiritually for all that God demands of us.” –John MacArthur
All this shows is that you and John have both misunderstood the passage. 🤷
Code:
In summary, why do we Reformed Protestants believe in Sola Scriptura? Because the written Word of God is sufficient for all matters concerning faith and life, and the Lord has not given the authority of His Word to any council of man, pope, private revelation, or the like, to interpret it to their own desires.
It is true that the authority given to the Church by Christ is not for their own desires.
It is to carry out the duties of equipping the saints for the work of the ministry. If His Word is not divinely preserved in the Church, then the servants could be led astray, and imperfectly equipped.
Code:
Praise God that he has given His all-sufficient Word to us, through which the Gospel of our Lord is so clearly laid out.
In Christ,

Chris
Amen! And praise Him also that he has founded His Church, through which He manifests Himself to the world.
 
Code:
i) Catholic theologians at this point cite parallel texts like col 1:28, 4:12, Mt 19:21 and argue that the word complete in 2 Tim 3:17 doesn’t mean sufficient. These are, unfortunately, not parallel passages, and the word used here is exartizo, meaning being suited for a task, as opposed to teleios. This is simply a weak argument.
I agree. It is fortunate that Catholic theologians do not determine the doctrine of the faith, which teaches that the Scriptures are sufficient. Of course, all the saints are to be fully equipped, and the Scripture is profitable in this process. I would add, essential. This is sufficiency.
Code:
c) Jesus consistently affirmed this position in his ministry
i) During His temptation in Mt 4, he consistently rebukes Satan with the written Word. Why did He not appeal to the traditions of Pharisaical interpretation? Because the written Word of God always stands alone. No tradition of man or council (although these can both be very important!) has the final say.
Although your premise is correct, the conclusion is not. Jesus gave full authority to His Church to teach and preach the Word. He opened their minds to understand the Scriptures, and they passed these gifts and responsibiliities to their successors.
ii) After His resurrection, in Luke 24, he appeared to several men on the road, and what did he do? Did he give them a new prophetic word? Or his interpretation of the written Word? No, he simply opened their minds to the Scriptures that were already written.
Various Objections:
  1. The Word of God is more than just the written Word
    I agree, but the Scripture bears witness that it alone is sufficient for salvation, life, and Godliness. The above statement has no bearing on the sufficiency of the written Word.
This is where the historic Apostolic Church differs from the modern innovations based upon the Reformation. We believe the Apostolic Teaching that the Word of God delivered to the Church is also sufficient for salvation. Besides, that is a false statement. The scripture nowhere says of itself that it alone is suffcient for salvaiton. It is sufficient to lead one to Christ, who HImself alone is sufficient for salvation. 😉

John 5:39-41
9 You search the scriptures, because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness to me; 40 yet you refuse to come to me that you may have life.

People can search the scriptures all their lives, yet fail to come to Him for salvation. The Scriptures themselves cannot save. Only the blood of Christ can do that.
Code:
2)	“The Church gives authority to the Scriptures, since the books of the Bible were not canonized until Damasus gave a list in 382, and nowhere in the Bible does it say which books are authoritative.”
By this you really mean that that the councils of men and popes must tell us what books are authoritative. But the Bible existed before 382, and certainly before 1546, when Trent was the first ecumenical council to define the cannon.
This is false for several reasons. The definition of the canon is not as statement that “popes and councils” must tell anything. But Christ has chosen to work through the Church to promulgate and protect His Word. Just as in the council of Jerusalem, the HS works with these successors of the Apostles to guide the Church in the faith.

The bible did NOT exist before 382. Up to that time, there was a consensus of the NT and OT canon. Councils of Hippo and Carthage also affirmed these collections. What happened in 382 is that these collections were drawn together and "closed’ to be the NT canon, and bound together with the Alexandrian Seputagint to form what is today called the Bible.

Furhter, Trent was not an ecumenical council in the same tradition as the first 7, since it did not include the Eastern bishops, who have a slightly different OT canon.
Code:
 As a matter of fact, the divinely inspired apostolic letters had all been written long before that. The Scriptures have always been self-authenticating.
I agree with this principle, however, there were 400+ works floating around in 382 also claiming the same for themselves. The Church found it necessary to exclude those works claiming to be scripture that were not received by the Church.
 
Code:
For every covenant in the Bible, and unique canon was always given by God, free from being bound by authoritative interpretation of one particular tradition. This Word is not judged by us, rather it judges us (Heb 4:12). The councils did not give authority to a body of writing, but rather simply recognized what the people of God had already tried and tested as inspired. Thus it recognized the Word, but did not give authority to it.
I agree with this also, that Scripture is Scripture as soon as it is written, and that the NT writings were already received by the Church. But there were also other writings being used by the Church on the same level as Scripture, such as the Shepherd of Hermas and the letters of Clement. These writings did not make the closed canon, and other books were hotly disputed, such as Revelation, Jude, and James, that did make the canon. This sorting and discerning required an authoritative body.
Code:
-Augustine did not appeal to the councils or popes to answer the question of the cannon. He appeals to the variety in the catholic churches and urges the believer to assess what was the general consensus. He writes: “"In the matter of canonical Scriptures he should follow the authority of the greater number of catholic Churches, among which are those which have deserved to have apostolic seats and receive epistles. He will observe this rule concerning canonical Scriptures, that he will prefer those accepted by all catholic Churches to those which some do not accept; among those which are not accepted by all, he should prefer those which are accepted by the largest number of important Churches to those held by a few minor Churches of less authority. If he discovers that some are maintained by the larger number of Churches, others by the Churches of weightiest authority, although this condition is not likely, he should hold them to be of equal value."
there is no doubt that the Scriptures were in custody of the Church and that the testimony of the sensus fidelum was present. But you are wrong about Augustine. He submitted to the Teaching of the Church in all things. These principles he uses are among those used by the pope and councils to determine the authentic documents.
On Sola Scriptura he writes: “Among those things which are said openly in Scripture are to be found all those teachings which involve faith, the mores of living, and that hope and charity which we have discussed.” (Augustine, On Christian Doctrine trans. by D.W. Roberston, Jr. (New York: Liberal Arts Press, 1958) 11:9.)
(Continued in next post)
No, csobel, he was not writing about he modern doctrinal innovaiton of sola scriptura here. He was writing the Catholic doctrine of the sufficiency of the Scriptures. If you look at the top of the thread, you will find a link for “thread tools”. Type “Augustine” in there, and it will take you to several posts on this thread that demonstrate Augustine did not espouse the modern notion of SS.

You are making a great start! Keep up the good work. 👍
 
Greetings brethren,
c) Jesus consistently affirmed this position in his ministry
i) During His temptation in Mt 4, he consistently rebukes Satan with the written Word. Why did He not appeal to the traditions of Pharisaical interpretation? Because the written Word of God always stands alone. No tradition of man or council (although these can both be very important!) has the final say.
ii) After His resurrection, in Luke 24, he appeared to several men on the road, and what did he do? Did he give them a new prophetic word? Or his interpretation of the written Word? No, he simply opened their minds to the Scriptures that were already written.
 
Hello, and I beg your pardon, I must not have been very clear in explaining my perspective. In my KJV Bible, God’s Plan of Salvation is revealed to me personally, and I get to know my Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, who came in the flesh, personally. To me, Christ Jesus is a Living Person! In my Bible He says that He will come again a second time, the way He left, physically descending from Heaven.

I don’t understand the Catholic faith. I am trying to learn but I am struggling with the extra-biblical writings, trying to line them up with the Bible. It’s confusing to me.
Well, for starters, why don’t you research the original KJV, it has the original 73 books. The removal of the D-C books was only done sometime in the 1800s. Once you reseach this, my question to you is this: Who gave or where did those who removed the DC books out of the Bible get the authority to do that?
 
Sola Scriptura posits that all things necessary for salvation, and concerning faith and life are clearly laid down in the Scriptures so that any ordinary believer may understand them.
This seems to be in conflict with what St. Peter wrote:

2 Peter 3
15And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you;
16As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.
 
Hello csobel.

Welcome to CAF.

Regarding the Canon of Scripture, you said:
. . . Trent was the first ecumenical council to define the cannon (sic)
Please read the (Ecumenical) Council of Florence (1438-1445).

You can read it here: ewtn.com/library/councils/florence.htm .

If you use Internet Explorer for your browser you can click “edit” then “find on this page” then type in “Genesis” and it will take you directly to the Canon of Scripture which was being RE-affirmed years before the Protestant “Reformation” was invented. If you use Mozilla, once on the link, click “Edit” then “find” and type in “Genesis” and the same will occur.

But the issue again is WHO has the AUTHORITY to authoritatively interpret the Word of God (ALL of the Word of God—written and oral) in a manner that is PROTECTED by God from error?

The Jehovah’s Witnesses would claim they do. Many Protestants I’ve talked to claim they personally do. Who’s right? The Witnesses? The Protestants? Which Protestants? Neither? Nobody?

And if nobody is given any protected God-given authority HOW do you get ANY Canon of Scripture?

There is NO VERSE in the Bible that states:
HYPOTHETICAL VERSE “The books, letters, etc. that belong in the Bible include: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, etc. etc. Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. etc. Jude and Revelation.”
This is the unsolvable dilemma for the sola Scriptura adherent.

Sola Scriptura is a tradition of men that nullifies the commandments of God.

God bless.
 
How can the written word of god be self authenticating?

Gods word is always self authenticating. Adam had no means in the garden to establish that God’s Word was his very word other than to take it at face value. The first sin In the garden was to subject Gods word to Adams reason and the interpretation of the serpent… Adam did not need a council, or a body of interpreters to understand the Word because the Word has a high degree of clarity, and yet he found it a good idea to draw that into question.

By what authority do I make the claim of Sola Scriptura one of you asked? Hey now… Let’s keep it charitable. What I have stated is the reformed Protestant position on the Bible, because we see that is what the Scriptures teach. I am confused as to what you are getting at here?

Re the Law: again, what I have not stated is that the interpretations of men play no part in carrying authority in a believers life. This is why i made a straw man plea… But Because the law was read aloud does not mean that interpretations upon interpretations were addded that carried as much weight as the original law.

The church as the gathered body of believers is not found in scripture… Can you substantiate that claim I am not sure where you’re coming from on this?

Ivebeenshown … no, it does not contradict what Peter said. Peter here is saying that some things in scripture are hard to understand. No doubt! But the way to salvation through the blood of Jesus Christ is abundantly clear.

Cathoholic… You may very well be right that I misquoted the Church counsel, if so, please forgive me, I have overextended myself. I flipped through the link you gave but I don’t see what your wanting me to see… Can you summarize please?

Regarding authority of interpretation, we know the JWs are wrong because their views don’t stack up to Scripture. That is not a question of authority, but rather simply going to the Word to see if it’s true.

Again, can we take God at his word, or does it need the stamp of man to make it authoritative? You say ss is a tradition of man that nullifies the Word… So saying that Gods own words must stand alone as the highest authority is a tradition of man that nullifies his words? I am not trying to mock you here just let me know if I am misquoting you, but this seems to be the proposition.

God bless, and thank you for your most freverent responses!

Chris
 
I would also like to take a moment to acknowledge what we do share in common, if not for my own edification, so that this thread does not just focus on our differences as believers.

Lord,

Thank you for the great redemption that you have accomplished on our behalf by sending your Son to die in our place, and for sealing us with your Spirit. If there is falsehood or strife in any of our words, forgive us, and I pray that we would esteem each other better than ourselves and answer each other with all humility.

In the name of Jesus,

Amen

Thanks guys!
 
How can the written word of god be self authenticating?
What exactly do you mean by “authenticate”?
Code:
Gods word is always self authenticating. Adam had no means in the garden to establish that God's Word was his very word other than to take it at face value. The first sin In the garden was to subject Gods word to Adams reason and the interpretation of the serpent... Adam did not need a council, or a body of interpreters to understand the Word because the Word has a high degree of clarity, and yet he found it a good idea to draw that into question.
Yes.

But, that was before the Fall.

After the Fall, we have a sin nature, and this interferes with our ability to hear and respond to the Word of God.
Code:
By what authority do I make the claim of Sola Scriptura one of you asked? Hey now... Let's keep it charitable. What I have stated is the reformed Protestant position on the Bible, because we see that is what the Scriptures teach. I am confused as to what you are getting at here?
Thank you for your presentation of hte Reformed Protestant position on the bible. I think the question is, by what authority do Reformed Christians depart from the Teaching of the Apostles on this matter?

Where we see Christ authorizing the Apostles, we do not see any such thing occuring during the Reformation.
what I have not stated is that the interpretations of men play no part in carrying authority in a believers life.
Would that this were true.If it were, we would not have such fragmentation in the Body, and such confusion. For we all agree that the HS only leads to unity and harmony, therefore, when two devout Christians read the same Scripture, and come out with opposite understandings, we know it is not the HS who has led this.
Because the law was read aloud does not mean that interpretations upon interpretations were addded that carried as much weight as the original law.
Yes, but clearly the “ordinary” person needs assistance:

Ex 18:13-23
13 On the morrow Moses sat to judge the people, and the people stood about Moses from morning till evening. 14 When Moses’ father-in-law saw all that he was doing for the people, he said, “What is this that you are doing for the people? Why do you sit alone, and all the people stand about you from morning till evening?” 15 And Moses said to his father-in-law, “Because the people come to me to inquire of God; 16 when they have a dispute, they come to me and I decide between a man and his neighbor, and I make them know the statutes of God and his decisions.” 17 Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “What you are doing is not good. 18 You and the people with you will wear yourselves out, for the thing is too heavy for you; you are not able to perform it alone. 19 Listen now to my voice; I will give you counsel, and God be with you! You shall represent the people before God, and bring their cases to God; 20 and you shall teach them the statutes and the decisions, and make them know the way in which they must walk and what they must do. 21 Moreover choose able men from all the people, such as fear God, men who are trustworthy and who hate a bribe; and place such men over the people as rulers of thousands, of hundreds, of fifties, and of tens. 22 And let them judge the people at all times; every great matter they shall bring to you, but any small matter they shall decide themselves; so it will be easier for you, and they will bear the burden with you. 23 If you do this, and God so commands you, then you will be able to endure, and all this people also will go to their place in peace.”

Jesus knew there would be disputes and misunderstandings. That is why He provided for their resolution.
The church as the gathered body of believers is not found in scripture… Can you substantiate that claim I am not sure where you’re coming from on this?
Scripture does not limit the meaning of “church” to the body of gathered believers. Such a definition of "church’ falls way short of what the Apostles believed and taught about the nature of the Church.

When the Reformers grew weary of corruption, they wanted to bring purity to the Church which they were not witnessing. In order to make this work, they redefined “church”, abandoning what other things were said in Scripture about the Church, along with the Sacred Traditions of the Catholic Church.
Code:
Peter here is saying that some things in scripture are hard to understand. No doubt! But the way to salvation through the blood of Jesus Christ is abundantly clear.
Yes, and this, in a nutshell, is the distinction between material and formal sufficiency. 😉
Regarding authority of interpretation, we know the JWs are wrong because their views don’t stack up to Scripture. That is not a question of authority, but rather simply going to the Word to see if it’s true.
You are making yourself your own authority. YOu are comparing what JW teach with how you understand the Scripture. Because the JW teaching does not mesh with how you understand the Scripture, you reject it. You believe it is scripture making this decision, but it is yourself. Words don’t make decisions, no matter how Holy they are.
Code:
So saying that Gods own words must stand alone as the highest authority is a tradition of man
Yes. God did not intend for His word to be alone. He entrusted it to faithful men, who were able to teach others also. It is in the hands of these men that Scripture is profitable in equipping the saints for the work of the ministry.
 
Hello csobel.

Welcome to CAF.

Regarding the Canon of Scripture, you said:

Please read the (Ecumenical) Council of Florence (1438-1445).

You can read it here: ewtn.com/library/councils/florence.htm .

If you use Internet Explorer for your browser you can click “edit” then “find on this page” then type in “Genesis” and it will take you directly to the Canon of Scripture which was being RE-affirmed years before the Protestant “Reformation” was invented. If you use Mozilla, once on the link, click “Edit” then “find” and type in “Genesis” and the same will occur.

But the issue again is WHO has the AUTHORITY to authoritatively interpret the Word of God (ALL of the Word of God—written and oral) in a manner that is PROTECTED by God from error?

The Jehovah’s Witnesses would claim they do. Many Protestants I’ve talked to claim they personally do. Who’s right? The Witnesses? The Protestants? Which Protestants? Neither? Nobody?

And if nobody is given any protected God-given authority HOW do you get ANY Canon of Scripture?

There is NO VERSE in the Bible that states:

This is the unsolvable dilemma for the sola Scriptura adherent.

Sola Scriptura is a tradition of men that nullifies the commandments of God.

God bless.
St Jerome distinguished between canonical books and ecclesiastical books. The latter he judged were circulated by the Church as good spiritual reading but were not recognized as authoritative Scripture . . . The situation remained unclear in the ensuing centuries . . . According to Catholic doctrine, the proximate criterion of the biblical canon is the infallible decision of the Church. This decision was not given until rather late in the history of the Church at the Council of Trent . . . The Council of Trent definitively settled the matter of the Old Testament Canon. That this had not been done previously is apparent from the uncertainty that persisted up to the time of Trent?
New Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. I (Washington D.C.: Catholic University, 1967), p. 390.
 
"Thank you for your presentation of hte Reformed Protestant position on the bible. I think the question is, by what authority do Reformed Christians depart from the Teaching of the Apostles on this matter?

Where we see Christ authorizing the Apostles, we do not see any such thing occuring during the Reformation."

We don’t depart from any Apostolic teaching, nor do we depart from the Scriptures. By what authority does the catholic church depart from the teachings of the Word, we would similarly like to know? How is it that the Scriptures declare that there is only one mediator between man and God, Jesus Christ, and yet movements abound to make Mary a partner to this? Or that the prophetic word is still given to the church that conveniently entitles it to find all her doctrines in scripture? It goes both ways, my friend, for as long as you make accusations that the Reformed Church is departing from the traditions of the apostles, we similarly see the catholic church departing from Scripture on many fronts.

“Yes. God did not intend for His word to be alone. He entrusted it to faithful men, who were able to teach others also. It is in the hands of these men that Scripture is profitable in equipping the saints for the work of the ministry.”

Yes, but it is not an elite core of individuals who have a monopoly on interpretation. Those teachings must be subjected to the Word as the final authority… a the reformers saw that this teaching was not stacking up. It remains very clear to those outside the church.

“Would that this were true.If it were, we would not have such fragmentation in the Body, and such confusion. For we all agree that the HS only leads to unity and harmony, therefore, when two devout Christians read the same Scripture, and come out with opposite understandings, we know it is not the HS who has led this.”

Yes, there is only one correct interpretation of Scripture. Confusion? Actually, in Reformed communities I see a whole lot of agreement upon issues such as The Trinity, The Gospel, justification by faith alone, and the authority of God’s Word. Disagreements on secondary issues? Sure, but if you don’t have the primaries right, everything else may as well be thrown to the wayside–and these are the things we don’t see the catholic church getting right. In the end, you can appeal to protestant practice vs. catholic doctrine but lets compare apples with apples here, yes? Doctrine to doctrine or practice to practice.

“When the Reformers grew weary of corruption, they wanted to bring purity to the Church which they were not witnessing. In order to make this work, they redefined “church”, abandoning what other things were said in Scripture about the Church, along with the Sacred Traditions of the Catholic Church.”

You are inventing this narrative of the Reformers to suit your view of church history. While on one hand they were tired of the corruption, the reformation was primarily about justification by faith alone, how the work of Christ is credited to the believer, and the authority of Scripture. It was primarily a doctrinal issue, that false doctrine was being perpetuated.

“You are making yourself your own authority. YOu are comparing what JW teach with how you understand the Scripture. Because the JW teaching does not mesh with how you understand the Scripture, you reject it. You believe it is scripture making this decision, but it is yourself. Words don’t make decisions, no matter how Holy they are.”

The weight of these accusations should of course be felt and considered. What you are saying is that the Scriptures are so confusing that it cannot clearly be seen that, for example, the JW teaching that “Jesus did not rise from the dead in his physical body” plainly contradicts the Word. That is not my interpretation, as 1+1=2 is not my interpretation of that equation, but rather truth. Your argument falls apart quickly, however, because by what authority do you say I am making myself my own authority? Certainly not by the authority of God’s Word, because this is what I have been arguing for all along.

“Yes. God did not intend for His word to be alone. He entrusted it to faithful men, who were able to teach others also. It is in the hands of these men that Scripture is profitable in equipping the saints for the work of the ministry.”

Well that depends what they are teaching. Yes, the Scriptures are profitable in the hands of men who have been called and anointed by God to preach the Word, in particular if they are not teaching errant doctrines regarding baptismal regeneration and the like. This is not purely a catholic issue, either, as many protestant churches teach errant doctrines. Those faithful men do not give Scripture its authority, however. Only the Word of God stands alone in authority.

🙂
 
St Jerome distinguished between canonical books and ecclesiastical books. The latter he judged were circulated by the Church as good spiritual reading but were not recognized as authoritative Scripture . . . The situation remained unclear in the ensuing centuries . . . According to Catholic doctrine, the proximate criterion of the biblical canon is the infallible decision of the Church. This decision was not given until rather late in the history of the Church at the Council of Trent . . . The Council of Trent definitively settled the matter of the Old Testament Canon. That this had not been done previously is apparent from the uncertainty that persisted up to the time of Trent?
New Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. I (Washington D.C.: Catholic University, 1967), p. 390.
Trent was not an ecumenical council. It did not have representatives from the Eastern Church. That is why, to this day, they have a different OT collection from the Western Church.

Both East and West accepted the Decree of 382 on the contents of the NT.

It was reiterated at Trent due to rampant heresy.
Code:
St Jerome distinguished between canonical books and ecclesiastical books. The latter he judged were circulated by the Church as good spiritual reading but were not recognized as authoritative Scripture . . . The situation remained unclear in the ensuing centuries . . . According to Catholic doctrine, the proximate criterion of the biblical canon is the infallible decision of the Church. This decision was not given until rather late in the history of the Church at the Council of Trent . . . The Council of Trent definitively settled the matter of the Old Testament Canon. That this had not been done previously is apparent from the uncertainty that persisted up to the time of Trent?
New Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. I (Washington D.C.: Catholic University, 1967), p. 390.
Yes, but the Sacred Tradition is not maintained by any single person, though he be respected theologian or even doctor of the Church. Despite his opinions, Jerome submitted to the Church in all his scholarship. He writes to Damascus

"Therefore, though your greatness makes me fear, yet your kindness invites me. From the priest I ask the salvation of the victim; from the shepherd the safety of his sheep. Away with envy, away with all canvassing of the Roman power; it is but with the successor of the fisherman and the disciple of the Cross that I speak. Following none in the first place but Christ, I am in communion with your beatitude, that is, with the Chair of Peter. On that rock I know the Church is built. Whosoever shall eat the Lamb outside that house if profane. If any be not with Noah in the Ark, he shall perish beneath the sway of the deluge. And because for my sins I have migrated to this solitude, where Syria borders on the barbarians, and I cannot always at this great distance ask for the Holy One of the Lord from your holiness, therefore I follow here your colleagues the Egyptian confessors; and under these great ships my little vessel is unnoticed. letters to St. Damasus written about the years 376-377
 
csobel, please humor us by learning to use the “quote” feature. It is very difficult to track who said what when you don’t.
"guanophore:
"Thank you for your presentation of hte Reformed Protestant position on the bible. I think the question is, by what authority do Reformed Christians depart from the Teaching of the Apostles on this matter?

Where we see Christ authorizing the Apostles, we do not see any such thing occuring during the Reformation."
Code:
We don't depart from any Apostolic teaching, nor do we depart from the Scriptures.
Of course you don’t believe you do, since you are many generations descended from those who did, and don’t realize how much of the One Faith you have lost. If you believed you had departed, you would come back!
Code:
 By what authority does the catholic church depart from the teachings of the Word, we would similarly like to know?
It appears to you that this has happened, because you are not reading them from the point of view of those who wrote them. But I assure you, there are no departures in the Catholic Church from the Holy Writ.
How is it that the Scriptures declare that there is only one mediator between man and God, Jesus Christ, and yet movements abound to make Mary a partner to this?
Mary has a unique role in Christ’s mediation. To some extent, we are all “partners to this” when we are taken up into His ministry. None of us, though, has a role equal to that or Mary. It was God’s “movement” to make Mary who she is. We just accept what He has done.

2 Cor 5:18-21
18 All this is from God, who through Christ reconciled us to himself and gave us the ministry of reconciliation; 19 that is, in Christ God was reconciling the world to himself, not counting their trespasses against them, and entrusting to us the message of reconciliation. 20 So we are ambassadors for Christ, God making his appeal through us. We beseech you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God. 21 For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

Mary was the first to be enlisted in the ministry of reconciliation. All this is from God.
Code:
 Or that the prophetic word is still given to the church that conveniently entitles it to find all her doctrines in scripture?
I think are confused, csobel. There was never any effort made to commit the full compendium of the faith to writing. The New Testament reflects the faith of the Church, but is not the Source of it. Jesus is the Source. Any teachings of Jesus that are found in scripture are present because the Catholic Church put them there.
Code:
 It goes both ways, my friend, for as long as you make accusations that the Reformed Church is departing from the traditions of the apostles, we similarly see the catholic church departing from Scripture on many fronts.
It was not meant to be an accusation, csobel, but an observation. You cannot help but be in a condition of separation from the Apostolic faith, because you received your doctrines from those who came before you. The original Reformers did this willfully,but you did not. That is why we do not hold you accountable for the sin of separation.

The only reason it seems to you that the CC “departs from Scripture” is because you are suffering a truncated version of the gospel as a result of your ancestors’ separation.
"guanophore:
“Yes. God did not intend for His word to be alone. He entrusted it to faithful men, who were able to teach others also. It is in the hands of these men that Scripture is profitable in equipping the saints for the work of the ministry.”
Code:
 Yes, but it is not an elite core of individuals who have a monopoly on interpretation.
No, it is not. It is the Magesterium, or the Teaching Authority appointed by Christ. You can observe from the first generation of teaching authority(the Apostles) that they were far from “elite”. They were fishermen, tax collectors, etc. They were unschooled and all ran away from Jesus when He was taken into custody.
Code:
Those teachings must be subjected to the Word as the final authority...
This is one of the traditions of man that cannot be found in the Scriptures.

While it is true that none of the Apostolic Teachings will contradict the Scriptures, it is not possible for Scripture to be “a final authority”. This is because authority can only be wielded by persons, not writings, however Holy.

This doctrine was invented during the Reformation so that there could be justification to replace those who were in the Apostolic Succession as authorities over the flock.
Code:
the reformers saw that this teaching was not stacking up. It remains very clear to those outside the church.
I am sorry, I cannot tell what teaching you are referring to here. Yes, the Scripture as final authority is not stacking up to Scripture, but I don’t think you are talking about that!

There are no believers “outside the church”. Jesus only founded ONE CHURCH, therefore, all who are in Christ are members of her.

guanophore said:
“Would that this were true.If it were, we would not have such fragmentation in the Body, and such confusion. For we all agree that the HS only leads to unity and harmony, therefore, when two devout Christians read the same Scripture, and come out with opposite understandings, we know it is not the HS who has led this.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top