Sola Scriptura and why do Protestants like it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornAgain2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, John 6 isn’t about Holy Communtion. I actually did a paper on the concept of bread in John 6, and its intent isn’t eucharistic at all. Jesus’ flesh as bread is being compared to Moses’ bread, manna (see verses 30-35). Furthermore, Jesus tells them to “work for the bread that leads to eternal life” (John 6:27).
Ahhh…

More “discharge”. :coffeeread:
So, while the bread is Jesus’ body, this analogy isn’t in a eucharistic sense, but rather as a way of telling the Jews that a new way is coming, the New Covenant is upon them, and it is coming time to put Moses away and follow Him.
It is interesting that this is not consistent with what Jesus taught…
Seems to me that any who receive the Holy Spirit are given this power.
Of course it does! You have to take such things out of their context in order to justify your doctrinal innovations.
Because the text doesn’t support the RCC expansion of it.
Clearly no reading of the text form your point of view will support Catholic doctrine.😉
Well, again, you’re imposing upon this text that the Pope and Bishops inherit this, rather than all Christians generally. This is what the RCC commonly does. It claims for itself the authority of the apostles, when there isn’t any basis for such a claim.
It was the authority that the Catholic Bishops received from the Apostles that wrote, preserved, promulgated, and canonized those Scriptures. All this was done on the authority that Jesus gave to the Church.

Individuals can benefit to the extent that they are in unity with the One Church.

You are right, it all boils down to the issue of authority.
Code:
What you're missing is the RCC imposition that it (alone) is the sole inheritor of what is given to ALL of the apostles, to the exclusion of everyone else, without textual mandate.
The authority did not come from the “textual mandate”. The text was produced by the authority.

Jesus only founded One Church. Jesus only put His Own Apostles in charge of it.Those apostles passed on the authority given to them by Christ to their successors (ordained and trained by them).

One cannot just pick up the Scripture and assume their own authority. All authority comes form God, and He created a system in which to pass it.
 
So, we are where we are today. we have a church that can’t continue to exist without maintaining it’s claim to infallible teaching taht has never been fallible, and protestants who point out the problems.
Yes, here we are. Some people are still suffering from a deficient concept of the Church, and cannot grasp that the Church is pure and holy, without spot, but that there are still fallible men attached to her who sometimes excommunicate themselves by sinning.
What things?

Titus 2:11For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, **12training us to renounce **ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, 13 waiting for our blessed( hope, the( appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, 14( who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works.

15Declare these things; exhort and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.

Who among us ISN"T given the authority to declare the gospel of salvation and to “make disciples”?
It seems that you are quite invested in rejecting the scriptural evidence of an authority structure in the Church.

Who was given the authority to perform the duties about which Paul was writing to Titus?
 
We follow the instruction of 1 Timothy 3, where the elders of the local church are to be the man of one wife. This is the only heirarchy given in Scripture under Christ for ruling the Church.
Wow.

So much scripture has to be ignored to get here. :bigyikes:

Titus 2
15These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.

I guess if you can’t prove Titus was married, then he can’t have any authority.

Come to think of it, there is no proof that Timothy was married either.
2Now I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I delivered them to you.

…
16 If anyone is inclined to be contentious, we have no such practice, nor do the churches of God.

We don’t have any evidence of this being written to ANY other Church. Indeed, this seems to be something that the Corinthians were taught, and then were having difficulting following.
Exactly. He only wrote this to the Church at Corinth because they were having trouble following what had been delivered to them by the Apostle. The reason Paul knows that no other practice exists in the Churches of God is because he has been to them, and was teaching the Apostolic Message that was the same everywhere.
It seems pretty clear that this was given orally to these other Churches.
Why, if it is just a tradition of men, or only for local use?
Code:
Again, is honoring one's husband a moral or discipline issue?  How about honoring Christ?
Again, is it your contention that oral tradition is not related to morals?
Code:
Ah... but there was no command to do so in Acts 2:45.  It simply began to happen.  That isn't even oral tradition.  When they found that it became an issue, Stephen and other men were appointed to deal with it, and that practice went away.
No, Muze, the practice never “went away”. the fact that Protestant communities don’t have this practice is part of the faith of the Apostles that has been lost when they departed from the Teachings of the faith.
Code:
It's only a problem for The Church claiming to be The Authority in all matters of morals and faith, and claiming infallibility in its teachings.
It is not a problem for Catholics because the Catholic Chruch is not fragmented by it. The problem results from the fragmenting and splintering of the One Body that is caused by this heretical teaching.
Code:
2) Having 30,000 groups united around the core principles of Christianity, and leaving the disputable matters to be disputed and resolved in a friendly way, rather than excommunicating each other and declaring others to be non-Christian over non-essential stuff,
Muze,.you seem to have a somewhat limited experience with history and current events. There has never been unity among the Children of the Reformers with regard to Christian doctrine. On the contrary, the Reformers executed one another with as much fervency as they did Catholics. There is no consistency in what is “essental” and what is “disputable matters”. Scripture does not support either concept, and Jesus clearly taught an alternative method for resolving disputes.
would be preferable to having one organizaiton consolidating all power into a few people who dictate to the masses, and an organization that threatens excommunication (and previously other more … severe… punishments) for those who disagree.
Jesus only created one organization, Muze, and you are right, it is prefereable. 👍

I am sorry that the monarchical style of Jesus government offends you, but the truth is that He is Head of the Church, and He consolidated His authority into only a few people, whom He then sent to the masses. If you don’t like His government style, you will have to take it up with HIm.
TBH, in the early church, this is where things were headed. Maybe not 30,000 groups, but there were 7 Churches in the original Church.
I hope you continue to study the history of your faith, Muze. Shortly you will find out that this is a serious error.
Code:
Unfortunately, that took 350 years or so, and built into the Church an institutional and power controlling mindset, which resulted in things like the abuse of indulgences, which was allowed to go on with the Pope's knowledge for far too long, and other issues where Church image and power was given precedence over truth and morality.
You are mixing apples and garbage, Muze. The institution and authority of the Church was in place before any of the communities mentioned in Revelation were started. The complete authority given by Christ belonged to the Apostles, and those to whom they authorized to teach and preach.

The fact that valid authority exists is not related to abuses of it. Jesus authority over heaven and earth was not diminished by Judas’ betrayal of HIm.

There have always been wolves among the sheep.

Indeed there were times when the greed of men in positions of authority was given precedence over truth and morality. Jesus did not promise that people would be without sin. Only that the Church would be infallible. When people depart from the Teaching of the Church, they are no longer protected by this promise.
 
Really? Where?
NT:1956

epiluo (ep-ee-loo’-o); from NT:1909 and NT:3089; to solve further, i.e. (figuratively) to explain, decide:

(Biblesoft’s New Exhaustive Strong’s Numbers and Concordance with Expanded Greek-Hebrew Dictionary. Copyright © 1994, 2003 Biblesoft, Inc. and International Bible Translators, Inc.)

Interesting that even Protestant Scholars disagree with your “expulsion” on this term.

2 Peter 1:19-21
  1. Observe, No scripture prophecy is of private interpretation (or a man’s own proper opinion, an explication of his own mind), but the revelation of the mind of God.
(from Matthew Henry’s Commentary on the Whole Bible: New Modern Edition, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1991 by Hendrickson Publishers, Inc.)

2 Peter 1:19
If, however, as the more obvious sense of this passage seems to be, and as many suppose to be the correct interpretation (see Doddridge, in loc., and Professor Stuart, on the Canon of the Old Testament, p. 329), it means that the prophecy was more sure, more steadfast, more to be depended on than even what the three disciples had seen and heard in the mount of transfiguration, this may be regarded as true in the following respects:

(1) The prophecies are numerous, and by their number they furnish a stronger proof than could be afforded by a single manifestation. however clear and glorious.

(2) They were “recorded,” and might be the subject of careful comparison with the events as they occurred.
(from Barnes’ Notes, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1997 by Biblesoft)

2 Peter 1:20
Knowing this first, that no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation.

[Knowing this first] Considering this as a first principle, that no prophecy of the Scripture, whether that referred to above, or any other, is of any private interpretation-proceeds from the prophet’s own knowledge or invention, or was the offspring of calculation or conjecture. The word epilusis (NT:1955) signifies also impetus, impulse; and probably this is the best sense here; not by the mere private impulse of his own mind.(from Adam Clarke’s Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1996 by Biblesoft)

2 Peter 1:20
as the word is the Holy Spirit’s,** it cannot be interpreted by its readers (anymore than by its writers) by their private human powers, **but by the teaching of the Holy Spirit (John 16:14); for it was by the Holy Spirit that its speakers and writers were “moved.”
(from Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1997 by Biblesoft)
 
The Word of God is the writings of the apostles. Nothing more. Peter is telling his readers to follows the writings of the apostles.
Except that they did not have them yet. :tsktsk:

You are really reaching now, Muze.
That would be the gospel.
You just can’t let yourself, see, can you, that the Word of God has never been limited to the Scriptures.

1 Thess 2:13-14
hen you received the word of God which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers.

This is a clear reference to the Sacred Tradition = the Word of God from the Apostles that is at work in the Church.
Nice assertion.
It is curious that you do not recieve the Teaching Authority appointed by Christ to the Church as “nice”. In fact, you seem to want to deny it all together, even though the Scriptures clearly testify to it.
Which wouldn’t be a bad thing. Once we establish the few fundamental doctrines of Christianity, then we can begin to discuss the disputable matters in a friendly way. There is simply no need for the RCC to make an official and infallible declaration about birth control. None.
There is no need for any of us to redefine any doctrines that we received from the Apostles. The fundamental doctrines, as well as the advanced ones, were all given in a “once for all” deposit to the Church through the Apostles.

Indeed there is a need for the Chruch to make official infallible declarations. This has been the case from the beginning, because sheep have a tendency to get lost.
 
No. Because it is pretty obvious that Peter is saying a couple of things:
  1. He (and the other apostles) are dying off. The Church is going to need a solid foundation on which to build and hold of false teachers. We can see this just before verse 16 and in the beginning of chapter 2.
No, Muze. The solid foundation on which to build was already put in place by Christ, and they passed on their authority to hold off false teachers. Teaching, reproving, and correcting are duties of persons, not writings, however Holy.
Code:
2) He goes to great lengths to create a very distinct group that were with Christ and saw His glory.  He uses four exclusive "we"s in a row.
He is referencing the transfiguration and the assumption. The “we” are the fledgling Church, which constitute the solid foundation built by Christ.
  1. He then goes on to say that those same “we” (who saw Christ’s glory) have the Word made more sure, and the first identification of their writings as being of God is made.
Yes. it is the apostolic witness that validates the Scriptures.
Nowhere in here does Peter talk about tradition or interpretation. He is pointing directly to the writings of himself and others who saw Christ’s glory. Thus, to translate this word (which only appears here in the bible, and in other Greek writings is translated “releasing” or “discharging”) in context, “revelation” or “generation” (the former gets the point more clearly) just makes the most sense.
No, Muze. Peter is here referencing the prophesies of the OT.

As far as the meaning of the word, I refer you back to several Protestant scholars I referenced above. They understand it the same way the Catholics received from the Apostles. You are the one who seems to cling to the divergent view, and that is primarily to reject the authority that Jesus gave to the CAtholic Church.
To translate as “interpretation” simply diverges far too much from the point Peter makes.
And would reinforce the authority vested in him by Christ as the one to feed and care for the flock.
Now, I can understand why ECFs would translate or use this as “interpretation”. It’s a great way to keep people from running off into their own private theologies. And I can understand why the RCC has an investment in keeping it that way.
😃
But the context and evidence about the word in other Greek texts simply doesn’t fit.
The context that Muze does not wish to subject himself to the authority appointed by Christ, and is therefore pulling at straws to find ways to justify not doing so.
 
Muze,

I asked you a series of questions about the authorship and authority of different books of the bible. You said:

"The OT canon was: (a) determined by “Jews” (you don’t say who they were - you just say “Jews”), (b) it was closed by Malachi (but you don’t say when), (c) determined by those acting under authority from God via the “Old Covenant”, through the Levites (but you don’t provide a source for this).

Then you said the NT canon was “determined by God, via Peter” (which would be hard to do when you are dead).

Muze, can you please tell me wherein the bible does it say all of what you just said above? How do you know Jews were the ones who determined the OT canon? How do you know that Malachi was the last person to write an OT-inspired book? How do you know that the Levites were the ones who had the authority to determine the OT canon based on their status as religious leaders? How could Peter have determined the NT canon when Peter died before all of the NT books were written?

Can’t you see how fallacious your *sola scriptura *argument is? Everything you just said above is not in the bible!!!.

For example, who authored Judges? Where, in the bible, does it name the author of Judges? When was Judges written? What about Judges made it worthy to be part of the OT canon? You see, Muze, not one of these questions about Judges can be answered by looking solely to the bible - not one.

But ONCE you look to someone or something outside of scripture to answer a question ABOUT scripture, the basis of *sola scriptura *falls downs miserably (and loudly, I might add).

Regarding my second post, I must admit, Muze, you are too funny.

I asked you: “Prior to the Protestant Revolt in the Middle Ages, how was man supposed to learn about God’s word and how was man supposed to be sure that what he was hearing, was, in fact, the correct teaching of that word?”

You responded: “Unless he was educated enough to read Greek and Hebrew, he couldn’t, apart from the teachings of the Churches. He wouldn’t know whether it was proper teaching or not. Those under Arian bishops or in the Oriental Orthodox Church had the same problem. This is why the invention of the printing press and the movable type was instrumental in fomenting the Protestant Reformation: Suddenly bibles were available for people to read.”

That’s really funny . . . you know why? ***Because the first complete book printed for distribution to others on the printing press by Gutenberg was the Latin Vulgate - the “official bible” of the Catholic Church !!!

Do you honestly take the position that, until the printing press, someone had to be educated and wealthy (only the wealthy could afford bibles for their homes and private use) to be able to study scripture, except from what he or she learned from “churches”? And what “churches” were those? I don’t know of any Methodist, Baptist, Lutheran, Church of God, Church of Christ, (and on and on and on). How were these poor, illiterate people supposed to know what they were being taught was correct? Do you really* believe that God set up a system in which his* true teachings *would be taught to his people by (and I am using your words) “a group of elders getting together and hashing it out”?

That is plain ridiculous!

What if your pastor and his elders come to one conclusion about baptism and another church down the road (both protestant, of course) has its pastor and elders come together and come to a completely different conclusion about baptism - which one is correct? They can’t both be correct.

Muze - don’t you realize? God does not see gray - he sees black and white! God does not have to “hash things out”. God does not have to “think” about things. God knows all. aFor God, there is no moral uncertainty. You either baptize infants or you don’t. The bread and wine either turn into Christ’s body and blood or they don’t. There is no “in between” on these matters.

It is man’s finite mind that prevents him from knowing all there is to know, but it is man’s pride that prevents him from listening to others (such as the Catholic Church) teach him what God’s word really means.

I have to say that it is really, really sad to see educated people believe that God allowed his people roam the earth for 15 centuries in ignorance and then suddenly, decided to “wake them up” and give the world people such as Luther (a vicious anti-Semite), Henry VIII (a degenerate who could not keep his pants on), et al., as teachers of his word.

P.S. - I am curious about something else you said on how the invention of the printing press fostered in a new age of everyday man being able to read and study the bible

How do you know that the bible first printed was an accurate translation of the original manuscripts first written by the original authors of the books of the bible?

I can write a book, claim that St. Paul wrote it, but other than the logical fallacy of ipse dixit (“it is so because I say it is so”), it is impossible for me or anyone else to prove St. Paul wrote it. One needs God to ensure that what we have is really an inspired book or an institution begun by and protected by God.

I sincerely ask you to really think about that. Other than his Church, what (and this is my phrase) “delivery mechanism” did God institute in order for his word to be “given” to man so that man could be sure the books he was reading was really part of sacred scripture? Remember - God didn’t give the bible to his people like he gave the Ten Commandments to Moses written on a stone by God himself. The bible took hundreds and hundreds of years to come together into one cohesive whole.**
 
Muze,

I asked you a series of questions about the authorship and authority of different books of the bible. You said:…
Excellent job, Savatore. I hope he will try to answer your questions. It would help him a lot. 👍
 
Hi, Guanophore,

This was an excellent set of posts - very enjoyable to read! 👍

And, there is even the creatio of a new metaphor … ‘mixing apples and garbage…’! 😃

God bless
No, Muze. The solid foundation on which to build was already put in place by Christ, and they passed on their authority to hold off false teachers. Teaching, reproving, and correcting are duties of persons, not writings, however Holy.

He is referencing the transfiguration and the assumption. The “we” are the fledgling Church, which constitute the solid foundation built by Christ.

Yes. it is the apostolic witness that validates the Scriptures.

No, Muze. Peter is here referencing the prophesies of the OT.

As far as the meaning of the word, I refer you back to several Protestant scholars I referenced above. They understand it the same way the Catholics received from the Apostles. You are the one who seems to cling to the divergent view, and that is primarily to reject the authority that Jesus gave to the CAtholic Church.

And would reinforce the authority vested in him by Christ as the one to feed and care for the flock.

😃

The context that Muze does not wish to subject himself to the authority appointed by Christ, and is therefore pulling at straws to find ways to justify not doing so.
 
guanaphore,

Thank you.

I must admit that Muze’s “take” on Christ’s disciples grumbling because they thought that they were going to have to deal with Moses’s “rules” again is the most unique interpretation of John 6 I have ever heard.

Even non-believers in transubstantiation acknowledge that John 6 is definitely referring to the Eucharist - the question for them is whether it was literal vs. figurative.

The disciples grumbled because they did not like the idea of eating meat and drinking blood, something that was anathema to them dating back to ancient times.

How people can read John 6, see that many disciples do not like the idea of transubstantiation (although that is not what they called it) it, began to leave Christ because of their dislike of what he was saying, and Christ does NOT correct their “misunderstanding” because he meant what he said, baffles me.

I have always said from day-one: If Christ had been misunderstood, why would he have allowed those disciples to leave vs. tell them they misunderstood and that “X is what I really meant, so please don’t go”?

I have had fundamentalists (on my wife’s side of the family) argue with me that the earth is only 6000 years old, that dinosaurs were “planted” by modern man to make the earth appear older than it really is (for what reason, they have no explanation 😦 ), and yet out of all the passages in the bible, they render the most important part as “figurative” rather than “literal”.
 
You’re making the rash assumption that wrong teaching is always of the Devil.
Ultimately all that is wrong with this world - including people not receiving doctrine directly from God - “is of the Devil”
False dichotomy. Two people, honestly desiring to serve Christ, can come to different conclusions about doctrine. One or both may be wrong, but that doesn’t mean the Devil made them do it.
Perhaps not, but one thing it does mean is that Sola Scriptura does not allow one to know God’s will for them in certain areas. That would be the main point for this thread: if Sola Scriptura allows and condones the misunderstanding of the Gospel, then why do you like it?? 🤷 Why bother recording the Gospel if it can be misunderstood by those genuinely seeking to understand it?
But just out of curiousity, why don’t you explain exactly who or what would allow someone “honestly desiring” to understand the Christian faith to not understand it?
 
Hi, Salvatore,

Ah, now … don’t be ‘nasty’… 😃 Muze could have written that ‘paper’ for a creative writing course! Heck, I would have given him an “A+” - it totally caught me off guard. 😃
OK… I did kind’a stretch that one just a bit… .😃

In my limited experience I have found that none of the groups that wave the SS banner around really believe in it. Most of them really get vocal if anyone claims more than six 24-hour days… and, that is OK… but present John 6 and, “It’s a metaphor!” or “The flesh profits nothing - so eating Christ’s Flesh would profit nothing!” or “Moses did not allow for cannibalism!” and that is strange, indeed. Try those arguments with the Genesis account of Creation and they will not tolerate it.

This is the longest public discourse the Christ has with non-Apostles present. Christ hits the same point about Him not only being the Bread come down from heaven - but this Bread MUST be eaten if you are to have life in you - about 16 times from different angles all in an effort to bring about understanding. And, it works!

It worked in the sense that they understood Him. (“How can this man give us his flesh to eat?”) It wasn’t initially successful in human terms in that once they really understood what He was talking about - they walked away. So many walked away that I am left with the impression that there were just the Twelve left after the dust cleared. And those who walked had seen the feeding of the 5,000 and quite possibly other miracles. These ‘walkers’ left Christ strictly because of doctrine - and you know what - that is going on to this very day.

Now, when it comes to in-laws … I have 40 years of experience. And, while mine are all Catholic - they are strange indeed. But, you may have me beat - as nutty as mine are, I never did hear about burrying fossils as a method of deceiving people through bogus science.

I have enjoyed reading your posts.

God bless
guanaphore,

Thank you.

I must admit that Muze’s “take” on Christ’s disciples grumbling because they thought that they were going to have to deal with Moses’s “rules” again is the most unique interpretation of John 6 I have ever heard.

Even non-believers in transubstantiation acknowledge that John 6 is definitely referring to the Eucharist - the question for them is whether it was literal vs. figurative.

The disciples grumbled because they did not like the idea of eating meat and drinking blood, something that was anathema to them dating back to ancient times.

How people can read John 6, see that many disciples do not like the idea of transubstantiation (although that is not what they called it) it, began to leave Christ because of their dislike of what he was saying, and Christ does NOT correct their “misunderstanding” because he meant what he said, baffles me.

I have always said from day-one: If Christ had been misunderstood, why would he have allowed those disciples to leave vs. tell them they misunderstood and that “X is what I really meant, so please don’t go”?

I have had fundamentalists (on my wife’s side of the family) argue with me that the earth is only 6000 years old, that dinosaurs were “planted” by modern man to make the earth appear older than it really is (for what reason, they have no explanation 😦 ), and yet out of all the passages in the bible, they render the most important part as “figurative” rather than “literal”.
 
Hi, Guanophore,

This was an excellent set of posts - very enjoyable to read! 👍

And, there is even the creatio of a new metaphor … ‘mixing apples and garbage…’! 😃

God bless
😃

I was going to say oranges, like usual, then I realized that it did not qualify as a nutritious foodstuff. I was tired,a nd could not think of an adequate substitute.
 
Hi, Guanophore,

Well… just as long as you were not discriminationg against oranges … 😃

I am going to call it a night - I can’t believe I got so little done on my “Honey Do Lilst…”!
😃 I will catch you in the morning.

God bless
😃

I was going to say oranges, like usual, then I realized that it did not qualify as a nutritious foodstuff. I was tired,a nd could not think of an adequate substitute.
 
Greetings brethren,

I have read through some of the material on this thread and am quite shocked at the amount of straw men that are being set up to take down ‘sola scriptura’!

First, let us clearly define the terms:

Sola Scriptura posits that all things necessary for salvation, and concerning faith and life are clearly laid down in the Scriptures so that any ordinary believer may understand them. Scripture stands alone as the highest authority on matters of faith and life for the believer, and is the ultimate court of appeal.

It does not posit that Scripture is the only authority that may bear on a persons life, or that the church (as in the gathered body of true believers) is not an authoritative interpreter of those Scriptures. But we deny that a specific church or see or progression of men has the sole authority of interpreting those very Scriptures.

Here is the proof of this:
  1. This is the way that God has always worked
    a) The mosaic law is a prime example. The law stands on its own, and does not require a third party interpreter to infuse it with authority. It was written down (cf. Deut 31:9-12), the people listened to it, and it was in this very word that life was to be found. It was a common occurrence in the ministry of Jesus Christ that he strongly rebuked the traditions of the Pharisees in regards to the interpretation of the mosaic law: " You hypocrites, rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you:‘THIS PEOPLE HONORS ME WITH THEIR LIPS, BUT THEIR HEART IS FAR AWAY FROM ME. ‘BUT IN VAIN DO THEY WORSHIP ME, TEACHING AS DOCTRINES THE PRECEPTS OF MEN.’ (Mt 15:7)
    Much of the sermon on the mount is dedicated to the stripping away of these man made traditions that were polluting his Law (Mt 5-7).
    The law clearly stood on its own; it was sufficient for salvation (Micah 5:8).
    b) This does not change with the glorious realization of the shadows and types of the mosaic economy in Christ, but rather finds its perfect fulfillment. Paul exhorts Timothy and reaffirms that the Scriptures (he’s probably talking about the OT here) are able to make him wise in salvation through Christ Jesus (2Tim3:15-17) and that they can equip the godly man for every good work.
    i) Catholic theologians at this point cite parallel texts like col 1:28, 4:12, Mt 19:21 and argue that the word complete in 2 Tim 3:17 doesn’t mean sufficient. These are, unfortunately, not parallel passages, and the word used here is exartizo, meaning being suited for a task, as opposed to teleios. This is simply a weak argument.
    c) Jesus consistently affirmed this position in his ministry
    i) During His temptation in Mt 4, he consistently rebukes Satan with the written Word. Why did He not appeal to the traditions of Pharisaical interpretation? Because the written Word of God always stands alone. No tradition of man or council (although these can both be very important!) has the final say.
    ii) After His resurrection, in Luke 24, he appeared to several men on the road, and what did he do? Did he give them a new prophetic word? Or his interpretation of the written Word? No, he simply opened their minds to the Scriptures that were already written.
    Various Objections:
  2. The Word of God is more than just the written Word
    I agree, but the Scripture bears witness that it alone is sufficient for salvation, life, and Godliness. The above statement has no bearing on the sufficiency of the written Word.
  3. “The Church gives authority to the Scriptures, since the books of the Bible were not canonized until Damasus gave a list in 382, and nowhere in the Bible does it say which books are authoritative.”
    By this you really mean that that the councils of men and popes must tell us what books are authoritative. But the Bible existed before 382, and certainly before 1546, when Trent was the first ecumenical council to define the cannon. As a matter of fact, the divinely inspired apostolic letters had all been written long before that. The Scriptures have always been self-authenticating. For every covenant in the Bible, and unique canon was always given by God, free from being bound by authoritative interpretation of one particular tradition. This Word is not judged by us, rather it judges us (Heb 4:12). The councils did not give authority to a body of writing, but rather simply recognized what the people of God had already tried and tested as inspired. Thus it recognized the Word, but did not give authority to it.
    -Augustine did not appeal to the councils or popes to answer the question of the cannon. He appeals to the variety in the catholic churches and urges the believer to assess what was the general consensus. He writes: ““In the matter of canonical Scriptures he should follow the authority of the greater number of catholic Churches, among which are those which have deserved to have apostolic seats and receive epistles. He will observe this rule concerning canonical Scriptures, that he will prefer those accepted by all catholic Churches to those which some do not accept; among those which are not accepted by all, he should prefer those which are accepted by the largest number of important Churches to those held by a few minor Churches of less authority. If he discovers that some are maintained by the larger number of Churches, others by the Churches of weightiest authority, although this condition is not likely, he should hold them to be of equal value.”
    On Sola Scriptura he writes: “Among those things which are said openly in Scripture are to be found all those teachings which involve faith, the mores of living, and that hope and charity which we have discussed.” (Augustine, On Christian Doctrine trans. by D.W. Roberston, Jr. (New York: Liberal Arts Press, 1958) 11:9.)
    (Continued in next post)
 
  1. The Scriptures must be read within the living tradition of the whole Church (CCC 113)
    This is a subtle way of saying that you can’t understand the Scriptures without the teaching of the Catholic church. Essentially, that the authority of Scripture derives from the church. The appeal to the equal authority of the Word in written form as well as Tradition is often to 2 Thessalonians 2:15, 2 Timothy 2:2, and 1 Cor 11:2. But do these really teach an authoritative tradition equal to the word of God? Does Scripture contradict itself with stern warnings not to add to the written Word (Deut 4:2, Rev 22:18)?
    “So then, brothers, stand firm and hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter.” (2 Thes 2:15) Just to clarify, the Greek here for tradition is paradosis, which denotes authoritative doctrine. But context and the rest of Scripture, not the applying of Scripture to a pet doctrine, must be the rule of sound biblical exegesis. In this context, Pual is rebuking the Thessalonians for buying on to a phony doctrine in a false letter when they should have known better than to swallow, given his personal visit and earlier letter. We cannot say here that Paul established a (T)radition that was to be passed down and would be equal with the word, but rather that the Thessalonians were not to believe anything but the very words that came out of his mouth, or was not signed by his very pen. To say that this establishes a Tradition that is passed down through the Church and coequal with Scripture is an exegetical fallacy. Paul contrasts the Thessalonians, who easily swallowed the traditions of man, over against the Bereans, who he commended in Acts 17:11 for submitting the Apostolic teaching to the Scriptures. Why? Because they are the highest authority in life and faith, and Paul knew that.
    2 Timothy 2:2—Nowhere in this verse would you take away that Paul was passing down an infallible tradition unless you tried to read it into the Scripture. This describes the process of discipleship, rather.
    “Apostolic preaching was equally binding for those who heard it from the apostles’ own mouths. Beyond that, Scripture lays no burden on anyone’s shoulders. But, thank God, His own Word assures us that Scripture is fully sufficient to bring us to salvation and to equip us spiritually for all that God demands of us.” –John MacArthur
    In summary, why do we Reformed Protestants believe in Sola Scriptura? Because the written Word of God is sufficient for all matters concerning faith and life, and the Lord has not given the authority of His Word to any council of man, pope, private revelation, or the like, to interpret it to their own desires.
    Praise God that he has given His all-sufficient Word to us, through which the Gospel of our Lord is so clearly laid out. Jesus Christ has born the wrath of God concerning sinners who would turn to Him in faith, and it is the glory of this finished work and the risen Christ to which we turn for our only salvation.
In Christ,

Chris
 
That’s nice, but it doesn’t answer BA’s question. How can the doctrine of sola scriptura be practical when it has failed Protestantism so miserably?

Bible devotion nourishes, I won’t dispute that. But where in the Bible does Jesus give us a Bible?

Spot the fake verse!
51] I am the bible which came down from heaven; if any one reads this book, he will live for ever; and the bible which I shall give for the life of the world is my book."
51] I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any one eats of this bread, he will live for ever; and the bread which I shall give for the life of the world is my flesh."

That’s a beautiful dissertation. But it doesn’t explain how sola scriptura is practical when it has caused so much disunity. Personally, I don’t think that SS is Protestants main problem. SS spiritualizes real food and real drink into text. The Church is an extension of the Incarnation united by the Eucharist. SS redefines “Church” as something invisible, and spiritualized Jesus words of eternal life as if He meant all His words in the New Testament, and not in the context of Peter’s answer in John 6:68. What “words of eternal life” is Peter talking about? SS leans too heavily on a literal approach to scripture, but selectively spiritualizes one chapter in the Bible. John 6. That’s why a new denomination is being formed every 12 hours. It’s ONE BREAD, not a separate bread for each offering. It’s ONE BODY, not a broken home.

Acts 9:4-5; 22:8; 26:14-15 – Jesus asks Saul, “Why are you persecuting me?” when Saul was persecuting the Church. Jesus and the Church are one body (Bridegroom and Bride), and we are one with Jesus through His flesh and blood (the Eucharist).

We pray that God leads you home

Hello, and I beg your pardon, I must not have been very clear in explaining my perspective. In my KJV Bible, God’s Plan of Salvation is revealed to me personally, and I get to know my Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, who came in the flesh, personally. To me, Christ Jesus is a Living Person! In my Bible He says that He will come again a second time, the way He left, physically descending from Heaven.

When Jesus Christ walked the Earth, he was a Jew, and He is the foretold Messiah that Israel was waiting for. In the Last Supper, which was the passover meal that the jews celebrated in rememberance of the exodus from Egypt and the promise of a Priest-King, Jesus reveals to them that the second of the three unleavened matzo-bread they break symbolising the Messiah, was in fact Himself. In the Bible is explained that He was speaking figuratively, because he tells them to eat unleavened bread, and this is new doctrine, as leaven throughout the Bible is seen as traditions and teachings that corrupt the new covenant which is wholly spiritual and the work of God alone.

The real offering of flesh and blood was done once on the Cross when Jesus took upon his sinfree self all the sins of the world so that we might be saved through faith in Him. Jesus is no longer on the Cross because He is now in heaven with God, risen and alive. As a protestant with a personal relationship with and love for Jesus Christ who is the Lord of my life, I am so happy that He set me free from the bondage of works. I could just as well have been born Jewish and raised in the traditions of Pharisees who still wait for the Messiah and think they have anything to offer that could trump God’s work.

Lord Jesus Christ said on the Cross: It is finished. In the glorious Gospel God’s Plan of Salvation is crystal clear; remain in the Lord until the end, and suffer persecution from Pharisees gladly because the reward is worth it. Jesus Christ gives those who believe on Him, the Spirit of Truth, and thus we find all the answers in the Bible alone.

This is how I as a follower of my Lord Jesus Christ have found salvation, by reading the Gospel and asking Jesus to give me understanding and discernment so that no man may deceive me. I put all my trust and faith in Him alone.

I don’t understand the Catholic faith. I am trying to learn but I am struggling with the extra-biblical writings, trying to line them up with the Bible. It’s confusing to me.
 
Nikella,

You said: “Hope this explains why the Bible is so important to us Protestant Christians.”

The bible, Nikella (and Muze), is just as important to Catholics. After all, we preserved it so that it is available for use today. Without the Catholic Church, the bible would have never survived the first 1500 years from the death of Christ until the Protestant Revolt.

The problem with protestants and sola scriptura is that neither will EVER be able to authenticate the bible itself by using only the bible. To even THINK that one could do such a thing is ludicrous.

How can something authenticate itself?

Protestants always say, “the Jew determined the OT canon and Peter determined the NT canon”. Where in the world do such conclusions come from?

The Jews determined JUDAIC canon, but that wasn’t done until several centuries after Christ died.

Peter could not have determined the NT canon because he died in 67 AD, and the NT was not even finished being written yet, let alone compiled by the time of Peter’s death.

To show you the illogic of your position that the bible is self authenticating, please tell me where, in the entire bible, does it state which books should be in the bible. I will save you the trouble of looking and tell you that it is not there, but feel free to search yourself . . .

Do you not realize that the table of contents and an index are NOT inspired? Do you realize that the original manuscripts were NOT puctuated with periods, paragraph breaks, verse numbers, etc.? Where do you think these came from?

Suppose that one was to say, “well, the bible authenticates itself because we know who authored the books of the bible and (as Muze said), once we know that Paul wrote a book, then it is clearly part of the bible”.
  1. How do you know that Paul did not write anything other than what is in the bible? Are you suggesting that EVERY THING that Paul wrote was divinely inspired, and thus is in the bible? Where does the bible say that?
  2. What book in the bible specifically states that the OT has X number of books and the NT has Y number of books, and Z are the books that comprise the bible? Muze said that the Jews did this for the OT and Peter did this for the NT, but if you accept what Muze said, then you just violated your sacred principle of sola scriptura, because you are relying on something or someones (“Jews” and “Peter”) to tell you what is or is not inspired.
So much for relying ONLY on the bible to determine what should be IN the bible . . . :rolleyes:
Hello,
I was not there when King James ordered the KJB to be compiled, but I believe the 66 books of the KJV are sufficient for me to have in order to understand God’s Plan of Salvation. I have no need to prove the Bible wrong, as the Gospel to me is the Truth, through Faith.

I don’t know how to explain Faith to you. I just believe in God the Holy Father, Jesus Christ the Head of His Church, and the Holy Spirit the Vicar of Christ.

God bless.
 
"…I don’t understand the Catholic faith. I am trying to learn but I am struggling with the extra-biblical writings, trying to line them up with the Bible. It’s confusing to me.
Forums can be helpful in understanding the Catholic faith, but it’s not the best way. The best way is to attend RCIA classes, and learn with others. That is how the scriptures were presented: to a community of believers. We identify some of the meaning of scriptures by how they were understood by that early community.

Here is something I found years ago that might help clear up some of your confusion:

What distinguished the Catholic reformers of the 16th century from the Protestants was their method. The Protestants thought that they had a way of knowing the doctrines and practices of the Apostolic Church without recourse to the Church’s magisterium, which they believed was discredited.

*Their recourse was to literary analysis. It is part of the Protestant tradition to suspend judgment on doctrine until the individual is satisfied that he can find it in the Scriptures, for “the whole counsel of God, concerning all things necessary for his own glory, man’s salvation, faith and life is either expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence may be deduced from Scripture” (WCF 1:6). *

No religious teacher, not even the Church, deserves credence unless he teaches what the reader, enlightened by the Spirit, finds in the Scriptures. The believer therefore must set for himself that this or that doctrine is true. Before he accepts it, he weighs the doctrine in the balance of his own understanding of the Scriptures.

This is just the reverse of the Catholic’s approach to belief. As the Catholic sees it, he must accept God on God’s terms and not his own, which means to accept it from the hands of God’s authorized teacher. It is not for him to “judge” the divine message but only to receive it. The basic difference between Catholic and non-Catholic approach to religious truth is that the non-Catholic constructs it, while the Catholic receives it so that no construction is called for or even in place of.

Over the Book stands the Church, while according to the Reformation conception, over the Church stands the Book. This fundamental vision of the Church causes the Catholic to look to the episcopate for doctrine, because the bishops are the authentic exponents of God’s message to the world.


*The Church is an organized visible fellowship. Because it is divine institution and dynamism, the Holy Spirit dwells in it, keeping it alive, keeping it true, and making it grow. The Spirit is the source of the life of the Church, but that life is the life of a body. *

*The body is made up of many members who are distinguished one from the other by functions for which they have a fixed structure. In the Body, the bishops have the function of teaching and guiding, and this task they perform through the power of the Spirit who transfuses the whole Body, making each member effective in his function. *

The Body is one, and so the episcopate is one, and the unity of the episcopate is achieved through solidarity with the prime source of Episcopal power, the Bishop of Rome. In the Catholic vision the pope teaches in the name of the episcopate and the episcopate teaches in the name of the Church and the Church teaches in the name of Christ, and Christ teaches in the name of God.

source unavailable
 
Hello,
I was not there when King James ordered the KJB to be compiled, but I believe the 66 books of the KJV are sufficient for me to have in order to understand God’s Plan of Salvation. I have no need to prove the Bible wrong, as the Gospel to me is the Truth, through Faith.

I don’t know how to explain Faith to you. I just believe in God the Holy Father, Jesus Christ the Head of His Church, and the Holy Spirit the Vicar of Christ.

God bless.
King James did not order the Bible to be compiled—it already had been, for abut 1200 years. Until Luther, it was held by everyone that there were 73 books of the Bible, by the authority of the Church. Being a priest, what authority did Luther have to contradict Church councils?

I cannot even begin to address your articulation of the Trinity. You seem to have separated them into three distinct individuals without regard to their unity as a single God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top