G
guanophore
Guest
Ahhh…Well, John 6 isn’t about Holy Communtion. I actually did a paper on the concept of bread in John 6, and its intent isn’t eucharistic at all. Jesus’ flesh as bread is being compared to Moses’ bread, manna (see verses 30-35). Furthermore, Jesus tells them to “work for the bread that leads to eternal life” (John 6:27).
More “discharge”. :coffeeread:
It is interesting that this is not consistent with what Jesus taught…So, while the bread is Jesus’ body, this analogy isn’t in a eucharistic sense, but rather as a way of telling the Jews that a new way is coming, the New Covenant is upon them, and it is coming time to put Moses away and follow Him.
Of course it does! You have to take such things out of their context in order to justify your doctrinal innovations.Seems to me that any who receive the Holy Spirit are given this power.
Clearly no reading of the text form your point of view will support Catholic doctrine.Because the text doesn’t support the RCC expansion of it.
It was the authority that the Catholic Bishops received from the Apostles that wrote, preserved, promulgated, and canonized those Scriptures. All this was done on the authority that Jesus gave to the Church.Well, again, you’re imposing upon this text that the Pope and Bishops inherit this, rather than all Christians generally. This is what the RCC commonly does. It claims for itself the authority of the apostles, when there isn’t any basis for such a claim.
Individuals can benefit to the extent that they are in unity with the One Church.
You are right, it all boils down to the issue of authority.
The authority did not come from the “textual mandate”. The text was produced by the authority.Code:What you're missing is the RCC imposition that it (alone) is the sole inheritor of what is given to ALL of the apostles, to the exclusion of everyone else, without textual mandate.
Jesus only founded One Church. Jesus only put His Own Apostles in charge of it.Those apostles passed on the authority given to them by Christ to their successors (ordained and trained by them).
One cannot just pick up the Scripture and assume their own authority. All authority comes form God, and He created a system in which to pass it.