Sola Scriptura and why do Protestants like it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornAgain2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It also allows those outside the power hierarchy of the Church to recognize the errors of their leaders.
It allows you to decide what is error and not error based upon your own understanding of Scriptures. Which, rest assured, differs from a large number of groups who claim to ‘just teach what the bible teaches.’
 
It also allows those outside the power hierarchy of the Church to recognize the errors of their leaders.
The Holy Spirit protects the Church from teaching error. Unless you think that God is incapable of protecting the Church from the Devil. These are really the only two positions. Either God can protect His Church from error, or He can’t. If He can, then we can trust in the Church. If He can’t, then is he truly omnipotent?
 
Well, as I see it, ‘rebuke with all authority’ includes excommunication of those who refuse to assent to proper doctrine and discipline. Paul says elsewhere that if anyone doesn’t keep the tradition they received from the Apostles, to have no company with them, and admonish (rebuke) them as a brother.
Well, as I see it, the passage is about the gospel and discipleship.
If you want another example of certain authority given to certain people, look at Hebrews 13 verses 7 and 17.
Yeah, elders of the local church.
Well, the word you cite, ‘forced’, also appears in verse 3 of the same chapter but is translated as ‘compelled’. Sounds a bit biased to me.
Doesn’t really matter. Peter was actively compelling Gentiles to act like Jews.
The Gentiles were likely compelled to imitate Peter by their sense of duty to imitate the Apostles in combination with their lack of knowledge regarding circumcision-related theology, but nowhere does the passage show Peter saying ‘hey, you must be circumcised, this is official doctrine!’
LOL… SO, Peter was uncircumsized, but made sure that everyone in Galatia saw him getting circumsized, hoping they’d all feel compelled to follow? Or was he going around showing people that he was circumsized?

Seriously… whether forced or compelled, there is simply no way to objectively look at this passage and not see that Peter is verbally instructing Gentiles to live like Jews.
I told you what they did in the very post you quoted, sir – they received the word with readiness of mind and then searched the Scriptures, able to see how what Paul preached matched up because of their open mind. In contrast, Paul reasoned with the Thessalonians from the very same Scriptures but did not have the same readiness of mind, otherwise they would have seen Paul’s message line up with Scripture.
So, their acceptance of Paul’s preaching was subject their own personal interpretation and review of what Paul taught. And they were praise for this.
No, I am not saying that those two instances have no impact.
Well, then cite them and make your case…
 
The Holy Spirit protects the Church from teaching error. Unless you think that God is incapable of protecting the Church from the Devil. These are really the only two positions. Either God can protect His Church from error, or He can’t. If He can, then we can trust in the Church. If He can’t, then is he truly omnipotent?
I don’t think Protestants would say God “can’t” establish a Holy Kingdom with a prime minister and various governmental offices that is protected to doctrinal errors, but they would say God “didn’t.”
 
Yeah, elders of the local church.
And how are these elders appointed? Which elders do you submit to when these disagree with those?
Doesn’t really matter. Peter was actively compelling Gentiles to act like Jews.
LOL… SO, Peter was uncircumsized, but made sure that everyone in Galatia saw him getting circumsized, hoping they’d all feel compelled to follow? Or was he going around showing people that he was circumsized?
Seriously… whether forced or compelled, there is simply no way to objectively look at this passage and not see that Peter is verbally instructing Gentiles to live like Jews.
Oh! I read the passage wrong. What Peter did had nothing to do with anybody getting circumcised. He just separated himself from eating with the Gentiles (verse 12.) Anyways, you say ‘Peter verbally instructed the Gentiles to live like the Jews’, but where is that in the passage? All the passage tells us is that Peter compelled the Gentiles to live like the Jews, and I maintain that this ‘compelling’ was indirect.
So, their acceptance of Paul’s preaching was subject their own personal interpretation and review of what Paul taught. And they were praise for this.
No. The Bereans accepted Paul’s interpretation and message with readiness of mind. When they read the Scriptures, they read them with the same interpretation Paul had preached, not their own. They were praised for accepting the authoritative word of an Apostle.
Well, then cite them and make your case…
:confused: I already cited them. One was Mark 4:34, ‘Jesus expounded all things to his disciples.’
 
I don’t think Protestants would say God “can’t” establish a Holy Kingdom with a prime minister and various governmental offices that is protected to doctrinal errors, but they would say God “didn’t.”
I will actually wait for the Protestant to answer this question. Jesus clearly established a hierarchical Church with offices. He also promised to Send the Holy Spirit. Can the Holy Spirit ensure that the Church founded by Christ is free from error?
 
I will actually wait for the Protestant to answer this question. Jesus clearly established a hierarchical Church with offices. He also promised to Send the Holy Spirit. Can the Holy Spirit ensure that the Church founded by Christ is free from error?
I’m just saying, what you posted seems like a false dichotomy.
 
I’m just saying, what you posted seems like a false dichotomy.
It looks like a false dichotomy, but it isn’t really, as it can be shown from the Scriptures that a hierarchical Church was founded, with the accompanying promise of the Spirit of Truth.
 
And how are these elders appointed? Which elders do you submit to when these disagree with those?
Local church determines how to appoint. I would look for elders to come into agreement.
Oh! I read the passage wrong. What Peter did had nothing to do with anybody getting circumcised. He just separated himself from eating with the Gentiles (verse 12.) Anyways, you say ‘Peter verbally instructed the Gentiles to live like the Jews’, but where is that in the passage? All the passage tells us is that Peter compelled the Gentiles to live like the Jews, and I maintain that this ‘compelling’ was indirect.
Either way, Peter was, in some way, compelling Gentiles to live like Jews. That’s more than just choosing to live that way. If that were the case, Paul would be a hypocrite, as he did the same thing in Jerusalem. The difference is that Paul wasn’t compelling anyone to do anything by acting as he did.

So, clearly Peter’s hypocrisy was more than just not buying bacon at the local market. There was an element of force which clearly indicates some form of instruction to the Gentiles, underwhich they were compelled to live as Jews.
No. The Bereans accepted Paul’s interpretation and message with readiness of mind. When they read the Scriptures, they read them with the same interpretation Paul had preached, not their own. They were praised for accepting the authoritative word of an Apostle.
Um… they read them “they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so.”

They were judging for themselves by reading the bible whether the teaching was true or not. Even Paul did not expect those to whom he preached to accept his words, but to search the Scriptures to see if what he was preaching was true.

And they were called noble for doing it.
:confused: I already cited them. One was Mark 4:34, ‘Jesus expounded all things to his disciples.’
Ah… I misunderstood why you were citing those.

The word epiluw in classical Greek means to “loose” or “untie”, generally, it can mean to “solve” or “explain”, but not really in an interpretive sense, but rather in a revealing sense. I am explaining something by revealing something to you.

So, even the usage here, while it is OK to be translated “explain”, has more of a revelation than interpretation feel to it. And that fits the passage. Jesus is revealing the truth of the parable to them.

Thus, my contention that the word is better translated “revelation” rather than “interpretation” makes more sense.
 
It allows you to decide what is error and not error based upon your own understanding of Scriptures. Which, rest assured, differs from a large number of groups who claim to ‘just teach what the bible teaches.’
Which, if we can get away from the power struggles and claims of power from various groups, is just fine, because then we can begin to hash these things out together. But as long as one claims to have the whole truth and everyone who disagrees is wrong, there is no accountability and power stands over truth.
 
There is nothing more infuriating that having a question ignored. A simple response of “I will have to look into that” is better than acting like it was never asked.
 
The Holy Spirit protects the Church from teaching error. Unless you think that God is incapable of protecting the Church from the Devil.
You’re making the rash assumption that wrong teaching is always of the Devil.
These are really the only two positions. Either God can protect His Church from error, or He can’t. If He can, then we can trust in the Church. If He can’t, then is he truly omnipotent?
False dichotomy. Two people, honestly desiring to serve Christ, can come to different conclusions about doctrine. One or both may be wrong, but that doesn’t mean the Devil made them do it.
 
You’re making the rash assumption that wrong teaching is always of the Devil.

False dichotomy. Two people, honestly desiring to serve Christ, can come to different conclusions about doctrine. One or both may be wrong, but that doesn’t mean the Devil made them do it.
So let me get this straight. Two people honestly seeking Christ can come up with two opposing doctrines (example: Baptism is regenerative and in necessary for salvation/Baptism is just a symbol of obedience) and both are from God? This is ludicrous. It violates the law of non-contradiction. One is true and from God, and the other is a lie from Satan.
 
So let me get this straight. Two people honestly seeking Christ can come up with two opposing doctrines (example: Baptism is regenerative and in necessary for salvation/Baptism is just a symbol of obedience) and both are from God? This is ludicrous. It violates the law of non-contradiction. One is true and from God, and the other is a lie from Satan.
Why does it have to be from Satan? Can’t one individual simply be mistaken?
 
No. You seem to imply that Satan is powerless.
Never said that at all. I’m simply pointing out that humans make errors without Satan being there to make them do it. Not every mistake is an act of the devil.
 
Never said that at all. I’m simply pointing out that humans make errors without Satan being there to make them do it. Not every mistake is an act of the devil.
All sin comes from the devil. Sin is our conscious decision to succumb to temptation. Sola Scriptura actually feeds a very specific sin: pride. How? You don’t need the Church; you can figure Scripture out on your own. If you and the Church come to different conclusions, it is not you that could possibly be wrong, but the Church. Sola Scriptura is a manifestation of pride, clear and simple. It is a sin straight form Hell that is used in an attempt to cuase division in the Church.
 
All sin comes from the devil. Sin is our conscious decision to succumb to temptation.
James seems to say otherwise:

14But each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire. 15Then desire when it has conceived gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.
Sola Scriptura actually feeds a very specific sin: pride. How? You don’t need the Church; you can figure Scripture out on your own.
10 The brothers immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea, and when they arrived they went into the Jewish synagogue. 11Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so. 12 Many of them therefore believed, with not a few Greek women of high standing as well as men.

These people heard the teaching, but went home and searched their bibles to see if what Paul taught was true…

Sounds like sola scriptura to me…

Were they prideful, sinful, or noble?
If you and the Church come to different conclusions, it is not you that could possibly be wrong, but the Church. Sola Scriptura is a manifestation of pride, clear and simple. It is a sin straight form Hell that is used in an attempt to cuase division in the Church.
So, we should believe what the Church says, even if it is wrong?
 
James seems to say otherwise:

14But each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire. 15Then desire when it has conceived gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.

10 The brothers immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea, and when they arrived they went into the Jewish synagogue. 11Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so. 12 Many of them therefore believed, with not a few Greek women of high standing as well as men.

These people heard the teaching, but went home and searched their bibles to see if what Paul taught was true…

Sounds like sola scriptura to me…

Were they prideful, sinful, or noble?

So, we should believe what the Church says, even if it is wrong?
Which chapter of James was that? Protestants tend to cherry pick and ignore all context. Your citation from Acts does nothing to prove the heresy of Sola Scriptura. It doesn’t even matter if it did. Arianism, Nestorianism, and any other heresy you want can be defended with Scripture when you fail to be mindful of the content and unity of the whole Scripture. Lastly name one Doctrine or Dogma the Church taught in error.
 
Local church determines how to appoint. I would look for elders to come into agreement.
Sir, I find it highly unlikely that the Apostles had no particular tradition relating to how clergy are ordained.
Either way, Peter was, in some way, compelling Gentiles to live like Jews. That’s more than just choosing to live that way. If that were the case, Paul would be a hypocrite, as he did the same thing in Jerusalem. The difference is that Paul wasn’t compelling anyone to do anything by acting as he did.
So, clearly Peter’s hypocrisy was more than just not buying bacon at the local market. There was an element of force which clearly indicates some form of instruction to the Gentiles, underwhich they were compelled to live as Jews.
Paul wasn’t compelling anyone to live under Mosaic customs by what he did, because Paul wasn’t separating himself from eating with Gentiles for intimidation of the Jews who were keeping the dietary laws as Peter was. A Gentile who saw Peter doing that would think “Oh, I’m not worthy enough for Peter’s company as I am apparently, I must be just as he is doing to fellowship” and feel compelled to take on that lifestyle.

There is no element of force in play, so no, Peter was not ‘clearly instructing’ Gentiles to take the dietary laws upon themselves. There is no explicit statement that Peter verbally taught error in the guise of Christian doctrine. Isn’t this Sola Scriptura thing great?
Um… they read them “they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so.”
They were judging for themselves by reading the bible whether the teaching was true or not. Even Paul did not expect those to whom he preached to accept his words, but to search the Scriptures to see if what he was preaching was true.
And they were called noble for doing it.
Of course Paul could not expect everyone who heard him to accept his message, but the Bereans did accept it with readiness of mind. They already accepted Paul’s message, so of course they are going to see it harmonizing with Scripture. You don’t receive the Church’s teachings with readiness of mind, so when you read the Scriptures you find contradictions (or so they appear to be, in your unready mind.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top