Hi, Muze,
I think you have hit upon the very heart of the problem - the distortion of SS combined with personal interpretation, leads inevitably to novel doctrine. When I read your response, I honestly was surprised to see that you had written a paper on the Eucharistic Discourse in John 6.
Let me take another look…
Well, John 6 isn’t about Holy Communtion. I actually did a paper on the concept of bread in John 6, and its intent isn’t eucharistic at all. Jesus’ flesh as bread is being compared to Moses’ bread, manna (see verses 30-35). Furthermore, Jesus tells them to “work for the bread that leads to eternal life” (John 6:27). …
So, when we come to the point where Jesus says that they have to eat his flesh and drink his blood, he’s not referring to Eucharist, but rather to giving up following the ways of Moses and following the ways of Jesus, instead. This is why many of His disciples stopped following Him. He was telling them that the way of life they’d lived, and that their ancestors had lived for 1800 or so years was coming to an end.
I think the interpretation you have provided can only be sustained if there is another agenda to be accomplshed. Don’t you think it very obliging of the Jewish listeners to go along with Christ’s obvious muddling of words and say, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” when this was really code for, “How can this man tell us the Law of Moses has come to an end?” What an amazing view… don’t you think?
Here is the way I see John 6 … and, you can follow right along. I have taken the liberty of counting the number of times Christ actully focuses in on Him being Bread to be actually eaten - I think you can count 18 times this comes up. There is no other section in the NT where so many verses are used to develop an idea - even in the face of outright rejection, Christ continues to preach His Eucharistic Discourse.
**1-15 **Jesus feeds the 5,000 - Christ has total control over nature and feeds hungry people
**16- 21 **Jesus walks on water - Christ has total control over nature, clams the storm and the boat arrives immediately at its destination.
**22-27 **Jesus contronts the Jews who just found Him wanting a free meal - and Christ tells them to “work for the food that lasts for eternal life”
28-40 Jesus advances His Eucharistic Discourse:
1- v32 My Father gives you the real bread
2- v33 For the bread that God gives is he who comes down from heaven
3- v35 I am the bread of life
4- v35 Those who come to me will never be hungry
41-69 Jesus is challenged, responds and is rejected
5- v41-2 The people grumbled about him BECAUSE he said, “I am the bread that came down from heaven.”
(These Jews thought Jesus came from Nazareth.and they think they know his parents.)
6- v48 I am the bread of life
7- v50 But the bread that comes down … whoever eats it will not die
8- v51 I am the living bread that came down from heaven
9- v51 If you eat this bread you will live forever
10- v51 The bread that I will give you is my flesh that I will give so that the world may live
11- v52 “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?”
(The Jews understood Christ meant His Flesh - and these people REJECTED Christ becaue of this doctrine.)
Code:
12- v53 If you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you will not have life in yourselves. ***(Christ is in their face reinforcing this doctrine - there can be no honest doubt about what Christ means at this point.)***
13- v54 Those who eat my fles and drink my blood have eternal life....
14- v55 For my flesh is the real fook; my blood is the real drink.
15- v56 Those who eat my flesh and drink my blood live in me, and i live in them
16- v57 The Living Father sent me ... whoever eats me will live because of me
17- v58 It is not like the bread that your ancestors ate, but then later died. Those who eat this bread will live forever.
18- v68 Simon Peter answered him, "Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words that give eternal life.
I submit that this same type of rejection is going on throughout the world in every church that rejects Christ and His Church… and that would be the Catholic Church. SS - if it were truly believed would have embraced the Eucharistic Discourse immediately - but, it appears to be a doctrine of convenience - it is not convenient to believe John 6 because then a priest would be needed to consecrate the common bread and wine into the Body, Blood, Human Soul and Diviinity of Jesus Christ. The priest would have this power traceable back to the bishop who ordained him and the bishop would be traceable back to the Apostle who ordained him - and ultimately to the Catholic Church founded by Christ.
Can’t have that. So, it is SS when we say it is SS and a new interpretation when required.
God bless