Sola Scriptura and why do Protestants like it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornAgain2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
[The RCC] claims for itself the authority of the apostles, when there isn’t any basis for such a claim.
Titus 2
15These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.

The Apostles were apparently able to give someone ‘all authority’… 🤷
 
Muse,

The ‘silence’ in that passage seems to relate to teaching and authority, and as I’ve said teaching and authority in the Catholic church is male. What about in your church?
We follow the instruction of 1 Timothy 3, where the elders of the local church are to be the man of one wife. This is the only heirarchy given in Scripture under Christ for ruling the Church.
 
We need to make a distinction here between Oral and Written communications. 1Cor 11 is an example of written. There is no written example of oral - it is spoken and handed down word of mouth.
Umm…

2Now I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I delivered them to you.

…
16 If anyone is inclined to be contentious, we have no such practice, nor do the churches of God.

We don’t have any evidence of this being written to ANY other Church. Indeed, this seems to be something that the Corinthians were taught, and then were having difficulting following.

It seems pretty clear that this was given orally to these other Churches.
It was previously identified that head coverings was a discipline - like not eating meat on Friday - and both are examples of disciplines that have been modified at the direction of the Church.
Again, is honoring one’s husband a moral or discipline issue? How about honoring Christ?
Observing Christ’s command to baptize all nations and preach the Good News is a requirement that the Church must follow.
Note that the early Church in Acts 2:45 held everything in common, with private property being sold and the proceeds being shared with the group. This was a practice that is no longer followed except in religious communities.
Ah… but there was no command to do so in Acts 2:45. It simply began to happen. That isn’t even oral tradition. When they found that it became an issue, Stephen and other men were appointed to deal with it, and that practice went away.
And, honestly Muze, if you have, “…examples to the contrary…” identify them - so we know what they are. I do not want you slipping back into those one line quips… 😃
Again, I think you’re dismissing 1 Cor 11 a bit too hastily, especially given that it talks about this as oral tradition before he comments on it.
SS is a basic problem because it denies the teaching authority of the Church - and, that would be exactly what those leading the Protestant Revolt intended.
It’s only a problem for The Church claiming to be The Authority in all matters of morals and faith, and claiming infallibility in its teachings.
Of course, looking at 30,000+ competing groups is probably not what they intended either. :rolleyes::rolleyes:
  1. There aren’t 30,000 denominations. That is an invented figure.
  2. Having 30,000 groups united around the core principles of Christianity, and leaving the disputable matters to be disputed and resolved in a friendly way, rather than excommunicating each other and declaring others to be non-Christian over non-essential stuff, would be preferable to having one organizaiton consolidating all power into a few people who dictate to the masses, and an organization that threatens excommunication (and previously other more … severe… punishments) for those who disagree. Groups on all sides are guilty of this.
TBH, in the early church, this is where things were headed. Maybe not 30,000 groups, but there were 7 Churches in the original Church. Obviously several fundamental issues surrounding Christian doctrine were under attack from various heresies, and so the Church had to come together to defeat these things. Unfortunately, that took 350 years or so, and built into the Church an institutional and power controlling mindset, which resulted in things like the abuse of indulgences, which was allowed to go on with the Pope’s knowledge for far too long, and other issues where Church image and power was given precedence over truth and morality.

So, we are where we are today. we have a church that can’t continue to exist without maintaining it’s claim to infallible teaching taht has never been fallible, and protestants who point out the problems.
 
Um… This is the only place in the bible that this word is used. In scholaraly terms, it is known as a “hapax legomenon.”

(consider yourself shown.)
Do note I referred to the root word as well, which does appear twice within the New Testament. I have not searched the Greek Septuagint Old Testament for these words either. I do feel more inclined to trust the vast majority of scholarly translators (which include Protestants) who agree the word should be ‘interpretation’ than some guy on the internet with a novel understanding of the passage.
Not a surprise, given that Jerome did the Vulgate.
Yes, and the Vulgate NT was largely a revision of the Old Latin texts, not Greek texts.
 
Titus 2
15These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.

The Apostles were apparently able to give someone ‘all authority’… 🤷
What things?

Titus 2:11For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, **12training us to renounce **ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, 13 waiting for our blessed( hope, the( appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, 14( who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works.

15Declare these things; exhort and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.

Who among us ISN"T given the authority to declare the gospel of salvation and to “make disciples”?

(TBH, you guys are getting to be as bad as the Calvinist in using proof texts without considering context…)
 
Do note I referred to the root word as well, which does appear twice within the New Testament.
Really? Where?
I have not searched the Greek Septuagint Old Testament for these words either. I do feel more inclined to trust the vast majority of scholarly translators (which include Protestants) who agree the word should be ‘interpretation’ than some guy on the internet with a novel understanding of the passage.
I suppose that’s not a surprise, but I don’t do theology by democracy.
Yes, and the Vulgate NT was largely a revision of the Old Latin texts, not Greek texts.
And where did the Old Latin texts get translated from?
 
Because men are fallible, and the only guarantee of infallibility in the bible is for the bible itself. Like it or not, tradition and magisterium are man made, and do not carry any promise of infallibility.
We are all fortunate that what you are saying here is false.

It is not the Holy Scripture that enables men to act infallibly, because they were acting infallibly when they produced the Scriptures. It is the Power of of God that makes people infallible -

2 Peter 1:20-21
20 First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy of scripture is a matter of one’s own interpretation, 21 because no prophecy ever came by the impulse of man, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God.

It is also false that Sacred Tradition is “man made”. Sacred Tradition is the Word of God.

1 Thess 2:13-14

13 And we also thank God constantly for this, that when you received the word of God which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers.

The Magesterium, the teaching authority of the Church, is also not “man made” but created by Christ.

The reason the Church carries the promise of infallibility is because mankind needs it. Without divine intervention, everyone who reads the scriptures might interpret them differently, creating an uncountable number of denominations.
 
What things? Who among us ISN"T given the authority to declare the gospel of salvation and to “make disciples”? (TBH, you guys are getting to be as bad as the Calvinist in using proof texts without considering context…)
It’s not a matter of ‘what things’ – I was merely pointing out that the Apostles had some ability to delegate authority to others. After all, Christ appears to give the Church as an institution some authority above that of ‘two or three brethren’ (Matthew 18:17.)
Really? Where?
Mark 4:34 as ‘explained’ and Acts 19:39 as ‘determined’.
 
It’s not a matter of ‘what things’ – I was merely pointing out that the Apostles had some ability to delegate authority to others. After all, Christ appears to give the Church as an institution some authority above that of ‘two or three brethren’ (Matthew 18:17.)
It IS a matter of ‘what things’ because Paul says, “THESE THINGS’”.
Mark 4:34 as ‘explained’ and Acts 19:39 as ‘determined’.
Act 19: 38If therefore Demetrius and the craftsmen with him have a complaint against anyone, the courts are open, and there are proconsuls. Let them bring charges against one another. 39But if you seek anything further, it shall be settled in the regular assembly. 40For we really are in danger of being charged with rioting today, since there is no cause that we can give to justify this commotion." 41And when he had said these things, he dismissed the assembly.

Huh?
 
We are all fortunate that what you are saying here is false.

It is not the Holy Scripture that enables men to act infallibly, because they were acting infallibly when they produced the Scriptures. It is the Power of of God that makes people infallible -

2 Peter 1:20-21
20 First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy of scripture is a matter of one’s own interpretation, 21 because no prophecy ever came by the impulse of man, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God.

It is also false that Sacred Tradition is “man made”. Sacred Tradition is the Word of God.
The Word of God is the writings of the apostles. Nothing more. Peter is telling his readers to follows the writings of the apostles.
1 Thess 2:13-14
13 And we also thank God constantly for this, that when you received the word of God which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers.
That would be the gospel.
The Magesterium, the teaching authority of the Church, is also not “man made” but created by Christ.
Nice assertion.
The reason the Church carries the promise of infallibility is because mankind needs it. Without divine intervention, everyone who reads the scriptures might interpret them differently, creating an uncountable number of denominations.
Which wouldn’t be a bad thing. Once we establish the few fundamental doctrines of Christianity, then we can begin to discuss the disputable matters in a friendly way. There is simply no need for the RCC to make an official and infallible declaration about birth control. None.
 
Act 19: 38If therefore Demetrius and the craftsmen with him have a complaint against anyone, the courts are open, and there are proconsuls. Let them bring charges against one another. 39But if you seek anything further, it shall be settled in the regular assembly. 40For we really are in danger of being charged with rioting today, since there is no cause that we can give to justify this commotion." 41And when he had said these things, he dismissed the assembly.

Huh?
King James Version has ‘determined’, but ‘settled’ works as well, as in ‘settling a dispute.’ The same word is used in Mark as ‘explained’. All this aside, why do you seek to replace the word used in 2 Peter 1:20 by the majority of scholars with another word?

Is it because you believe that prophecies of the Scriptures ARE of private interpretation? :confused:
It IS a matter of ‘what things’ because Paul says, “THESE THINGS’”.
My intent was not to discuss ‘what things’ but to show how the Apostles have the authority to give others authority.
 
King James Version has ‘determined’, but ‘settled’ works as well, as in ‘settling a dispute.’ The same word is used in Mark as ‘explained’. All this aside, why do you seek to replace the word used in 2 Peter 1:20 by the majority of scholars with another word?

Is it because you believe that prophecies of the Scriptures ARE of private interpretation? :confused:
No. Because it is pretty obvious that Peter is saying a couple of things:
  1. He (and the other apostles) are dying off. The Church is going to need a solid foundation on which to build and hold of false teachers. We can see this just before verse 16 and in the beginning of chapter 2.
  2. He goes to great lengths to create a very distinct group that were with Christ and saw His glory. He uses four exclusive "we"s in a row.
  3. He then goes on to say that those same “we” (who saw Christ’s glory) have the Word made more sure, and the first identification of their writings as being of God is made.
  4. We then have the verse in question.
  5. We then have the verse about Scripture being spoken from God and the authors of written prophecy being carried along by the Holy Spirit.
Nowhere in here does Peter talk about tradition or interpretation. He is pointing directly to the writings of himself and others who saw Christ’s glory. Thus, to translate this word (which only appears here in the bible, and in other Greek writings is translated “releasing” or “discharging”) in context, “revelation” or “generation” (the former gets the point more clearly) just makes the most sense.

To translate as “interpretation” simply diverges far too much from the point Peter makes.

Now, I can understand why ECFs would translate or use this as “interpretation”. It’s a great way to keep people from running off into their own private theologies. And I can understand why the RCC has an investment in keeping it that way.

But the context and evidence about the word in other Greek texts simply doesn’t fit.
 
My intent was not to discuss ‘what things’ but to show how the Apostles have the authority to give others authority.
But this authority is given by CHrist to us, not by the apostles. Paul is just telling Titus to use it.
 
Hi, Muze,

I think you have hit upon the very heart of the problem - the distortion of SS combined with personal interpretation, leads inevitably to novel doctrine. When I read your response, I honestly was surprised to see that you had written a paper on the Eucharistic Discourse in John 6.

Let me take another look…
Well, John 6 isn’t about Holy Communtion. I actually did a paper on the concept of bread in John 6, and its intent isn’t eucharistic at all. Jesus’ flesh as bread is being compared to Moses’ bread, manna (see verses 30-35). Furthermore, Jesus tells them to “work for the bread that leads to eternal life” (John 6:27). …
So, when we come to the point where Jesus says that they have to eat his flesh and drink his blood, he’s not referring to Eucharist, but rather to giving up following the ways of Moses and following the ways of Jesus, instead. This is why many of His disciples stopped following Him. He was telling them that the way of life they’d lived, and that their ancestors had lived for 1800 or so years was coming to an end.
I think the interpretation you have provided can only be sustained if there is another agenda to be accomplshed. Don’t you think it very obliging of the Jewish listeners to go along with Christ’s obvious muddling of words and say, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” when this was really code for, “How can this man tell us the Law of Moses has come to an end?” What an amazing view… don’t you think? :rolleyes:

Here is the way I see John 6 … and, you can follow right along. I have taken the liberty of counting the number of times Christ actully focuses in on Him being Bread to be actually eaten - I think you can count 18 times this comes up. There is no other section in the NT where so many verses are used to develop an idea - even in the face of outright rejection, Christ continues to preach His Eucharistic Discourse.

**1-15 **Jesus feeds the 5,000 - Christ has total control over nature and feeds hungry people

**16- 21 **Jesus walks on water - Christ has total control over nature, clams the storm and the boat arrives immediately at its destination.

**22-27 **Jesus contronts the Jews who just found Him wanting a free meal - and Christ tells them to “work for the food that lasts for eternal life”

28-40 Jesus advances His Eucharistic Discourse:
1- v32 My Father gives you the real bread
2- v33 For the bread that God gives is he who comes down from heaven
3- v35 I am the bread of life
4- v35 Those who come to me will never be hungry

41-69 Jesus is challenged, responds and is rejected
5- v41-2 The people grumbled about him BECAUSE he said, “I am the bread that came down from heaven.” (These Jews thought Jesus came from Nazareth.and they think they know his parents.)
6- v48 I am the bread of life
7- v50 But the bread that comes down … whoever eats it will not die
8- v51 I am the living bread that came down from heaven
9- v51 If you eat this bread you will live forever
10- v51 The bread that I will give you is my flesh that I will give so that the world may live
11- v52 “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” (The Jews understood Christ meant His Flesh - and these people REJECTED Christ becaue of this doctrine.)
Code:
12- v53  If you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you will not have life in yourselves. ***(Christ is in their face reinforcing this doctrine - there can be no honest doubt about what Christ means at this point.)***

13- v54 Those who eat my fles and drink my blood have eternal life....
14- v55  For my flesh is the real fook; my blood is the real drink.
15- v56  Those who eat my flesh and drink my blood live in me, and i live in them
16- v57  The Living Father sent me ... whoever eats me will live because of me
17- v58  It is not like the bread that your ancestors ate, but then later died. Those who eat this bread will live forever.
18- v68  Simon Peter answered him, "Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words that give eternal life.
I submit that this same type of rejection is going on throughout the world in every church that rejects Christ and His Church… and that would be the Catholic Church. SS - if it were truly believed would have embraced the Eucharistic Discourse immediately - but, it appears to be a doctrine of convenience - it is not convenient to believe John 6 because then a priest would be needed to consecrate the common bread and wine into the Body, Blood, Human Soul and Diviinity of Jesus Christ. The priest would have this power traceable back to the bishop who ordained him and the bishop would be traceable back to the Apostle who ordained him - and ultimately to the Catholic Church founded by Christ.

Can’t have that. So, it is SS when we say it is SS and a new interpretation when required.

God bless
 
think the interpretation you have provided can only be sustained if there is another agenda to be accomplshed. Don’t you think it very obliging of the Jewish listeners to go along with Christ’s obvious muddling of words and say, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” when this was really code for, “How can this man tell us the Law of Moses has come to an end?” What an amazing view… don’t you think? :rolleyes:
 
But this authority is given by CHrist to us, not by the apostles. Paul is just telling Titus to use it.
Titus and Timothy would both have a particular type of authority because they were bishops, and they were given that authority by God through the sacrament of Holy Orders. That’s what I was getting at. Not everyone has that type of authority. You were saying that the RCC claims to have apostolic authority – that is the very authority of the clergy.

The Apostles had the ability and authority, from God, to correctly interpret Scriptures. Do you think they could have been erroneous at all? The Thessalonians thought them to be erroneous in their interpretation. The Bereans accepted their interpretation willingly.
 
Titus and Timothy would both have a particular type of authority because they were bishops, and they were given that authority by God through the sacrament of Holy Orders. That’s what I was getting at. Not everyone has that type of authority.
Hold on a second… This passage is talking about salvation and making disciples… something everyone in the Church is called to do. Are you saying that only bishops have the authority to preach the gospel?
You were saying that the RCC claims to have apostolic authority – that is the very authority of the clergy.
Except that we don’t see this being passed along.
The Apostles had the ability and authority, from God, to correctly interpret Scriptures. Do you think they could have been erroneous at all?
Peter was at Galatia.
The Thessalonians thought them to be erroneous in their interpretation. The Bereans accepted their interpretation willingly.
Umm… the Bereans didn’t accept it until they verified it for themselves, because they went home and searched the Scripture to see if what was claimed was true.

Color me Berean.

(Did you find those other instances of epilusis in the NT yet?)
 
Hold on a second… This passage is talking about salvation and making disciples… something everyone in the Church is called to do. Are you saying that only bishops have the authority to preach the gospel?
No, I do not believe that.
Except that we don’t see this being passed along.
Correction: you don’t see it.
Peter was at Galatia.
Paul called Peter a hypocrite, as in, Peter taught correctly but wasn’t practicing his own teaching. There is no explicit statement in Paul’s letter to the Galatians that Peter taught something erroneous relating to the faith.
Umm… the Bereans didn’t accept it until they verified it for themselves, because they went home and searched the Scripture to see if what was claimed was true.
Color me Berean.
The Bereans received the word with ‘all readiness of mind.’ If you don’t have the readiness of mind to receive the Word as it relates to the Church, then of course you won’t see it in the Scriptures – just like the Thessalonians.
(Did you find those other instances of epilusis in the NT yet?)
There are none, and I never did claim otherwise. I was very open about there being one instance, plus the two instances of its root (or very close word.)
 
Sure, Muze,
Perhaps you could start by showing us in the bible where **any bread **was consecrated as part of the Eucharist.
The Jews refused to believe what Christ had proclaimed and with their hardened hearts walked away grumbling about how anyone could give their flesh to be eaten. As I understand the matter, Christ is not saving us on our terms and based on our understanding - but on His Terms and on our Faith in His Word.

Here are the scriptural references for Christ’s Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity being hidden under the appearances of common bread and wine. You are right, Christ did not use the word Eucharist - but, He did say, “Take and eat, THIS IS MY BODY.” I really do not think He was joking or playing games with His friends on the night before He died. I honestly think He would want His Apostles to understand as best as they could right then and there that His plain words were what He meant. In about 18 hours He knew He would be dead.

And, that’s the way it is. All of the following references will reinfoce this basic idea. It really is a matter of just reading what is there and having faith that Christ (as demonstrated in the beginning of John 6) has total power over nature) is in charge.

Matthew 16:5–12

Mark 14:22-24

Luke 22:19–20.

John 6:32–71

1 Cor. 10:16–17

1 Cor. 11:23–31
 
Hi, Ivebeenshown,

There is an interesting dialogue between Christ and the Apostles recorded in Matthew 13:10-12 that may go a way in expalining that the Apostles were different from the others who may have been following Christ.

**10
The disciples approached him and said, “Why do you speak to them in parables?”
11
He said to them in reply, "Because knowledge of the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven has been granted to you, but to them it has not been granted.
12
To anyone who has, more will be given and he will grow rich; from anyone who has not, even what he has will be taken away. **

Not only did Christ select His Apostles, we have Paul selecting his successor bishops. These were special men and consecrated to God.

God bless
Titus and Timothy would both have a particular type of authority because they were bishops, and they were given that authority by God through the sacrament of Holy Orders. That’s what I was getting at. Not everyone has that type of authority. You were saying that the RCC claims to have apostolic authority – that is the very authority of the clergy.

The Apostles had the ability and authority, from God, to correctly interpret Scriptures. Do you think they could have been erroneous at all? The Thessalonians thought them to be erroneous in their interpretation. The Bereans accepted their interpretation willingly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top