Sola Scriptura--now I get

  • Thread starter Thread starter aurora77
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
AquinasXVI:
It may sound like a surrender but in reality it’s liberation. Many protestants who come in invariably will say that upon understanding what the church teaches, it’s like they were set free. It’s a beautiful paradox.
👍
He who is enslaved by the compass, has the freedom of the sea.
 
“We dont worship Mary.” “I practice…”
Don’t be too fast to say that. YOU might not, but there are many in your religion that DO. Some also wear medals of saint-this and saint-that. They say it’s for “protection”. So many exits from the straight and narrow. Don’t go to them.

You can take this opportunity to show the fruits of the Lord in your life.

Though I agree with some of the teachings of your religion, there’s some that I don’t agree with. We can go round and around on this (the thread proves it), but I cannot stray from it studying the Bible and the actions of the people in it.

It’s like saying “What would Jesus do?” and then looking it up in the Bible to see what He did. Some things that may seem cloudy to you are crystal clear to me. Of course we both know that abortion is not in the Bible, but we KNOW that the Bible says “thou shalt not kill” and that includes the living babies inside the wombs.

As far as fruits.

There’s been miracles performed and lives changed. Dozens and dozens of people accepting Jesus as their Savior. The hungry are fed, the naked are clothed and the homeless have shelter from the winter. Some of them went on to get employment, pay for a roof over their head and be productive in life.
(Where I go, we do NOT believe in “once saved, always saved”. I pray for those people.)

In my own family: my children are “angels” compared to my siblings and I when we was their age.
Not one is on drugs or alcohol. Not one is using the internet for evil (we have spyware that my children don’t know of.). Not one of my children (all teens) are sexually active. Not one of them swear.
All of them are active at our church. One teaches children. Another helps in the media ministry. Three more are active in the youth group and are part of the prayer team.

Not one bad report from their schools or from other people. All I hear is how they are blessings to other people and to the church.

We’re all born again and are looking forward to sitting next to Jesus on His Throne. (Rev 3:21)
 
“We dont worship Mary.” “I practice…”
Don’t be too fast to say that. YOU might not, but there are many in your religion that DO. Some also wear medals of saint-this and saint-that. They say it’s for “protection”. So many exits from the straight and narrow. Don’t go to them.
Two alarms just went off: The “Myth Alarm,” and the “Cliche Alarm.”

One of the most persistant anti-Catholic chimeras is the idea of the Catholic “Mariolator.” No anti-Catholic actually knows one of these people, but they know somebody who knows somebody who knows somebody who does. Or they “just know” some Catholics do. They see a statue or a medal and then just assume it’s worship. But, nobody can produce a single Mary-worshipper.

Why? BECAUSE THEY DON’T EXIST. And even if you were to find someone who actually did, he’d be in direct opposition to what the Church teaches.

So, drop the “you have Mary-worshippers in your religion” cliche. It’s lazy and dishonest. If we have Mariolators, please produce an e-mail address or phone number so we can send them a copy of the Bible and Catechism.
 
40.png
montanaman:
If we have Mariolators, please produce an e-mail address or phone number so we can send them a copy of the Bible and Catechism.
:thumbsup: [smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/17/17_1_34.gif](http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb001_VSXXXXXX46US)
 
As far as fruits.
There’s been miracles performed and lives changed. Dozens and dozens of people accepting Jesus as their Savior. The hungry are fed, the naked are clothed and the homeless have shelter from the winter. Some of them went on to get employment, pay for a roof over their head and be productive in life.
(Where I go, we do NOT believe in “once saved, always saved”. I pray for those people.)
In my own family: my children are “angels” compared to my siblings and I when we was their age.
Not one is on drugs or alcohol. Not one is using the internet for evil (we have spyware that my children don’t know of.). Not one of my children (all teens) are sexually active. Not one of them swear.
All of them are active at our church. One teaches children. Another helps in the media ministry. Three more are active in the youth group and are part of the prayer team.
Not one bad report from their schools or from other people. All I hear is how they are blessings to other people and to the church.
We’re all born again and are looking forward to sitting next to Jesus on His Throne. (Rev 3:21)
My ex-girlfriend of recent memory had a family like that. Everyone was perfect. Everyone smiled all the time, was nice, did good works, etc.

That was just the surface, however. Beneath that was every kind of self-serving vice–pride, jealousy–one even had a porn problem.

I wouldn’t start pre-judging yourself yet. Life is short, but it’s long enough to mangle things.
 
kujo313 said:
“We dont worship Mary.” “I practice…”
Don’t be too fast to say that. YOU might not, but there are many in your religion that DO. Some also wear medals of saint-this and saint-that. They say it’s for “protection”. So many exits from the straight and narrow. Don’t go to them.

You can take this opportunity to show the fruits of the Lord in your life.

Though I agree with some of the teachings of your religion, there’s some that I don’t agree with. We can go round and around on this (the thread proves it), but I cannot stray from it studying the Bible and the actions of the people in it.

It’s like saying “What would Jesus do?” and then looking it up in the Bible to see what He did. Some things that may seem cloudy to you are crystal clear to me. Of course we both know that abortion is not in the Bible, but we KNOW that the Bible says “thou shalt not kill” and that includes the living babies inside the wombs.

As far as fruits.

There’s been miracles performed and lives changed. Dozens and dozens of people accepting Jesus as their Savior. The hungry are fed, the naked are clothed and the homeless have shelter from the winter. Some of them went on to get employment, pay for a roof over their head and be productive in life.
(Where I go, we do NOT believe in “once saved, always saved”. I pray for those people.)

In my own family: my children are “angels” compared to my siblings and I when we was their age.
Not one is on drugs or alcohol. Not one is using the internet for evil (we have spyware that my children don’t know of.). Not one of my children (all teens) are sexually active. Not one of them swear.
All of them are active at our church. One teaches children. Another helps in the media ministry. Three more are active in the youth group and are part of the prayer team.

Not one bad report from their schools or from other people. All I hear is how they are blessings to other people and to the church.

We’re all born again and are looking forward to sitting next to Jesus on His Throne. (Rev 3:21)

From your post you seem to be very lacking in the knowledge of the Church. Please do yourself a favor and research something before you start accusing others of soemthing you don’t have the slightest idea of. Don’t take the word of just anyone, but do the research yourself.

A good book to read (besides the the Bible and the CC) is a Map of Life by Frank Sheed. I have many more ideas if you need any.

I really think that the fact that you are here is a very good start. 👍

Keep asking questions and looking.

Monica
 
40.png
montanaman:
Two alarms just went off: The “Myth Alarm,” and the “Cliche Alarm.”

One of the most persistant anti-Catholic chimeras is the idea of the Catholic “Mariolator.” No anti-Catholic actually knows one of these people, but they know somebody who knows somebody who knows somebody who does. Or they “just know” some Catholics do. They see a statue or a medal and then just assume it’s worship. But, nobody can produce a single Mary-worshipper.

Why? BECAUSE THEY DON’T EXIST. And even if you were to find someone who actually did, he’d be in direct opposition to what the Church teaches.

So, drop the “you have Mary-worshippers in your religion” cliche. It’s lazy and dishonest. If we have Mariolators, please produce an e-mail address or phone number so we can send them a copy of the Bible and Catechism.
k, email addy.
 
kujo313 said:
“We dont worship Mary.” “I practice…”
Don’t be too fast to say that. YOU might not, but there are many in your religion that DO. Some also wear medals of saint-this and saint-that. They say it’s for “protection”. So many exits from the straight and narrow. Don’t go to them.

You can take this opportunity to show the fruits of the Lord in your life.

Though I agree with some of the teachings of your religion, there’s some that I don’t agree with. We can go round and around on this (the thread proves it), but I cannot stray from it studying the Bible and the actions of the people in it.

It’s like saying “What would Jesus do?” and then looking it up in the Bible to see what He did. Some things that may seem cloudy to you are crystal clear to me. Of course we both know that abortion is not in the Bible, but we KNOW that the Bible says “thou shalt not kill” and that includes the living babies inside the wombs.

As far as fruits.

There’s been miracles performed and lives changed. Dozens and dozens of people accepting Jesus as their Savior. The hungry are fed, the naked are clothed and the homeless have shelter from the winter. Some of them went on to get employment, pay for a roof over their head and be productive in life.
(Where I go, we do NOT believe in “once saved, always saved”. I pray for those people.)

In my own family: my children are “angels” compared to my siblings and I when we was their age.
Not one is on drugs or alcohol. Not one is using the internet for evil (we have spyware that my children don’t know of.). Not one of my children (all teens) are sexually active. Not one of them swear.
All of them are active at our church. One teaches children. Another helps in the media ministry. Three more are active in the youth group and are part of the prayer team.

Not one bad report from their schools or from other people. All I hear is how they are blessings to other people and to the church.

We’re all born again and are looking forward to sitting next to Jesus on His Throne. (Rev 3:21)

What I meant by showing the fruits of the Lord in your life is that you can show your brotherly love here on this forum by stopping the attacks/accusations of Mariolotry and other alleged idolatry by the Catholic Church.
 
40.png
Angainor:
Are you being serious? Do you really think I would be allowed to be Catholic?

MrS [post=1387062]doesn’t seem to think so[/post]. Who should I believe?
To avoid any misunderstanding… and if you read the entire post… you cannot come to Christ on your terms, and be part of the Catholic Church. So, yes, if you were open and told the bishop or parish priest what you believed and that your intent was to continue to believe that… and then asked to come into the Church with that baggage, they would have to say no.
 
40.png
Angainor:
Are you being serious? Do you really think I would be allowed to be Catholic?

MrS [post=1387062]doesn’t seem to think so[/post]. Who should I believe?
You have been Protestant too long 😉 There really is a thing called authority - It doesnt matter what anyone on this board thinks - they do not hold any authority. You need to see a priest who can advise you, but the ultimate “confirmation” will come from the Bishop of the Diocese that you are in.
 
40.png
montanaman:
And now you have a powerful understanding of our love for Mary, the mother of Christ, our Savior. If we are to honor our own mothers, how much more so should we honor the woman whose “yes” gave us the Savior?
Not only that, but we - by virtue of being in Christ and to the degree to which we are conformed to him - are the mystical body of Christ and actually have Mary for our Mother…
 
40.png
Angainor:
Beats me. It never should have gone to Federal Court.I agree, pure fantasy.
Thank you. These two acknowledgements on your part invalidate your original argument.
 
kujo313 said:
“Maryologists”
Don’t be too fast to say that. YOU might not, but there are many in your religion that DO.
There are many in your faith background who practice or are bordering on Bible worship rather than worshipping God. I don’t make the claim because of them, that your faith teaches bibliolatry.
 
In my own family: my children are “angels” compared to my siblings and I when we was their age
Are you blaming the Church? Because that would seem to reflect poorly on your parents if not yourself entirely.
 
It’s like saying “What would Jesus do?” and then looking it up in the Bible to see what He did. Some things that may seem cloudy to you are crystal clear to me. Of course we both know that abortion is not in the Bible, but we KNOW that the Bible says “thou shalt not kill” and that includes the living babies inside the wombs.
I assume then, that your church also teaches that it is morally wrong to use abortifacient birth control (contraceptives such as the birth control pill or patches). No? Hmm. :hmmm:
 
40.png
MrS:
To avoid any misunderstanding… and if you read the entire post… you cannot come to Christ on your terms, and be part of the Catholic Church. So, yes, if you were open and told the bishop or parish priest what you believed and that your intent was to continue to believe that… and then asked to come into the Church with that baggage, they would have to say no.
I understand the basic idea you are trying to get across. I could argue with various ways you chose to express the idea though. (“baggage”, “on my terms”, etc.) This part is especially strange: "your intent was to continue to believe that"

What kind of person doesn’t intend to continue to believe in the future what he believes in the present? “I believe in Bigfoot, but I intend not to someday.” weird.

Anyway:

The last 6 words of your post sum it up: "they [emphasis mine]** would have to say no."**

I am not welcome.
 
40.png
Angainor:
I understand the basic idea you are trying to get across. I could argue with various ways you chose to express the idea though. (“baggage”, “on my terms”, etc.) This part is especially strange: "your intent was to continue to believe that"

What kind of person doesn’t intend to continue to believe in the future what he believes in the present? “I believe in Bigfoot, but I intend not to someday.” weird.

Anyway:

The last 6 words of your post sum it up: "they [emphasis mine]** would have to say no."**

I am not welcome.
Would your church gladly welcome me if my interaction with you and yours was to proclaim the Real Presence, the invalidity of the Solas, rejection of female pastors, etc etc etc…??

I think not.

You’re elders would have to say no.
 
40.png
Angainor:
What kind of person doesn’t intend to continue to believe in the future what he believes in the present? .
For a start each of the Apostles. And certainly Saul did not continue to believe as Paul what he believed before God knocked him down.

Additionally, a change or developement in the understanding of one’s beliefs is quite different from changing your beliefs,

Those in the Catholic Church enjoy being part of a Church that is alive and growing and will eventually bring us to the fullness of Truth. (cause it ain’t all in Scripture 😉 )

Those outside the Church, IMHO, too often have to “change churches” to find what suits them.

We should all strive to attain a “More of Him and less of me” holiness. But that is hindered outside the Catholic Church because, again IMHO, the foundations are built on Sola Scriptura, Sola Fide, and Sola Meo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top