=landon13;11479433]Hi,
Correlative, but not necessarily causative, even if one accepts the 33,000 notion (which includes 248 or some such separate Catholic Churches because it lists them by country).I understand where you are coming from but you have to see that we can’t get anywhere based on the Bible alone. Look at Protestantism. They believe in sola scriptura and there are 33,000 denominations all saying they interpret the Bible the correct way. Do you think all of them are right?
Hmmm. what about the other apostolic traditions that are the same age, and claim the same Tradition?In 2 Peter, St. Peter tells us that “There are some things in [the Scriptures] that are hard to understand, which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction, as they do the other scriptures.” We need the apostolic tradition of the Catholic Church to interpret the Bible correctly for us in line with 2,000 years of apostolic tradition.
And not even then or since, has there ever been universal agreement on the canon, even prior to the Reformation era.Did you know that the New Testament was not formally compiled until about AD 300?
Indeed! Where written scripture has its source.What were they relying on until then? The early Catholic Church relied on the apostolic tradition of letters and oral word from the apostles who Christ anointed to go and preach the Gospel. That is why so many times in the letters of St. Paul he reminds readers to “hold fast to the traditions you have been taught” or to listen to the “oral tradition”
No argument. But who decides what has been revealed, and how does that happen exactlyYes, the Bible is the final public revelation of God to man. But, everything God has revealed to man is not inside the 73 books of the Bible. St. John in his Gospel tells us that “there are also many other things which Jesus did; were every one of them to be written, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written.” There is a lot more that was revealed to us than what is in the Bible alone. This is continued and held by the apostolic tradition whether in the writings of the early Church fathers or written by doctors of the Church hundreds of years later, these “traditions” are necessary for the preservation of the Church and the interpretation of Scripture.
And may you be blessed there in word and sacrament.Take all of this from a former Protestant. I found within the Catholic Church the true Biblical understanding of the Bible and following of Apostolic Tradition that I could find no where else.
Jon