Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for correcting me. I knew there was something about the Baptist’s thinking they were original, but I didn’t know which one or how original they were claiming to be. I learned a little of that in high school and just remember learning that there was no proof to back up their claim and there is no mention of them in by any ECF, any early writings or even the Bible. I just chalked that up to wishful thinking.
They’ll no doubt claim John the Baptist.

Their history’s as lacking as their theology.
 
Church Militant:
Yet the fact is that by comparison it supports far more Catholic belief than n-C.
Which argument stated another way would say: The Catholic church has less error than the protestant church.

Great argument, Michael.
Church Militant:
Frankly, I would even say that the poster is correct to say that scripture supports Catholic belief and that, (for the reason I point out below) it does not support n-C beliefs.
Frankly, I’d expect you to say nothing else.
Church Militant:
Which particular n-C sect will you now tell us has that fullness of truth?
Define “fullness of truth,” please?
Church Militant:
So… do you feel better now that you made a carnal argument appear as if it is meritorious?
That’s an appeal to emotion, Michael, which is a fallacy; appeal to emotion can have merit, when it’s not used to manipulate; however, IMO, that’s what you’re attempting to do.
Church Militant:
I and others here have refuted your arguments using both scriptures and historic facts, and yet, just as you say here, “…you reject the argument as not valid, all the while insisting that the argument, when used against my beliefs is valid, and it disproves my beliefs.”. So how are you any better than the person above?
Of course, you’ve refuted my arguments—every single one of them. :rolleyes:

With respect to the “blued” part, you’ve missed the point of what I said. It’s not about whose better than who, but it is about whether or not the the argument MIZER presented is a double standard.
Church Militant:
In fact, most of the better Catholic apologists actually are far more sound than any of their n-C counterparts. I know because I have seen both in action.
While that may be true, I have a question for you: how do you define the word, “bias?”
Church Militant:
So long as n-C apologists begin their apologetics with Sola Scriptura, (which none of them have yet to make a convincing case for in the 500 years since the error came into being) then their every argument fails because of that fundamental error.
Michael, will you clearly state your opinion of what it is you believe to be the ”fundamental error of Sola Scriptura?”
 
Just a little extra information here… There is at least one other church making the claim to apostolic succession and that is the Landmark Independent Baptist church. If I understand them correctly, they claim to be the church founded by Jesus and can supposedly trace their lineage back to John the Baptist. Clearly, they have no historical support for their position, but they claim it none-the-less.
Just FYI
One can say what one wants, but where is the proof?
 
Sandusky,
All I can think of when I read your posts is how magnificent you are at “playing on words.” There is no proof in your writing, but you are great at making it seem as if it IS true anyway. I am sorry, but you don’t seem to be trying to consider ANYTHING we are teaching/showing you. We are around practicing and teaching what we practice and teach for over 1500 years before your denomination came into existance. We taught it, you use our bible, which was changed, to argue against our teachings and our Bible. That in itself, doesn’t make sense. Sola Scriptura and individual interpretation and so much more only came about as “fact and practice” in the Reformation.

Here is a little fact for you. After you read it, I wonder if you will question ANYTHING at all in regards to the founding of Protestantism. Because if Luther did this, changed so much, so blatantly, what else was he capable of:

In 1520, Luther proposed to adopt the canon used by rabbinic Judaism of 39 books as the OT canon. He opposed books of the Christian OT because they taught doctrines he did not like, such as prayers for the dead (2 Maccabees 12:42-46). The Councl of Trent in 1546AD dogmatically reaffirmed the 73-book canon. The Catholics Church did not ADD seven books to the Bible at the Council of Trent. We had always had 46 books in our OT. Martin Luther actually subtracted seven books to better promote his own novel opinions. Trent merely reaffirmed the same canon the Catholic Church had established almost 1200 years previoiusly, and condemned anyone who sought to tamper with Sacred Scripture. Which OT would you rather use - the OT used by the apostles and other NT writers and the early Church, or the OT used by the later jews who rejected Jesus Christ. If your bible includes the seven books, you follow the apostles and the other NT writers and the early Church. If your Bible omits the seven books, you follow the non-Christian rabbis and Martin Luther - a man whose view of Sacred Scripture allowed him to deliberately add the word “alone” to his German translation of Romans 3:28. Luther’s private judgment was his only justificatoin for adding the word “alone.” “You tell me what a great fuss the Papists are making because the word ‘alone’ is not in the text of Paul. If your Papist makes such an unneccessary row about the word ‘alone,’ say right out to him: ‘Dr. Martin Luther will have it so,’ and say: ‘Papists and asses are the one and the same thing.’ I will have it so, and I order it to be so, and my will is reason enough. I know very well the word ‘alone’ is not in the Latin and Greek text, and it was not necessary for the Papists to teach me that.”
Luther also said, “I hate Esther and 2 Maccabees so much that I wish they did not exist; they contain too much Judaism and no little heathen vice. It is noteworthy here that Luther shows his private judgement here by including Ester (an UNDISPUTED canonical book) under the same condemnation as 2 Maccebees…” (The Canon of Scripture, 101)
 
What non-C’s? There weren’t even any non-Catholics at the time.

Now you watch, I’ll bet sandusky doesn’t have a cleaver retort for this.😉 :cool:
Good catch! The non-Catholics were the pagan, gentiles, etc., that needed to hear the Good News! All Christians during that time were Catholic.
 
Always For Him:
Sandusky,

All I can think of when I read your posts is how magnificent you are at “playing on words.” There is no proof in your writing, but you are great at making it seem as if it IS true anyway. I am sorry, but you don’t seem to be trying to consider ANYTHING we are teaching/showing you.
If you look up at the right-hand-corner of any of my posts, you’ll see how long I’ve been on this forum, and how many posts I’ve made (add to that number about 800 that were lost in the great crash of 2006).

You’re mistaken about my not “considering anything.”
Always For Him:
Here is a little fact for you. After you read it, I wonder if you will question ANYTHING at all in regards to the founding of Protestantism. Because if Luther did this, changed so much, so blatantly, what else was he capable of:

In 1520, Luther proposed to adopt the canon used by rabbinic Judaism of 39 books as the OT canon. He opposed books of the Christian OT because they taught doctrines he did not like, such as prayers for the dead (2 Maccabees 12:42-46). The Councl of Trent in 1546AD dogmatically reaffirmed the 73-book canon. The Catholics Church did not ADD seven books to the Bible at the Council of Trent. We had always had 46 books in our OT. Martin Luther actually subtracted seven books to better promote his own novel opinions.
Yes, Luther did consider those 7 books to be “secondary,” or, “deutero.”

Those books had been in dispute for a long time, thus the distinction of protocanon, as opposed to deuterocanon.

From your own Catholic Encyclopedia:The terms protocanonical and deuterocanonical, of frequent usage among Catholic theologians and exegetes, require a word of caution. They are not felicitous, and it would be wrong to infer from them that the Church successively possessed two distinct Biblical Canons. Only in a partial and restricted way may we speak of a first and second Canon. Protocanonical (protos, “first”) is a conventional word denoting those sacred writings which have been always received by Christendom without dispute. The protocanonical books of the Old Testament correspond with those of the Bible of the Hebrews, and the Old Testament as received by Protestants. The deuterocanonical (deuteros, “second”) are those whose Scriptural character was contested in some quarters, but which long ago gained a secure footing in the Bible of the Catholic Church, though those of the Old Testament are classed by Protestants as the “Apocrypha”. These consist of seven books: Tobias, Judith, Baruch, Ecclesiasticus, Wisdom, First and Second Machabees; also certain additions to Esther and Daniel.There has always been dispute over those books as the above citation states (though, IMO, they soften that fact).
Always For Him:
Which OT would you rather use - the OT used by the apostles and other NT writers and the early Church, or the OT used by the later jews who rejected Jesus Christ.
You’re attempting to persuade me by appealing to my emotions. :tsktsk:

That those Jews rejected Christ has nothing to do with the legitimacy, or illegitimacy of their canon.

(continued below)
 
(continued from post #383)
Always For Him:
If your Bible omits the seven books, you follow the non-Christian rabbis and Martin Luther - a man whose view of Sacred Scripture allowed him to deliberately add the word “alone” to his German translation of Romans 3:28. Luther’s private judgment was his only justificatoin for adding the word “alone.”
Yes, Luther added the word “alone” to Romans 3:28.

The Roman Catholic writer Joseph A. Fitzmyer points out that Luther was not the only one to translate Romans 3:28 with the word “alone.”Robert Bellarmine listed eight earlier authors who used sola (Disputatio de controversiis: De justificatione 1.25 [Naples: G. Giuliano, 1856], 4.501-3):

Origen, Commentarius in Ep. ad Romanos, cap. 3 (PG 14.952).

Hilary, Commentarius in Matthaeum 8:6 (PL 9.961).

Basil, Hom. de humilitate 20.3 (PG 31.529C).

Ambrosiaster, In Ep. ad Romanos 3.24 (CSEL 81.1.119): “sola fide justificati sunt dono Dei,” through faith alone they have been justified by a gift of God; 4.5 (CSEL 81.1.130).

John Chrysostom, Hom. in Ep. ad Titum 3.3 (PG 62.679 [not in Greek text]).

Cyril of Alexandria, In Joannis Evangelium 10.15.7 (PG 74.368 [but alludes to Jas 2:19]).

Bernard, In Canticum serm. 22.8 (PL 183.881): “solam justificatur per fidem,” is justified by faith alone.

Theophylact,
Expositio in ep. ad Galatas 3.12-13 (PG 124.988).

To these eight Lyonnet added two others (Quaestiones, 114-18):

Theodoret, Affectionum curatio 7 (PG 93.100; ed. J. Raeder [Teubner], 189.20-24).

Thomas Aquinas, Expositio in Ep. I ad Timotheum cap. 1, lect. 3 (Parma ed., 13.588): “Non est ergo in eis [moralibus et caeremonialibus legis] spes iustificationis, sed in sola fide, Rom. 3:28: Arbitramur justificari hominem per fidem, sine operibus legis” (Therefore the hope of justification is not found in them [the moral and ceremonial requirements of the law], but in faith alone, Rom 3:28: We consider a human being to be justified by faith, without the works of the law). Cf. In ep. ad Romanos 4.1 (Parma ed., 13.42a): “reputabitur fides eius, scilicet sola sine operibus exterioribus, ad iustitiam”; In ep. ad Galatas 2.4 (Parma ed., 13.397b): “solum ex fide Christi” [Opera 20.437, b41]).

See further:

Theodore of Mopsuestia, In ep. ad Galatas (ed. H. B. Swete), 1.31.15.

Marius Victorinus (ep. Pauli ad Galatas (ed. A. Locher), ad 2.15-16: “Ipsa enim fides sola iustificationem dat-et sanctificationem” (For faith itself alone gives justification and sanctification); In ep. Pauli Ephesios (ed. A. Locher), ad 2.15: “Sed sola fides in Christum nobis salus est” (But only faith in Christ is salvation for us).

Augustine, De fide et operibus, 22.40 (CSEL 41.84-85): “licet recte dici possit ad solam fidem pertinere dei mandata, si non mortua, sed viva illa intellegatur fides, quae per dilectionem operatur” (Although it can be said that God’s commandments pertain to faith alone, if it is not dead [faith], but rather understood as that live faith, which works through love”). Migne Latin Text: Venire quippe debet etiam illud in mentem, quod scriptum est, In hoc cognoscimus eum, si mandata ejus servemus. Qui dicit, Quia cognovi eum, et mandata ejus non servat, mendax est, et in hoc veritas non est (I Joan. II, 3, 4). Et ne quisquam existimet mandata ejus ad solam fidem pertinere: quanquam dicere hoc nullus est ausus, praesertim quia mandata dixit, quae ne multitudine cogitationem spargerent [Note: [Col. 0223] Sic Mss. Editi vero, cogitationes parerent.], In illis duobus tota Lex pendet et Prophetae (Matth. XXII, 40): licet recte dici possit ad solam fidem pertinere Dei mandata, si non mortua, sed viva illa intelligatur fides, quae per dilectionem operatur; tamen postea Joannes ipse aperuit quid diceret, cum ait: Hoc est mandatum ejus, ut credamus nomini Filii ejus Jesu Christi, et diligamns invicem (I Joan. III, 23) See De fide et operibus, Cap. XXII, §40, PL 40:223.

Source: Joseph A. Fitzmyer Romans, A New Translation with introduction and Commentary, The Anchor Bible Series (New York: Doubleday, 1993) 360-361. Here, Luther explains why he added the word “alone.”
Always For Him:
Luther also said, “I hate Esther and 2 Maccabees so much that I wish they did not exist; they contain too much Judaism and no little heathen vice. It is noteworthy here that Luther shows his private judgement here by including Ester (an UNDISPUTED canonical book) under the same condemnation as 2 Maccebees…” (The Canon of Scripture, 101)
Again, you attempt to persuade me by manipulating my emotions. :tsktsk:

“The best of men, are men at best.”
 
If, as you say, individual interpretation results in one becoming his/her own church then you put yourself on the very horns of the dilemma upon which you try to impale those who don’t believe what you believe. {/quote]

The difference it that Catholics have a consistent standard against which to test their private interpretation. I think many Protestants do also,but they don’t realize the tradition they are using comes from men, and not directly from Christ.
sandusky;3811947:
I read Catholics who constantly question what they consider to be the wrong teachings of their priests, and bring those questions and concerns to these forums.

The standard advice? Talk to the priest; if that doesn’t work, write the Bishop; if that doesn’t work, go to another parish.
IMHO, you’re blinded to the identical problems in the CC that you hang on Protestant churches.

The difference is that there is one stable standard of Catholic doctrine. Yes, there are individuals who make errors, and sometimes it is necessary to report them to the bishop. It is also true that there are bishops who are not diligent about addressing wrong teachings. None of this changes the one immoveable standard, though. The Bishop, the priest and the laypersons are all accountable to that same standard. It is not a matter for private interpretation, but a matter of the Magesterium’s interpretation.
 
(continued from post #383)

I have not read the writings of all of those you have listed, but the ones that I do know, I know you have taken it out of context. Where is the part before and after that to show the whole context?
Your “proof” is taken out of context, separated away from the rest of the scripture as to “prove” your beliefs.

No ECF, No Catholic, No Apostle, EVER taught “alone”, Sola Scriptura, Bible alone!!!

Your quotes seem to come from some anti-Catholic book to refute Catholic teaching. If you read all of those in entirety without your Protestant glasses on, you would come to believe something else. Sola Scriptura DID NOT EXIST until Martin Luther made it up!

“Works of the law” you practice works of the law. Does your church have you tithe?

I am not trying to persuade you by manipulating your emotions. He did it. He said it. It is historical fact that he came to believe that and forever changed Christianity, split his followers from the True Church of Christ. I just think it is a bitter pill for you to swallow because you have never been taught that and have never been exposed to any different belief. It seems your interpretation and study material only support the Protestant position. But, then again, it has to. Otherwise, it would have to shine a positive light for a change on the Catholic Church.
 
Grammatically, that’s not an interpretation; try again.
17 Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls and will give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with sighing — for that would be harmful to you.
Heb 13:17

The Fathers indicate that the interpretation of this passage means that we are to obey the Bishops, as we would obey Christ.
Not at all.
So, there were holy people left after the NT was written, but they did not pass on the depth of their holy knowledge to anyone, and their authority died with them?
What Jesus said is recorded in the scripture; what Jesus taught from, and what He held the Jews responsible for knowing was the extant scripture of His day.
If you think about this, you will see that what you are asserting is patently false. Jesus was not bound to the scripture. In fact, He was fond of going beyond it:

Matt 5:22
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:28
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:32
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:34
" But I say to you,…"

Matt 5:39
“But I say to you,…”

Matt 5:44
“But I say to you,…”

Luke 6:27

“But I say to you”

You will also note that in each and every one of these references, he is citing “what was said” - not what was written. However, some of them are direct quotes from the scripture. Jesus did not limit Himself to the scripture, nor did he distinguish between the Written and Oral Sacred Tradition when He explained that our rightousness must exceed theirs.
Sola scriptura binds the true church together.
There were divisions and schisms prior to the heresy of SS,but nothing in all of history on the scale we now have, with each one doing what he sees is right in his own eyes.
Christ did not command unity, but prayed to the Father for unity; since the Father always answers the Son’s prayer, it’s specious to claim that Christ’s true church is not united.
I see your point, and, in truth, there is only One Body, and all who are joined to Him are members of it. However, what Jesus wanted is visible unity, so that all would know of Him by our love for one another. To the extent that we are not visibly united, then we fail in His desire for us.

John 13:34-35
34 I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another. 35 By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another."

Unity is necessary for love to manifest to the world. The reason for this is that we cannot love error. To the extent that we believe one another to be in error, unity is lacking, and therefore, love is lacking. If you do not think this is a commandment, why not? Do you believe it is possible to love as Christ loves, when there is error present? Is not the loving thing to put the wrongdoer out?
Thanks for admitting once again that Catholicism “never claimed to be bible based.”
You are most welcome. The Word of God upon whom Catholicism is based transcends our Bible, and our own selves. He is the image of the invisible God, who is all in all. He cannot be confined to written pages, but rules over His Body as the Head and chief cornerstone! 👍

It is He that is the Sole Ruler of our faith and morals, and not our private understanding of the writings which are subject to error (fallible).
 
17 Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls and will give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with sighing — for that would be harmful to you.
Heb 13:17

The Fathers indicate that the interpretation of this passage means that we are to obey the Bishops, as we would obey Christ.

So, there were holy people left after the NT was written, but they did not pass on the depth of their holy knowledge to anyone, and their authority died with them?

If you think about this, you will see that what you are asserting is patently false. Jesus was not bound to the scripture. In fact, He was fond of going beyond it:

Matt 5:22
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:28
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:32
“But I say to you…”

Matt 5:34
" But I say to you,…"

Matt 5:39
“But I say to you,…”

Matt 5:44
“But I say to you,…”

Luke 6:27

“But I say to you”

You will also note that in each and every one of these references, he is citing “what was said” - not what was written. However, some of them are direct quotes from the scripture. Jesus did not limit Himself to the scripture, nor did he distinguish between the Written and Oral Sacred Tradition when He explained that our rightousness must exceed theirs.

There were divisions and schisms prior to the heresy of SS,but nothing in all of history on the scale we now have, with each one doing what he sees is right in his own eyes.

I see your point, and, in truth, there is only One Body, and all who are joined to Him are members of it. However, what Jesus wanted is visible unity, so that all would know of Him by our love for one another. To the extent that we are not visibly united, then we fail in His desire for us.

John 13:34-35
34 I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another. 35 By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another."

Unity is necessary for love to manifest to the world. The reason for this is that we cannot love error. To the extent that we believe one another to be in error, unity is lacking, and therefore, love is lacking. If you do not think this is a commandment, why not? Do you believe it is possible to love as Christ loves, when there is error present? Is not the loving thing to put the wrongdoer out?

You are most welcome. The Word of God upon whom Catholicism is based transcends our Bible, and our own selves. He is the image of the invisible God, who is all in all. He cannot be confined to written pages, but rules over His Body as the Head and chief cornerstone! 👍

It is He that is the Sole Ruler of our faith and morals, and not our private understanding of the writings which are subject to error (fallible).
Just want to acknowledge that I’ve read your posts (2 of them).
 
I have not read the writings of all of those you have listed, but the ones that I do know, I know you have taken it out of context. Where is the part before and after that to show the whole context?
Your “proof” is taken out of context, separated away from the rest of the scripture as to “prove” your beliefs.

No ECF, No Catholic, No Apostle, EVER taught “alone”, Sola Scriptura, Bible alone!!!

Your quotes seem to come from some anti-Catholic book to refute Catholic teaching. If you read all of those in entirety without your Protestant glasses on, you would come to believe something else. Sola Scriptura DID NOT EXIST until Martin Luther made it up!

“Works of the law” you practice works of the law. Does your church have you tithe?

I am not trying to persuade you by manipulating your emotions. He did it. He said it. It is historical fact that he came to believe that and forever changed Christianity, split his followers from the True Church of Christ. I just think it is a bitter pill for you to swallow because you have never been taught that and have never been exposed to any different belief. It seems your interpretation and study material only support the Protestant position. But, then again, it has to. Otherwise, it would have to shine a positive light for a change on the Catholic Church.
Thanks for you response AFH; it seems that my posting and my responses on this thread have gotten you and some others addled and irritated, and, as I’m not inclined on this thread to change my tack, I’ll take my leave.

Thank you all.

Michael I’ll look in later for your response, that is, if you’re inclined to respond. :tiphat:
 
Guanophor,

Again you amaze me. This is just one of several responses you’ve made to sandusky that I will have to try and remember. This is right on!!!
I see your point, and, in truth, there is only One Body, and all who are joined to Him are members of it. However, what Jesus wanted is visible unity, so that all would know of Him by our love for one another. To the extent that we are not visibly united, then we fail in His desire for us.
Perfect. Right out of Scripture. I’ll have to look this up. Is it the same passage where Jesus prays for unity, after the passover meal, that he states that it is our unity, visible by our love for each other, that will be a sign to the world that he was who he said he was?

Thanks again for taking some of Sandy’s hits for me. I run out of time.
 
Thanks for you response AFH; it seems that my posting and my responses on this thread have gotten you and some others addled and irritated, and, as I’m not inclined on this thread to change my tack, I’ll take my leave.
Sandusky,
If you are still reading this thread, I am sorry to hear you say that. While I understand that it is difficult for a non-C that has never been taught the way of Catholocism to understand, absorb, believe, agree with what we are trying to teach and show here on these threads, you have to understand how difficult it must be for us (especially the ones who are giving wonderful, thorough scholarship), to see it just put back on us as heresy, untrue, not founded, made-up, mis-interpreted, etc… Catholocism has been practicing this since Peter and the Apostles. They taught the very things we are trying to teach you through oral and Sacred Tradition. It would be nice if there was an attempt on your part to consider our scholarship. It has been around for 2,000 years. The changes came in the Reformation. It is difficult for us to keep on trying to discuss this with you when you give the responses that you give. I really don’t think anything I or others could have said to you, is as bad as the harsh refuting you have done of our faith. Yet, we are still trying. So, if you feel you can be open and have an open conversation, please do not “take your leave.”
 
One can say what one wants, but where is the proof?
There is no proof – but that does not stop them from vehemently arguing their position. I’ve had some contact with one of them via email, and it is frightening how these folks will believe anything as long as it supports their views. A college freshman with Western Civ. 101 under his/her belt could do better research.

Per the rules, I know that we cannot post URLs here. However, you can do a Goggle search on “Landmark Independent Baptist Florida Sovereign Grace” and see just how far a field this denomination is (Visit the Pastor’s literature link for their theology).

Not only do they believe in their own fallacious background, but they also believe that the evil Catholics destroyed their early church documents and persecuted them since the time of Christ with the ultimate goal of erasing them from history. Additionally, they believe that any translation other than the 1611 King James Version of the bible is heretical and of the devil. There are other ridiculous claims and if you have plenty of time to waste, you can check them out for yourself.

Later,
tmac1956
 
There is no proof – but that does not stop them from vehemently arguing their position. I’ve had some contact with one of them via email, and it is frightening how these folks will believe anything as long as it supports their views. A college freshman with Western Civ. 101 under his/her belt could do better research.

Per the rules, I know that we cannot post URLs here. However, you can do a Goggle search on “Landmark Independent Baptist Florida Sovereign Grace” and see just how far a field this denomination is (Visit the Pastor’s literature link for their theology).

Not only do they believe in their own fallacious background, but they also believe that the evil Catholics destroyed their early church documents and persecuted them since the time of Christ with the ultimate goal of erasing them from history. Additionally, they believe that any translation other than the 1611 King James Version of the bible is heretical and of the devil. There are other ridiculous claims and if you have plenty of time to waste, you can check them out for yourself.

Later,
tmac1956
Oh, we get plenty of them around here. We deluge them with evidence and then they move on, disgruntled.

Still, it’s fun to try to get a coherent argument out of them for their beliefs. Since they’re based neither on evidence, nor on reasoning, but rather on their own very late manmade tradition, there isn’t much for a KJV-only fundamentalist apologist to do BUT recite propaganda.

Seeds planted may grow even in the rockiest ground, though, so one must spread the truth even if the odds aren’t good.

Asking them why Jesus turned water into wine and not the other way around’s always amusing, anyway.
 
Sandusky

Before you beg off, can you please tell me and the other computer illiterates, what is:

IMO

There are other, what are they, anachronims? which you have used and I don’t know what they mean. Can you at least clear this one up?

Thanks,

BTW, see I’m getting some of these, I don’t think you should have to leave this thread. Personally I’d like to hear some of the reasons why you believe as you do if you are so inclined to enlighten us. So far you haven’t really answered many of the questions posed to you, not really. You’ve done a lot of skirting around. I’d like to know why?

It seems every time I engage in debate with a non-C they always beg out saying “we’ll have to agree to disagree” and I’m always left wondering, why? If you agree there is but one truth of Christ’s revelation, aren’t you curious to know what that truth is?
 
Sandusky are you still with us?

Sandusky posted:

You argued concerning the manner in which new protestant converts are instructed. I argued identically concerning the manner in which new converts to Catholicism are instructed.

my point was that non-C’s claim to follow “bible alone” but really they learn by being taught. I don’t deny that Catholics are taught this way. You deny that non-C’s are taught this way. Since you are planning to quit, I will claim victory on this one.

You argued that scripture doesn’t support many protestant beliefs. I argued identically that scripture doesn’t support many Catholic beliefs.

All we have to do is read the Bible and we can see that the whole thing supports Catholicism and precious little supports Protestantism. I’ll claim victory on this too.

You argued that protestant interpretation proves that protestants can make the bible say anything they want it to say. I argued identically that Catholic interpretation proves that Catholics can make the bible say anything they want it to say.

The Catholic Church lets the Bible mean what it says. In many a verse there is no need to “interpret” because it is written so plainly. I win!

IOW, when I turn your manner of argument against your beliefs, you reject the argument as not valid, all the while insisting that the argument, when used against my beliefs is valid, and it disproves my beliefs.

Here’s another one. What is IOW? I never reject the argument as not valid. The argument is perfectly valid. Just because the argument proves Catholicism over Protestantism does not invallidate the argument. This is an obvious victory for me, I’ll take it, thank you very much.

It’s a double-standard. no, no double standard, the CC can stand up to any argument posed against her. She has the truth. The truth wins.

You’re going to have to think about it for while because you’re either using the argument of some other Catholic apologist, and assume that all Catholic apologetics are air-tight and true; or, you’ve been using the argument for so long, and no one has recognized the manner of the argument for what it is, and so, you’ve never been called on it.

Wrong on both counts. Sorry, I win again.
 
Final installment re: 123’s third paragraph:
God Bless you in your struggles. Keep searching. I’m sure you’ll find your way home eventually. I’ll be praying for you to.
From your writtings I can sense that you are very strong in your faith and that you have God in your life. I know that God is smiling hearing your kind words and your spritual strength.Thank you for your time and patience. You said that you think God is tapping me on my shoulder, well He is not tapping He has been doing more than tapping. I know that He wants me to learn more and that is why He puts all these questions before me. I know He wants me to be strong in my faith so I can share it with others with confidence.(Like you do). Thank you for praying for me.
 
I can not distinguish how Catholicism escapes works as a prerequisite for “earning” your way to heaven
Best advice: grab Catechism, a pencil, and a chair.

So glad I came to the Church after I had become old enough to stop taking people’s words for things knowing that folks get things wrong.

For good or ill, I say to anyone with honest questions about the faith, begin with the Catechism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top