Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I may have choosen my words poorly. I meant that memorization is a way of forcing the brain to learn and remember the material. You are absolutely right about modern day educational practices. They are not very effective. I worry for my Grandkids (not born yet). I don’t know how they will learn anything. What’s wrong is we have abandoned the best the past had to offer in favor of what’s new, what’s different. Look at our advertising today and the products advertised. The best example of my point is Jiff crunchy peanut butter. It was the absolutely best peanut butter on the market. You can’t even get it now. They don’t make it anymore. Now all you can buy is extra crunchy and it won’t even spread without tearing up the bread. They couldn’t leave a perfect product alone and just sell that. They had to make it “different” and supposedly “better.” Now we don’t have a decent crunchy peanut butter. What a loss.
Try Skippy Creamy, I still buy that. But I do agree that our values have gone to the pits in the secular world. If it weren’t for my strong Catholic Faith, and love for the Holy Mass, and TRUST in Jesus Christ, I might be setting in a corner talking to myself. I have seen my family, (all relatives) literally fall apart in the last 30 years. Loose their faith, some on drugs, kids you can’t even reason with, most don’t even bother to marry anymore, those that do, many have divorced and remarried a time or two, or just living together, single mothers of 4-5 kids, different fathers for each one, I could go on and on, it breaks my heart. Those of us that are hanging onto our Faith for dear life, have to keep going for their sake. I have had so many of my nieces and nephews come and ask me questions about God, the Church etc, because they know I am there. They were not taught as children. Some have decided that this crazy lifestyle is not worth it. A few have come into the Catholic Faith and are really trying to get their life back in order. I pray constantly for my family and all families. God Bless,Memaw.
 
As to the question of literacy, finding a good reference for the time of Christ is difficult. Israel in modern times stands out at 95%. So if all the men in the time of Christ were literate (highly unlikely), then it’s literacy would have hovered around 50%. The rest of the region today, and at the time of Christ, is lower. Even today, Egypt is slightly above 50%, it would have been much lower back then.

mfa.gov.il/MFA/Facts+About+Israel/Israel+in+Maps/Literacy+rate.htm
 
sandusky elloquently states:
I responded to this in an earlier post.
sandusky is repeating the answer given to Tim 3:15.

The answer is that he/she believes the church mentioned, is the local church, which in protestant/fundamentalism is based on the individual interpretation of Scripture. The individual decides for himself what it means and is therefore his/her own church.

OR, One might say the Pastor of the independant local church has the authority to solve disputes, but he too is an individual who is self interpreting and if one doesn’t like his interpretation then one is free to go down the street to another local pastor who interpretates the word the way the individual with the problem does and so get the answer he/she is looking for. Either way, there is no continuity, no one, definitive answer to what is the one truth of Scripture.

This can’t possibly be the plan Christ had in mind when he founded the church, nor what the Apostle had in mnd when he penned the words, '…the household of the living God, the pillar and foundation of truth. Nor does it answer the question posed to Sandusky regarding the validity of believing that the Bible is the sole rule of faith, the bastion of infallible teaching when the Bible itself states that it is the church that is the bastion of teaching.

Just one of the many, many, many contradictions in the mind’s on non-C’s.
 
Always for him attempts to get through to Sandusky with this:
It really appears that you are so steeped in your own Church’s teachings and traditions, that you can’t let yourself be open to the Truth as it has been since Peter and the Apostles.
I’ve had the same feeling talking to my Baptist sister and two Fundamentalist brothers. I don’t know much about it but is what we see in protestant/fundamentalism a form of brain washing? It seems like it might be becuase it is so hard to get them to realize their beliefs are not reasonable, based on the text of Scripture no less.
 
Interesting. One thing is clear to me, the current Protestant chaos of differing denominations is not the work of the Holy Spirit. They claim to agree on the “essentials”, yet can’t (or won’t) develop a creed to define the essentials.

Very interesting.
 
Hi again Sandusky,

I hope I’m not coming off as sarcastic. I don’t mean to. Because the written word is inherrently prone to misinterpretation, I want to be sure you realize that my tone is not one of sarcasm. Frustration, perhaps, but I do not wish to offend you.

You stated to guanophor:
That’s what you believe; that doesn’t explain how you know that what you believe is true.
To reiterate what I said in a recent post to you, we trust the CC is true, essentially because Christ promised she would be. The challenge for post-reformation believers is to find the one church founded by Jesus, which is Apostolic in nature. To do that you must first study and learn what the Apostles taught and then what their successors taught following thier deaths.

Now I know you don’t believe the Apostles had successors but this belief is contrary to what we read in scripture. As a non-C (May I know what faith tradition you practice? It would make it a lot easier to direct you if I had an inkling of your present mindset. Are you fundamentalist?), especially if you are fundamentalist, then you have studied St. Paul’s letters. He was very clearly grooming Timothy to be his successor. Wouldn’t you agree with that? He told Timothy, from prison, to select and train others to perservere in the ministry. No where in Paul’s letters does he tell the faithful (believers, if you are Baptist, Christians, if you are mainline Protestant) to read the Bible and go their own way based on what they individually determined it to mean.

Other verses in the Bible support the idea that the offices the Apostles held were permanent. The gift of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost was a perpetual gift to Christ’s Church, you believe that don’t you? It doesn’t make any sense to think that the offices held by the Apostles, the pre-figurement of which is the 12 tribes of Isreal, would end with thier deaths. The offices held by the leader of each tribe did not end under OC law. Why would anyone think the offices held by the Apostles would end under new covenant law?

Mattthew 23:2 has Jesus telling the disiciples to follow the teachings of Scribes and Pharisees because they seat in the seat of Moses. The seat (or chair) is the same as an office and it implies succession. Think of the office of the Presidency in our own form of government which was modeled after christian faith. The office is around as long as the nation is around. If the office is vacant, it needs to be filled.

If you will read the passage surrounding this verse you will learn that Jesus is getting ready to chastize the behavior of the Scribes and Pharisees because they don’t practice what they preach. Before He does this however, he assures the people that thier teachings (on matter’s of faith) are sound. This is the exact same situation we have today (and have had for two millenia) with the Papacy and the magesterium (the teaching body) of the CC. It doesn’t matter how the Pope('s) behave(s) or have behaved throughout history because the promise, the gift, the charism, if you will, is on the chair, that is the office.

In the book of acts, the first order of business of the new-born church was to choose a successor for Judas. Now the last time I checked, Judas was an Apostle and he died. His office did not die with him. Matthias was choosen his successor. If it was so important to replace the Apostle who betrayed Jesus, why wouldn’t it be even more important to replace the Apostle who Jesus choose to shepherd his flock (“feed my lambs, tend my sheep”) after His ascension?

If you will answer this one question, you will suddenly be compelled to start the study, which the catholics on this board have done, which leads one to the truth in it’s fullness. Study the faith of the early fathers. We have their writtings available to us today. What a gift that is. You can read what the first Christians, Ignatius of Antioch, Clement of Rome, Barnabas, Polycarp, St. Justin Martyr believed about the faith. These are all men who wrote in the first two centuries a.d. Take advantage of this web site. You can access many of the writings right here. If you are truely interested in coming to knowledge of Christ then you will do this. If you are simply interested in arguing with Catholics then you won’t. But please remember, you put yourself here. What lead you to come to Catholic Answers in the first place?

I would be very careful about rejecting out of hand the wealth of information at your fingertips, easily accessable to your mind. We will all have to account, someday, for the choices we made in this life. Faith, although the free gift of God, is still the choice of our free will. Like the free gift of a life preserver thrown to a drowning man, the drowning man must choose to reach for it or he will loose his life.
 
Always For Him:
sandusky,

I am really having a difficult time understanding how you could possibly believe that opposing interpretations (35,000-40,000 opposing interpretations.) won’t affect doctrine.
True doctrine is true, false doctrine is false; that’s the been the case since the writing of the NT in which false teachers were, even then, infiltrating the church.

False teaching and idolatry has plagued the church from the beginning, as it plagued Israel.

The only way to know what’s true, is to read that which Christ Himself called true—God’s word.
 
40.png
sodak:
Are you really trying to argue that the majority of the population at 100 AD were literate and had Bibles? Are you also saying that as of 100 AD, all the Bibles were bound and ready for shipment to the general population?
I didn’t raise the issue of literacy—you did.

What I stated is that all of inspired scripture that was to be written was written before 100 A.D.
40.png
sodak:
As to the question of literacy, finding a good reference for the time of Christ is difficult. Israel in modern times stands out at 95%. So if all the men in the time of Christ were literate (highly unlikely), then it’s literacy would have hovered around 50%. The rest of the region today, and at the time of Christ, is lower. Even today, Egypt is slightly above 50%, it would have been much lower back then.
It doesn’t matter; either way you look at it, in response to my statement concerning the writing of scripture, the literacy argument is a very poor argument; in fact, it’s a non-sequitur.
 
40.png
MIZER:
If the Bible was the sole rule of faith it would, firstly, tell us so and secondly there would be no opposing interpretations as every sincere reader would come to the same conclusion as to it’s meaning.

The revelation found in the correct interpretation of Scripture is singular, the interpretations of the many opposing sects, however, are not.

Logic, sandusky. Reason. You will remain lost without these two.
If opposition to something proves that it’s wrong, then you must admit the error of the Papacy.
40.png
MIZER:
sandusky is repeating the answer given to Tim 3:15.

The answer is that he/she believes the church mentioned, is the local church, which in protestant/fundamentalism is based on the individual interpretation of Scripture. The individual decides for himself what it means and is therefore his/her own church.
If, as you say, individual interpretation results in one becoming his/her own church then you put yourself on the very horns of the dilemma upon which you try to impale those who don’t believe what you believe. IMHO, you’re not thinking through these arguments that you are taking from others, but merely repeating them.
40.png
MIZER:
OR, One might say the Pastor of the independant local church has the authority to solve disputes, but he too is an individual who is self interpreting and if one doesn’t like his interpretation then one is free to go down the street to another local pastor who interpretates the word the way the individual with the problem does and so get the answer he/she is looking for. Either way, there is no continuity, no one, definitive answer to what is the one truth of Scripture.
Read the forums, MIZER.

I read Catholics who constantly question what they consider to be the wrong teachings of their priests, and bring those questions and concerns to these forums.

The standard advice? Talk to the priest; if that doesn’t work, write the Bishop; if that doesn’t work, go to another parish.

IMHO, you’re blinded to the identical problems in the CC that you hang on Protestant churches.
40.png
MIZER:
I’ve had the same feeling talking to my Baptist sister and two Fundamentalist brothers. I don’t know much about it but is what we see in protestant/fundamentalism a form of brain washing? It seems like it might be becuase it is so hard to get them to realize their beliefs are not reasonable, based on the text of Scripture no less.
That argument will end up being another case of special pleading.

Where does scripture state that the IC of Mary is a part of the Gospel that must be believed upon the pain of a loss of salvation?
 
I don’t recall ever seeing this so concise followed by the revelation that non-C’s are missing the sanctification part of the equation. I will use this to teach other’s. This is perfect.
In my experience, most Protestants don’t “miss” sanctification. They just consider that leading a life obedient to Christ is something a saved person should do.
Is it correct then to say, charity in action (works) = sanctification?
I would say “yes” an “no”. If you mean by this that the believer works out his salvation with fear and trembling, knowing that he is saved by grace, through faith, I would say yes. Works of righteousness that please God are those based in the grace of our salvation, and are those works that God has prepared beforehand that we should walk in them.

I would say “no” because many people (especially Catholics) lose sight of the grace by which they are justified, and fall into doing works of the flesh. This is why so many Protestants think that Catholics believe we can work our way to heaven. Without faith, it is impossible to please Him, and no matter how much “good deeds” we accomplish, if we lose the foundation of faith, they will not be of eternal value.

I will also say that sanctification is about purification of the soul, to bring our character in line with God’s character. People can do good works all day long, and still avoid inner transformation.
So when non-C’s say the catholic church teaches faith (alone) + works, denying that works is an integral part of faith, we can say, no, faith (justification) + sanctification is the catholic teaching?
I will add one more to the formula. Justification + sanctificaton = glorification. Our final salvation and resting in the presence of God depends upon the other two together. Most Protestants separate them, saying we are saved eternally when we are justified. Catholics believe that we are saved eternally after we leave this life, and are in the presence of God.
 
They disagree with you.
Yes, of course they do! However, human disagreement does not nullify God’s Truth. Jesus appointed His Apostles, and entrusted the Church to them. They then passed the Authority of Christ to their successors, the Bishops. Those who are in unity with the bishops are those who are in unity with the Church Christ founded. Disagreement does not alter the facts.
That’s what you believe; that doesn’t explain how you know that what you believe is true.
We know it in the same way that you know you are saved. We choose to believe God’s promises, and trust Him that He will keep His word. It would be hard for you to “prove” to anyone that you are saved, would it not? I suppose you have some things that might demonstrate you as a saved person, but for the skeptic, it will not work. It all boils down to faith. Catholics believe that Jesus meant what He said, and we trust Him to fulfill His promises.
What interpretations did the apostles pass on in Sacred Tradition?
That we are to be obedient to the Bishops as we are to Christ.
Then the two must be identical.
No. Complimentary, rather.
Explain how your statement has anything to do with my post that you cite?
You seem to believe that God’s preservation left the Church after the Apostles died, and that the holy men who produced the NT under the inspiration of the HS had no other holy men follow them that could propagate the faith properly.
If scripture has always been the solr rule of faith, then everything Jesus said, unless he was quoting scripture, is invalid!
I have no idea what you’re saying.
Sola Scriptura creates disunity, which is a road to no where. Jesus commanded unity, which is found in the Truth (Himself). This Truth he committed to his Apostles.
Opposing interpretations do not affect the doctrine of scripture as the sole rule of faith.
No, but it is a fruit. It is the fruit of division. It grows from the root of the reformation, which is a tree of division.
Even if billions of interpretations existed, the scripture is singular, and true.
No arguement there! However, since everyone perceives differently, Jesus found it necessary to commit the Teaching Authority to certain persons He had personally trained.
I believe that all of the examples you offer above are nothing more than fallacious special pleadings.
They are indeed special pleadings! It is an appeal to get you and other “bible christians” that there are a great many traditions of men that are taught which are believed as though they are in the Bible, but they are not.
While you unquestioningly accept the arguments you put forth concerning what I believe (and obviously, you do; otherwise, why would you make those arguments?), you would either reject those same arguments when applied to what you believe, or, you would attempt to make some kind of exception in the case of what you believe, thereby exempting your beliefs from the same standards you apply to mine.
No, because Catholicism has never claimed to be “bible based”. From the beginning, all of our Teaching has come from outside the NT. The NT represents part of the Sacred Tradition, but not all.
 
I am sure that Protestant Churches wouldn’t call it brainwashing. But, in the end it is a lot of mispreresentation and untruths about the Catholic Church, and non-C’s are essentially being brainwashed against the Catholic Church. I think they must all be teaching that while the Catholic Church preserved (or not) the teachings of Jesus and recorded it into the Bible (or not) for all Christians, that we at some point, subsequent to that, lost the Truth, didn’t really understand the Truth and changed SO much that their Church had to be formed to continue on with the real Truth b/c Catholics had gotten so far away from it. They don’t understand that their Church HAS to have them think that! Their Church has to misrepresent Peter being the Rock and being given the keys, the reason(s) for the Reformation, and just about everything about the teachings of the Catholic Church because they need their congretation to be loyal to them, loyal to their teachings. Sola Scriptura wasn’t taught by the Apostles. Just a cursury look at the history of the Church will prove that. At this point in this thread, they do know that Martin Luther added alone and admitted that he knew it wasn’t there, but wanted it there, right? Just that alone would make me question the reasons/reasoning for the Reformation and if it was truly just or not. I am sure they don’t teach their congreation any of that or that just about everything in Protestantism has changed over he last 500 years, even from the initial founding of Protestantism. How many more Churches have to be splintered off b/c they have now believe that they have always had the truth and the others haven’t? How could Protestant Churches not question why so many interpretations or at least be curious as to why Catholocism has never changed.
 
What interpretations did the apostles pass on in Sacred Tradition?
Sandusky, Guanophor seems to be absent from class so, if you will allow me.

The entire NT was written in the Tradition passed on by the Apostles. Tradition came before the written text. Tradition is like the umbrella, underwhich the written text was produced.

Specifically, the interpretations you ask about here would be, for example, interpreting Matt 16:18 to mean a.) Jesus was establishing a visible church, b.) Jesus was establishing His church on the foundation of rock, c.) that foundation was the man, Simon/Peter, d.) with this establishment Jesus was creating (He is the Word of God, through which all things came to be. That is creation itself. God, the Father is “I am that I am,” Jesus is, “It is that it is.”) an office (a chair) which would be the fullfillment of the chair of Moses. This is the interpretation of the Apostles and it is a part of the Deposit of Faith which Christ made to His Church and it is Sacred Tradition.

I’ll give you another example.

The interpretation of the Bread of Life Discourse found in the 6th chapter of John’s Gospel. The apostolic interpretation would be, a.) Jesus is the bread of life come down from heaven (prefigurement is the manna in the dessert which kept the Isrealites alive for 40 years), b.) this bread is His flesh (really and truely) c.) one must eat this flesh (the bread of life, ie: the eucharist, valid communion, the wafer, for you anti-catholics out there), d.) and if you don’t eat this bread then you will not have eternal life. This is the interpretation of the Apostles, and it is Sacred Tradition.

You realize there is much more which illustrates Sacred Tradition found in the interpretation of the Apostles. If you learn about the faith of the early fathers you will realize this is what they believed as well as they where the disciples of the Apostles.

Does this answer your question?
 
Sandusky, you are confused in your thinking that Sacred tradition is identical with Sacred writings.
Then the two must be identical.
This would be like saying that the Constitution of the United States is identical to the Bill of Rights.

Sacred Tradition produced the Bible.

Do you still have a question about this?
 
True doctrine is true, false doctrine is false; that’s the been the case since the writing of the NT in which false teachers were, even then, infiltrating the church.

False teaching and idolatry has plagued the church from the beginning, as it plagued Israel.

The only way to know what’s true, is to read that which Christ Himself called true—God’s word.
To me, this just seems like circular discussion. It seems like a blanket statement to refute Catholic belief. There are no facts or no real points proof in your statement, just blanketing naysaying. False teachings that infiltratated the Church early on were determined and proven to be false and therefore, NEVER became any part of Catholic Church’s teachings. It may have quietly stayed in the minds of a few and carried on that way for centuries, only to come out at the Reformation. But, it never became Catholic teachings. Where do you have any proof of this? I would like to know where I can find it. Did it exist before the Reformation or before your particular denomination was founded?

Idolotry has NEVER plagued the Catholic Church!!! Is that what Protestantism teaches??? That is blatantly untrue. Please show me proof of that accusation. That is just one of the many untruths Protestantism has had to impart onto it’s followers to continue to separate them from the Catholic Church - the Truth.
 
A heretic is one who teaches contrary to God’s word.
I agree. It is a fallacy to attempt to limit the Word of God (Jesus) to the pages of the text, as holy as they are. The Word of God is eternal, and transcends our puny manuscripts and translations. The Word of God also never limited Himself to those pages, and committed His truth to His Aposltes in the Deposit of Faith which was once for all delievered. Not all of this is found in the pages of the holy writ.
That’s a strawman; I’m a Christian, and I believe that Christ is building His Church.
Why are you on CAF, sandy? Are you here to build Christ’s church?
What do the ECF’s have to do with the writings of the Apostles?
They were the keepers of the Apostolic Tradition, and understood the Scripture as it was written.
How do you know that the RCC is the one true church? What method have you employed to arrive at that conclusion?
I know you like to bash on “Romanism”, sandy, but the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church is not “Roman”. It so happens that this is the Rite most common in the West, but it Catholicism is not limited to, nor defined by “Romishness”
 
If opposition to something proves that it’s wrong, then you must admit the error of the Papacy.

That is just what you are really trying to prove, and you will never be able to prove that. If you want to prove anything, look at why your Church teaches ANYTHING different that the Early Church and prove to us the justification and truth for those changes.

If, as you say, individual interpretation results in one becoming his/her own church then you put yourself on the very horns of the dilemma upon which you try to impale those who don’t believe what you believe. IMHO, you’re not thinking through these arguments that you are taking from others, but merely repeating them.

Again, cirucular and really not admitting the truth. Individual interpretation is the Very reason there are 35,000-40,000 Protestant Churches that each claim to be the correct interpreters of scripture. We are repeating nothing. We have stayed true to ONE Truth. Protestantism has repeatedly re-invented scripture and doctrine over the last 500 years. They are the ones “repeating” error.

Read the forums, MIZER.

I read Catholics who constantly question what they consider to be the wrong teachings of their priests, and bring those questions and concerns to these forums.

These Catholics are in peril. They don’t know enough about their faith to refute their Protestant friends. That is sad. They have to apply themselves to learning their faith. No one else can do it for them. Why would they question anything if there weren’t 35,000-40,000 different beliefs out there confusing them?

The standard advice? Talk to the priest; if that doesn’t work, write the Bishop; if that doesn’t work, go to another parish.

Isn’t that what Prostants do, go from Church to Church until they find one that teaches what they believe? Really, this particular statement of yours does not make any sense. We teach the same ONE Truth as handed to us by Christ in EVERY one of our Churchs - the same teachings, the same interpretation. Protestantism can’t say that. - EVER.

IMHO, you’re blinded to the identical problems in the CC that you hang on Protestant churches.

You are absolutely wrong - grabbing at straws with yet again another negative blanket statement because you cannot prove anything. But out of curiousity, what exactly are we blinded to in the CC that we are hanging on Protestant Churches? Are you saying we have different beliefs/interpretations? If you are, then you really don’t know anything true about Catholocism to say anything at all.
 
If opposition to something proves that it’s wrong, then you must admit the error of the Papacy.

That is just what you are really trying to prove, and you will never be able to prove that. If you want to prove anything, look at why your Church teaches ANYTHING different that the Early Church and prove to us the justification and truth for those changes.

If, as you say, individual interpretation results in one becoming his/her own church then you put yourself on the very horns of the dilemma upon which you try to impale those who don’t believe what you believe. IMHO, you’re not thinking through these arguments that you are taking from others, but merely repeating them.

Again, cirucular and really not admitting the truth. Individual interpretation is the Very reason there are 35,000-40,000 Protestant Churches that each claim to be the correct interpreters of scripture. We are repeating nothing. We have stayed true to ONE Truth. Protestantism has repeatedly re-invented scripture and doctrine over the last 500 years. They are the ones “repeating” error.

Read the forums, MIZER.

I read Catholics who constantly question what they consider to be the wrong teachings of their priests, and bring those questions and concerns to these forums.

These Catholics are in peril. They don’t know enough about their faith to refute their Protestant friends. That is sad. They have to apply themselves to learning their faith. No one else can do it for them. Why would they question anything if there weren’t 35,000-40,000 different beliefs out there confusing them?

The standard advice? Talk to the priest; if that doesn’t work, write the Bishop; if that doesn’t work, go to another parish.

Isn’t that what Prostants do, go from Church to Church until they find one that teaches what they believe? Really, this particular statement of yours does not make any sense. We teach the same ONE Truth as handed to us by Christ in EVERY one of our Churchs - the same teachings, the same interpretation. Protestantism can’t say that. - EVER.

IMHO, you’re blinded to the identical problems in the CC that you hang on Protestant churches.

You are absolutely wrong - grabbing at straws with yet again another negative blanket statement because you cannot prove anything. But out of curiousity, what exactly are we blinded to in the CC that we are hanging on Protestant Churches? Are you saying we have different beliefs/interpretations? If you are, then you really don’t know anything true about Catholocism to say anything at all.
Thanks for your post; however, ISTM that you’ve not understood anything I said in the post to which you’ve responded. 😦
 
Sandusky posted:
I believe that all of the examples you offer above are nothing more than fallacious special pleadings.
I could make the same arguments concerning new Catholic converts not reading their bible, and being told what to believe; I could argue that purgatory, the papacy, the Marian doctrines and others are not found in Scripture; I could argue that the CC’s atrocious use of the OT to validate some of its novel teachings about Mary demonstrate that anyone can make the bible say anything they want it to say.
While you unquestioningly accept the arguments you put forth concerning what I believe (and obviously, you do; otherwise, why would you make those arguments?), you would either reject those same arguments when applied to what you believe, or, you would attempt to make some kind of exception in the case of what you believe, thereby exempting your beliefs from the same standards you apply to mine.
So which is it for you when your arguments are applied to your beliefs?
Rejection of the arguments, or exemption from them?
Sandusky, There is so much to reply to here. Would you please consider the fact that you have offered no support, what so ever for any of the arguments you make. Your statements aren’t really arguments they are more like unsubstantiated claims.
I could argue that the CC’s atrocious use of the OT to validate some of its novel teachings about Mary demonstrate that anyone can make the bible say anything they want it to say
This is just an absurdity that really doesn’t deserve a response.

How dare you try to use our beliefs about the Blessed Mother in the same context I was using to point out the truly agregious private interpretations of the Holy Bible. Private interpretation is an abuse in and of itself. That one can come up with support from the Bible for abortion or homosexual behavior should alert you to the fact that your practice of private interpretation is not only sinful, but dangerous.

Can you comment on the fact that people can make the Bible mean whatever they want it to mean in the context that you believe the Bible is the sole rule of faith, or not? Apparently, not.

It is your faith that goes against the Bible and teaches we are to privately interpret the Sacred text for ourselves, not mine.
I could make the same arguments concerning new Catholic converts not reading their bible, and being told what to believe;
But you wouldn’t have to because I would make that argument first. By the design of Christ, creation incarnate, the Very Word of God, we are told what to believe by the Church He created to teach us. It is your tradition that says that Jesus’ intent was that we would learn the true faith by reading the Bible, not mine.

Do you see the sillyness of your point? It doesn’t respond to the point I am trying to make to you that this process is not only contrary to what you believe is the process Christ intended for our faith education, it is also the process used, by not only Catholics but non-C’s as well. You non-C’s don’t really use the process you claim is the one intended by Christ, ie, Bible alone.

I think that’s called hypocrissy. Feel free to correct me if I am wrong but I will expect some support for your argument if you wish to argue that it is not hypocrissy.

What do you think? Please, Sandusky, run this through your grey matter and then, and only then, tell me what you think, don’t just call me a hypocrite in reaction. We all are very interested to know what it is you think. Can you articualte that?
 
Sandusky,

I just can’t put this down without responding to everything you’ve said, it is so…frustrating because you are not explaining why you believe as you do, you are just rejecting, seemingly out of hand, the truth we Catholics are trying to graciously show you.
you would either reject those same arguments when applied to what you believe, or, you would attempt to make some kind of exception in the case of what you believe, thereby exempting your beliefs from the same standards you apply to mine.
So which is it for you when your arguments are applied to your beliefs?
I make no exception and do not exempt the CC, when I ask questions or come up with an argument which may challange my faith.

The fact of the matter is, I have already applied every single one of the arguments I place before you, to Catholicism. I tested many of the denominations, as well when I did this many years ago. The reason I am Catholic today is that I found that Catholicism reasonably answered my questions and arguments when every denomination failed to. I expempted the CC from nothing. And you wouldn’t have to either if you would apply a little reason and thought to what you are being told, honestly try to answer the questions put to you and open your mind and heart to follow wherever the Holy Spirit may be leading you in the process.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top