Hi again Sandusky,
I hope I’m not coming off as sarcastic. I don’t mean to. Because the written word is inherrently prone to misinterpretation, I want to be sure you realize that my tone is not one of sarcasm. Frustration, perhaps, but I do not wish to offend you.
You stated to guanophor:
That’s what you believe; that doesn’t explain how you know that what you believe is true.
To reiterate what I said in a recent post to you, we trust the CC is true, essentially because Christ promised she would be. The challenge for post-reformation believers is to find the one church founded by Jesus, which is Apostolic in nature. To do that you must first study and learn what the Apostles taught and then what their successors taught following thier deaths.
Now I know you don’t believe the Apostles had successors but this belief is contrary to what we read in scripture. As a non-C (May I know what faith tradition you practice? It would make it a lot easier to direct you if I had an inkling of your present mindset. Are you fundamentalist?), especially if you are fundamentalist, then you have studied St. Paul’s letters. He was very clearly grooming Timothy to be his successor. Wouldn’t you agree with that? He told Timothy, from prison, to select and train others to perservere in the ministry. No where in Paul’s letters does he tell the faithful (believers, if you are Baptist, Christians, if you are mainline Protestant) to read the Bible and go their own way based on what they individually determined it to mean.
Other verses in the Bible support the idea that the offices the Apostles held were permanent. The gift of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost was a perpetual gift to Christ’s Church, you believe that don’t you? It doesn’t make any sense to think that the offices held by the Apostles, the pre-figurement of which is the 12 tribes of Isreal, would end with thier deaths. The offices held by the leader of each tribe did not end under OC law. Why would anyone think the offices held by the Apostles would end under new covenant law?
Mattthew 23:2 has Jesus telling the disiciples to follow the teachings of Scribes and Pharisees because they seat in the seat of Moses. The seat (or chair) is the same as an office and it implies succession. Think of the office of the Presidency in our own form of government which was modeled after christian faith. The office is around as long as the nation is around. If the office is vacant, it needs to be filled.
If you will read the passage surrounding this verse you will learn that Jesus is getting ready to chastize the behavior of the Scribes and Pharisees because they don’t practice what they preach. Before He does this however, he assures the people that thier teachings (on matter’s of faith) are sound. This is the exact same situation we have today (and have had for two millenia) with the Papacy and the magesterium (the teaching body) of the CC. It doesn’t matter how the Pope('s) behave(s) or have behaved throughout history because the promise, the gift, the charism, if you will, is on the chair, that is the office.
In the book of acts, the first order of business of the new-born church was to choose a successor for Judas. Now the last time I checked, Judas was an Apostle and he died. His office did not die with him. Matthias was choosen his successor. If it was so important to replace the Apostle who betrayed Jesus, why wouldn’t it be even more important to replace the Apostle who Jesus choose to shepherd his flock (“feed my lambs, tend my sheep”) after His ascension?
If you will answer this one question, you will suddenly be compelled to start the study, which the catholics on this board have done, which leads one to the truth in it’s fullness. Study the faith of the early fathers. We have their writtings available to us today. What a gift that is. You can read what the first Christians, Ignatius of Antioch, Clement of Rome, Barnabas, Polycarp, St. Justin Martyr believed about the faith. These are all men who wrote in the first two centuries a.d. Take advantage of this web site. You can access many of the writings right here. If you are truely interested in coming to knowledge of Christ then you will do this. If you are simply interested in arguing with Catholics then you won’t. But please remember, you put yourself here. What lead you to come to Catholic Answers in the first place?
I would be very careful about rejecting out of hand the wealth of information at your fingertips, easily accessable to your mind. We will all have to account, someday, for the choices we made in this life. Faith, although the free gift of God, is still the choice of our free will. Like the free gift of a life preserver thrown to a drowning man, the drowning man must choose to reach for it or he will loose his life.