Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You agreed with the argument when MIZER made it with respect to her surprise that more people were not coming into the CC because of the appointment of a homosexual bishop; however, when the same manner of argument was brought to bear on your beliefs, you now reject it—again, IMO, we see the hypocrisy, and the double standard.
I think you both need to calm down a little bit.

As far as the “double standard”, I think there is a difference between the two situations.
  • In the Episcopal/Anglican instance, it is a matter of the church actually teaching (ie using its teaching authority) that something sinful is not sinful and acting on it.
  • In the Catholic instance there was not then, nor was there later an endorsement by the Church that pedophilia was a moral behavior. Nor was there ever a statement by the Church that concealing pedophile priests was acceptable.
    So in the context of a discussion regarding infallibility, the two transgressions are apples and oranges.
 
I think you both need to calm down a little bit.

As far as the “double standard”, I think there is a difference between the two situations.
  • In the Episcopal/Anglican instance, it is a matter of the church actually teaching (ie using its teaching authority) that something sinful is not sinful and acting on it.
  • In the Catholic instance there was not then, nor was there later an endorsement by the Church that pedophilia was a moral behavior. Nor was there ever a statement by the Church that concealing pedophile priests was acceptable.
    So in the context of a discussion regarding infallibility, the two transgressions are apples and oranges.
Thanks for that, Phil

However, I would add that one is always sorry for ones actions, and quick to condemn them, once one is caught.
 
Again Teflon, it’s not on the list.
So you say, but, as we have seen, you say many things which do not comport with the facts.
Of course I haven’t, Teflon, and you would know that; wouldn’t you?
Anyone who’s been following this thread knows it. It is no mean feat to note such a thing, I’m afraid.
The structure’s the same—singular head, teaching body, all claim to have the truth sans error.
Here’s how it’s done:
  1. Some religious communities have a singular head, a teaching body, and claim to possess the truth without error.
  2. The Mormon Church is run by _____, taught by ______, and claims to be infallible, which they define as _________(source)
  3. The Jehovah’s Witnesses is run by ____, taught by ______, and claims to be infallible, which they define as ______(source)
  4. The Catholic Chruch is run by Pope Benedict XVI, taught by the Pope, bishops, priests and deacons using the Catechism of the Catholic Church, and claims to be infallible, which they define as protection from error by the Holy Spirit when teaching ex cathedra on a matter of faith and morals (link to the Catechism; passage quoted above).
  5. Therefore, the Catholic Church, LDS, and JW have very similar views of infallibility.
I had mentioned that only to make the point that my church is not structured as is yours, but it is local, and independent; therefore, you were comparing apples to oranges in your statement that brought out that specific response from me.
Is your community not comprised of men? Apples to apples if so.
No, it’s unbelievable, and your question is, IMO, akin to stating that your church is not concerned with its purity; is your church concerned with its purity, or not?
Red herring. You confuse, as is your wont, your notion of “purity” with the Church’s proper understanding of holiness. We do not shun sinners for the same reason Christ didn’t—the Church is a hospital for them. Those separated brethren who have rejected the sacrament of penance often compensate by shunning their brothers and sisters who sin in a most unChristian fashion.
Actually I think for you, the better term would be frustrating, not interesting.
Not at all—I knew you wouldn’t answer the question. We get many around here who claim the wonders and uniqueness of their congregation, but lack the courage to proclaim it. How different than the apostles!

And yet you know which Church I belong to. I am a Catholic, and proud of it.
It’s not hidden Teflon.
Sure it is. How can we judge its fruits if you’re afraid to identify it?
You agreed with the argument when MIZER made it with respect to her surprise that more people were not coming into the CC because of the appointment of a homosexual bishop; however, when the same manner of argument was brought to bear on your beliefs, you now reject it—again, IMO, we see the hypocrisy, and the double standard.
No, we see your inability to form a coherent argument.

Here’s the telling difference:

The Catholic Church teaches that homosexual practice is a sin.

The Episcopal Church teaches that it is a lifestyle choice, and endorsed it by appointing that particular bishop. Their Anglican parent has now sanctified it by marrying two homosexual priests.

Is it any wonder that those Anglicans and Episcopalians who abhor such immorality would cross the Tiber?
The last word is yours. :tiphat:
Really? I’d better make it an apt one then. How about: “Evidence.”?
 
So you say, but, as we have seen, you say many things which do not comport with the facts.

Anyone who’s been following this thread knows it. It is no mean feat to note such a thing, I’m afraid.

Here’s how it’s done:
  1. Some religious communities have a singular head, a teaching body, and claim to possess the truth without error.
  2. The Mormon Church is run by _____, taught by ______, and claims to be infallible, which they define as _________(source)
  3. The Jehovah’s Witnesses is run by ____, taught by ______, and claims to be infallible, which they define as ______(source)
  4. The Catholic Chruch is run by Pope Benedict XVI, taught by the Pope, bishops, priests and deacons using the Catechism of the Catholic Church, and claims to be infallible, which they define as protection from error by the Holy Spirit when teaching ex cathedra on a matter of faith and morals (link to the Catechism; passage quoted above).
  5. Therefore, the Catholic Church, LDS, and JW have very similar views of infallibility.
Is your community not comprised of men? Apples to apples if so.

Red herring. You confuse, as is your wont, your notion of “purity” with the Church’s proper understanding of holiness. We do not shun sinners for the same reason Christ didn’t—the Church is a hospital for them. Those separated brethren who have rejected the sacrament of penance often compensate by shunning their brothers and sisters who sin in a most unChristian fashion.

Not at all—I knew you wouldn’t answer the question. We get many around here who claim the wonders and uniqueness of their congregation, but lack the courage to proclaim it. How different than the apostles!

And yet you know which Church I belong to. I am a Catholic, and proud of it.

Sure it is. How can we judge its fruits if you’re afraid to identify it?

No, we see your inability to form a coherent argument.

Here’s the telling difference:

The Catholic Church teaches that homosexual practice is a sin.

The Episcopal Church teaches that it is a lifestyle choice, and endorsed it by appointing that particular bishop. Their Anglican parent has now sanctified it by marrying two homosexual priests.

Is it any wonder that those Anglicans and Episcopalians who abhor such immorality would cross the Tiber?

Really? I’d better make it an apt one then. How about: “Evidence.”?
I’ve read your conclusions, Teflon; thank you.
 
Thanks for that, Phil

However, I would add that one is always sorry for ones actions, and quick to condemn them, once one is caught.
Sometimes it takes our back up against the wall before we can see how horribly wrong we were. And yes there can be and is true sorrow and repentance for such serious sins. Until recently, the Church depended on the sincerity of the penitent, the decisions of those that counciled them, (many were “experts” in the field) and they were thought to be repentant. Only in recent years has specialist in this field said it is incurable. These men are homosexuals, and while you are so quick to condemn a priest, our society is doing everything it can to make homosexuality legal and acceptable. And many protestant churches are eager to go along with that, in spite of all the harm it has done and is doing to family life and society as a whole. The Catholic Church has NEVER condoned it in any way. So instead of looking down your nose at the Catholic Church, why don’t you try to do something to help your own denomination to clean up their act. It is far worse among protestant denominations than Catholics but the media never tells us about that.
 
I want to clear up this point you make:
40.png
Teflon93:
Red herring. You confuse, as is your wont, your notion of “purity” with the Church’s proper understanding of holiness. We do not shun sinners for the same reason Christ didn’t—the Church is a hospital for them. Those separated brethren who have rejected the sacrament of penance often compensate by shunning their brothers and sisters who sin in a most unChristian fashion.
It’s not a red-herring, but a misunderstanding.

When I say “remove them,” I mean from leadership; the purpose of church discipline is not to “shun” anyone, but ultimately to restore that one to Christ, and the church.

IMO, those who had any hand in the coverup are no longer fit for leadership; as I said to Phil in response to the same argument you raised: everyone is sorry for their actions, and quick to condemn them once they’re caught.

That’s it.
 
Sometimes it takes our back up against the wall before we can see how horribly wrong we were. And yes there can be and is true sorrow and repentance for such serious sins. Until recently, the Church depended on the sincerity of the penitent, the decisions of those that counciled them, (many were “experts” in the field) and they were thought to be repentant. Only in recent years has specialist in this field said it is incurable. These men are homosexuals, and while you are so quick to condemn a priest, our society is doing everything it can to make homosexuality legal and acceptable. And many protestant churches are eager to go along with that, in spite of all the harm it has done and is doing to family life and society as a whole. The Catholic Church has NEVER condoned it in any way. So instead of looking down your nose at the Catholic Church, why don’t you try to do something to help your own denomination to clean up their act. It is far worse among protestant denominations than Catholics but the media never tells us about that.
The issue is not homosexuality; but the ensuing coverup by the leadership of your church.

(BTW, my denomination does not condone homosexuality, and the only thing we can do about it, is what your church does about it, and that is call it what it is—sin.)
 
Lisdogan posted:

You should be aware that the Catholic Church is not a denomination. It is incorrect to speak of the Catholic Church and then “other” denominations. Christ did not establish denominations. He established, The Church. Man established denominations.
As a Catholic, I am aware that many within the Church do not like the idea of CC being a ‘denomination’. But for many others, **the Church **is the universal church of Christ, which incorporates all those who are of God, the Triune God of Christianity. There are (unfortunate) divisions within the universal church of Christ, many of them called (mainline) denominations, and the CC is one of them. It may be the oldest and the biggest, but it is a denomination, whether we like to call it that or not.

And perhaps it is useful to start thinking in terms of a universal church of Christ, as there are now more Muslims than Catholics globally. This will keep us focussed on the apostolic dimension of our Christian beliefs, rather than on our divisiveness. Christianity’s affirmations are better served in this way.

Jabulani!

You are beautiful because I have clothed you in my spelndour.
 
Lisdogan posted further this question:

So we are to intelligently look to her [the CC] for the correct translation and charitably point out to those who use other translations the potential for error not only in following their own, private interpretation but also in the very words they privately interpret.

.
So which translations/versions of the Bible are approved, and which are not. Which Bible does your home church use? Which one do you use? Is there a Vatican imprimature on any version?

I have about 6-7 different English versions of the Bible, but have not been taught by CC to use any one in favour of another.

Jabulani!
 
And perhaps it is useful to start thinking in terms of a universal church of Christ, as there are now more Muslims than Catholics globally. This will keep us focussed on the apostolic dimension of our Christian beliefs, rather than on our divisiveness. Christianity’s affirmations are better served in this way.

Jabulani!

You are beautiful because I have clothed you in my spelndour.
There are only more Muslims if we fail to account for the very real divisions amongst them, Sunni and Shi’a and the rest. There is no Caliph to be the equivalent of our Pope. Islam is not united.

To compare 1.3 billion Catholics to 1.5 billion Muslims (Sunni + Shi’a + all the rest) may be useful as propaganda, but tortures the truth.

Christians still outnumber Muslims in totality, about 2 billion to 1.5 billion. And this despite Islam being mandatory in most places where it is found.
 
Lisdogen:

If we use these other translations we must realize that the words may have been altered to suit the needs (desires) of the translater, who does not enjoy the protection of the Holy Spirit.

…our Catholic Bibles
Are we likely to be heretics in my CC because we use the Good News and/or New Jerusalem Bibles?

What are ‘Catholic Bibles’ - perhaps you could point me in the right direction. And it would also help to know by which process the Vatican approves or disapproves any major biblical translation.

Jabulani!
 
Are we likely to be heretics in my CC because we use the Good News and/or New Jerusalem Bibles?

What are ‘Catholic Bibles’ - perhaps you could point me in the right direction. And it would also help to know by which process the Vatican approves or disapproves any major biblical translation.

Jabulani!
Revised Standard Version - Catholic is the best English translation in my opinion.

I regularly post excerpts from the KJV simply because then Protestants can’t claim I employ one of those eeeevil Catholic Bibles to refute their arguments.

You may find this link useful:

catholic.com/library/bible_translations_guide.asp
 
Dear friend, Sandusky,

Please, will you please study the faith our Lord saw fit to have you Baptised into? Although our personal decision to believe that the one true church Christ established is, today the Roman Catholic Church, may be fallible, the decision is based on a wealth of information you seem to be lacking. What we believe, that is the content of our faith is based on the infallible teachings of Christ and the Apostles. What you are settling for is a fallible decision based on the fallible teachings of other fallibe men. Wouldn’t you rather your own fallible decision to practice this or that form of Christitianity be based on infallabe truth?

If you were to go on an open-minded quest for the truth, I guaren dog-gone-tee you, you would make the same, albeit fallible, decision the rest of the Catholics on this board have made. You are a Baptised Catholic, so you say. Why don’t go searching for your roots?

Have you looked at another thread called, I can’t think of it now and I don’t want to backspace out of this, so I’ll take a stab and then check later to see if I got it right. It’s called “How can protestants who think Peter is the Rock, not be catholic,” or something like that. On or about page 5 or 6 the discussion was primarily being carried by two extremely knowlegeabe men. I think one must be a professor of some sort with degrees in ancient languages or theology or something pertinent like that. The discussion was incredibly interesting (and it still is on that thread) and you would learn a lot if you set your mind to educating yourself. The most brilliant Christian minds seem to gravitate toward Catholicism. It must be the only Christian religion that the truely honest and intellectual can wrap their brains around. It’s the only one that is logical in its complexity and reasonable in it’s simplicity, all at the same time.

Is there any part of you that is just a little curious to know whether or not, what you believe is steeped in truth or in error?
You assume that I haven’t already done that.

I’ve done all of those things.

I have a sister who pointed out what you have.

After several years of discussion, a number of years ago, guess which church she and her family are no longer in?
 
As a Catholic, I am aware that many within the Church do not like the idea of CC being a ‘denomination’. But for many others, **the Church **is the universal church of Christ, which incorporates all those who are of God, the Triune God of Christianity. There are (unfortunate) divisions within the universal church of Christ, many of them called (mainline) denominations, and the CC is one of them. It may be the oldest and the biggest, but it is a denomination, whether we like to call it that or not.
I’ve been saying that for years.
 
Our society is doing everything it can to make homosexuality legal and acceptable. And many protestant churches are eager to go along with that,in spite of all the harm it has done and is doing to family life and society as a whole. The Catholic Church has NEVER condoned it in any way. So instead of looking down your nose at the Catholic Church, why don’t you try to do something to help your own denomination to clean up their act. **It is far worse among protestant denominations than Catholics **but the media never tells us about that.
These are really big generalisations! What is the evidence for this statement? If we fight with **flarb **instead of **facts **- not helpful.

Jabulani!
 
I’ve been saying that for years.
As we see above, however, Sandusky is far quieter when it comes to his own denomination.

My hypothesis is that to name it would be to encourage inquiry into its beliefs and claims, and the evidence for them.

There is nothing more common around these forums than non-Catholics who like to keep such things slippery while inveighing against the Church, which is not only visible, but which also publishes its teachings for all to see and consider.

This is why many of us recognize the Church as fundamentally different from those communities which envy her even as they emulate her.
 
40.png
Teflon93:
As we see above, however, Sandusky is far quieter when it comes to his own denomination.

My hypothesis is that to name it would be to encourage inquiry into its beliefs and claims, and the evidence for them.

There is nothing more common around these forums than non-Catholics who like to keep such things slippery while inveighing against the Church, which is not only visible, but which also publishes its teachings for all to see and consider.

This is why many of us recognize the Church as fundamentally different from those communities which envy her even as they emulate her.
I’ve said all that I have say on the subject, Teflon—move on.

Do as MIZER did earlier on the thread, and claim complete and total victory for yourself.

I won’t say anything; I’ll let your Sour Grapes do the talking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top