Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lisdogen:
I find major differences among the various English versions. Which does my Catholic Church use? We use the New Jerusalem or the Good News Bibles, but others are of course acceptable (NIV, KJV, NKJV).
They are only “acceptable” because we don’t follow our own private interpretation of the text. We follow the interpretation of the Church, lead by, the Holy Spirit. If we use these other translations we must realize that the words may have been altered to suit the needs (desires) of the translater, who does not enjoy the protection of the Holy Spirit.

Consider the fact that none of our Catholic Bibles, not even the Douey Rhiems (if I remember correctly) has the angel Gabriel calling Mary, "full of Grace.) They all say “highly favored” or something like that. We know from Sacred Tradition, however, that the Angel not only called her “full of Grace,” and that’s where the words of the Hail Mary come from, but that she was, in fact, “full of Grace” in that she is the “immaculate conception.” It doesn’t matter that our Bible’s in their modern translation say something else because a.) our translater is the the true Church, and b.) our interpreter is also the true Church. Our Church enjoys the protection of the Holy Spirit, as the Spirit of truth, in ways the denominations do not. No brag, just fact. 😉
 
Excellent point Teflon:

When the Episcopal Church made a Bishop of an openly gay man, I thought all of Protestanism would see the fallacy of private interpretation and come flooding into Catholicism. I at least thought my siblings and other “fallen away Catholics” would take puase in great numbers and reconsider the unified and organized, Apostolic Church they left, in favor of this immoral chaos.

Didn’t happen.
It may yet happen—the laity is less enthused about such developments than the clergy seem to be. Certainly Anglican and Episcopal sanctuaries haven’t filled to overflowing with people who’ve returned to their folds due to their hipper politics.
 
Memaw said:
You have NO authority to decide who has the right interpretation.

Neither do you, Memaw, which brings us back to MIZER’s original conundrum: your decision that the CC is the true church is a fallible decision, which lacks any authority on your part; therefore, your decision could be wrong.
 
40.png
guanophore:
How do you understand the passage in Peter?
That passage is the only place in the NT where the Greek word translated “interpretation” appears, and it is about the prophets, and apostles, and their message.

“Private interpretation” is better translated “private disclosure.”

IOW, it’s not the interpretation of the reader that is in view, but the message of the prophets and the apostles, and Peter makes it clear that their message is not their own, but the Spirit’s
(cf Gal 1:11-12).

IMO, “private interpretation” is a translational bias; in fact, the Douay-Rheims is unabashed in its bias, going so far as to offer an explanation of the verse, the main point of which is, only the CC can correctly scripture—how impertinent.

The NIV translation of the verse is a good one:**2 Pet 1:20

Above all, you must understand that
no prophecy of Scripture came about by the prophet’s own interpretation.**The next verse in the passage, v21, explains that the prophet’s “interpretation” is from the Holy Spirit.

Once again, there is no prohibition against private interpretation of scripture, in scripture.
 
your decision that the CC is the true church is a fallible decision, which lacks any authority on your part; therefore, your decision could be wrong.
Or your decision to leave the Catholic Church could have been wrong. The Catholic Church has the authority that humans lack. Does your church?

Could you have been wrong? yes or no please?
 
MIZER said:
When the Episcopal Church made a Bishop of an openly gay man, I thought all of Protestanism would see the fallacy of private interpretation and come flooding into Catholicism.

When Apostolic Successors hid pedophiles, instead of turning them over to the civil authorities, as true Apostolic successors would have done, I thought all of Catholicism would see the fallacy of Apostolic Succession and go flooding out of Catholicism. 😦

(People in a glass church shouldn’t throw stones. 😉 )
 
Sean Boyle:
Or your decision to leave the Catholic Church could have been wrong.
My decision to leave your church was a correct one, because, while in your church, I was an unsaved, unregenerate Christ rejecter.

The question you should have asked is, after God caused me to be born again, “could I be wrong in having chosen a church that adheres to sola scriptura, instead of choosing the church that adheres to sola ecclesia?

The answer to that is yes—I’m fallible.

And you, Sean, are you fallible?

Could your choice of church be wrong?
 
You’ll not find my church among any of those listed.

The same, however, cannot be said of yours. 😉
You claim to be a member of the Reformed community in your profile. There are plenty of ministers in the list which belong to your tradition.

All claimed to be “regenerate”. All claim to be “saved”. And yet you can read the accounts for yourself.

Of course, you didn’t even bother to scan the list.

We all know why. 😉
 
40.png
Teflon93:
You claim to be a member of the Reformed community in your profile. There are plenty of ministers in the list which belong to your tradition.

All claimed to be “regenerate”. All claim to be “saved”. And yet you can read the accounts for yourself.

Of course, you didn’t even bother to scan the list.
I didn’t scan the list because I know my church is not on the list.

It’s incorrect to compare the structure of reformed churches to the structure of the RCC which is better compared to that of the Mormon, or Jehovah’s Witness churches—all have centralized authority; all claim teaching infallibility. 😉

The first concern of Christ’s church should be its purity, and not its public reputation.

Don’t think of the shame of the pedophile scandal in terms of it being your personal shame Teflon; it’s not yours; the shame is your “Apostolic Successors” shame for shifting the criminals from parish to parish across the country.

That type of leadership would have been condemned and completely removed from my church.

Has it been from yours?
 
I didn’t scan the list because I know my church is not on the list.
How do you know if you didn’t scan it? There are many communities on the list.

What is the name of yours? I can look it up for you.
It’s incorrect to compare the structure of reformed churches to the structure of the RCC which is better compared to that of the Mormon, or Jehovah’s Witness churches—all have centralized authority; all claim teaching infallibility. 😉
Feel free to provide evidence for such claims.

The Catholic Church’s definition of infalliblility, as you’ve been shown many, many, many times before, is not infallibility in the “clergy can do no wrong” sense your attempt to deflect the ignorant requires.

This is the definition:

891 “The Roman Pontiff, head of the college of bishops, enjoys this infallibility in virtue of his office, when, as supreme pastor and teacher of all the faithful - who confirms his brethren in the faith he proclaims by a definitive act a doctrine pertaining to faith or morals. . . . The infallibility promised to the Church is also present in the body of bishops when, together with Peter’s successor, they exercise the supreme Magisterium,” above all in an Ecumenical Council. When the Church through its supreme Magisterium proposes a doctrine “for belief as being divinely revealed,” and as the teaching of Christ, the definitions “must be adhered to with the obedience of faith.” This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.

It is a shame you were not better catechized, nor sufficiently faithful to open the Catechism of the Catholic Church, or you would never make so stupid an argument as “The Church cannot be infallible so long as any clergyman sins”.
The first concern of Christ’s church should be its purity, and not its public reputation.
Since this is the first concern of Christ’s church, according to you, show me from the Gospel where Christ says this is the first concern of his Church.

Christ didn’t seem overly concerned, meeting with sinners of all stripes, and scandalizing the Jews by interacting with Gentiles and other “impure” types.
Don’t think of the shame of the pedophile scandal in terms of it being your personal shame Teflon; it’s not yours; the shame is your “Apostolic Successors” shame for shifting the criminals from parish to parish across the country.
What is the name of your community? A quick search should determine the purity of it, by absence of criminality.
That type of leadership would have been condemned and completely removed from my church.
So you say. What’s the name of this wondrous community, this oasis of purity?
Has it been from yours?
Probably not, evil being evil, man being fallen, and the world being what she is until the Lord comes.

But perhaps you’ll show all of us here the shining beacon of an entire community of “They who are without sin.”

I eagerly await your response.
 
IMO, “private interpretation” is a translational bias; in fact, the Douay-Rheims is unabashed in its bias, going so far as to offer an explanation of the verse, the main point of which is, only the CC can correctly scripture—how impertinent.
It would be no more impertinant than Albert Einstein correcting misconceptions on some of his scientific papers.
When Apostolic Successors hid pedophiles, instead of turning them over to the civil authorities, as true Apostolic successors would have done, I thought all of Catholicism would see the fallacy of Apostolic Succession and go flooding out of Catholicism. 😦

(People in a glass church shouldn’t throw stones. 😉 )
Nice try at blurring the lines. People are fallible, even Bishops. They are only infallible when operating in the Magesterium on matters of faith and doctrine. But I suspect that you knew that.

If they knew of pedophiles that resulted from complaints, police investigations, etc., then yes, I would agree with you. If they became aware of it inside the Confessional, then they are bound not to break the seal of the Confessional.
 
Nice try at blurring the lines. People are fallible, even Bishops. They are only infallible when operating in the Magesterium on matters of faith and doctrine. But I suspect that you knew that.
Of course he does. He’s been told this many, many times before.
If they knew of pedophiles that resulted from complaints, police investigations, etc., then yes, I would agree with you. If they became aware of it inside the Confessional, then they are bound not to break the seal of the Confessional.
Moreover, unless there is some pronouncement of dogma that pedophelia or the sexual abuse of teenagers is okay, where is the challenge to the charism of infallibility?

Pope Benedict XVI, far from pronouncing any such suspect dogma, has made very clear that such things will not be tolerated. He has insisted upon the zero tolerance policy the Church has implemented. He spent several years having to review the evidence regarding priests who had done such heinous things. Has any other religious figure come out so strongly against such practices within the very body they lead?

Meanwhile, we see mainline Protestant community after mainline Protestant community embracing sexual immorality amongst their clegy. What does this say about the teaching authority of Protestant communities when it comes to matters of faith and morals?
 
40.png
Teflon93:
How do you know if you didn’t scan it? There are many communities on the list.
For your benefit, I’ve searched through them; as I said, it’s not there.
40.png
Teflon93:
But perhaps you’ll show all of us here the shining beacon of an entire community of “They who are without sin.”
I never made that claim; your twisting of my words belies your confusion and desperation.

IMO, you’d do better to channel that energy into writing letters to your leadership seeking the removal of those leaders who have not been removed—ISTM that would be the godly thing to do.
40.png
Teflon93:
It is a shame you were not better catechized, nor sufficiently faithful to open the Catechism of the Catholic Church, or you would never make so stupid an argument as “The Church cannot be infallible so long as any clergyman sins”.
Again, Teflon, I never made that claim, and, IMO, you’re not so stupid as to misunderstand what I said, but, IMO, you are desperate enough to twist what I’ve said.
40.png
Teflon93:
Feel free to provide evidence for such claims.
I find it difficult to believe that one who purports to know as much as you do about nearly everything is not familiar with the similarity of the structure and claims made by your Church, the LDS, the JWs. :rolleyes:
40.png
Teflon93:
The Catholic Church’s definition of infalliblility, as you’ve been shown many, many, many times before, is not infallibility in the “clergy can do no wrong” sense your attempt to deflect the ignorant requires.
I never claimed they did, Teflon; what I said is the structure, and claims of the RCC, LDS and JWs concerning infallibility are the same; each claims it.
40.png
Teflon93:
Since this is the first concern of Christ’s church, according to you, show me from the Gospel where Christ says this is the first concern of his Church.

Christ didn’t seem overly concerned, meeting with sinners of all stripes, and scandalizing the Jews by interacting with Gentiles and other “impure” types.
Unbelievable.
40.png
Teflon93:
What is the name of yours? I can look it up for you.

What is the name of your community? A quick search should determine the purity of it, by absence of criminality.

So you say. What’s the name of this wondrous community, this oasis of purity?

But perhaps you’ll show all of us here the shining beacon of an entire community of "They who are without sin.
My church is not on the lists you supplied Teflon.

Whether or not you believe that is not important to me. 🤷
 
For your benefit, I’ve searched through them; as I said, it’s not there.
And what is the name of it, that we may check for ourselves?
I never made that claim; your twisting of my words belies your confusion and desperation.
Oh please—save your hysterical emotionalism for altar call.
IMO, you’d do better to channel that energy into writing letters to your leadership seeking the removal of those leaders who have not been removed—ISTM that would be the godly thing to do.
Feel free to post the list of their names.
Again, Teflon, I never made that claim, and, IMO, you’re not so stupid as to misunderstand what I said, but, IMO, you are desperate enough to twist what I’ve said.
You haven’t formed a coherent enough argument to make anyone “desperate”. Same as it ever was.

Keep emoting though—it’s cathartic for you; amusing for me and the lurkers.
I find it difficult to believe that one who purports to know as much as you do about nearly everything is not familiar with the similarity of the structure and claims made by your Church, the LDS, the JWs. :rolleyes:
Really? From what little I know of LDS and JWs, they believe in separation and purity. Sounds like your hitherto-unnamed community to me. Are you LDS or JW?
I never claimed they did, Teflon; what I said is the structure and claims of the RCC, LDS and JWs are the very similar.
Let’s rewind the tape, shall we?
When Apostolic Successors hid pedophiles, instead of turning them over to the civil authorities, as true Apostolic successors would have done, I thought all of Catholicism would see the fallacy of Apostolic Succession and go flooding out of Catholicism.
then
It’s incorrect to compare the structure of reformed churches to the structure of the RCC which is better compared to that of the Mormon, or Jehovah’s Witness churches—all **have centralized authority; all claim teaching infallibility. **
Thus you were comparing not just the “structure” (whatever you mean by that), but specifically the claim of infallibility.

Having provided no evidence, how are we to compare such claims?
Unbelievable.
More like unanswerable.
My church is not on the lists you supplied Teflon.
Whether or not you believe that is not important to me. 🤷
Your reticence is interesting. Did not Christ warn us not to hide our light under a bushel?

Why yes, he did, in Matthew 5:
14: Ye are the light of the world. A city that is set on an hill cannot be hid.
15: Neither do men light a candle, and put it under a bushel, but on a candlestick; and it giveth light unto all that are in the house.
16: Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.
Is this praiseworthy community of yours so wonderful that you dare not speak its name?

No matter; we’ll just chalk it up to the usual hyperbole from good ol’ Sandusky.
 
Of course he does. He’s been told this many, many times before.
You’re right, of course. He doesn’t even bother answering me any more, and has left several of my points unanswered/unchallenged. Oh well, this is for subsequent lurkers, I keep trying to tell myself that.
Pope Benedict XVI, far from pronouncing any such suspect dogma, has made very clear that such things will not be tolerated. He has insisted upon the zero tolerance policy the Church has implemented. He spent several years having to review the evidence regarding priests who had done such heinous things. Has any other religious figure come out so strongly against such practices within the very body they lead?
Have I ever mentioned how much I love Pope Benedict? Exactly what the Church needs!
Meanwhile, we see mainline Protestant community after mainline Protestant community embracing sexual immorality amongst their clegy. What does this say about the teaching authority of Protestant communities when it comes to matters of faith and morals?
Good point.
 
40.png
Teflon93:
And what is the name of it, that we may check for ourselves?
Feel free to post the list of their names.
Your reticence is interesting. Did not Christ warn us not to hide our light under a bushel?

Why yes, he did, in Matthew 5:
Is this praiseworthy community of yours so wonderful that you dare not speak its name?

No matter; we’ll just chalk it up to the usual hyperbole from good ol’ Sandusky.
Again Teflon, it’s not on the list.
40.png
Teflon93:
You haven’t formed a coherent enough argument to make anyone “desperate”.
Of course I haven’t, Teflon, and you would know that; wouldn’t you?
40.png
Teflon93:
Thus you were comparing not just the “structure” (whatever you mean by that), but specifically the claim of infallibility.
The structure’s the same—singular head, teaching body, all claim to have the truth sans error.

I had mentioned that only to make the point that my church is not structured as is yours, but it is local, and independent; therefore, you were comparing apples to oranges in your statement that brought out that specific response from me.
40.png
Teflon93:
More like unanswerable.
No, it’s unbelievable, and your question is, IMO, akin to stating that your church is not concerned with its purity; is your church concerned with its purity, or not?
40.png
Teflon93:
Your reticence is interesting.
Actually I think for you, the better term would be frustrating, not interesting.
40.png
Teflon93:
Did not Christ warn us not to hide our light under a bushel?
It’s not hidden Teflon.
40.png
Teflon93:
No matter; we’ll just chalk it up to the usual hyperbole from good ol’ Sandusky.
You agreed with the argument when MIZER made it with respect to her surprise that more people were not coming into the CC because of the appointment of a homosexual bishop; however, when the same manner of argument was brought to bear on your beliefs, you now reject it—again, IMO, we see the hypocrisy, and the double standard.

The last word is yours. :tiphat:
 
Neither do you, Memaw, which brings us back to MIZER’s original conundrum: your decision that the CC is the true church is a fallible decision, which lacks any authority on your part; therefore, your decision could be wrong.
Dear friend, Sandusky,

Please, will you please study the faith our Lord saw fit to have you Baptised into? Although our personal decision to believe that the one true church Christ established is, today the Roman Catholic Church, may be fallible, the decision is based on a wealth of information you seem to be lacking. What we believe, that is the content of our faith is based on the infallible teachings of Christ and the Apostles. What you are settling for is a fallible decision based on the fallible teachings of other fallibe men. Wouldn’t you rather your own fallible decision to practice this or that form of Christitianity be based on infallabe truth?

If you were to go on an open-minded quest for the truth, I guaren dog-gone-tee you, you would make the same, albeit fallible, decision the rest of the Catholics on this board have made. You are a Baptised Catholic, so you say. Why don’t go searching for your roots?

Have you looked at another thread called, I can’t think of it now and I don’t want to backspace out of this, so I’ll take a stab and then check later to see if I got it right. It’s called “How can protestants who think Peter is the Rock, not be catholic,” or something like that. On or about page 5 or 6 the discussion was primarily being carried by two extremely knowlegeabe men. I think one must be a professor of some sort with degrees in ancient languages or theology or something pertinent like that. The discussion was incredibly interesting (and it still is on that thread) and you would learn a lot if you set your mind to educating yourself. The most brilliant Christian minds seem to gravitate toward Catholicism. It must be the only Christian religion that the truely honest and intellectual can wrap their brains around. It’s the only one that is logical in its complexity and reasonable in it’s simplicity, all at the same time.

Is there any part of you that is just a little curious to know whether or not, what you believe is steeped in truth or in error?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top