This is your belief, and I respect it, even though I cannot share it.
Perhaps you do not share it yet?

Those who do not accept the infallibility of the Church are not united to the Catholic doctrine. Even if such persons call themselves Catholic, they are lacking in catholicity.
Code:
As an historian I disagree that there is *proof *of unchanged doctrine in faith and morals (viz 1300-1600 say), or of leadership (the dual (Avignon) papacy). We should also check our 'proven history', as our understanding of the actual and factual history of the CC changes regularly.
God allows factions in order to bring to light those who are “true”
" Indeed, there have to be factions among you, for only so will it become clear who among you are genuine." 1 Cor 11:18-19
Where there have been attempts to change doctrine, and disingenuine “popes”, it has brought to light where the genuine may be found.
At the time Christ established his Church through Peter, there was no other Christian church, although very early on there were distinct differences in interpretations of Christ’s mission, as we see from the letters of St Paul to various communities. So I think we must adjust your statement here. There was no other church but Christ’s church, but there were a number of community variations.
Such variations are termed “heresies” and Paul does not speak in a complementary manner about them.
Gal 5:11-12
" I wish those who unsettle you would castrate themselves!"
Subsequently various so-called ‘heresies’ evolved within the CC, which were generally put down. Some still survive within the Catholic community. This was
before the Reformation.
The protesters for reform had good reason to protest - we must agree on that I believe.
Perhaps. The manner in which they did so, however, has been a great wound to the Body.
Code:
At this point, I think of a tree, with deep roots and a solid trunk, tall and straight, with many branches. The branches are part of the tree, growing from that beautiful trunk. True, some branches are weak and puney from lack of nourishment; others are suckers, parasites. But many are fruitful, bearing leaves and fruit reflecting the nature of the roots and trunk of the wonderful tree.
It seems like what you are saying is that all the branches that come from the root are valid, even if they are separated from Catholicism.
And so the Reformation, for me, burst open some of the disgusting habits into which the CC had fallen - it pointed out suckers and parasites, crookedness and undernourishment; it opened minds and hearts of the gardeners to a fresh look at Christ’s teachings, example and mission, and set the foundation for a re-formation (sic) of CC doctrine and institutional arrangments.
Such a formulation leads the reader to believe that there is not an accurate perception of the Church. The Church cannot err because her Head is Christ, and she is ensouled by the Holy Spirit. It is the immuntable elements of the Body that make her infallible. To say that the Holy and pure bride of Christ is part and parcel with “suckers and parasites” is insulting to the One who has joined HImself to her. Such language should be reserved only to the fallible persons who have acted in crookenness and corruption, and not equated with the Bride herself.
" …Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, 26 in order to make her holy by cleansing her with the washing of water by the word, 27 so as to present the church to himself in splendor, without a spot or wrinkle or anything of the kind — yes, so that she may be holy and without blemish." Eph 5:25-27
Jesus has cleansed the Church, made her to be without spot or wrinke, or anything of the kind. She is holy and without blemish. A distinction about the Holy Bride must be made, because when corrupt men behave crookedly, they separate themselves by their actions from the grace that joins them to the Church. Although they may appear to outsiders to be members of her, spiritually they are cut off. We know them by their fruits.
Here is a good link to read some material on “the branch theory”.
I cannot denigrate the power of the Reformation for setting the CC back on track. Nor can I discount out of hand those Christian denominations that truly reflect Christ’s teaching within their own paradigm.
I agree that denigration is not fruitful, however, it was not the Refromers that “set the CC back on track”. The CC never left the track. Further, it is not “men” who have any power to guide the Church, but only her Head, which is Christ. I agree that men are constantly in need of reform, and the HS worked through these events to make it clear how sinners are separated from the pure bride.
Yes, the earliest church was the church founded by Christ, but I am not sure that it was called the ‘Catholic Church’, and am not sure when that name was applied, or to what it referred.
This is a good point. The word “
catholic” comes from the Greek. It is translated "universal’. In the NT, we see this word translated “throughout the whole”
" I want you to know, beloved, that what has happened to me has actually helped to spread the gospel, 13 so that it has become known
throughout the whole" Phil 1:12-13
kath holos = throughout the whole
Col 1:6
Just as it is bearing fruit and growing in the
whole world,
kathos = whole
The church has been called this since the NT was penned.
This statement is often made, but without proof. If you said that Christendom, in its own wobbly way, has sustained the profound and divine truth of Christ throughout the ages, I would agree that is true, because we are still here 2000 years later. But that is
Christendom, not *we - the only church. *
I suppose you are right, it is an article of faith, and thus does not commend itself to “proof”.
“… making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. 4 There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, 5 one Lord, one faith, one baptism, 6 one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all.” Eph 4:3-6
Unity is found when all are in truth. I know that you have some different thoughts about truth. But for Catholics, Jesus is the Truth, and He is absolute. To the extent that any and all of us are not united to Him, we have fallen from unity and truth.
He only has One Body, which is the Church. Therefore, all who are connected the Head are members of that One Body.
Lisdogan;3859749:
Code:
Yes, *all Christian denominations *
depended on one or more men (or women) to found and sustain them, including CC. The important point is, I think, that this does not inhibit many of them from reflecting Christian truth either existentially or in daily life. They cannot all be tarred by your commonly-held generalisation.
I agree with you about God working through people to bring all of us to holiness, wherever we are. However, the Catholic Church is not a “
denomination”. This word comes from the Latin “to designate”. All Protestant communities have designated themselves based upon how they differ from Catholicism. It is the one uniting factor in all non-Catholic communities.