Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not intend to be inflammatory: far from it. However, I think that the constant emphasis on the ‘one true church’ with its implications for other Christian denominations/churches/sects/ cults/communities/groups - whatever you want to call them - does tend to promote unnecessary divisiveness within Christendom. And I wonder if CC is following this line of ‘only true faith’ as firmly as some suggest, at least as far as mainstream denominations are concerned.

Try something. Close your eyes. Imagine a lake, any lake, anywhere in the world, any time of the day or night. I shall do the same.

Now tell me what your lake is like - its size, the colour of its water, whether it is calm or is rushing with ‘white horses’ on a windy day, what surrounds your lake (in my case, pines, cedars and rocks of the Cambrian Shield in northern Ontario), whether you see it at sunrise or sunset.

No one person’s image of ‘their’ lake is like that of any other’s. Doctrine and dogma may be fixed, but personal interpretation is not.

I am grateful for your many helpful lessons, which I shall absorb in time, but not before my confirmation tomorrow! This is a long journey into a new spiritual paradigm - give me a few decades.
It is certainly true that there are many, many perspectives contained within the Church, and most of these licit.

Regarding ecumenism, there is a wide range of valid approaches. I take heat from time to time because I am less dogmatic than some on “no salvation outside of the Church”. As I read the Catechism, non-Catholic Christians, Muslims, and Jews have some relation to the Church, although a very imperfect one. It would be better for all to become Catholic, surely, but God judges, and the best evidence we have is that some of these will indeed be saved, perhaps only by a baptism of desire on their deathbeds.

There is certainly nothing wrong with desiring that all of our brothers and sisters be saved—it is the most Christian of attitudes to have, in my opinion.
 
You claimed to be a professional historian in this thread, and a researcher in another. You did so to lend authority to what you were saying. Since anyone can claim anything within the anonymity of an Internet forum, it is good form to back up any claims with reasonable evidence, while preserving anonymity if you prefer. to do so.

Your insinuations are silly, paranoid, and irrelevant. I asked because you asserted authority without presenting your bona fides.

I appreciate the offer, but unnecessary for this purpose.

You have claimed separately to be an historian, a researcher, and your profile says you’re an educator. Perhaps these three instersect if you are a history instructor or a history professor or even a graduate student. Of course, a history professor who has made it their life’s calling to study the Reformation or Christian theology would command a great deal of respect and consequently their opinions a great deal of weight in this subject. A college student working toward a degree in the humanities would carry much less respect in this regard, as their expertise level is far lower. If you’re going to assert authority, you should provide enough insight as to the authority you have that your interlocutors may weigh it appropriately.

As I’ve mentioned, I have a degree in military history from a service academy. Unfortunately, questions of military art rarely come up here, so even my limited expertise in that field hardly puts the oomph in my opinions of it. I work professionally in the quality engineering field; likewise, process engineering and statistics only rarely arise here.

The only way my scribblings here have any weight at all, then, is when they are backed up from Scripture, Magisterium, and Tradition and argued logically. I cannot buttress theological arguments with authority and expertise I cannot claim. But I can get my facts straight, and argue from them—which is what I always try to do.

When you say in 3 above that you have been studying Catholic theology, liturgy, doctrine, dogma, history etc full time, in what capacity was this? Again, you don’t need to release specific details, but anyone can see that 4 years of such study doesn’t necessarily speak of significant experience in any of these fields, much less all of them. If asserting authority to lend credence to one’s arguments, one should clearly highlight the boundaries of one’s experience and knowledge. This is so that people are not led astray in presuming that your opinions somehow represent a specific community of expertise.

For example, Richard Dawkins, a biologist of some accomplishment, runs around beating the drum for atheism. Are we to believe that his doctorate in biology lends him special expertise as a theologian? Of course not! And still he asserts his credentials at every opportunity, as people in general respect a PhD.

Congratulations! I will say a prayer for you.

Previous threads (if I recall correctly) responded to you in the female form; I presumed they were accurate as I don’t recall a correction. If you are a male, I apologize for my error.

Jabulani right back at you.
Well!! Telfon. I am completely insulted!!! Apologizing for calling s/him a her. Subtle, subtle and I am sure not at all intentional.😉 Peace.
 
It is certainly true that there are many, many perspectives contained within the Church, and most of these licit.
Then can we not allow for licit variations within the universal/catholic church of Christ?
As I read the Catechism, non-Catholic Christians, Muslims, and Jews have some relation to the Church, although a very imperfect one.
For information, some of which is surprising (Islam eg):

In the Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, paragraph 16, the Vatican II Council Fathers wrote: "Those who have not yet received the gospel are related to the People of God in various ways.

There is, first, that people to which the covenants and promises were made, and from which Christ was born according to the flesh (cf. Romans 9:4-5): In view of the divine choice, they are a people most dear for the sake of the fathers, for the gifts of God are without repentance (cf. Romans 11:28-29).

"But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Moslems: These profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind’s judge on the last day.

"Nor is God remote from those who in shadows and images seek the unknown God, since he gives to all men life and breath and all things (cf. Acts 17:25-28), and since the Saviour wills all men to be saved (cf. 1 Timothy 2:4).

Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through dictates of their conscience—those too, may achieve eternal salvation.

“Nor shall divine providence deny the assistance necessary for salvation to those who, without any fault of theirs, have not yet arrived at an explicit knowledge of God, and who, not without grace, strive to lead a good life.”

So the Fathers of the Council do not exclude anyone acting in good faith from the possibility of salvation.
It would be better for all to become Catholic, surely, but God judges, and the best evidence we have is that some of these will indeed be saved, perhaps only by a baptism of desire on their deathbeds.
Why? How do you know? Why not just get on with Catholic Christian dailiness and let others deal with their own souls and salvation in their own way?
There is certainly nothing wrong with desiring that all of our brothers and sisters be saved—it is the most Christian of attitudes to have, in my opinion.
I agree sincerely. I would only add that one might desire not only salvation for those of faith, but that they would manifest that faith in Christian dailiness, Beloved of Christ and Christ in the Beloved, as followers of Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus promised that those who are faithful will come unto the Father, through Him.
 
I do not intend to be inflammatory: far from it. However, I think that the constant emphasis on the ‘one true church’ with its implications for other Christian denominations/churches/sects/ cults/communities/groups - whatever you want to call them - does tend to promote unnecessary divisiveness within Christendom. And I wonder if CC is following this line of ‘only true faith’ as firmly as some suggest, at least as far as mainstream denominations are concerned.

Try something. Close your eyes. Imagine a lake, any lake, anywhere in the world, any time of the day or night. I shall do the same.

Now tell me what your lake is like - its size, the colour of its water, whether it is calm or is rushing with ‘white horses’ on a windy day, what surrounds your lake (in my case, pines, cedars and rocks of the Cambrian Shield in northern Ontario), whether you see it at sunrise or sunset.

No one person’s image of ‘their’ lake is like that of any other’s. Doctrine and dogma may be fixed, but personal interpretation is not.

I am grateful for your many helpful lessons, which I shall absorb in time, but not before my confirmation tomorrow! This is a long journey into a new spiritual paradigm - give me a few decades.
The Lake mepaphore is nice. How did your Confirmation go today? I am happy that you have found your home in the Catholic Church… She is so rich with blessings, you will enjoy your journey! With your history/research background, it won’t take you a few decades. I am glad you are here sharing your story with us. I look forward to seeing your growth in the Catholic faith on this forum. I look forward to learning more from you too. I may not always share your opinion on something, but I bet ya I will learn alot from you.

Anyway, I just wanted to let you know that I thought of you today and I am so happy for you.

Kristie
 
So the Fathers of the Council do not exclude anyone acting in good faith from the possibility of salvation.

Why? How do you know? Why not just get on with Catholic Christian dailiness and let others deal with their own souls and salvation in their own way?
Glad you are reading your catechism. 👍

This is the best advice I have read all day. It seems to me that we each have our hands full keeping ourselves and the straight and narrow way, without pointing the finger at others we think may not be on the path.
 
Lisdogan! Prayers are with you on your confirmation. Are you a recent convert to Catholicism? You should find, for the most part, that Catholics are loving, tolerant beings, at peace with their God and fellow man – happy to have you aboard. Congratulations!
 
Dear Peeps,

Thank you for your loving messages. I have just returned from a very happy service at St John Fisher Catholic Church in Pretoria, and have finally received communion as a full member of the Catholic Church. I have waited; the timing was right.

I am happy. I have been blessed. And I have a long journey to make. I keep Thomas Merton’s prayer always in mind:

My Lord God, I have no idea where I am going.
I do not see the road ahead of me.
I cannot know for certain where it will end.
Nor do I really know myself,
and the fact that I think that I am following your will
does not mean that I am actually doing so.
But I believe that the desire to please you does in fact please you.
And I hope I have that desire in all that I am doing.
I hope that I will never do anything apart from that desire.
And I know that if I do this you will lead me by the right road
though I may know nothing about it.
Therefore, will I trust you always though I may seem to be lost
and in the shadow of death.
I will not fear, you are ever with me,
and you will never leave me to face my perils alone.
Thomas Merton

And Teflon - thank you for your assuaging note received this morning. Neophytes think, pray, but they have a lot to learn. Thank you.

You can all take pleasure in ‘helping your Protestant friend’.

Love from C/Lisdogan

But they that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength; they shall mount up with wings as eagles; they shall run and not be weary; and they shall walk and not be weak. Isaiah 40:31
 
I do not intend to be inflammatory: far from it. However, I think that the constant emphasis on the ‘one true church’ with its implications for other Christian denominations/churches/sects/ cults/communities/groups - whatever you want to call them - does tend to promote unnecessary divisiveness within Christendom. And I wonder if CC is following this line of ‘only true faith’ as firmly as some suggest, at least as far as mainstream denominations are concerned.

Try something. Close your eyes. Imagine a lake, any lake, anywhere in the world, any time of the day or night. I shall do the same.

Now tell me what your lake is like - its size, the colour of its water, whether it is calm or is rushing with ‘white horses’ on a windy day, what surrounds your lake (in my case, pines, cedars and rocks of the Cambrian Shield in northern Ontario), whether you see it at sunrise or sunset.

No one person’s image of ‘their’ lake is like that of any other’s. Doctrine and dogma may be fixed, but personal interpretation is not.

I am grateful for your many helpful lessons, which I shall absorb in time, but not before my confirmation tomorrow! This is a long journey into a new spiritual paradigm - give me a few decades.
Your right, Doctrine may be “fixed” but personal interpretations are not, thats what has caused all the problems and divisions within the protestant denominations. God Bless you on your journey, I am a life-long and long life, Catholic and I am still learning!
 
This is my time of day for thinking (6-10 hours ahead of you), and I need to raise several matters relevant to this discussion.

(1) Can someone please define exactly what the words *doctrine and dogma *– when they are used in informal discussions like this one – mean? Sounds a simple question but semantic accuracy is vital here in any discussion with other denominations.

(2) Is it not useful to think as much about commonality among Christian denominations, as about divisiveness and the unique qualities of the CC? For example
  • we say the same Nicene Creed
  • we use the same Bibles
  • we sing the same hymns (although protestants are by far the better singers)
  • we look for the same manifestations of Christ’s example for us in our daily lives
  • we look for support and guidance from the same modern-day popular theologians – Merton, Vanier, Rolheiser, Nolan, Nouwen, et al (in this case all Catholic, but freely used by protestants)
  • we all have the same ongoing concerns/arguments about salvation by faith alone, or salvation by faith and works
  • we have churches (mainline) that have the same architecture (at least in the so-called West), the same internal configurations around the altar, many of the same liturgical vestments and instruments.
(3) Three questions which I think are related to Christian doctrine/dogma roam around in my mind:

What if Pope John Paul II had, as he apparently wished to do – infallibly – declared the Virgin co-redemptrix? It seems common cause that he was persuaded not to do so by Cardinal Ratzinger. (See for example John Paul II Apostolic Letter, Rosarium Virginis Mariae, 2002; Unsworth, T in National Catholic Reporter, July 1997). Would this have been a change in doctrine, dogma, or merely interpretation – ending in a Trinity +?

In John Paul II, *The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church *(Report of the Pontifical Biblical Commission, Vatican, 1993, Chair: Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger) there is a spirited discussion of the progress of scientific knowledge and the ‘Catholic interpretation of the Bible’ (sic), noting the differences between the encyclical *Providentissimus Deus *(Leo XIII, 1893) and *Divino afflante Spiritu *(Pius XII, c1943). Pope Leo’s encyclical wanted to protect Catholic interpretation of the Bible from the attacks of rationalistic science; that of Pius XII was primarily concerned to defend Catholic interpretation from attacks that opposed the use of science by exegetes, and that wanted to impose a non-scientific, so-called ‘spiritual’ interpretation of the Sacred Scripture (ref pp 8-9. I have written about this elsewhere.) What does this say to us about doctrine, dogma, infallibility or otherwise, contextual influence on interpretation, divine interpretation by virtue of the Magisterium, and consistency of doctrinal interpretation over 2000 years?

This morning during my confirmation, I vowed a huge vow: that ‘I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches and proclaims to be revealed by God’. First of all, very few Catholics will have read all the weighty tomes of church tradition (Iowa Mike carefully made a list of all last year, and asked if I made my contribution having read the lot). Second, I have been advised, or I would not/could not have taken the vow, that in fact it refers to a limited number of revelations which are manageable by faithful Catholics. (I cannot yet make a list. Am I the only one?) How do individual Catholics understand this vow, taken by everyone who is received into the Church; what individual interpretations are possible; and how do we define what is ‘revealed by God’?

Just thinking.
 
This is my time of day for thinking (6-10 hours ahead of you), and I need to raise several matters relevant to this discussion.

(1) Can someone please define exactly what the words *doctrine and dogma *– when they are used in informal discussions like this one – mean? Sounds a simple question but semantic accuracy is vital here in any discussion with other denominations.
Well, let’s see what distinction the Catechism makes:

88 The Church’s Magisterium exercises the authority it holds from Christ to the fullest extent when it defines dogmas, that is, when it proposes, in a form obliging the Christian people to an irrevocable adherence of faith, truths contained in divine Revelation or also when it proposes, in a definitive way, truths having a necessary connection with these.

Dogma therefore must be believed by the faithful; doctrine should be believed by the faithful.
(2) Is it not useful to think as much about commonality among Christian denominations, as about divisiveness and the unique qualities of the CC? For example
  • we say the same Nicene Creed
We do not; the Orthodox object to The Filioque in the Catholic and common Protestant formulations. Some Protestants reject the Nicene Creed in favor of the Apostles Creed; a few reject the Trinity altogether.
  • we use the same Bibles
We do not; most Protestant Bibles do not recognize 7 books as canonical and reject portions of some others.
  • we sing the same hymns (although protestants are by far the better singers)
Not really—Catholic hymnals do not include dogmatically Protestant hymns. As has been lamented many times, this includes some very beautiful Protestant hymns which nonetheless are in error theologically.
  • we look for the same manifestations of Christ’s example for us in our daily lives
That depends—Pentecostals routinely look for speaking in tongues; I don’t know any Catholics who do. In the broadest sense, yes, we all seek experience of the divine.
  • we look for support and guidance from the same modern-day popular theologians – Merton, Vanier, Rolheiser, Nolan, Nouwen, et al (in this case all Catholic, but freely used by protestants)
I haven’t heard of any of these, as either a Protestant or a Catholic. You may be correct; I simply have no knowledge of this
  • we all have the same ongoing concerns/arguments about salvation by faith alone, or salvation by faith and works
Having conversations and agreeing on matters of the greatest importance are two different things. We view salvation quite differently, even if there is a semantic debate which contributes to this disagreement.
  • we have churches (mainline) that have the same architecture (at least in the so-called West), the same internal configurations around the altar, many of the same liturgical vestments and instruments.
What would we call the West if not the West? I presume you mean Europe, Canada, the United States et al. Again, Protestant denominations vary widely in how much of Catholic liturgy they’ve retained.

I’m afraid the list of similarities is not very impressive. There are more items we could add to the list, such as shared (for the most part) moral values and the like which are more significant than similarities of ritual or liturgy. One must probe deeper, however. Bread and grape juice is passed out once a month at our old Pentecostal Church of God. To them, it is nothing more than a memorial ceremony. The bread is discarded without much thought, the juice drunk or not drunk and left in pews, the Bible is misquoted to replace “wine” with “juice”. This is very different from the Catholic and Orthodox treatment of the Eucharist, although there are surface similarities. I wouldn’t celebrate the incidentals while downplaying the fundamentals.
(3) Three questions which I think are related to Christian doctrine/dogma roam around in my mind:
What if Pope John Paul II had, as he apparently wished to do – infallibly – declared the Virgin co-redemptrix? It seems common cause that he was persuaded not to do so by Cardinal Ratzinger. (See for example John Paul II Apostolic Letter, Rosarium Virginis Mariae, 2002; Unsworth, T in National Catholic Reporter, July 1997). Would this have been a change in doctrine, dogma, or merely interpretation – ending in a Trinity +?
It would depend on whether the Pope defined a doctrine or a dogma or simply provided his opinion. The fact that his successor was the one to restrain him is interesting, though, isn’t it?
In John Paul II, *The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church *(Report of the Pontifical Biblical Commission, Vatican, 1993, Chair: Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger) there is a spirited discussion of the progress of scientific knowledge and the ‘Catholic interpretation of the Bible’ (sic), noting the differences between the encyclical *Providentissimus Deus *(Leo XIII, 1893) and *Divino afflante Spiritu *(Pius XII, c1943). Pope Leo’s encyclical wanted to protect Catholic interpretation of the Bible from the attacks of rationalistic science; that of Pius XII was primarily concerned to defend Catholic interpretation from attacks that opposed the use of science by exegetes, and that wanted to impose a non-scientific, so-called ‘spiritual’ interpretation of the Sacred Scripture (ref pp 8-9. I have written about this elsewhere.) What does this say to us about doctrine, dogma, infallibility or otherwise, contextual influence on interpretation, divine interpretation by virtue of the Magisterium, and consistency of doctrinal interpretation over 2000 years?
It says that heresies abound and often resemble one another. Take a look at the early heresies around the nature of Christ, which claimed: a) Christ was man but not God; b) Christ was God but not man; and c) Christ was man and God but separate natures in one body. A condemnation of a) would not preclude a condemnation of b) and c), nor would it contradict itself. The fact is that Christ is the 2nd person of the Trinity, perfect God and perfect man simultaneously and inextricably. That is what the Church infallibly defined as Christian dogma.

As it was, so shall it ever be.
This morning during my confirmation, I vowed a huge vow: that ‘I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches and proclaims to be revealed by God’. First of all, very few Catholics will have read all the weighty tomes of church tradition (Iowa Mike carefully made a list of all last year, and asked if I made my contribution having read the lot). Second, I have been advised, or I would not/could not have taken the vow, that in fact it refers to a limited number of revelations which are manageable by faithful Catholics. (I cannot yet make a list. Am I the only one?) How do individual Catholics understand this vow, taken by everyone who is received into the Church; what individual interpretations are possible; and how do we define what is ‘revealed by God’?
Just thinking.
The oath references dogma. The Nicene Creed embodies the vast majority of it, beyond that, the Catechism refers to the immaculate conception and the Assumption of Mary. There is some debate over which aspects of Trent were considered to be dogmatic, but in any case I have yet to find a dogma which is difficult for me to believe given the evidence the Church provides.

When in doubt, one can always ask a priest or bishop. If you feel as though you are struggling with any dogma or doctrine, praying for faith helps, as does sharing your doubt at Confession.
 
Wow, Good job guys!

Lisdogan is a very intelligent person, but he struggles to understand distractions and details and misses the simple stuff. Teflon63 is doing a great job of making the complicated simple to understand. I bet Teflon is a really good teacher. Thanks to both for the open discussion. For the first time I am seeing the intellectual and spiritual struggle with faith. As a lifer Catholic I have just always accepted the teachings of the Catholic Church from childhood just on blind faith. I always felt that for 2000 years the saints in the church hammered out all the details and history and time usually brings out the truth.

Blessing to you both!
 
As a lifer Catholic I have just always accepted the teachings of the Catholic Church from childhood just on blind faith. I always felt that for 2000 years the saints in the church hammered out all the details and history and time usually brings out the truth.

Blessing to you both!
You are a blessing in your own right!

What you are seeing in me is the difficulty of not being a cradle-Catholic. If you wish to convert to Catholicism, the brain kicks in overwhelmingly and it takes ages to get to the faithful heart. Plus you have to wade through all the formal doctrine/dogma stuff. You do not get the 11 years of mandatory catechism classes for young people. For adults in South Africa, we have only one year of adult enquiry classes for people like me who wish to become members. And so we flounder, and often feel we have to learn it all before we join the CC.

I just decided to take the plunge during my spiritual journey (sanyassi) following career burnout. Now I can move into the next phase of growing head and heart together.

In Christ
 
You are concentrating on divisiveness when I asked if we could not concentrate on commonality. I look in all my missals, hymn books etc., and for Catholics and mainstream protestants, the creeds are the same, and are used regularly.
Actually, I’m pointing out that significant numbers of Protestants do not agree with what you listed as common. Anglicans, Methodists, Lutherans, and some Presbyterians are closer to the Catholic Church in liturgical norms and in some sacramental views. Unfortunately, these also happen to be the Protestant communities in decline at the expense of the nondenominational and evangelical communities, both of which are further away from Catholic liturgy and sacraments.
I asked recently whether there is such a thing as a ‘Catholic Bible’ There is, apparently, but Catholic Churches now often use New Jerusalem or Good News (at least as far as my research indicates). King James is often used by posters, as well as in church, by both protestants and Catholics, although several new translations (above) are more popular. Furthermore, you will find that the deuterocanonical books are now included in virtually every edition of the Bible, at least in English. I have been checking because they are new to me. But they are there in most Bibles, whether used by Catholics or protestants.
I certainly hope Catholics don’t use Protestant translations, particularly the very loose Good News kind of translations, for anything but apologetics purposes. There have been some dishonest translations over the years—think Luther’s adding “faith alone” to St Paul’s epistle in support of his heretical dogma. I myself reference the King James for apologetics purposes. I wouldn’t use it but for the small cadre of KJV-only fundamentalists. I myself prefer the Revised Standard Version-Catholic edition.
Been checking for the past year. Not all hymns are reflected identically in hymnals. But my statement remains true, although hardly worth arguing.
Not at all—many find the current state of musical liturgy within the Church to be sadly lacking, particularly given how many great composers were Catholic. We do lose some Catholics for this reason, sadly. Even Christmas carols have become controversial—a school band here wasn’t allowed to play “Ave Maria” at a Christmas concert because it was too Catholic.
I do not mean speaking in tongues, or experiencing the divine. I mean manifesting Christ’s example in the way we live daily: following the rules he set out in the Beatitudes, the New Covenant as we would call it, as well as in his own behaviour and the parables. Do we behave like Christians towards others? Yes, many of us try to do so. And please don’t refer to pentecostals, or fundamentalists or evangelicals as if they are the only protestants around. Perhaps it would help to find out a great deal more about mainstream protestant denominations.
I grew up Episcopalian and attended Methodist and Presbyterian communities for over two years, so I think I know something about both camps. It may be easy in your part of the world to ignore the fundamentalists and evangelicals, but here in the Bible Belt it’s tough to do!
I am sorry you are unaware of Vanier, Nolan, Merton (!), Nouwen et al. I think that this is one of the problems for many Christians, and many members of CAF. We are so hung up on the Bible, church literature, radio and TV broadcasts, that we are missing out on very significant Christian thought, by very significant Christian thinkers, many of them Catholic. Check on Google. You will find the Nouwen Society has a website for example; I am sure you will also find one for Vanier’s L’Arche communities, and his moral and theological philosophy.
I will check it out. Certainly, there is much more to the Church than the Bible, and many lay and clerical theologians add significantly to our understanding of it. I do get “First Things” in order to keep up with theology and its policy ties. I simply note you’re probably in the minority in terms of having read these thinkers; perhaps now that an eminent theologian is Pope more will follow your lead.
I did not mention agreement: I simply said we are all discussing matters of great importance, using similar language within paradigms that differ to a greater or lesser extent.
True, but words do mean things, and in this case similar words often mean very different things. Just because we call something “justification” doesn’t mean Lutherans see great commonality with us beyond surface similarity in terminology.
Many development workers now refer to North and South, or any other reasonable geographic partition which separates the world’s 2% rich from the 98% poor. I was not talking liturgy in particular, but architecture and several other aspects. Why set up a straw man by picking out one element?
I just thought “so-called West” was odd. We’re talking religion and theology, “Western” is a useful label for a certain strain of Judeo-Christian philosophy, which is a very different mode of thought than even our Orthodox Christian brothers and sisters hold to. Sometimes people seek to bash Western civilization with such asides, civilization without which the world would undoubtedly be 1/1000th % rich and the rest poor, as is the case in the East.
If you read the list your way, it may not seem impressive, but perhaps you do not want to see the similarities. I have been on both sides of the stream remember: I see the similarities, and view many of them positively (bona fides available).
No bona fides needed; you of course have a right to your opinion.
This is such a hoary old schlok! I have never seen this happen in a protestant church. However (1) remember that not everyone drinks alcohol (I am allergic); (2) I took communion at a Catholic retreat last week which consisted of broken crackers and wine; (3) I am truly upset that at Christmas and Easter when our Catholic congregation takes communion of both kinds: the host is dipped in the wine (intinction) by some congregants, resulting in soggy host falling to the floor to be trodden upon by those who follow. The practice has now been forbidden by the Archbishop.
You may find it schlocky, but you haven’t been at a Pentecostal communion service. The point is they elevate their traditional anti-alcohol stance over Scripture, which they ought not do.
Yes interesting. But more interesting is the fact that it would have been a Bull and therefore infallible and undoable. So what are the implications for dogma?
If the Pope were to issue an ex cathedra statement regarding a matter of faith and morals and declared it to be “de fide” (necessary for the faith), and the Holy Spirit allowed him to do so, then it would be dogma. My point about Pope Benedict XVI having intervened is perhaps the Holy Spirit intervened.
You have wandered down a sidebar. I spoke about two orthodox Papal Encyclicals. What would have been the implication for the Magisterium? Question stands.
I’m not sure that there is an implication. My point was that the Church never contradicts itself. Anti-Catholics often try to pull documents centuries apart and cast them in opposition to one another by stripping the context and meaning from them.

If you doubt the Magisterium, or its infallibility, praying over it and talking to your priests and bishop will likely help. Many wrestle with these notions.
 
What are you talking about? Are you saying the truth is whatever we want it to be?
No, of course not. This is a second reply to your posting. I have been thinking!

You must be referring to Absolute Truth by which CC claims its authority. Let’s ask some questions:

What do we mean by ‘Absolute Truth’ (define)?

Is there ‘an’ Absolute Truth; are there clusters of ‘Absolute Truths’?

Is it possible to discern, understand and know this ‘Absolute Truth’? Or is it, by nature - as with God Creator - unknowable, a Mystery?

Or is all ‘truth’ (define) relative? What does this mean - we use the phrase often, usually against ANOther; relative to what? Who defines and authorises or legitimates such ‘truths’ or ‘Absolute Truth’?
  • Or are we all assuming that
  • what Jesus is reported to have said
  • by men writing some time after His death, and
  • interpreted and agreed (not without controversy)
  • by men (some of them self-interested at the very least)
  • to be part of the Sacred Scriptures
  • believed to be the ‘firm foundation’ of the Church
  • is unalterably, unequivocably and inevitably
  • ‘the truth’ or the ‘Absolute Truth’?
Any thoughts on this? Or should we just assume that we are all on the same page?
 
NO other Church was around really that could EVER make that claim. The early Church, was the Catholic Church. Jesus promised to guide His One Church in Truth until the end of time. We are the ONLY Church that has retained that One Truth. He Has protected His Church.
Eish, I had such a good reply, and it went poof into the ether. So this will have to be a shorter thinkpiece. Probably better that way.

We use phrases or words perhaps without thinking what they mean. For example, what is a ‘Church’: buildings with steeples? a group of people who believe in something or someone? a set of principles, values, beliefs? an institution with a world-known leader? something like a cult or sect?

I have dealt with the question of defining truth elsewhere, as in ‘guiding his one church in truth’, the phrase you use, which is not completely clear to me.

Can we think perhaps that Christ has in fact guided His church - the holy catholic, ie universal, church of Christ - by buttressing it, keeping it stimulated, allowing for differences of understanding and perception - depending on context, era, geographical differences, existing indigenous belief systems.

We know that democracy is, generally, a Good Thing. Where there is not a democracy, autocracy rises (think Hitler in Germany, Stalin in Russia, Mugabe in Zimbabwe, Than Shwe in Myanmar/Burma, Mao Zedong in China inter alia). Which is stronger, more able to withstand the changes of time and power, more humanitarian, and more likely to be held to account for its rules, regulations and performance?

So I says to myself, Self I says, perhaps the Trinity has protected Christians and their church in ways that we have not considered. Perhaps there is strength in diversity, as the common saying goes.
 
Don’t say you are not a historian - we are all historians in one way or another, if we are alive and observant!

You’ve made lots of good observations about the church, faith and interpretations which make us think. So I don’t want to deal in detail with your post, but to think about it.
I understand what you are saying about there being different interpretations, but that does not take away from the fact that there was no other Church that could ever claim to be founded by Jesus. The CC is the Church founded by Jesus and nothing or no one else’s interpretation negates that. Different interpretations are just what they are, separate beliefs and not a part of the Catholic Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top