This is my time of day for thinking (6-10 hours ahead of you), and I need to raise several matters relevant to this discussion.
(1) Can someone please define exactly what the words *doctrine and dogma *– when they are used in informal discussions like this one – mean? Sounds a simple question but semantic accuracy is vital here in any discussion with other denominations.
Well, let’s see what distinction the Catechism makes:
88 The Church’s Magisterium exercises the authority it holds from Christ to the fullest extent when it defines dogmas, that is, when it proposes, in a form obliging the Christian people to an irrevocable adherence of faith, truths contained in divine Revelation or also when it proposes, in a definitive way, truths having a necessary connection with these.
Dogma therefore must be believed by the faithful; doctrine should be believed by the faithful.
(2) Is it not useful to think as much about commonality among Christian denominations, as about divisiveness and the unique qualities of the CC? For example
- we say the same Nicene Creed
We do not; the Orthodox object to The Filioque in the Catholic and common Protestant formulations. Some Protestants reject the Nicene Creed in favor of the Apostles Creed; a few reject the Trinity altogether.
We do not; most Protestant Bibles do not recognize 7 books as canonical and reject portions of some others.
- we sing the same hymns (although protestants are by far the better singers)
Not really—Catholic hymnals do not include dogmatically Protestant hymns. As has been lamented many times, this includes some very beautiful Protestant hymns which nonetheless are in error theologically.
- we look for the same manifestations of Christ’s example for us in our daily lives
That depends—Pentecostals routinely look for speaking in tongues; I don’t know any Catholics who do. In the broadest sense, yes, we all seek experience of the divine.
- we look for support and guidance from the same modern-day popular theologians – Merton, Vanier, Rolheiser, Nolan, Nouwen, et al (in this case all Catholic, but freely used by protestants)
I haven’t heard of any of these, as either a Protestant or a Catholic. You may be correct; I simply have no knowledge of this
- we all have the same ongoing concerns/arguments about salvation by faith alone, or salvation by faith and works
Having conversations and agreeing on matters of the greatest importance are two different things. We view salvation quite differently, even if there is a semantic debate which contributes to this disagreement.
- we have churches (mainline) that have the same architecture (at least in the so-called West), the same internal configurations around the altar, many of the same liturgical vestments and instruments.
What would we call the West if not the West? I presume you mean Europe, Canada, the United States et al. Again, Protestant denominations vary widely in how much of Catholic liturgy they’ve retained.
I’m afraid the list of similarities is not very impressive. There are more items we could add to the list, such as shared (for the most part) moral values and the like which are more significant than similarities of ritual or liturgy. One must probe deeper, however. Bread and grape juice is passed out once a month at our old Pentecostal Church of God. To them, it is nothing more than a memorial ceremony. The bread is discarded without much thought, the juice drunk or not drunk and left in pews, the Bible is misquoted to replace “wine” with “juice”. This is very different from the Catholic and Orthodox treatment of the Eucharist, although there are surface similarities. I wouldn’t celebrate the incidentals while downplaying the fundamentals.
(3) Three questions which I think are related to Christian doctrine/dogma roam around in my mind:
What if Pope John Paul II had, as he apparently wished to do – infallibly – declared the Virgin co-redemptrix? It seems common cause that he was persuaded not to do so by Cardinal Ratzinger. (See for example John Paul II Apostolic Letter, Rosarium Virginis Mariae, 2002; Unsworth, T in National Catholic Reporter, July 1997). Would this have been a change in doctrine, dogma, or merely interpretation – ending in a Trinity +?
It would depend on whether the Pope defined a doctrine or a dogma or simply provided his opinion. The fact that his successor was the one to restrain him is interesting, though, isn’t it?
In John Paul II, *The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church *(Report of the Pontifical Biblical Commission, Vatican, 1993, Chair: Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger) there is a spirited discussion of the progress of scientific knowledge and the ‘Catholic interpretation of the Bible’ (sic), noting the differences between the encyclical *Providentissimus Deus *(Leo XIII, 1893) and *Divino afflante Spiritu *(Pius XII, c1943). Pope Leo’s encyclical wanted to protect Catholic interpretation of the Bible from the attacks of rationalistic science; that of Pius XII was primarily concerned to defend Catholic interpretation from attacks that opposed the use of science by exegetes, and that wanted to impose a non-scientific, so-called ‘spiritual’ interpretation of the Sacred Scripture (ref pp 8-9. I have written about this elsewhere.) What does this say to us about doctrine, dogma, infallibility or otherwise, contextual influence on interpretation, divine interpretation by virtue of the Magisterium, and consistency of doctrinal interpretation over 2000 years?
It says that heresies abound and often resemble one another. Take a look at the early heresies around the nature of Christ, which claimed: a) Christ was man but not God; b) Christ was God but not man; and c) Christ was man and God but separate natures in one body. A condemnation of a) would not preclude a condemnation of b) and c), nor would it contradict itself. The fact is that Christ is the 2nd person of the Trinity, perfect God and perfect man simultaneously and inextricably. That is what the Church infallibly defined as Christian dogma.
As it was, so shall it ever be.
This morning during my confirmation, I vowed a huge vow: that ‘I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches and proclaims to be revealed by God’. First of all, very few Catholics will have read all the weighty tomes of church tradition (Iowa Mike carefully made a list of all last year, and asked if I made my contribution having read the lot). Second, I have been advised, or I would not/could not have taken the vow, that in fact it refers to a limited number of revelations which are manageable by faithful Catholics. (I cannot yet make a list. Am I the only one?) How do individual Catholics understand this vow, taken by everyone who is received into the Church; what individual interpretations are possible; and how do we define what is ‘revealed by God’?
The oath references dogma. The Nicene Creed embodies the vast majority of it, beyond that, the Catechism refers to the immaculate conception and the Assumption of Mary. There is some debate over which aspects of Trent were considered to be dogmatic, but in any case I have yet to find a dogma which is difficult for me to believe given the evidence the Church provides.
When in doubt, one can always ask a priest or bishop. If you feel as though you are struggling with any dogma or doctrine, praying for faith helps, as does sharing your doubt at Confession.