Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
ronald coat posted:
Mizer, I can assure you that when you are on your death bed, words are not being wasted just to argue or that my thoughts are “laughable”. What calloused comments!
If Catholics can “tear me apart’, that is what I was I was hoping for. I seek the truth from qualified learned Catholics using this best Catholic apologetic website
At any rate, I look forward to further continuation of this dialog with you in the presence of the Lord, in Heaven, not purgatory.
May God richly bless you as you continue in these ministries, Ron
I apologize if I mischaracterized your interest here. Are you telling me you are on your death bed? Maybe I haven’t read each of the posts on this thread closely enough to be sure of whom I am speaking, before I speak. I certainly don’t wish to come off as callous. I’m sorry if I’ve offended you in any way. Not my intention. Your post appeared to be the classic list of fundamentalist mis-information about Catholicism. The list seems to be rampant and it is loaded with mis-information.

I didn’t say the catholics on the board would “tear you apart.” I would never say such a thing. I said, “tear your post apart.” I meant that you could be corrected in your mis-understandings by the catholics on this board and I was suggesting that you search the rest of the site as many of these mis-understandings are covered on the site apart from the forums.

Again, I hope you will forgive the harshness of my rash post.

May God Bless you in your truth seeking effort.

H
 
Ron,
I know that it is difficult to erase or “move aside” what your denomination has taught you your whole life, but just try to put it aside for a moment. It really is pretty simple (I know…) in a way. Jesus founded a church with Peter and the Apostles. Jesus gave Peter supreme Authority and the Keys to the Kingdom. They continued teaching Jesus’ Word and following Sacred Tradition (that Jesus also followed some and established some of his own.) The Early Church is the Catholic Church. Through Apostolic Succession, Apostolic Authority and led by the Holy Spirit, we recorded Jesus’ teachings into ONE book - The Holy Bible. Christians for Centuries knew exactly what the interpretation was, followed the same Sacred Tradition. Through glorious times and even scandalous times, the Catholic Church has NEVER, EVER changed interpretation of Scripture or Doctrine. NEVER. We still teach the teachings of Jesus Christ. No other Church can say that. We still practice the same today as we did when Jesus founded the Church. Luther didn’t have a problem with the things which we are discussing with you. 500 years of non-truths, some very deliberate, taught in the Protestant Churches has created the turmoil that Protestantism is in today. Protestants don’t practice a lot of teachings that Protestantism was founded on. There was a protest, the Catholic Church must have been evil, wrong, we misinterpret scripture, and that is what the Protestants know of us today. Oh, yeah, they know of our scandalous times. Can’t leave that out. The protest was for more political reasons, not faith, doctrine, Church reasons. We are the same Church that Christ established with Peter and I pray that you can come to see and believe that. If you can get your hands on a Scott Hahn CD, please do. He is captivating and evangelical. He was about as Anti-Catholic as you could get. You will love hearing the story of his conversion. It will warm you and open your eyes.
 
Ron,
I know that it is difficult to erase or “move aside” what your denomination has taught you your whole life, but just try to put it aside for a moment. It really is pretty simple (I know…) in a way. Jesus founded a church with Peter and the Apostles. Jesus gave Peter supreme Authority and the Keys to the Kingdom. They continued teaching Jesus’ Word and following Sacred Tradition (that Jesus also followed some and established some of his own.) The Early Church is the Catholic Church. Through Apostolic Succession, Apostolic Authority and led by the Holy Spirit, we recorded Jesus’ teachings into ONE book - The Holy Bible. Christians for Centuries knew exactly what the interpretation was, followed the same Sacred Tradition. Through glorious times and even scandalous times, the Catholic Church has NEVER, EVER changed interpretation of Scripture or Doctrine. NEVER. We still teach the teachings of Jesus Christ. No other Church can say that. We still practice the same today as we did when Jesus founded the Church. Luther didn’t have a problem with the things which we are discussing with you. 500 years of non-truths, some very deliberate, taught in the Protestant Churches has created the turmoil that Protestantism is in today. Protestants don’t practice a lot of teachings that Protestantism was founded on. There was a protest, the Catholic Church must have been evil, wrong, we misinterpret scripture, and that is what the Protestants know of us today. Oh, yeah, they know of our scandalous times. Can’t leave that out. The protest was for more political reasons, not faith, doctrine, Church reasons. We are the same Church that Christ established with Peter and I pray that you can come to see and believe that. If you can get your hands on a Scott Hahn CD, please do. He is captivating and evangelical. He was about as Anti-Catholic as you could get. You will love hearing the story of his conversion. It will warm you and open your eyes.
Great response, but I will try to make one correction. You stated that, " The Catholic Church must have been evil, wrong, we misinterpret the scripture, and that is what protestants know of us" I totally disagree with that statement… Jesus promised that HIS Church would NEVER teach error and the gates of Hell would NEVER prevail against it. The Catholic Church has NEVER been wrong, or evil or any such thing. The Holy Spirit would never allow that. But many people within the Church and at times even a few Popes have lived sinful lives and were not the holiest examples to the Catholic Christians. We saw that recently in the priest scandals. BUT the Catholic Church is not wrong or evil, it is the individual people that give scandal to the world. BUT in spite of the weakness and sinfulness of its members, the Catholic Church continues to teach, govern and sanctify as Christ commissioned it to do for the past 2,000 years. The Church has not and does not misinterpret scripture and never could. It continues to give us a better understanding of Sacred Scripture as the Holy Spirit guides the Church in her understandings of Scripture. We have to distinguish between the teachings of the Catholic Church and those who go against those teachings. Like I said, we have even as some “bad” popes that led sinful lives, BUT in spite of that, they never did anything to harm the Church or her Doctrine. Their personal lives left much to be desired but the doctrine of the Church was NEVER in danger. The Pope is Infallible when speaking to the Church on Faith, (what we believe), and Morals, (how we live what we believe) but he is not impeccable in his personal life, any more than you or I might be. Lets never forget the many, many very Holy Popes. Bishops. priests and lay people that have been very faithful in what the Church teaches as well as in their personal lives. As I said before, the Catholic Church has seen kingdoms rise and fall, nations come and go, it has suffered thru many hardships and scandals but it is still standing as straight and tall in its Doctrine and Sacraments and in the Apostolic Succession, valid Mass and Eucharist, as it has ever since Jesus Christ founded it. What other denomination can say that!!! The Pope, in spite of his human weakness, with his authority given by CHRIST, holds the Catholic Church together and without error thru the work of the Holy Spirit. Christ promised us HE would be with HIS Church till the End of Time… AND HE WILL.
 
That’s what I meant to say!!! 😃 When I wrote the “evil, wrong, misinterpret scripture” line, I was trying to speak to what the Protestants had to be thinking then and probably still think. I NEVER wanted to say that I THOUGHT the Catholic Church was evil. ETC… But, you really did say it better than I ever could.
I get the feeling that Protestants think since we claim that Jesus gave Peter his Authority and that since every successor to Peter receives that Authority, and we refer to them as infallible, that Peter and all popes are divine or something, or infallible in all aspects of their life. Only Jesus was completely infallible. Do Protestants think the popes were somehow immune to sin, or maybe Jesus’ guidance over them would prevent them from sin? Jesus was divine. Peter and the subsequent popes are human. They are led by the Holy Spirit and infallible in guiding the Church in Faith and Morals, its teachings and interpretation of scripture from the time Jesus gave it to them! They have made mistakes in their personal lives, but those mistakes NEVER affected the Church’s Holy guidance and protection of Christ’s teachings.
 
BUT the Catholic Church is not wrong or evil, it is the individual people that give scandal to the world. BUT in spite of the weakness and sinfulness of its members, the Catholic Church continues to teach, govern and sanctify as Christ commissioned it to do for the past 2,000 years. The Church has not and does not misinterpret scripture and never could. It continues to give us a better understanding of Sacred Scripture as the Holy Spirit guides the Church in her understandings of Scripture.
Perfectly said. How could anyone not see that we were taught by Jesus and taught forth His teachings and traditions? We are the only Church that claims that. We are the only Church that can claim that. We wrote the Bible. How could they believe in the Bible, but think we are not the One Church founded by Christ, but theirs that was founded 1500 years after Christ, is?
 
I have a few questions.

If Jesus’ Authority wasn’t passed from Peter to subsequent Popes, why is it that anyone believes in the Bible?

Since non-C’s aren’t ordained in any lineage from Peter, and since non-C’s believe that Jesus’ authority and power stopped with Peter (or that Peter never had any authority or power), where do they derive their power or authority to perform baptisms, perform marriage ceremonies, or to confirm (some do that) in the name of God or through God? Mere mortals and lay people don’t have any power or authority to perform these duties do they? Is it just words, or do they believe that God is working through them?
 
I have a few questions.

If Jesus’ Authority wasn’t passed from Peter to subsequent Popes, why is it that anyone believes in the Bible?

Since non-C’s aren’t ordained in any lineage from Peter, and since non-C’s believe that Jesus’ authority and power stopped with Peter (or that Peter never had any authority or power), where do they derive their power or authority to perform baptisms, perform marriage ceremonies, or to confirm (some do that) in the name of God or through God? Mere mortals and lay people don’t have any power or authority to perform these duties do they? Is it just words, or do they believe that God is working through them?
You just don’t get it, AFH—obviously, the same Holy Spirit who couldn’t possibly infallibly protect the ex cathedra pronouncements in matters of faith and morals of one man (the Pope) infallibly guides the Scripture readings of every Protestant—whoops, every “right-thinking” Protestant.

THAT should clear it up.
 
You just don’t get it, AFH—obviously, the same Holy Spirit who couldn’t possibly infallibly protect the ex cathedra pronouncements in matters of faith and morals of one man (the Pope) infallibly guides the Scripture readings of every Protestant—whoops, every “right-thinking” Protestant.

THAT should clear it up.
?, What are you saying?
 
Thanks for spelling that out for me. I thought it was something like that, but just wanted to be sure!
 
Always for Him and Teflon,

Notice, none of the non-c’s on the board are answering this question you pose. If they did they would say something like Teflon’s response. They believe the Bible because the Holy Spirit told them directly that it’s God’s very Word. Even though the Bible itself proclaims that the person of Jesus Christ is God’s very Word, but that’s another argument.

I once asked a follow-up question to this, of a Baptist. The next question is, obviously: if the Holy spirit is leading each individual Christian into the truth of the Bible, then why do people come to opposing beliefs? This particular Baptist said the reason was because not every believer listens. Can you believe that? Some people “choose” not to listen so they get it wrong. That of course would be sinful so here we have sinners who have no way to learn the truth and be saved because they sin and don’t listen to the Holy Spirit who is trying (unsuccessfully) to teach them, from within.

Can any non-catholic believer out there wiegh in on this and perhaps enlighten us, bringing us out of our confusion? Did my Baptist friend get this wrong? Is there a better explanation as to why there are so many conflicting denominations if the HS is leading each of you into the One Truth of Scripture? How could the Episcopal church go so far against the spriptural understanding of homosexual behavior? Did the Holy Spirit stop leading them or did they choose not to listen anymore?
 
Always for Him and Teflon,

Notice, none of the non-c’s on the board are answering this question you pose. If they did they would say something like Teflon’s response. They believe the Bible because the Holy Spirit told them directly that it’s God’s very Word. Even though the Bible itself proclaims that the person of Jesus Christ is God’s very Word, but that’s another argument.

I once asked a follow-up question to this, of a Baptist. The next question is, obviously: if the Holy spirit is leading each individual Christian into the truth of the Bible, then why do people come to opposing beliefs? This particular Baptist said the reason was because not every believer listens. Can you believe that? Some people “choose” not to listen so they get it wrong. That of course would be sinful so here we have sinners who have no way to learn the truth and be saved because they sin and don’t listen to the Holy Spirit who is trying (unsuccessfully) to teach them, from within.

Can any non-catholic believer out there wiegh in on this and perhaps enlighten us, bringing us out of our confusion? Did my Baptist friend get this wrong? Is there a better explanation as to why there are so many conflicting denominations if the HS is leading each of you into the One Truth of Scripture? How could the Episcopal church go so far against the spriptural understanding of homosexual behavior? Did the Holy Spirit stop leading them or did they choose not to listen anymore?
They have a way of getting around everything. I had a Southern Baptist Friend, many, many years ago that believed “once saved always saved” and prided herself that her whole family would go straight to heaven as they were all “saved.” When he oldest son was in high school he became involved in a satanic group and was caught stealing choir robes from their church. she insisted He was falsely accused as he had been “saved” and wouldn’t do anything like that. A couple years later he was caught along with others grave robbing, and she insisted that God used him to expose the others. we moved and I lost touch with them and I don’t know to much more except he was later kicked out of the service for his satanic practices. Would you believe me if I told you it all started with an Oije Board his mother got him for Christmas when he was about 12 years old!!! He claimed he could talk to spirits. I forbid him to even bring it or even talk about it in my home.
 
Always for Him and Teflon,

Notice, none of the non-c’s on the board are answering this question you pose. If they did they would say something like Teflon’s response. They believe the Bible because the Holy Spirit told them directly that it’s God’s very Word. Even though the Bible itself proclaims that the person of Jesus Christ is God’s very Word, but that’s another argument.

I once asked a follow-up question to this, of a Baptist. The next question is, obviously: if the Holy spirit is leading each individual Christian into the truth of the Bible, then why do people come to opposing beliefs? This particular Baptist said the reason was because not every believer listens. Can you believe that? Some people “choose” not to listen so they get it wrong. That of course would be sinful so here we have sinners who have no way to learn the truth and be saved because they sin and don’t listen to the Holy Spirit who is trying (unsuccessfully) to teach them, from within.

Can any non-catholic believer out there wiegh in on this and perhaps enlighten us, bringing us out of our confusion? Did my Baptist friend get this wrong? Is there a better explanation as to why there are so many conflicting denominations if the HS is leading each of you into the One Truth of Scripture? How could the Episcopal church go so far against the spriptural understanding of homosexual behavior? Did the Holy Spirit stop leading them or did they choose not to listen anymore?
This explains the general grammatical-historical method, that should be used.

geocities.com/CollegePark/Classroom/1284/ibible.html
 
Perfectly said. How could anyone not see that we were taught by Jesus and taught forth His teachings and traditions? We are the only Church that claims that. We are the only Church that can claim that. We wrote the Bible. How could they believe in the Bible, but think we are not the One Church founded by Christ, but theirs that was founded 1500 years after Christ, is?
The Roman Catholic Church wrote the bible!? Now I have heard everything. I believe that God wrote the bible, at least the one I read. My bible say scripture is:God breathed” II Timothy 3:16," …true words of God.” Revelation 19:9. I would like to see your bible and where it says the Roman Catholic Church wrote it!?!
 
The Roman Catholic Church wrote the bible!? Now I have heard everything. I believe that God wrote the bible, at least the one I read. My bible say scripture is:God breathed” II Timothy 3:16," …true words of God.” Revelation 19:9. I would like to see your bible and where it says the Roman Catholic Church wrote it!?!
Take a look at the copyright page of your Bible.

Unless it says “Copyright Eternity by God”, I’m afraid you’ll need to provide some evidence as to how you came by it.
 
The Roman Catholic Church wrote the bible!?
Yes. In the sense that the bishops along with the Pope determined from all of the writing in use in the 3rd and 4th centuries, which ones were inspired and which ones were not. The ones that were so determined, were canonized into the bible.
Now I have heard everything.
I don’t think so.
I believe that God wrote the bible, at least the one I read.
So where was God when He put “pen to paper” to do so? Last I checked human beings, inspired by God, put in writing the words of the bible.
My bible say scripture is:God breathed” II Timothy 3:16," …true words of God.” Revelation 19:9.
So does mine (RSV CE). Note that is says “God breathed” not God written.
I would like to see your bible and where it says the Roman Catholic Church wrote it!?!
Since the Bible is not a history textbook, other reliable sources must be consulted to determine how the bible came about.
 
Since the Bible is not a history textbook, other reliable sources must be consulted to determine how the bible came about.
Not only that—since the Bible lacks a table of contents, and there are many different translations and compilations all purporting to be the Bible, we need an external source to define what precisely it is.

This is the fundamental flaw of sola scriptura.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top