Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Memaw posted: They have a way of getting around everything.
This is absolutely correct. They go around and around and around. Nieither asking themselves the tough questions or answering the questions we pose to them, because they are tough. If they answered (or tried to answer them), they would embark on an incredible journey that would lead them across the Tiber and into the truth and it is just too much for them when that truth looks like it is eminating from the one church they have been taught to hate.

Look at this from disciple 123:
The Roman Catholic Church wrote the bible!? Now I have heard everything. I believe that God wrote the bible, at least the one I read. My bible say scripture is:God breathed” II Timothy 3:16," …true words of God.” Revelation 19:9. I would like to see your bible and where it says the Roman Catholic Church wrote it!?!
This is exactly what I’m talking about. God never “wrote” a line of Scripture. Unless one want’s to talk about the ten commandments where we believe the finger of God came down in a flame and etched the words onto the tablets of stone. This is not how the Bible was written.

Disciple 123 makes a classic statement, followed by a most traditional (the tradition of men) question. Notice he/she doesn’t even attempt any of the questions asked by the Catholics and posed to the non-catholics on this thread. Just attack, attack, attack. “Show me in the Bible!” Show me in the Bible where it says the RCC wrote it."

Ok 123, see if you can accept this. The NT says, that the Holy Spirit came upon The Church as a gift, to protect her and guide her into the one truth. There are many verses which support this understanding of what we call Pentecost.

In Tim 3:15 we see that it is This Church that is the pillar and foundation of truth. The word household implies a building. A structure that has a roof and holds a certain gathering of people. I’m not saying that any such “building” existed, at the time, but the verse does use this analogy so that we can be sure what Christ meant when he said, “I will build my church.” He meant he would build His church, Matt 16:18, not “gather His people.” This is one of the many verses you probably won’t allow to mean what it says so lets just move on.

It is a fact of reality that men, physically wrote the Bible. God did not. The men who wrote the Bible where inspired by God but they are the one’s who took quil in hand and did the writing. God did not do the writing. So to say, “God wrote the Bible,” is simply false. Men, inspired by God, wrote the Bible. These men where, by faith, Catholic.

You say you believe God wrote the Bible because of 2Tim3:16. OK, then what does it mean when Jesus breathes on the Apostles, telling them “recieve the Holy Spirit?” This is in the Gospel of John. In typical Catholic fashion I can’t give you the cite because I’ve temporarliy misplaced my study Bible where I have the verse highlighted and because I’m sure none of this will matter much to you until you decide for yourself that something isn’t passing the smell test in your own system of faith, I’m not going to take the time to find it right now.

At any rate, it’s John’s rendition of Pentecost and he has Jesus breathing directly on these specific men, Peter at the helm, giving them the gift He promised them, His spirit, as “the spirit of truth.” No where in the Bible do we have Jesus giving every believer the gift of the Holy Spirit, as “the spirit of truth” much less breathing on every believer in the way God Breathed life into Adam, in the book of Genesis. This pentecostal rendition in the Gospel of John is a picture of Jesus breathing life into His one true church. That would be the Catholic Church, the only church in existance at the time. The men who wrote the Bible were inspired by God. They were “breathed on” by God and enabled, thusly, to write the words. That’s why the verse says the Bible is “God breathed.”

The word breath does not mean ‘to write’. I really wish you non-C’s would use a dictionary when you read your Bibles. It would help a lot if you could understand english. Now that I’ve answered your question, can you scroll back through this thread and pick out just one of the questions posed by Always for Him and attempt to answer it? Just give it your best shot. Well all applaud you for it. If you have the truth, it should be easy. **Go for it! **
 
Not only that—since the Bible lacks a table of contents, and there are many different translations and compilations all purporting to be the Bible, we need an external source to define what precisely it is.
This is the fundamental flaw of sola scriptura.
One of many!
 
Kaycee,

What do you mean by this:
This explains the general grammatical-historical method, that should be used.
Why be so criptic?

If you have a comment why don’t you just make it in a way we can understand?

Does anybody know what kaycee means by this?
 
Kaycee,

What do you mean by this:

Why be so criptic?

If you have a comment why don’t you just make it in a way we can understand?

Does anybody know what kaycee means by this?
I’m more interested in the “should be used” part of what kaycee said.

Where in Scripture does God say, “Use the grammatical-historical method to interpret the Bible”?
 
Kaycee,

What do you mean by this:

Why be so criptic?

If you have a comment why don’t you just make it in a way we can understand?

Does anybody know what kaycee means by this?
Essentially, it means, what did the author intend to convey. Why was he writing it? When, to whom, etc.
 
40.png
Teflon93:
Not only that—since the Bible lacks a table of contents, and there are many different translations and compilations all purporting to be the Bible, we need an external source to define what precisely it is.

This is the fundamental flaw of sola scriptura.
No, no, no, no, no, no. That’s an artificial flaw created by Catholics who reject the Bible as the sole rule of faith and practice.

We owe the early church a great debt for preserving and caring for the Biblical manuscripts.

Sola Scriptura (the Rule of Faith & Practice) by A. A. Hodge
 
The Roman Catholic Church wrote the bible!? Now I have heard everything. I believe that God wrote the bible, at least the one I read. My bible say scripture is:God breathed” II Timothy 3:16," …true words of God.” Revelation 19:9. I would like to see your bible and where it says the Roman Catholic Church wrote it!?!
Please don’t “quote” me out of context. It has been stated many times on the previous pages of this thread that it is only the Catholic Church writing/recording Jesus’ Teachings through the guidance of the Holy Spirit. So, as to not have to continue with the obvious explanation as to how we came to write the Bible, I just said “wrote the Bible.” Please be more fair in your responses.
 
Please don’t “quote” me out of context. It has been stated many times on the previous pages of this thread that it is only the Catholic Church writing/recording Jesus’ Teachings through the guidance of the Holy Spirit. So, as to not have to continue with the obvious explanation as to how we came to write the Bible, I just said “wrote the Bible.” Please be more fair in your responses.
Indeed, if this person had noted my signature line, it would have been clear that even Martin Luther, no friend of the Catholic Church, respected her for producing the Holy Bible.

And here I’d thought Protestants had become LESS anti-Catholic since the 16th century!
 
This is absolutely correct. They go around and around and around. Nieither asking themselves the tough questions or answering the questions we pose to them, because they are tough. If they answered (or tried to answer them), they would embark on an incredible journey that would lead them across the Tiber and into the truth and it is just too much for them when that truth looks like it is eminating from the one church they have been taught to hate.
Look at this from disciple 123:

This is exactly what I’m talking about. God never “wrote” a line of Scripture. Unless one want’s to talk about the ten commandments where we believe the finger of God came down in a flame and etched the words onto the tablets of stone. This is not how the Bible was written.

Disciple 123 makes a classic statement, followed by a most traditional (the tradition of men) question. Notice he/she doesn’t even attempt any of the questions asked by the Catholics and posed to the non-catholics on this thread. Just attack, attack, attack. “Show me in the Bible!” Show me in the Bible where it says the RCC wrote it."

Ok, you have no idea who I am so how can you assume I “hate” the church. For your information I am a catholic,born raised and raised my children as catholics. I know that God didn’t sit down and pen the bible but the statement I was responding to made it sound like man wrote the bible. I was bringing about the fact that “God is the author” of the bible not man. Talk about “attack, attack, attack” You guys wont bring anyone to believe in God if you attack the way you do. Use a little humility and kindness when trying to help someone understand. Does that sound familiar? It should it is how Jesus spoke to those He was trying to teach. I can’t remember any where in the bible that says He used sarcasm or riducule to reach out to people. He use love, yes love. He even loved those who were lost.
 
MIZER;3801434:
This is absolutely correct. They go around and around and around. Nieither asking themselves the tough questions or answering the questions we pose to them, because they are tough. If they answered (or tried to answer them), they would embark on an incredible journey that would lead them across the Tiber and into the truth and it is just too much for them when that truth looks like it is eminating from the one church they have been taught to hate.
Look at this from disciple 123:

This is exactly what I’m talking about. God never “wrote” a line of Scripture. Unless one want’s to talk about the ten commandments where we believe the finger of God came down in a flame and etched the words onto the tablets of stone. This is not how the Bible was written.

Disciple 123 makes a classic statement, followed by a most traditional (the tradition of men) question. Notice he/she doesn’t even attempt any of the questions asked by the Catholics and posed to the non-catholics on this thread. Just attack, attack, attack. “Show me in the Bible!” Show me in the Bible where it says the RCC wrote it."

Ok, you have no idea who I am so how can you assume I “hate” the church. For your information I am a catholic,born raised and raised my children as catholics. I know that God didn’t sit down and pen the bible but the statement I was responding to made it sound like man wrote the bible. I was bringing about the fact that “God is the author” of the bible not man. Talk about “attack, attack, attack” You guys wont bring anyone to believe in God if you attack the way you do. Use a little humility and kindness when trying to help someone understand. Does that sound familiar? It should it is how Jesus spoke to those He was trying to teach. I can’t remember any where in the bible that says He used sarcasm or riducule to reach out to people. He use love, yes love. He even loved those who were lost.

And your profile says “baptist” because…?
 
To make it easier to answer some of my questions, I will post my questions again. This time I am going to be a little more thorough.

If Jesus’ Authority wasn’t passed from Peter to subsequent Popes, or magisterium, why is it that ANYONE believes in the Bible?

Since non-C’s aren’t ordained in any lineage from Peter, and since non-C’s believe that Jesus’ authority and power stopped with Peter (or that Peter never had any authority or power), where do they derive their power or authority to perform baptisms, perform marriage ceremonies, or to confirm (some do that) in the name of God or through God?

Is baptism merely symbolistic because it is mentioned in the Bible? Or, do you believe it washes away Original Sin? Why was it mentioned in the Bible at all if there wasn’t some signifigance to it? Why the big deal about Jesus getting baptized if there wasn’t some major signifigance to it?

Mere mortals and lay people don’t have any power or authority to perform these duties do they? Is it just words, or do they believe that God is working through them? If they believe that God is working through them, then did God give them the power or authority to perform those functions? I didn’t mention the Consecration of the Eucharist, the forgivness of sins in Reconciliation because I don’t think they believe in those sacraments. Am I correct on that?

Do non-C’s annoint the sick? If they do, where do they get the power an authority to do that? Does it actually do anything, or is it just symbolism because it is in the Bible?

When Protestant ministers are ordained, is it through some type of power? Do they receive some kind of power or authority when ordained? If so, where does that power or authority come from?

I ask these questions because non-C’s say that Jesus didn’t give Peter His Authority or Power. Or, they say that it stopped with Peter. Either way, how could some normal, everyday, man, who was born of original sin, who has not been breathed upon by Jesus, or given the keys to the Kingdom, or isn’t a successor to Peter or any of the Apostles for that matter, have any power or authority to perform these sacraments, duties, ceremonies, whatever you want to call it? It doesn’t say anything of this sort in the Bible. And of course, non-C’s say everything is in the Bible.
 
The Catholic Church was the only Church in existance at that time, how could any other Church claim to be THE Church? Actually, I don’t think there are any other Churches that claim that, but they think they are the Chosen Church, or correct interpreters of Jesus’ teachings and scripture. Why is that? Where did they get that idea? There are 35,000 different Protestant Churches out there that think that?
 
To make it easier to answer some of my questions, I will post my questions again. This time I am going to be a little more thorough.

Is baptism merely symbolistic because it is mentioned in the Bible? Or, do you believe it washes away Original Sin? Why was it mentioned in the Bible at all if there wasn’t some signifigance to it? Why the big deal about Jesus getting baptized if there wasn’t some major signifigance to it?
I know that priests aren’t the only ones who can baptise. When my nephew was born 4 months premature, my brother was worried he would die before being baptised and when the priest came he said you could have baptised him yourself. So I guess anyone can baptise in an emergency.
 
Essentially, it means, what did the author intend to convey. Why was he writing it? When, to whom, etc.
I would love to hear your answers to your own questions. Are you referring to each author of each reading, verse, book in the Bible, who each author was speaking to when they spoke, etc… Or, are you referring to the author that wrote the Bible? If it is the latter, that couldn’t be answered as it wasn’t just one author that wrote the Bible.
 
Wow, disciple 123, I have to say that you really came across as anti-Catholic. I assumed that myself. Are you trying to play devil’s advocate or are you seriously questioning your faith?

“but the statement I was responding to made it sound like man wrote the bible. I was bringing about the fact that “God is the author” of the bible not man.”

I guess I shouldn’t have assumed that those who have been having these discussions on all of these pages, and shouldn’t have assumed that others would have read all of the previous posts before just jumping in with a very strong post without any prior knowledge of discussion. It is a factual statement to say that the Catholic Church wrote the Bible. If you are Catholic, it is understood by whose guidance, being led by the Holy Spirit as to how it came to be written. That should go unsaid and unquestioned by a Catholic. By the way, it did feel like you attacked me. Please don’t ask anyone to use humility and kindness until you can do that first. We have been understanding, kind, patient and helpful to everyone seeking the Truth about Catholocism. You are right though in sense, but you have to have the truth repeatedly refuted and thrown back in your face by those who have been taught to hate the Catholic Church and all that it stands for because they think their interpretation is correct and we are always wrong.
 
I know that priests aren’t the only ones who can baptise. When my nephew was born 4 months premature, my brother was worried he would die before being baptised and when the priest came he said you could have baptised him yourself. So I guess anyone can baptise in an emergency.
In an emergency, being the key phrase. We all understand that.
 
Since I am up to asking questions, here are a few more:

Martin Luther believed in all seven sacraments. He founded Protestantism on them. (At least he wanted to. The other Refromers may have had a hand in removing one or two of those beliefs.) What has happened to the belief and practice of Reconciliation, and receiving the Holy Eucharist?

All three Reformers believed in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist. What has happened to that belief over the last 500 years? Real Presence, meaning exactly what Jesus said it said. This was the only time that any disciples left Jesus because they found a teaching of his to be to difficult.

All three Reformers believed in Marian Dogma. What has happend to that belief over the last 500 years?

Why don’t non-C’s question the truth in the “changes” Martin Luther made? He wasn’t really refuting Church teachings, interpretation or doctrine. He was a Roman Catholic Priest, so at least at one point he beleived in Apostolic Authority, Apostolic Succession and Papal Infallibility.

I really don’t know why non-C’s don’t question why he ommitted 7 books of the Bible. They had been part of the Bible and Catholic teaching for 1200 years before he through them out! So, why don’t you question that.

He admits that he knew alone wasn’t in the translation, but he wanted it in there, so he put it in there. That really established Sola Scriptura. If Catholics had done that, we would be burned at the stake for that. Why don’t you question that?

Jesus told Peter, “You are the rock and on this rock I will build my Church.” ETC… Why is it that you don’t take that literally? Who else was he speaking to? He didn’t turn and address the rest of the Apostles to make any clarification. They all knew and understood what he was saying. There is so much more in scripture to support that. How can all of that be ignored or misinterpreted?

There are more questions, but I am short on time, so I will leave it at that for now.

I really look forward to real, true, honest answers to these and all of my questions.
 
I also want to give a shout out to kaycee, with whom I do not often agree, but who makes his Reformed Baptist background quite clear in his public profile, and also references it from time to time in posts.

We may disagree, but I certainly respect the fact that kaycee boldly proclaims his affiliation on a Catholic forum. When I post, you know my POV is a Catholic one; when kaycee posts, you know you’re getting a POV from the Reformed Baptist tradition. This helps those following the discussion understand the inherent worldview, theology, and consequent biases each of us brings to this discussion.

While not required, it is a helpful practice, I think.
 
I also want to give a shout out to kaycee, with whom I do not often agree, but who makes his Reformed Baptist background quite clear in his public profile, and also references it from time to time in posts.

We may disagree, but I certainly respect the fact that kaycee boldly proclaims his affiliation on a Catholic forum. When I post, you know my POV is a Catholic one; when kaycee posts, you know you’re getting a POV from the Reformed Baptist tradition. This helps those following the discussion understand the inherent worldview, theology, and consequent biases each of us brings to this discussion.

While not required, it is a helpful practice, I think.
I agree with you wholeheartedly, 100%. I am trying to learn the beliefs and differences of interpretation and understanding that are different from my own. It would be nice to know what Church affiliation’s teachings that I am learning. There are too many for me to learn and remember all from each Church, but I would like to gain a better understanding of the major ones.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top