Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Final installment re: 123’s third paragraph:

The information you are looking for is basically found in the Chatechism of the Catholic Church, the writings of the Early Church Fathers and the Holy Bible.

See if you can get a copy of the three volume set of The Faith of the Early Fathers by William A. Jergens. Otherwise, go to the home page of this web site, Catholic Answers and put ‘early church fathers’ into the search bar. Search other topics you are interested in. There is a wealth of information at your fingertips, right here.
Thank you again for your patience.
You’re welcome.

You know, if you just apply logic and reason to what you already know about Jesus and the Bible, you will learn a lot from yourself. Most of what Protestantism teaches is simply not reasonable.

Really, does it make sense that the Bible says God wishes all to come to knowledge of the truth and yet Jesus didn’t leave any means for us to know what that one truth fully is?

Does it make sense the Christ (who is God) would pray for unity in the church yet make no provision for there to be a final authority figure to ensure that unity?

Does it make sense that the Bible is the sole rule of faith when it says that the written record doesn’t even begin to cover all the teachings christ delivered?

Does it make sense that we have assurance of salvation by faith alone when the Bible speaks volumns on hope and says that the greatest of these, faith, hope and love, is love? Wouldn’t you logically think that if faith alone is all we need for salvation, that the greatest of the three would be faith?

Does it make sense that Christ said he would BUILD His church if he really meant that He would gather his assembly of people? The word build, implies…building something, doesn’t it? Something one can see. Like a city on a hill or a net holding both good and bad fish. Both of these are analogies that the Bible uses for the Church.

Anyway,

God Bless you in your struggles. Keep searching. I’m sure you’ll find your way home eventually. I’ll be praying for you to.
 
Thanks for that, MIZER; however, you’re not responding to the questions in my posts.
Sorry about that Sandusky. I think I got you mixed up with another poster. :confused: 😃
 
40.png
guanophore:
How can Catholics “reject” something that never existed?
Prior to the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would ever be written was written, so I find your statement specious.
40.png
guanophore:
The Full Deposit of Faith was complete and entire with the Apostles prior to a word of it was ever written.
Only for those who heard it from the apostles; by the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would be written was written.
40.png
guanophore:
Jesus gave His authority to His Apostles, and they passed it on to their successors, the bishops. The Bible was never “the sole rule of faith and practice”.
I reject that, however, that’s a different topic that, in my experience, goes nowhere.
40.png
guanophore:
On the contrary, the sole rule of faith and practice has always been the Teaching of the Apostles.
Correct.
40.png
guanophore:
The Catholics preserved and cared for the manuscripts because they were written by, for, and about Catholics!
They did preserve the manuscripts, and for that I’m grateful to the Lord for using them to do so.
 
It appears to be a “tradition” that is much older than the 16th century.
It is amazing to me that you read this and apparently see only the parts that support your theory. Let’s look at some of the other passages that you seem to skip…
St. Cyril

This seal have thou ever on thy mind; which now by way of summary has been touched on in its heads, and if the Lord grant, shall hereafter be set forth according to our power, with Scripture-proofs. For concerning the divine and sacred Mysteries of the Faith, we ought not to deliver even the most casual remark without the Holy Scriptures: nor be drawn aside by mere probabilities and the artifices of argument. **Do not then believe me because I tell thee these things, unless thou receive from the Holy Scriptures the proof of what is set forth: for this salvation, which is of our faith, is not by ingenious reasonings, but by proof from the Holy Scriptures **(A Library of the Fathers of the Holy Catholic Church (Oxford: Parker, 1845), The Catechetical Lectures of S. Cyril 4.17).
St. Cyril clearly is speaking of the Divine Mysteries which have been delivered. Of course they are all supported by the Scripture, since they both came from the same Source!
St. CyrilBut take thou and hold that faith only as a learner and in profession, which is by the Church delivered to thee, and is established from all Scripture. For since all cannot read the Scripture, but some as being unlearned, others by business, are hindered from the knowledge of them; in order that the soul may not perish for lack of instruction, in the Articles which are few we comprehend the whole doctrine of Faith…And for the present, commit to memory the Faith, merely listening to the words; and expect at the fitting season the proof of each of its parts from the Divine Scriptures.
The faith has always been, and is still, delivered by the Church. The Church was established by Christ, and Scripture reflects this establishment. The Church was formed before the NT was written, and the Church was not deficient. The Church then documented the Teachings (to some extent) in the NT. The Church did not then become deficient afterward.
St. CyrilFor the Articles of the Faith were not composed at the good pleasure of men: but the most important points chosen from all Scriptures, make up the one teaching of the Faith. And, as the mustard seed in a little grain contains many branches, thus also this Faith, in a few words, hath enfolded in its bosom the whole knowledge of godliness contained both in the Old and New Testaments. Behold, therefore, brethren and hold the traditions which ye now receive, and write them on the table of your hearts (Ibid., Lecture 5.12).
And, who decides what are “the most important points”? Is it not clear that every sect thinks differently about what these are? And here at the last, hold the traditions which you now receive". How is it that the reformers decided to disobey this part, but keep the rest?
 
The pages of a book are inanimate; how is it you think that inanimate pages can judge?
There are different circumstances one encounters in which scripture is used. For instance, in study group, the one leading the group would be offering his teaching, or, in a counseling setting, the counselor would be interpreting and applying the lessons of scripture to the situation of the counselee, or, in a home setting, the husband would be doing the interpreting.

The individual, local church.
It is this perspective that results in the vast divergence of faith and practice. Jesus gave the Authority to Teach and interpret to His Apostles. When people depart from that, there is error, heresy, confusion, and all manner of division.
The Bible is the sole rule of faith.
And it does not bother you that the Scripture itself says the opposite?

Matt 18:17-19
17 If the member refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if the offender refuses to listen even to the church, let such a one be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. 18 Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.

Jesus never directs them to resolve differences by “looking it up”.🤷
Misinterpretations don’t teach—men do.
So, we agree that men teach, and not the writing. This is why we say that Scripture is not infallible. Fallibility requires action, and the written word does not act, of itself.

God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us through the teaching body he established on Earth, that is through the magesterium of HIS One True Church.
That is the position of Rome.
That is true, but that is also a small matter, since it is also the position of all the Apostolic Churches, even those that are not presently in communion with Rome. This is the Teaching that was received from the Apostles, long before the See of Rome took precedence.
My faith is in Christ, and He certainly is not the wrong individual in which to have faith; correct?
Certainly not! The problem is that you reject the Authority that He appointed, so that you are in danger of rejecting HIm.

16 “Whoever listens to you listens to me, and whoever rejects you rejects me, and whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me.” Luke 10:16
 
40.png
guanophore:
It is this perspective that results in the vast divergence of faith and practice. Jesus gave the Authority to Teach and interpret to His Apostles. When people depart from that, there is error, heresy, confusion, and all manner of division.
His apostles are dead, and they’ve been in the grave for quite some time, and the office of apostle ended at that time.
40.png
guanophore:
And it does not bother you that the Scripture itself says the opposite?
Actually, I find that it’s the Catholic who denigrates scripture rather than scripture denigrating itself.
40.png
guanophore:
God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us through the teaching body he established on Earth, that is through the magesterium of HIS One True Church.
That is the position of Rome.
40.png
guanophore:
That is true, but that is also a small matter, since it is also the position of all the Apostolic Churches, even those that are not presently in communion with Rome. This is the Teaching that was received from the Apostles, long before the See of Rome took precedence.
I have all of the teachings of the apostles in the form of the New Testament.

As Augustine stated: Christ gave the believer the scriptures to confirm his heart from them, and that Christ directed the writing of the scripture so that the believer would have them to read.
40.png
guanophore:
Certainly not! The problem is that you reject the Authority that He appointed, so that you are in danger of rejecting HIm.
I follow the teachings of Christ, and His apostles through His written word which, according to Augustine, Christ commissioned His apostles to write so that I would have them to read.
 
I raise the issue as these are Catholics who “interpret” Church teachings and arrive at their conclusions. I assume that upon reading about sedevacantists that you’ll disagree with them; therefore, I would like you to explain to me why their interpretations and conclusions are wrong, while yours, you will probably claim, are the correct interpretations and conclusions.
No, sandy, they are not Catholic. They are schismatics. Catholics are in unity with the successor of Peter.
Code:
  The information that you’re putting forth from your interpretation of Scripture?
I am glad we can agree that everyone does interpret scripture, whether they believe they are, or not. 👍
If you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret the scriptures, how do you know that what you are being taught is true?
We do what the church has always done. We compare what we are taught with the Divine Deposit of Faith that was once and for all delivered to the saints.
But if you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret the scriptures how do you know your interpretation is correct let alone that the interpretation of the Church is correct?
We know that the Church is correct because we believe in the Lord Jesus, and His precious promises. He promised that He would remain with the Church until the end of the age, and that the gates of hell will not prevail. Once one begins believing and teaching error, one passes through the gates of hell, would you not agree?
You seem to be claiming to be able to distinguish a difference between my interpretation and the church’s interpretation, but how do you discern which is true, and which is false if you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret the scripture?
That is the purpose and benefit of Sacred Tradition. We use the interpretation that was passed on to us by the Apostles.
 
Prior to the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would ever be written was written, so I find your statement specious.
I did not mean to imply that scripture did not exist, or is not essential. The Holy Writings were never meant to be separated from the Sacred Tradition that produced them.
Only for those who heard it from the apostles; by the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would be written was written.
And where in that Holy Writ does it state that the complete gospel of grace is not found in the Church that produced the Scripture?
I reject that, however, that’s a different topic that, in my experience, goes nowhere.
You reject the notion that the Scripture was NEVER the lose source of faith and moral teaching?

If one is acquainted with history, I would think it is constantly a “road to nowwhere” one rejects the apostolic succession. 🤷
 
Thanks again Teflon, for your thoroughness,

This quote from the Early Father is key. It illustrates the early teaching that would become the Churches definition for salvation by faith, faith being defined as our human response to God’s Grace and not defined as faith alone.

Chrysostom (fl 386-407):

God’s mission was not to save people in order that they remain barren or inert. For Scripture says that faith has saved us. Put better: Since God willed it, faith has saved us. Now in what case, tell me, does faith save without itself doing anything at all? Faith’s workings themselves are a gift of God, lest anyone should boast. What then is Paul saying? Not that God has forbidden works but that he has forbidden us to be justified by works. No one, Paul says, is justified by works, precisely in order that the grace and benevolence of God may become apparent! “Homily on Ephesians 4.2.9”

He does not say “so that we might begin” but “so that we should walk”—all the way.** For walking is a metaphor that suggests continuance, extending to the end of our lives. **Suppose we had to walk a road that leads to a royal city, but after having gone almost all the way we grow faint almost at the end and stop. We would then have no profit. Instead, Paul says we are created “for good works”. “Homily on Ephesians 4.2.9”

I was looking back at the beginning of this thread and as is often the case when we converse with non-C’s the subject centered on the faith alone vs. not by faith alone debate. Non-C’s often insist that the Catholic faith is a “works righteous” religion. They insist that we believe we are saved by works as opposed to faith. Why is that?

Why won’t any of the Non-C’s on this thread comment on what you have given us on this subject both from Scripture and ECF’s?

It seems they miss the fact that the disagreement is not in faith alone vs. works alone but rather the definition of the word faith. They believe that faith alone saves and then works proceed from that salvation. That’s my understanding anyway. In their world, however, sin has no place. If one sins, well then he didn’t have the right kind of faith and/or he wasn’t saved in the first place. This is not Biblical.

The Church has defined faith to mean our human response to the free gift of Grace and it is similar to love in that it includes our actions. Love is not affection alone and faith is not belief alone.

On this thread, St. Paul was said to be teaching faith alone. This is not true. Nowhere does Paul use the word alone, following the word faith. In fact his teaching very clearly stresses that salvific faith is faith acting in love. So how is it that Non-C’s don’t see the truth of the Church’s teaching on this?
 
This quote from the Early Father is key. It illustrates the early teaching that would become the Churches definition for salvation by faith, faith being defined as our human response to God’s Grace and not defined as faith alone.
Indeed, we see that the ECFs, unlike Protestants, did not see a conflict between James and Paul on the subject of works. The Church teaches based on Scripture and Tradition that salvation begins with the grace of God guiding the head of the household to baptize it, resulting in God’s justifying grace and the removal of original sin. God continues to grant sanctifying grace to protect us in this new creation, as we do the good works for which we were created and receive in turn still more sanctifying grace. Thus, in Catholic teaching, justification is an event and sanctification a process, ending in salvation. Where the fundamentalists get tripped up is in the justification = salvation error—many of the distortions of fundamentalism result from trying to reconcile the missing piece of sanctification. Since they lack the sacraments for this, they recreate them in poor fashion with things like the Sinner’s Prayer, altar calls, new laws against alcohol and dancing, and the like; all man-made and all terribly ineffective. Moreover, as we have seen, they distort Scripture to try to claim support for such things, and ignore Scripture even where it plainly contradicts their practices.
They insist that we believe we are saved by works as opposed to faith. Why is that?
They simply regurgitate the errors the Reformers used to justify their original sin of disobedience. They can look up what Catholics believe in the Catechism, like everybody else. It teaches no such thing, nor does the Church. Salvation = justifying grace + faith + sanctifying grace + works. There are simply too many Scripture references attesting to the importance of what the faithful do for salvation. Indeed, when Christ talks of judgment in the parable of the sheep and goats, he clearly indicates that what separates the saved from the damned is what they did, not what they believed. Given Christ’s praise of the Good Samaritan and other non-believers this should come as no surprise. What we do matters to God—there’s no way around it.
After all, if it didn’t, there would be no salvation. Salvation benefits us, not God.
Why won’t any of the Non-C’s on this thread comment on what you have given us on this subject both from Scripture and ECF’s?
I had expected some to forward the false claim of the “works salvation”. Perhaps they’ve come to realize that Catholics agree with everything the ECFs have said on the subject. We do not believe that one can be saved by doing good works without faith and without God’s grace; indeed, what is good within us is God, what gives us faith is God, and what good works we do our God’s. That said, merely saying “Christ is Lord” is not enough—we must obey the Lord. Luke 6:46 - Why do you call me Lord, Lord, but do not do as I say?

Faith is obedience, not belief.
It seems they miss the fact that the disagreement is not in faith alone vs. works alone but rather the definition of the word faith. They believe that faith alone saves and then works proceed from that salvation. That’s my understanding anyway. In their world, however, sin has no place. If one sins, well then he didn’t have the right kind of faith and/or he wasn’t saved in the first place. This is not Biblical.
Of course not—among other things, one must ask why the epistles needed to be written at all if OSAS. If the Corinthians could never fall, clearly they were in no danger, even having a fornicator amongst them. So why did St Paul write?
The Church has defined faith to mean our human response to the free gift of Grace and it is similar to love in that it includes our actions. Love is not affection alone and faith is not belief alone.
On this thread, St. Paul was said to be teaching faith alone. This is not true. Nowhere does Paul use the word alone, following the word faith. In fact his teaching very clearly stresses that salvific faith is faith acting in love. So how is it that Non-C’s don’t see the truth of the Church’s teaching on this?
Indeed, I have posted St Paul’s clear Eucharistic teaching from 1 Corinthians 11 previously, to deafening silence. I can only presume that non-Catholics do not read the full epistles, even St Paul’s. They certainly tend to quote from the introductions in verse fragments more than from the whole passages.

It’s classic cherrypicking, in my opinion—they start with the doctrine they wish to believe, then strive to assemble as many verse fragments as possible in “support” of their doctrine. The Word of Faith movement is rather notorious for this.
 
Mizer,

Beautifully said but I would disagree with one statement, we were NOT Literally FORCED to learn the Baltimore Catechism. We were taught it and memorization was a big part of learning in all subjects then. We had to memorize the Gettisburg Address and many poems and other things, the kids today don’t even know what they are. I can still after 60+ years recite several verses of Hiawatha as well as all the states and capitols. My grandkids are amazed because I can answer many of their questions easily. Learning is NOT what it used to be in so many ways. My grandkids “learn” the states and capitols long enough to pass a test, then 2 weeks later they can’t remember them. Whats wrong???
 
Sandusky posted:
His apostles are dead, and they’ve been in the grave for quite some time, and the office of apostle ended at that time.
Can you quote the Scripture verse that tells us, the office the Apostles held during their lives, would cease to exist upon thier deaths?

Why did the Apostles replace Judas with the words, “let another take his office.” in the book of Acts, if what you say is true? How would the one truth of the Gospel be spread throughout the world for the next two thousand years without this safeguard?

You state that the Bible is the sole rule of faith, but you cannot account for the thousands of opposing interpreations. You can’t give us any explanation about how people might have learned the revelation of Christ for most of Christian history. The printing press wasn’t invented until the 16th century and even then a Guttenberg printed Bible cost something like three years wages. Illiteracy was rampant and is still a hinderance to education today in the modern world.

The truth is people learn the faith through the spoken word. Even today, outside Catholicism, evangelists tell people what to believe and then they show the new convert what they think is support for the belief in the Bible. When a new convert (to Protestantism/fundamentalism) has a question about a certain point of faith, he will go to another believer and say something like, “where do we find this or that belief in the Bible?” The new convert rarely sits with his own Bible studying away to find the revelation that there in plain language is the support for what he was taught to believe. That is impossible, as much of what non-C’s believe is not directly stated in the Bible. One must use creative interpretation to find most of it. “Faith alone”, “bible alone”, “private interpretation”, “the local independant church,” “the altar call,” “personal savior,” the sacraments are merely symbolic," “the office held by the Apostles either never existed or ceased to exist,” “no God given church authority,” none of these beliefs are found, spelled out in the Bible.

Outside the Tradition in which it was written, the Bible can be used to support just about anything. Abortion, homosexuality, ploygamy, unconditonal war, Baptising the dead, you name it, people use the Bible to support it.

You my dear, seperated sister (brother?) are deeply in denial of reality. Where does that come from? Why do you choose to stay in this state? Is there anything we can say or show you from scripture that might help you move from this state? Have you any desire to see reality as it exists in Christendom?

Or, are you as those who Fulten Sheen spoke of and someone on the board has the quote at the end of thier posts, something like, “some will reject even knowledge of Christ if that knowledge comes from Catholicism.” That’s not exact, but it’s the idea. Is that you, Sandusky? Do you blindly oppose anything Catholic on the basis that it is Catholic?
 
His apostles are dead, and they’ve been in the grave for quite some time, and the office of apostle ended at that time.
Yes, we are in agreement on this point. What you appear to reject is that the Apostles did have successors. The Apostles appointed faithful men, who were able to teach others also. This is how the Teaching Authority established by Christ was passed to successors. In the ECF’s,a s well as the NT, it is clear that these persons are bishops. It is the first care of the bishop to preserve the Divine Deposit of faith.
Actually, I find that it’s the Catholic who denigrates scripture rather than scripture denigrating itself.
Well, neither of these is the case. A Catholic knows that ignorance of Scripture is ignorance of Christ, and will value to Holy Writings as the Word of God. Misuse of the scripture by making it into something it is not (sole rule) is denigrating.
That is the position of Rome.
It is the position of Rome because it is Apostolic teaching. It is also the Teaching of all the Churches that received Apostolic Teaching, including those who are not in communion with Rome. How do you accout for that?
I have all of the teachings of the apostles in the form of the New Testament.
Even though the NT itself denies this idea? I think such a narrowing is essential, so that the Apostolic authority can be rejected.
As Augustine stated: Christ gave the believer the scriptures to confirm his heart from them, and that Christ directed the writing of the scripture so that the believer would have them to read.
Amen! But, Augustine would never dream of separating the Sacred Writings from the Sacred Tradition that produced them.🤷
I follow the teachings of Christ, and His apostles through His written word which, according to Augustine, Christ commissioned His apostles to write so that I would have them to read.
Yes, and I believe you, and the vast majority of “bible christians” do the best you can with what you have got, and I commend you for that.👍
 
Sandusky, amazingly, posted this:
Actually, I find that it’s the Catholic who denigrates scripture rather than scripture denigrating itself.
Is this just a senseless attack on Catholics or can you offer some evidence for believing this?

Did someone suggest that Scripture denigrates itself?

Are you digressing as is common when non-C’s can’t reasonably support their position?

Have you ever been to a Catholic Mass? Catholics venerate the Holy Bible. That’s the opposite of denigrate, in case you don’t realize.

A careful comparison of our interpretations would show that the Catholic interpretation, more often then not, allows the words to simply mean what they say while the protestant interpretation tortures the words into meaning something else entirely.

For example,

“I am the bread of life.” Unless you eat this bread you have no life in you." Catholics believe Jesus meant exactly what he said. Non-C’s do not. For you, bread is a metaphor for the message of the Gospel. Or, not, depending on your flavor of faith.

Jesus, speaking to Simon/Peter, “…and on this rock I will build my church.” Catholics say Jesus meant what he said. That he would build a church (in every sense of the word) and that Peter was the rock, the foundation. Non-C’s say Jesus meant something else. Anything else, but not what he plainly said. And if they do believe Peter was the foundation then they don’t believe Christ built a church in the clearest sense of the word or they don’t believe Peter had any authority (ignoring the keys) or if they believe peter had authority they don’t beleive that authority was passed on following his death. They make the passage surrounding this verse, senseless.

How about James 2:24 “…and not by faith alone.” Again, Catholics believe the verse means, “and not by faith alone.” Non-C’s think it means something else.

“…no prophecy of scripture is of any private interpretation.”

“…hear the church.”

“Baptism which saves you now.”

“The household of God, (the ONE church), the pillar and foundation of truth.”

I could go on all day, filling pages with verses that non-C’s torture to mean what they want (need) them to mean and which the Catholic Church teaches, mean simply what they say.

How is it denegrating Scripture to simply believe what it very plainly says?

Do you have any evidence at all, that what you said to guanophor is true?
 
His apostles are dead, and they’ve been in the grave for quite some time, and the office of apostle ended at that time.
Yes, we are in agreement on this point. What you appear to reject is that the Apostles did have successors. The Apostles appointed faithful men, who were able to teach others also. This is how the Teaching Authority established by Christ was passed to successors. In the ECF’s,a s well as the NT, it is clear that these persons are bishops. It is the first care of the bishop to preserve the Divine Deposit of faith.
Actually, I find that it’s the Catholic who denigrates scripture rather than scripture denigrating itself.
Well, neither of these is the case. A Catholic knows that ignorance of Scripture is ignorance of Christ, and will value to Holy Writings as the Word of God. Misuse of the scripture by making it into something it is not (sole rule) is denigrating.
That is the position of Rome.
It is the position of Rome because it is Apostolic teaching. It is also the Teaching of all the Churches that received Apostolic Teaching, including those who are not in communion with Rome. How do you accout for that?
I have all of the teachings of the apostles in the form of the New Testament.
Even though the NT itself denies this idea? I think such a narrowing is essential, so that the Apostolic authority can be rejected.
As Augustine stated: Christ gave the believer the scriptures to confirm his heart from them, and that Christ directed the writing of the scripture so that the believer would have them to read.
Amen! But, Augustine would never dream of separating the Sacred Writings from the Sacred Tradition that produced them.🤷
I follow the teachings of Christ, and His apostles through His written word which, according to Augustine, Christ commissioned His apostles to write so that I would have them to read.
Yes, and I believe you, and the vast majority of “bible christians” do the best you can with what you have got, and I commend you for that.👍
 
Thank you Teflon for this very concise gem. Is this straight from the ccc or have you put it so beautifully in a nutshell?
Thus, in Catholic teaching, justification is an event and sanctification a process, ending in salvation.
I don’t recall ever seeing this so concise followed by the revelation that non-C’s are missing the sanctification part of the equation. I will use this to teach other’s. This is perfect.

Is it correct then to say, charity in action (works) = sanctification?

So when non-C’s say the catholic church teaches faith (alone) + works, denying that works is an integral part of faith, we can say, no, faith (justification) + sanctification is the catholic teaching?
 
Memaw posted:
Beautifully said but I would disagree with one statement, we were NOT Literally FORCED to learn the Baltimore Catechism. We were taught it and memorization was a big part of learning in all subjects then. We had to memorize the Gettisburg Address and many poems and other things, the kids today don’t even know what they are. I can still after 60+ years recite several verses of Hiawatha as well as all the states and capitols. My grandkids are amazed because I can answer many of their questions easily. Learning is NOT what it used to be in so many ways. My grandkids “learn” the states and capitols long enough to pass a test, then 2 weeks later they can’t remember them. Whats wrong???
I may have choosen my words poorly. I meant that memorization is a way of forcing the brain to learn and remember the material. You are absolutely right about modern day educational practices. They are not very effective. I worry for my Grandkids (not born yet). I don’t know how they will learn anything. What’s wrong is we have abandoned the best the past had to offer in favor of what’s new, what’s different. Look at our advertising today and the products advertised. The best example of my point is Jiff crunchy peanut butter. It was the absolutely best peanut butter on the market. You can’t even get it now. They don’t make it anymore. Now all you can buy is extra crunchy and it won’t even spread without tearing up the bread. They couldn’t leave a perfect product alone and just sell that. They had to make it “different” and supposedly “better.” Now we don’t have a decent crunchy peanut butter. What a loss.
 
Thank you Teflon for this very concise gem. Is this straight from the ccc or have you put it so beautifully in a nutshell?

I don’t recall ever seeing this so concise followed by the revelation that non-C’s are missing the sanctification part of the equation. I will use this to teach other’s. This is perfect.

Is it correct then to say, charity in action (works) = sanctification?

So when non-C’s say the catholic church teaches faith (alone) + works, denying that works is an integral part of faith, we can say, no, faith (justification) + sanctification is the catholic teaching?
Great question, here’s the CCC:
2017 The grace of the Holy Spirit confers upon us the righteousness of God. Uniting us by faith and Baptism to the Passion and Resurrection of Christ, the Spirit makes us sharers in his life.
2018 Like conversion, justification has two aspects. Moved by grace, man turns toward God and away from sin, and so accepts forgiveness and righteousness from on high.
2019 Justification includes the remission of sins, sanctification, and the renewal of the inner man.
2020 Justification has been merited for us by the Passion of Christ. It is granted us through Baptism. It conforms us to the righteousness of God, who justifies us. It has for its goal the glory of God and of Christ, and the gift of eternal life. It is the most excellent work of God’s mercy.
2021 Grace is the help God gives us to respond to our vocation of becoming his adopted sons. It introduces us into the intimacy of the Trinitarian life.
2022 The divine initiative in the work of grace precedes, prepares, and elicits the free response of man. Grace responds to the deepest yearnings of human freedom, calls freedom to cooperate with it, and perfects freedom.
2023 Sanctifying grace is the gratuitous gift of his life that God makes to us; it is infused by the Holy Spirit into the soul to heal it of sin and to sanctify it.
2024 Sanctifying grace makes us “pleasing to God.” Charisms, special graces of the Holy Spirit, are oriented to sanctifying grace and are intended for the common good of the Church. God also acts through many actual graces, to be distinguished from habitual grace which is permanent in us.
2025 We can have merit in God’s sight only because of God’s free plan to associate man with the work of his grace. Merit is to be ascribed in the first place to the grace of God, and secondly to man’s collaboration. Man’s merit is due to God.
2026 The grace of the Holy Spirit can confer true merit on us, by virtue of our adoptive filiation, and in accordance with God’s gratuitous justice. Charity is the principal source of merit in us before God.
2027 No one can merit the initial grace which is at the origin of conversion. Moved by the Holy Spirit, we can merit for ourselves and for others all the graces needed to attain eternal life, as well as necessary temporal goods.
2028 “All Christians . . . are called to the fullness of Christian life and to the perfection of charity” (LG 40 § 2). “Christian perfection has but one limit, that of having none” (St. Gregory of Nyssa, De vita Mos.:PG 44, 300D).
2029 “If any man would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me” (Mt 16:24).
As I read it, justification makes us one of God’s sheep; sanctification is what helps us persevere throught the gate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top