Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
guanophor,

I will take a lesson from you in the kind maner you use on the forum. I tend to be abrasive and want to do better. I agree with your statement which follows in quote, although I’ll bet the non-c’s on the board would be surprised to know that because I haven’t yet developed the kind tone in writting that you have.
Yes, and I believe you, and the vast majority of “bible christians” do the best you can with what you have got, and I commend you for that.
Thanks for mentoring me.
 
40.png
MIZER:
Can you quote the Scripture verse that tells us, the office the Apostles held during their lives, would cease to exist upon thier deaths?
I don’t know that you’d be able to understand any explanation because you still haven’t answered my question as to the method you’ve employed to conclude that the CC is the true church because you’re not authorized to interpret scripture on your own.

How would you understand any scriptural interpretation I’d give?
 
40.png
guanophore:
No, sandy, they are not Catholic. They are schismatics.
They disagree with you.
40.png
guanophore:
We know that the Church is correct because we believe in the Lord Jesus, and His precious promises. He promised that He would remain with the Church until the end of the age, and that the gates of hell will not prevail. Once one begins believing and teaching error, one passes through the gates of hell, would you not agree?
That’s what you believe; that doesn’t explain how you know that what you believe is true.
40.png
guanophore:
That is the purpose and benefit of Sacred Tradition. We use the interpretation that was passed on to us by the Apostles.
What interpretations did the apostles pass on in Sacred Tradition?
40.png
guanophore:
The Holy Writings were never meant to be separated from the Sacred Tradition that produced them.
Then the two must be identical.
40.png
guanophore:
And where in that Holy Writ does it state that the complete gospel of grace is not found in the Church that produced the Scripture?
Explain how your statement has anything to do with my post that you cite?
40.png
guanophore:
You reject the notion that the Scripture was NEVER the sole source of faith and moral teaching?
Yes.
40.png
guanophore:
If one is acquainted with history, I would think it is constantly a “road to nowwhere” one rejects the apostolic succession.
I have no idea what you’re saying.
 
40.png
MIZER:
You state that the Bible is the sole rule of faith, but you cannot account for the thousands of opposing interpreations.
Opposing interpretations do not affect the doctrine of scripture as the sole rule of faith.

Even if billions of interpretations existed, the scripture is singular, and true.
40.png
MIZER:
The truth is people learn the faith through the spoken word. Even today, outside Catholicism, evangelists tell people what to believe and then they show the new convert what they think is support for the belief in the Bible. When a new convert (to Protestantism/fundamentalism) has a question about a certain point of faith, he will go to another believer and say something like, “where do we find this or that belief in the Bible?” The new convert rarely sits with his own Bible studying away to find the revelation that there in plain language is the support for what he was taught to believe. That is impossible, as much of what non-C’s believe is not directly stated in the Bible. One must use creative interpretation to find most of it. “Faith alone”, “bible alone”, “private interpretation”, “the local independant church,” “the altar call,” “personal savior,” the sacraments are merely symbolic," “the office held by the Apostles either never existed or ceased to exist,” “no God given church authority,” none of these beliefs are found, spelled out in the Bible.

Outside the Tradition in which it was written, the Bible can be used to support just about anything. Abortion, homosexuality, ploygamy, unconditonal war, Baptising the dead, you name it, people use the Bible to support it.
I believe that all of the examples you offer above are nothing more than fallacious special pleadings.

I could make the same arguments concerning new Catholic converts not reading their bible, and being told what to believe; I could argue that purgatory, the papacy, the Marian doctrines and others are not found in Scripture; I could argue that the CC’s atrocious use of the OT to validate some of its novel teachings about Mary demonstrate that anyone can make the bible say anything they want it to say.

While you unquestioningly accept the arguments you put forth concerning what I believe (and obviously, you do; otherwise, why would you make those arguments?), you would either reject those same arguments when applied to what you believe, or, you would attempt to make some kind of exception in the case of what you believe, thereby exempting your beliefs from the same standards you apply to mine.

So which is it for you when your arguments are applied to your beliefs?

Rejection of the arguments, or exemption from them?
 
Let me try to respond to some of these, my apologies for being away for a while.
The Bible is the sole rule of faith.
Actually, the Bible says that the Church is the Pillar and Foundation of Truth. Jesus, I would argue, stands at the center of all, and his Bride is the Church.
The sedevacantists claim you’re following a heretic. :hmmm:
IIRC, a heretic is one who teaches contrary to the Church. An apostate is one who leaves the Church and teaches/believes contrary to it’s teachings. So if these sedevacantists call themselves Catholic, then they are apostates, which is more serious than being a heretic.

In any event, why should we concern ourselves with their teachings?
That is the position of Rome.
Perhaps you should say the position of the Catholic Church. I realize that Protestants like to sling the term “Rome” around as a perjorative, but the Roman Rite of Catholicism is one of 23.
My faith is in Christ, and He certainly is not the wrong individual in which to have faith; correct?
Well said. Absolute right. So when Christ institutes his Church with Peter as it’s leader, we should take that pretty seriously.
(continued from post # 273)

Isn’t that your interpretation? What makes your interpretation the correct interpretation?

What method have you employed to arrive at your conclusion that you are in the one true Church?
Well, Apostolic succession for one, the fact that Christ founded the Church for another, gee, it’s amazing that non-Catholic Christians can believe that Christ saved the entire world with his sacrifice, but wasn’t able to put a church together that would last…
I raise the issue as these are Catholics who “interpret” Church teachings and arrive at their conclusions. I assume that upon reading about sedevacantists that you’ll disagree with them; therefore, I would like you to explain to me why their interpretations and conclusions are wrong, while yours, you will probably claim, are the correct interpretations and conclusions.

That is your opinion, based upon your interpretation of Scripture, and the other available data—that is the point you raised in your initial post to me: the validity of ones interpretation; isn’t it?

Why should I embrace your interpretation of Scripture over Hodge’s interpretation?

Again, why should I embrace your interpretation over Hodge’s?
See above. Apostates can lead you astray with blasphemy.
If you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret the scriptures, how do you know that what you are being taught is true?

Again, if you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret scripture, how do you know that what you are being taught is true?

But if you don’t have the authority to correctly interpret the scriptures how do you know your interpretation is correct let alone that the interpretation of the Church is correct?
We trust Jesus. See above.
Prior to the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would ever be written was written, so I find your statement specious.

Only for those who heard it from the apostles; by the end of the first century all of the inspired scripture that would be written was written.
Really? All scripture was written by the end of the first century?

Do you have some evidence of this? How then did it get disseminated to people, and how did they absorb it “to be saved” since the vast majority were illiterate?
 
They did preserve the manuscripts, and for that I’m grateful to the Lord for using them to do so.
But not grateful to them. Hmmmm…
His apostles are dead, and they’ve been in the grave for quite some time, and the office of apostle ended at that time.
You have some scriptural evidence that their office ended at their death?
That is the position of Rome.
See above comments about the relationship of “Rome” and the Catholic Church.
I have all of the teachings of the apostles in the form of the New Testament.
You have some of them. Wouldn’t it be nice to talk to them, or talk to their students? If you read some of the ECF’s, you can get even more information. But it doesn’t support your position…
I follow the teachings of Christ, and His apostles through His written word which, according to Augustine, Christ commissioned His apostles to write so that I would have them to read.
If you did, you would be Catholic, as Augustine was.
I had expected some to forward the false claim of the “works salvation”. Perhaps they’ve come to realize that Catholics agree with everything the ECFs have said on the subject. We do not believe that one can be saved by doing good works without faith and without God’s grace; indeed, what is good within us is God, what gives us faith is God, and what good works we do our God’s. That said, merely saying “Christ is Lord” is not enough—we must obey the Lord. Luke 6:46 - Why do you call me Lord, Lord, but do not do as I say?

Faith is obedience, not belief.

Indeed, I have posted St Paul’s clear Eucharistic teaching from 1 Corinthians 11 previously, to deafening silence. I can only presume that non-Catholics do not read the full epistles, even St Paul’s. They certainly tend to quote from the introductions in verse fragments more than from the whole passages.

It’s classic cherrypicking, in my opinion—they start with the doctrine they wish to believe, then strive to assemble as many verse fragments as possible in “support” of their doctrine. The Word of Faith movement is rather notorious for this.
Well said, thank you Teflon93!
Opposing interpretations do not affect the doctrine of scripture as the sole rule of faith.

Even if billions of interpretations existed, the scripture is singular, and true.
Oh please. All of the people who believe in such many opposing interpretations claim to be “guided by the Spirit” or “convicted by the Spirit”. Christ’s one true Church has had infallible dogma for 2000 years. Not thousands of conflicting beliefs.

That’s something that all these prancing preachers on stage can’t seem to ever grasp…
 
I asked Sandusky if he/she could quote me a scripture verse that tells us that the offices held by the Apostles ceased to exist upon their deaths and he/she answered with this:
I don’t know that you’d be able to understand any explanation because you still haven’t answered my question as to the method you’ve employed to conclude that the CC is the true church because you’re not authorized to interpret scripture on your own.
How would you understand any scriptural interpretation I’d give?
That’s a great big no, if I ever heard one.

Sandusky,

It has been explained over and over and over again how Catholics come to believe that the CC is the true church. We study. And we apply logic and reason to what we study. We study not only the Bible, but we study history and we study the writtings of the earliest christians. They are called the Early Fathers of the faith because they pioneered Christianity. Their writings paint a picture of the infant Catholic church. History paints a picture of the Catholic Church being the only christian church with any truth to it’s teachings, from the time of Christ to the present day and the Bible is a perfect rendition of every teaching to come out of the Catholic church (if it is taken as a whole and left to mean what it says).

You insult my intelligence with the last line of your post there. But that’s ok, I know you are to the point of grasping at straws so that’s ok. Rest assured, however, I am not a moron. I don’t have to have the God given authority to interpret Scripture which God gave to His Church, to be able to understand what I am reading, especially since I have done all of this study and have a pretty good grasp on what the Church teaches.

So if you give me the verse that tells us the offices of the Apostles became extinct upon their deaths, don’t worry, I’ll be able to figure it out. Won’t you please let me try? What’s the verse?
 
posted by sandusky:
Opposing interpretations do not affect the doctrine of scripture as the sole rule of faith.
Even if billions of interpretations existed, the scripture is singular, and true.
You are in error. Opposing interpretations telll us that the Bible can’t possibly be the sole rule of faith. You offer no evidence what so ever, for the claims you make. You just keep repeating yourself. If the Bible was the sole rule of faith it would, firstly, tell us so and secondly there would be no opposing interpretations as every sincere reader would come to the same conclusion as to it’s meaning.

The revelation found in the correct interpretation of Scripture is singular, the interpretations of the many opposing sects, however, are not.

Logic, sandusky. Reason. You will remain lost without these two.
 
Welcome Sodak,

This is a gallant effort, one I’ve already tried. Sandusky will not respond to this reasonable effort you make to shed some light on reality.
How then did it get disseminated to people, and how did they absorb it “to be saved” since the vast majority were illiterate?
 
.QUOTING Sandusky]

So which is it for you when your arguments are applied to your beliefs?

Rejection of the arguments, or exemption from them?..fbl9 says ask yourself the same question and we are all back to the same sides we are on.
 
40.png
sodak:
Actually, the Bible says that the Church is the Pillar and Foundation of Truth. Jesus, I would argue, stands at the center of all, and his Bride is the Church.
I responded to this in an earlier post.
40.png
sodak:
IIRC, a heretic is one who teaches contrary to the Church.
Begs the question: which church?

A heretic is one who teaches contrary to God’s word.
40.png
sodak:
An apostate is one who leaves the Church and teaches/believes contrary to it’s teachings.
That’s not how your catechism defines an apostate—better bone up on that.
40.png
sodak:
Well said. Absolute right. So when Christ institutes his Church with Peter as it’s leader, we should take that pretty seriously.
Begs the question: which church?
40.png
sodak:
Well, Apostolic succession for one, the fact that Christ founded the Church for another, gee, it’s amazing that non-Catholic Christians can believe that Christ saved the entire world with his sacrifice, but wasn’t able to put a church together that would last…
That’s a strawman; I’m a Christian, and I believe that Christ is building His Church.
40.png
sodak:
Really? All scripture was written by the end of the first century?
John was the last living apostle. Most date the writings of John’s Gospel between 80-90 A.D., and his epistles slightly later, and Revelation near the end of Domitian’s reign 81-96 A.D., though some date it during Nero’s reign some 40 years earlier; either way, all were finished by the end of the first century.
40.png
sodak:
How then did it get disseminated to people, and how did they absorb it “to be saved” since the vast majority were illiterate?
What was the percentage of illiteracy in the Early Church?
40.png
sodak:
You have some of them. Wouldn’t it be nice to talk to them, or talk to their students? If you read some of the ECF’s, you can get even more information. But it doesn’t support your position…
What do the ECF’s have to do with the writings of the Apostles?
40.png
sodak:
If you did, you would be Catholic, as Augustine was.
That doesn’t fit logically, and my not being a Catholic proves that.
40.png
sodak:
Oh please. All of the people who believe in such many opposing interpretations claim to be “guided by the Spirit” or “convicted by the Spirit”. Christ’s one true Church has had infallible dogma for 2000 years. Not thousands of conflicting beliefs.
How do you know that the RCC is the one true church? What method have you employed to arrive at that conclusion?
 
40.png
MIZER:
It has been explained over and over and over again how Catholics come to believe that the CC is the true church. We study. And we apply logic and reason to what we study. We study not only the Bible, but we study history and we study the writtings of the earliest christians. They are called the Early Fathers of the faith because they pioneered Christianity. Their writings paint a picture of the infant Catholic church. History paints a picture of the Catholic Church being the only christian church with any truth to it’s teachings, from the time of Christ to the present day and the Bible is a perfect rendition of every teaching to come out of the Catholic church (if it is taken as a whole and left to mean what it says).
Well, there are many who disagree with the conclusions you’ve reached on the basis of your private interpretation.

Which brings us back to the my question to you: why should I abandon my interpretation, and the interpretation of other learned Protestants, both learned laymen, and eminent theologians and scholars and accept your private interpretation, MIZER?
40.png
MIZER:
You insult my intelligence with the last line of your post there.
I’m sorry you feel that way.
40.png
MIZER:
But that’s ok, I know you are to the point of grasping at straws so that’s ok.
How is my insisting that you tell me how it is you arrived at the conclusion that RCC is the one true church “grasping at straws?”
40.png
MIZER:
I don’t have to have the God given authority to interpret Scripture

which God gave to His Church, to be able to understand what I am reading, especially since I have done all of this study and have a pretty good grasp on what the Church teaches.
At last we arrive at the truth!

Neither do I need your church’s alleged God-given authority to interpret and understand what the scriptures say.
 
Welcome Sodak,

This is a gallant effort, one I’ve already tried. Sandusky will not respond to this reasonable effort you make to shed some light on reality.
Thanks Mizer,

I thought I’d try and get one off before I go to bed! At least people that come later and read this thread can hopefully glean from it.
 
posted by sandusky:

Opposing interpretations do not affect the doctrine of scripture as the sole rule of faith.

Even if billions of interpretations existed, the scripture is singular, and true.

sandusky,
I am really having a difficult time understanding how you could possibly believe that opposing interpretations (35,000-40,000 opposing interpretations.) won’t affect doctrine. It has and drastically so. Protestantism affected doctrine from the get go. 500 years of continual splintering has changed the beliefs so much, that there is nothing really recognizable about the liturgy or much else anymore. Opposing interpretations is plural, not singular. I just don’t see where there is ONE singular scripture in Protestantism. It really appears that you are so steeped in your own Church’s teachings and traditions, that you can’t let yourself be open to the Truth as it has been since Peter and the Apostles. Can’t you try to consider that our teachings are the SAME teachings now as they were 2,000 years ago. Protestantism is only 500 years old. Before Protestantism, and post Apostles, there have been 1400 years of Church interpretation, tradition, practice and STUDY. It has never changed. It is Protestantism that ushered in the changes and that has changed.
 
I responded to this in an earlier post.
Too bad, I’m responding to your direct post.
Begs the question: which church?
It’s a Catholic forum. What do you think? I suspect the question is rhetorical, but it’s the one true Church that Jesus founded, not a heretical one founded later.
A heretic is one who teaches contrary to God’s word.
Wrong.
That’s not how your catechism defines an apostate—better bone up on that.
Really? Do you have a reference? I was thinking of Hebrews Chapter 6, but perhaps you could direct me to the appropriate part of the Catechism.
Begs the question: which church?
No question at all, it’s all over the New Testament.
That’s a strawman; I’m a Christian, and I believe that Christ is building His Church.
It’s no strawman at all if you believe the Bible.
John was the last living apostle. Most date the writings of John’s Gospel between 80-90 A.D., and his epistles slightly later, and Revelation near the end of Domitian’s reign 81-96 A.D., though some date it during Nero’s reign some 40 years earlier; either way, all were finished by the end of the first century.
References?
What was the percentage of illiteracy in the Early Church?
Not just the Church, but the general population. Very high, I would suppose, just like in the Middle Ages.
What do the ECF’s have to do with the writings of the Apostles?
If one of the ECF’s was a student of the Apostles, then he probably could shed quite a bit of insight on some of their teachings, Church disciplines, etc. I would absolutely take their word over someone elses, say, 1600 years later.
How do you know that the RCC is the one true church? What method have you employed to arrive at that conclusion?
To quote you, I have already answered this in an earlier post! You are certainly entitled to your own opinion, but you are NOT entitled to your own facts!
 
Quote:
I don’t know that you’d be able to understand any explanation because you still haven’t answered my question as to the method you’ve employed to conclude that the CC is the true church because you’re not authorized to interpret scripture on your own.

How would you understand any scriptural interpretation I’d give?

What does this even mean? It really doesn’t make sense. We couldn’t possible understand Sandusky’s answer to our question because how did we conclude that the CC is the True Church since we can interpret scripture?

We don’t self interpret because it would take us exactly where Protestantism is - 35,000-40,000 different meanings and interpretations. There are a million meanings to reading black print on white paper. We have the ONE True meaning as it was given to us 2,000 years ago by Christ. He founded his Church for us to continue his teachings. He promised to guard and guide His Church, His Word and he has. It has never been changed under our care. We recorded his Words for you Sandusky. We taught them through oral and sacred tradition up to and even after the Reformation. Do you really think we don’t know what we are talking about? Your Church has REALLY covered the Truth up well. I know that is hard to hear, but OUR Truth was around long before your Church’s teachings.
 
Let’s see where personal interpretation gets us (stolen from Scott Hahn). Interpret this sentence.

I never said you took the money.

Do you know what I mean? Let’s see…

I never said you took the money. She did.
I never said you took the money. But I sure implied it!
I never said you took the money. I said Frank did.
I never said you took the money. Maybe you just borrowed it for a while… wink wink.
I never said you took the money. I said you took the car!

This is a simple sentence that has not been translated at all. You have NO way of knowing what I meant without context. And this is one sentence.

And people wonder why we need our Magesterium!
 
40.png
sodak:
References?
From the Catholic website New Advent:**After Domitian’s death the Apostle returned to Ephesus during the reign of Trajan, and at Ephesus he died about A.D. 100 at a great age.**He was the last of the apostles to die.

The writing of all of inspired scripture was finished prior to 100 A.D.
40.png
sodak:
Really? Do you have a reference? I was thinking of Hebrews Chapter 6, but perhaps you could direct me to the appropriate part of the Catechism.
From the CCC:2089 Incredulity is the neglect of revealed truth or the willful refusal to assent to it. “Heresy is the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same; apostasy is the total repudiation of the Christian faith; schism is the refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him.”
40.png
sodak:
Not just the Church, but the general population. Very high, I would suppose, just like in the Middle Ages.
References?

sodak said:
Let’s see where personal interpretation gets us (stolen from Scott Hahn). Interpret this sentence.

I never said you took the money.

Do you know what I mean? Let’s see…

I never said you took the money. She did.
I never said you took the money. But I sure implied it!
I never said you took the money. I said Frank did.
I never said you took the money. Maybe you just borrowed it for a while… wink wink.
I never said you took the money. I said you took the car!

This is a simple sentence that has not been translated at all. You have NO way of knowing what I meant without context. And this is one sentence.

And people wonder why we need our Magesterium!

**Let’s see where oral transmission of Tradition gets us:John 21:18-23

“Truly, truly, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to gird yourself and walk wherever you wished; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands and someone else will gird you, and bring you where you do not wish to go.”

19 Now this He said, signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God. And when He had spoken this, He said to him, “Follow Me!”

20 Peter, turning around, saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them; the one who also had leaned back on His bosom at the supper and said, “Lord, who is the one who betrays You?”

21 So Peter seeing him said to Jesus, “Lord, and what about this man?”

22 Jesus said to him, “If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? You follow Me!”

23 THEREFORE this saying went out among the brethren that that disciple WOULD NOT DIE;

YET

JESUS DID NOT SAY TO HIM THAT HE WOULD NOT DIE,

BUT ONLY, “If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?”**Things get lost, changed, and completely turned upside-down in oral transmission.

(Let’s all thank the Lord for that illustration in John 21.)

That’s why we need sola scriptura.
 
And things get lost and totally turned around in written transmission also. When you look at all the Protestant denominations, and their widely varying beliefs, reading from the same Bible, need I say more?

Are you really trying to argue that the majority of the population at 100 AD were literate and had Bibles? Are you also saying that as of 100 AD, all the Bibles were bound and ready for shipment to the general population?
 
Maybe I am naive but it seems the scribes in the times of Jesus adopted a philosophy of sola scriptura. It did not go over too well. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top