Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is nothing more than Sandusky projecting what he wishes were true onto our most holy faith.

“Our soteriology” is as New Testament as it will ever get, as I point out in my blog article, Who REALLY Preaches “A Different Gospel”?. The same cannot correctly be asserted about the modern post reformation “gospel”. (Depending, of course, on all of them ever starting to preach that same exact gospel. I don’t see it happening.)I can say the very same thing about you and the majority of n-Cs/a-C that I encounter. Yet I have my testimony and personal witness.Please get off that martyr bit. It just doesn’t wash. You have us all figured out. Too bad that it’s a completely fallacious reasoning.

The reason that I (in particular), reject your position is rational and many fold.

Essentially, it comes down to the fact that I went where you are and came back after having examined both the teachings of the n-C faith communities that I have been exposed to, the Word of God, and the actual teachings of the Catholic Church. This was brought about by an extremely anti-Catholic attack on Catholic belief. (see my testimony for details).

I did the “homework” and I am heart and soul convinced that the n-Cs have their gospel messed up, and that the Catholic Church really is the direct doctrinal descendant of the New Testament Christian Church.

I have never thought you are lying or any other weird stuff…just that you are dead wrong.
Thanks for your observations, Michael.
 
What is reformed teaching?

The only thing you guys seem to agree on is the catholic Church being wrong.
Generally refers to those churches that follow Calvinistic theology. They may not follow it precisely according to what Calvin taught (such as “Reformed Baptists”; Calvin taught infant baptism), but still adhere to Reformed distinctives, such as predestination, covenant theology, symbolic view of sacramentology, etc.
 
Generally refers to those churches that follow Calvinistic theology. They may not follow it precisely according to what Calvin taught (such as “Reformed Baptists”; Calvin taught infant baptism), but still adhere to Reformed distinctives, such as predestination, covenant theology, symbolic view of sacramentology, etc.
I’m afraid we have to ask for the specific meaning, given that a given group may reject or modify even the distinctives, correct?
 
This is Sandusky:
(BTW, my denomination does not condone homosexuality, and the only thing we can do about it, is what your church does about it, and that is call it what it is—sin.)
He’s either athiest, laughing his butt off as he runs us all over the place, back and forth, upside down, all around, or…, and this is, MO,… he’s an independant, fundamentalist, bible, baptist and there is maybe a dozen or so congregants and one pastor who are all very righteous and pure in his independant, fundamentalist, bible baptist church.

That’s my guess. Am I right Sandusky?
 
He’s either athiest, laughing his butt off as he runs us all over the place, back and forth, upside down, all around, or…, and this is, MO,… he’s an independant, fundamentalist, bible, baptist and there is maybe a dozen or so congregants and one pastor who are all very righteous and pure in his independant, fundamentalist, bible baptist church.

That’s my guess. Am I right Sandusky?
Not even close.

However, I’m curious how you arrived at that conclusion?
 
Not even close.

However, I’m curious how you arrived at that conclusion?
I would guess it was due to your comments on purity and separation and independence, which are typically the earmarks of the independent fundamentalist Baptist folks.
 
I would guess it was due to your comments on purity and separation and independence, which are typically the earmarks of the independent fundamentalist Baptist folks.
OK; I don’t have that perception of those terms.

I don’t recall saying anything about separation, at least it doesn’t sound familiar.
 
I’m afraid we have to ask for the specific meaning, given that a given group may reject or modify even the distinctives, correct?
Yes, absolutely. It’s never enough for someone to say “I am a Calvinist” or “I am Reformed” as that could mean Presbyterian, Dutch Reformed, Reformed Baptist, Reformed non-denominational, blah blah etc. To be historically accurate for the moment, only Presbyterian or Dutch Reformed would actually qualify as being true to the teachings of John Calvin.
 
The issue is not homosexuality; but the ensuing coverup by the leadership of your church.

Oh really, if it wasn’t for homosexuality, we wouldn’t have had this problem.

(BTW, my denomination does not condone homosexuality, and the only thing we can do about it, is what your church does about it, and that is call it what it is—sin.)
Well then, what are you doing about the same problems that occur in your denomination? And don’t try to tell me you don’t have any, its everywhere!!!
 
Hey Sandusky:
I don’t recall saying anything about separation, at least it doesn’t sound familiar.
I arrived at my conclusion exactly how Teflon said. Although you haven’t used the word “seperation” you have used independant and you are seperate. You deny being in any of the groups “listed” on the web site and you do sound like the IFBB churhc members sound. Very conservative in your views, ultral anti-catholic, independant, think you are being lead personally into the truth of the bible etc…

Why won’t you state your faith tradition. Whats the mystery all about? What are you, a Mason?
 
Lisdogan posted:
Are we likely to be heretics in my CC because we use the Good News and/or New Jerusalem Bibles?
What are ‘Catholic Bibles’ - perhaps you could point me in the right direction. And it would also help to know by which process the Vatican approves or disapproves any major biblical translation.
No, I don’t think you are heretics for using any particular translation of the Bible. Heresy arrises in the way it is interpreted. So if your CC parish is teaching interpretation that is in conflict with settled church teaching, then you have a problem.

I know the American Standard Version is approved, as is the Douey Reims. I often use a website that lines up every verse of the Bible in three colums juxtaposing the KJV, the douey Rheims and the Latin Vulgate. That’s interesting but otherwise I don’t know if the CC condems certain translations while approving others (other than the ones I’ve mentioned) or not. I would have to study this and frankly I’m not inclined to as I don’t see that it matters as I’m more interested in interpretation than translation.

If this is an area of interest for you I would suggest that you put “Bible translations” or something to that affect into the search bar on the home page of this website and start there.
 
Sandusky posted: You assume that I haven’t already done that.
I’ve done all of those things.
I have a sister who pointed out what you have.
After several years of discussion, a number of years ago, guess which church she and her family are no longer in?
I’m sorry Sandusky but I’m having a hard time swallowing this. You don’t appear to have studied the truth of Catholicism as you continue to post outrageous beliefs about it. I have no clue as to what your sister has pointed out to you or not. I would think if she has also left the the one true faith which is the only faith that follows the true teachings, as delivered by Christ and the Apostles and confirmed by the Early Fathers, then her faith is as lacking as yours is and she is not a good mentor for you. You will have to better. Your crediblity in this regard is dubious at best.
 
Lisdogan posted:
As a Catholic, I am aware that many within the Church do not like the idea of CC being a ‘denomination’. But for many others, the Church is the universal church of Christ, which incorporates all those who are of God, the Triune God of Christianity. There are (unfortunate) divisions within the universal church of Christ, many of them called (mainline) denominations, and the CC is one of them. It may be the oldest and the biggest, but it is a denomination, whether we like to call it that or not.
Lisdogan, you are simply incorrect in your understanding of the term “denomination” and how it may apply to the One True Church or not. ** It does not**.
The fact that Sandusky, a bitter ex-Catholic, an anti-Catholic, if you will, has “been saying that (what you are saying) for years” and the fact that he, a schismatic at best, will use what you are saying as part of his defense for having left The True Church and then actually expend energy and time in arguing against her, should give you a clue.
The word denomination is a word that distinguishes, “one from another.” The CC teaches what you are stating here that the “universal church” does, in one sense, include every christian body that adheres to faith in Christ as the messiah, the second person of the Holy Trinity, however, those who are not in communion with the Holy See, are in fact seperated (shcismatic, which is an offense against unity, which Christ and the Apostles taught against, and is of the Devil, according to Scripture and Church teaching) from the trunk of the faith (to use the anology of a tree), the root of Jesse, and it is simply incorrect to say that the trunk, the root, is a denomination.
We must use the term, denomination to designate those shcismatic assemblies that have, by thier own will, seperated from the One True Church. The Church is not a denomination as there is no need to designate her, she is simply The Church, the Bride of Christ.
Some Catholics do not like the idea of The Church being called a denomination because it is untrue and using this terminology in referrence to her feeds the monster (evil) of shcism.
This second part of your statement:
And perhaps it is useful to start thinking in terms of a universal church of Christ, as there are now more Muslims than Catholics globally. This will keep us focussed on the apostolic dimension of our Christian beliefs, rather than on our divisiveness. Christianity’s affirmations are better served in this way./
is moot because we already think in terms of a u(U)niversal
c(C)hurch of Christ, both in the sense that this body includes our seperated brothers and sisters (universal) and in the sense that the unified body which is in communion with the Holy See (Universal, the CC) is at the same time, both One, and Universal in nature.

I do not believe that ignoring that which divides us (heresy) within the body of Christ is affirming to our Christian beliefs as this is a rather luke warm way of looking at the whole picture and the Bible itself speaks against such impassionate thought. We are to have more zeal for what we believe as it is what The Church, commissioned by Christ himself, teaches. And we are called to spread that One True Gospel as Disciples of Christ, not passively accept that there are those within the universal body who wish to spread heresy and division within her (Sandusky).

Christ is One, the Holy Trinity is One, the faith (the Gospel) is One. That which divides us, inasmuch as those false teachings result in division of mind and spirit in the body of Christ are anti-Christ. That which is anti-Christ, does not affirm that which is of Christ.

Could you possibly re-think your position on this so you may correct others who are of your present, luke warm mindset and truely build up the body of Christ by affirming that which is true by affirming that Christ’s intention (His prayer for us) was that His Body, The, U(u)niversal Church, would be One in Mind and in Spirit?

Again, Christ did not establish denominations, He established a (One) Universal Church. By His design, (He is the Word, Creation itself), there should be no need to designate One, from another.
 
*Thread has been pruned.

Please remain on topic and cease speculating on irrelevancies such as any given member’s faith affiliation.

Further departure from topic will cause this thread to be closed.
MF*
 
Lisdogan, In the Love of Christ, I am really struggling with much of what you say:
These are really big generalisations! What is the evidence for this statement? If we fight with flarb instead of facts - not helpful.
Memaw, did not make “big generalizations.” She spoke the politcally incorrect truth, that is all.

I think yours is an attitude that is by definition luke warm, which serves to tear down, rather than build up, the body of Christ
. Gender confusion is one of the first signs that a scociety is going down hill. The practice of homosexuality is a grave sin and it’s proliferation in our scociety should be of great concern to us all as chrisitans. The evidence that many a non-C, “christian” church is embracing it by calling it a lifestyle choice, something to be tollerated, rather than the sin (evil) that it is, is all around us. Pick up a newpaper, watch the news, pay attention to christian (in general and Catholic in particular) broadcasts and print media. If you are informed, I don’t know how you can call what Memaw said a big generalization. What is your evidence for that?
 
Now Sandusky I’ve had just about enough out of you youngman (oldman?):
I’ve said all that I have say on the subject, Teflon—move on.
Do as MIZER did earlier on the thread, and claim complete and total victory for yourself.
I won’t say anything; I’ll let your Sour Grapes do the talking.
We will move on when we are ready to move on. You are not the boss of us or of this thread. Get over yourself. If you have nothing more to say on an issue then keep your own sour grapes to yourself. Thank you, that is all.😉
 
Sandusky:
You’re not the first to ask this question of me, or, to ask this question of other ex-catholics on this forum.
I told you why I left the church—I was neither saved, nor regenerated while in the CC,
This by the force of your own rebellious will.
but you are unable to accept that,
I am perfectly able to accept that this is what you believe. Denial is a powerful internal force.
because, if you do, your soteriology crumbles, and everything else with it.
Not at all.
I have yet to meet a Catholic who will accept my true reason for my leaving their precious church.
The church is precious. And I do believe you. You raise the confusion yourself by what you say. Every true believer knows it is unreasonable to say that one is not “regenerated in the truth of Catholicism” because it is the denial of that truth, in the Eucharist for example, which would contribute to ones feeling of hopelessness and loss. You never availed yourself of the true teachings (evidenced by much of what you say about Catholicism here), choosing to lead with behavior (that behavior would include, but is not limited to choosing to believe in the One Truth of The One Church) which often drags the feeling behind, so yours is a self fullfilling prophecy of sorts. You lacked faith in the True Bride and so your (lack of) faith was seen, by you, as not being regenerative. Go figure. This was all a matter of your own will trumping the will of God.
It’s unfathomable to the Catholic that what I say is true; the Catholic seems unable even to entertain the possibility that their Catholicism is not true;
This is a false statement. Most Catholics who are strong in their faith, got that way by questioning the validity of the claims of The Chruch. They have simply proved to themselves that she is The True Church, something you have willfully chosen not to do.
therefore, the Catholic reasons that I’m lying, and the real truth is either that I was poorly catechized, or he goes to the extreme of priestly molestation.
How pitiable is that?
Again another false statement. I do not think you are lying. I think there is an element of denial which is necessary for one to cling to that which is unreasonable as if it where God’s own truth. It is ubelievably obvious to any Catholic who might read your posts that your were poorly caechized. That you deny this is the very definition of denial. How does one convince a crazy person that he is crazy? hmmm?

How does one convince another who is in denial that he is in denial?

You are the one who brought up priestly molestation. That was the extreme. Mine was an innocent question brought on by the confusion you create by your very words on this thread. I’m simply trying to figure you out. No easy task. That I’m not the first to ask this question of you should tell you something about how you present yourself. But this would require that you break through the wall of denial which protects you from true self exam.
 
Teflon states:
Now, if you were familiar with the Catholic view of pride and works, you’d understand that “claiming complete and total victory” simply isn’t what we do. There is no such thing until the Lord returns in glory and the faithful join him forever, and no guarantee of the eternal reward which must be worked out, as the apostle notes, with fear and trembling.
The complete and total victory will be the Lord’s.
This is true.

I was being facicious, just having a little fun.
 
S
Generally refers to those churches that follow Calvinistic theology. They may not follow it precisely according to what Calvin taught (such as “Reformed Baptists”; Calvin taught infant baptism), but still adhere to Reformed distinctives, such as predestination, covenant theology, symbolic view of sacramentology, etc.
Picking and choosing their own way to the bitter end. Can’t even follow their own theologian with any sense of loyalty. Why is this not seen as a red flag? I will never get it.
 
These are really big generalisations! What is the evidence for this statement? If we fight with **flarb **instead of **facts **- not helpful.

Jabulani!
Those facts have been reported on the news but they just exploit the Catholic Church event tho it has the smallest % of offenders.
My Mom used to say that people who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones. We all will one day have to stand before God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top