Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Memaw:
Well then, what are you doing about the same problems that occur in your denomination? And don’t try to tell me you don’t have any, its everywhere!!!
You don’t understand, Memaw, we do not belong to any specific denomination; but if we did, what would you suggest we do?

The homosexual movement is not going away; in fact, it will grow, and flourish, and be given more protective rights, and, I believe, it will eventually be given super-rights that will lessen everyone’s speech rights; except of course, for other “oppressed, downtrodden, misunderstood and entitled” minorities. 🤷

Again, my church does not have this problem.
 
This by the force of your own rebellious will.

I am perfectly able to accept that this is what you believe. Denial is a powerful internal force.

Not at all.

The church is precious. And I do believe you. You raise the confusion yourself by what you say. Every true believer knows it is unreasonable to say that one is not “regenerated in the truth of Catholicism” because it is the denial of that truth, in the Eucharist for example, which would contribute to ones feeling of hopelessness and loss. You never availed yourself of the true teachings (evidenced by much of what you say about Catholicism here), choosing to lead with behavior (that behavior would include, but is not limited to choosing to believe in the One Truth of The One Church) which often drags the feeling behind, so yours is a self fullfilling prophecy of sorts. You lacked faith in the True Bride and so your (lack of) faith was seen, by you, as not being regenerative. Go figure. This was all a matter of your own will trumping the will of God.

This is a false statement. Most Catholics who are strong in their faith, got that way by questioning the validity of the claims of The Chruch. They have simply proved to themselves that she is The True Church, something you have willfully chosen not to do.

Again another false statement. I do not think you are lying. I think there is an element of denial which is necessary for one to cling to that which is unreasonable as if it where God’s own truth. It is ubelievably obvious to any Catholic who might read your posts that your were poorly caechized. That you deny this is the very definition of denial. How does one convince a crazy person that he is crazy? hmmm?

How does one convince another who is in denial that he is in denial?

You are the one who brought up priestly molestation. That was the extreme. Mine was an innocent question brought on by the confusion you create by your very words on this thread. I’m simply trying to figure you out. No easy task. That I’m not the first to ask this question of you should tell you something about how you present yourself. But this would require that you break through the wall of denial which protects you from true self exam.
Thank you for that skosh, but to the point analysis of your perception of my problem.
 
sandusky:
Thank you for that skosh, but to the point analysis of your perception of my problem.
Skosh? Are you sure you are using that word correctly?

My goodness, if you were as adept in CC teaching and history as you are in vocabulary we might have less to disagree on. 🙂
 
You don’t understand, Memaw, we do not belong to any specific denomination; but if we did, what would you suggest we do?

The homosexual movement is not going away; in fact, it will grow, and flourish, and be given more protective rights, and, I believe, it will eventually be given super-rights that will lessen everyone’s speech rights; except of course, for other “oppressed, downtrodden, misunderstood and entitled” minorities. 🤷

Again, my church does not have this problem.
First of all I would suggest you stop pointing fingers at those who do have a problem and look into how they are trying to work it out. Stop being sooo judgmental. Like I said, the Catholic Church will work thru Her problems and be stronger for it. She will still be teaching the TRUTH long after were all dust.
I don’t know what denomination you belong to but you must belong to something and I am about 99% sure its not perfect.
 
I think I’ve got it figured out.
This is sandusky:
You don’t understand, Memaw, we do not belong to any specific denomination; but if we did, what would you suggest we do?
The homosexual movement is not going away; in fact, it will grow, and flourish, and be given more protective rights, and, I believe, it will eventually be given super-rights that will lessen everyone’s speech rights; except of course, for other “oppressed, downtrodden, misunderstood and entitled” minorities.
**Again, my church does not have this problem./**QUOTE]
To which Memaw, replied:
I don’t know what denomination you belong to but you must belong to something and I am about 99% sure its not perfect.
I think we’re all missing the point sandusky is making. Not our fault though, because he is so mysterious and rarely wants to clarify or answer a question. Please note I said rarely and not never.

In the above quote he plainly says, “we do not belong to denominations,” and again, for the second or third time, “my church does not have this problem.”

Ergo, sandusky belongs to the invisible universal church. That would be the universal assembly of all christians who share the belief that Christ is the savior, and his shed blood has washed away our sins, or some similar variation of that. Furthermore, the true members of this invisible church are true christians and as such would never engage in or promote homosexuality, hence his claim that his church does not have this problem.

The only thing I can’t figure out is why he wouldn’t just come right out with this. It’s not like any of us have never heard of this before or would condemn him for this belief, it would only allow us to know something about him which he knows about all of us.
 
This is one of the best threads that I have been able to read and learn from. I am going to go back and re-read some of the posts which are so illuminating and thoughtful. I am a convert and I have only been Catholic for 10 years so I have much to learn but I do my best. One issue that I have seen raised by non Catholics here and elsewhere is the “authority to interpret scripture”. I have read the question asked but not answered so here is my 2 cents worth. The Catholic Church does not have an official “interpretation” of every verse or chapter in the Bible.You are free to read the Bible from front to back and enjoy G-d’s word but don’t start changing the articles of our faith …Catholic faith. If you want to make up your own religion it is neccessary to leave and go to one of the thousands of non Catholic denoms whose members are free to reinvent Christianity.
 
This is one of the best threads that I have been able to read and learn from. I am going to go back and re-read some of the posts which are so illuminating and thoughtful. I am a convert and I have only been Catholic for 10 years so I have much to learn but I do my best. One issue that I have seen raised by non Catholics here and elsewhere is the “authority to interpret scripture”. I have read the question asked but not answered so here is my 2 cents worth. The Catholic Church does not have an official “interpretation” of every verse or chapter in the Bible.You are free to read the Bible from front to back and enjoy G-d’s word but don’t start changing the articles of our faith …Catholic faith. If you want to make up your own religion it is neccessary to leave and go to one of the thousands of non Catholic denoms whose members are free to reinvent Christianity.
As a non-Catholic, I can’t say I disagree with anything that you’ve written here. We are to interpret Scripture within the Church catholic; according to the regula fidae.
 
The Catholic Church does not have an official “interpretation” of every verse or chapter in the Bible.You are free to read the Bible from front to back and enjoy G-d’s word but don’t start changing the articles of our faith …Catholic faith.
CCC para. 109-114.
 
I had read the Catechism before I entered the Church but I don’t get the point of your reference since the Catechism does not disagree with my previous post. :confused:
No point.

You live in Pismo…I’m jealous. 😊
 
No point.

You live in Pismo…I’m jealous. 😊
I moved a couple of years ago but only a few miles away. It has been over 100 today including Pismo…I think Bakersfields weather came over for a few days:)
 
I moved a couple of years ago but only a few miles away. It has been over 100 today including Pismo…I think Bakersfields weather came over for a few days:)
I’m in San Fernando, just north of L.A. It’s been over 100 here for two days with huge Santa Ana’s last night; this heat’s early for us; June is usually overcast and can get quite foggy. 🙂
 
too bad
So Cal is nice, but I live just west of Portland Oregon God’s country
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

And our coast is a little greener.


I lived with my sister at pismo beach when I got out of the navy back in the 80’s, it was nice there, but I really love the northwest.
 
Yes very nice post cards of Oregon but the were not taken in January…I have been there.😃
 
Code:
You never availed yourself of the true teachings (evidenced by much of what you say about Catholicism here), choosing to lead with behavior (that behavior would include, but is not limited to choosing to believe in the One Truth of The One Church) which often drags the feeling behind, so yours is a self fullfilling prophecy of sorts.  You lacked faith in the True Bride and so your (lack of) faith was seen, by you, as **not** being regenerative.  Go figure.  This was all a matter of your own will trumping the will of God.
MIZER, I think you are being too hard on sandusky here. I say that because my background if very similar to his. I was raised in Catholic school and so called Catholic family. I left as a teen and joined a Southern Baptist congregation because I too believed that I was unregenerate and unsaved. The Baptists taught me to read and love the Word of God, something that I had not done before. They also taught me about fellowship, conversational prayer, and many other things about Christian life of which I had no experience. After that I sojourned in a variety of Protestant communities for about 20 years, after which I finally came home. While I admit that I did lack faith in the Bride of Christ, I dont’ think God’s will was thwarted in my life. I was not trying to “rebel” either, but to get closer to God. I wanted and needed the emotional and personal experiences that I did not have with God during my early years. I don’t think it is fair to say that a person “never availed himself of the teachings” under such circumstances. While this is true of me also, I did eventually come to a point of doing so.
This is a false statement. Most Catholics who are strong in their faith, got that way by questioning the validity of the claims of The Chruch. They have simply proved to themselves that she is The True Church, something you have willfully chosen not to do.
I disagree that most Catholics are strong in their faith. In fact, most American Catholics are not even practicing their faith. If they were, the parishes would be full, and our society would be much healthier. I agree that sandusky has willfully decided that the Catholic Church is not the True Church, he did so because he was led astray into Reformed theology that made more sense,and had more personal impact than his expereince in Catholicism. I think this is the case with the majority of fallen away Catholics, as it was also for me.
Again another false statement. I do not think you are lying. I think there is an element of denial which is necessary for one to cling to that which is unreasonable as if it where God’s own truth. It is ubelievably obvious to any Catholic who might read your posts that your were poorly caechized.
I agree that it is easy to see the poor catechesis, and the hostitility against Catholicism in the posts. However, I think you need to be fair, and accept that sandusky has embraced what seems reasonable to him, based on his own personal experience.

One also needs to keep in mind that any truth found in Protestant Communities came from the Catholic Church, and is what unites all of our separated brethren to the One Body of Christ.
Code:
 How does one convince another who is in denial that he is in denial?
I think by living the life that Christ intended, thereby bearing witness to Him. One must consider, why is sandusky here? He has been continuing the same old arguements for almost two years. Why has he not gotten bored, and left? Something here is pulling his energy and attention. Something inside him keeps bringing him back.
Code:
You are the one who brought up priestly molestation.  That was the extreme.  Mine was an innocent question brought on by the confusion you create by your very words on this thread.  I'm simply trying to figure you out.  No easy task.  That I'm not the first to ask this question of you should tell you something about how you present yourself.  But this would require that you break through the wall of denial which protects you from true self exam.
sandusky is under no obligation to reveal his affiliations, just as none of us are. If he chooses to protect himself from the inevitable onslaught that would occur if he revealed this personal information, it is incumbent upon us to respect his choice.
 
I think sandusky is here for a reason and I don’t think its because he wants to learn about or try to understand the Catholic Faith. He likes too stir things up and keep it going with his comments. Wouldn’t surprise me one bit if he didn’t even belong to any denomination at all Just floating around looking for a reaction. Well he can do what he wants, its a free country and he has a free will.

Its really something to hear some of you speak of your lack of catechises There is no such thing as a perfect Catholic family or perfect Catholic school or teacher that teaches everything perfectly. I grew up in a family where I went to Catholic school till I was in the 4th grade. Moved to a farm outside a small midwestern town with no Catholic Church within 15 miles, no car. Hardly ever got to Mass, every kid in school tried to get us to come to their protestant church and bible classes. Mom explained why we couldn’t. My younger bros. and sisters had to spend a month in the city, with relatives to make their First Holy Communion. On top of all this, my father was an alcoholic. BUT, my mother, God Bless her, taught us the faith and we learned to LOVE our Lord and His Blessed Mother, and we knew all the important teachings of the Catholic Faith. Learned about the Sacraments even tho we couldn’t participate in them very often. She taught us about the history of our Faith and why it is the One, True, Faith. About the role of the Pope in the Church, Bishops, Priests and Nuns. How we are supposed to live as faithful Catholics. She also taught us about so many of the Saints and Lourdes and Fatima, the Sacred Heart. I have soooo much to be thankful for as my mother only went to the 10th grade and died when she was 54 years old. But she left us a lifetime of love and devotion. I can hardly wait to see her again someday. My father finally did quit drinking before my Mom died, and came back into the Church before he died at age 73.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top