Some help with a religious dillemma?

  • Thread starter Thread starter braeden_mackay
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for providing the link, however I am a Catholic who is very skeptical of these private revelations even though they might be approved by the Church. I don’t believe in the Divine Mercy revelations to Sister Faustina nor the revelations of Fatima. I just don’t see how they help Catholics, for some they may be great devotions, but for me they aren’t helpful, I prefer to stick to Dogma and Traditional teachings. I don’t have to believe in any of these apparition’s of Mary or Jesus to be a Catholic or to be saved. This is just so that no one will come at me with more quotes etc. Thanks again though.
Private revelation :
St. Rose of Lima:

"One day, when the thought of the mystery of predestination caused St. Rose of Lima to fear greatly, Jesus said to her:

‘My daughter, I condemn only those who will to be condemned. Therefore, from today forth banish from your mind all uneasiness on the point.’"
 
Okay, so who exactly recorded this? And does it make her not a Saint? because I have a devotion to her because she is in heaven and a saint and is my patroness, whatever Jesus spoke to her privately in prayer is her and God’s business and none of ours. I don’t get your post.
 
=braeden mackay;11544630]Hello All,
I was received into the Roman Catholic Church this past Easter (March 30 2013). I enjoyed the RCIA program, however I was quite dissatisfied. I have been doing a lot of research and prayer over the past month or so and I have come to conclusion that It is highly likely I will convert to Orthodox Christianity. However, I feel lost and I don’t know where to go, I am still young but I want to find my place early in my life and not later, I want to do Gods will and I feel that He is pulling me towards Orthodoxy. I love Roman Catholicism but I just cannot get over the changes that Vatican II made to the Church. How will I tell the Catholic Priests that I know, that I wish to convert? How should I go about this? Can anyone offer me any advice? Thank you so much for your time and assistance!!!
BE EXTREMELY CAREFUL HERE MY YOUNG FRIEND

WHO;S IN CHARGE YOU; OR YOU’RE GOD:)

IN TRUTH [ALWAYS SINGULAR]

THERE IS ONLY ONE TRUE GOD

WHO CAN AND DOES HOLD ONLY ONE SET OF FAITH BELIEFS [EPH. 4:4-8]

& WHO FOUNDED ONLY ONE CHURCH WITH ONE MAN IN CHARGE

KNOW MY FRIEND THIS WAS NOT NEW:

Read Exodus 6:7

God, for reason only God fully understands has always with complete consistency chosen ONLY ONE “people” as His own. The Hebrew nation.

He insisted on ONLY ONE set of beliefs and practices for them [the Commandments and circumcision] for examples

And EXTREMELY and Critically important; God has always chosen, guided, guarded, and led ONLY ONE MAN:

Noah, Abram, Moses, the Judges, Kings Like David, The prophets like Isaiah, then John the Baptist; then Christ HIMSELF AS GOD choose Peter and established Succession by changing His MANDATE to the Apostles from the “Jews alone” Mt. 10:1-8 to the ENTIRE WORLD in Mk. 16:14-15 & Mt. 28:16-20.

NO OTHER CHURCH, FAITH OR SET OF BELIEFS AND PRACTICES ARE GUIDED FULLY BY GOD, PROTECTED FROM ERROR BY JESUS AND THE HOLY SPIRIT [JOHN 17:14-20], OR WERE GIVEN ALL OF THE KEYS TO HEAVENS ACCESS.

EVEN THE EASTERN CHURCHES IN SCHISM, LACK THE DEGREE OF PROTECTION
BUT GOD REMAINS IN CHARGE OF HIS ONLY FOUNDED CHURCH OR GOD IS A LIAR:eek:. And I hasten to point out the Eastern Churches in SCHISM are separated from the RCC, not the other way around. :o Christ Founded, desires and Blesses FULLY Only His RCC and those associated with Her.

So be very careful about you’re choices. It is an assumed impossibility that MORTAL MEN can actually know More, or know Better than God’s One TRUE Church. Amen:thumbsup:

**John.10: 16 “And I have other sheep, that are not of this fold; I must bring them also, and they will heed my voice. So there shall be one flock, one shepherd” **
 
Yeah, I agree with the above posters.

Eastern Catholic Rites. Research them.

Here’s a good post from another thread on this subject:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7510519&postcount=5

There are the 23 Rites of the Catholic Church, then all of these other “subrites” or uses of the Roman Rite which that post lists very well.

Yeah, there’s more there than I can even wrap my head around. But yeah, basically you should definitely talk to your local priests about this. And ask about the Eastern Catholic Churches. And Catholic, no matter what their stripe, can change Rites, though I’m not an expert on if they can do so more than 1 time.

Anyways, you are a Baptized and Confirmed Catholic, and you should explore this option first. Those Sacraments have left an indelible mark on your soul. So one last time: do check out Eastern Catholic Churches before doing anything too drastic.
 
I am thinking of joining the Antiochian Orthodox Church.

I have also explored the option of Eastern Catholic churches, however all services are in ethnic languages and they are all very ethnically based and didn’t seem very friendly or welcoming to me. there are only two Eastern Catholic Churches in my city and one speaks Greek and the other Ukrainian.
“Celtic Rite: Small schismatic sect from the Antiochian Orthodox Church has resurrected its use in Ireland”

From that post. That should be of particular interest to you. I imagine, again, as no expert, that they offer services in English. Anyways, you shouldn’t choose which Church to be a part of merely based on its availability in your area. Especially when it comes to Orthodox/ Eastern Catholic Churches in America.

**
 
I have been to a church run by a very odd group who are very traditional however they are Sede-vacantist and reject the current pope.
Ummm you’re considering rejecting the current Pope too…

Seriously though, I can see you have made up your mind to leave thinking you will find satisfaction in the next place. A year ago you thought the Roman church would provide the same. Once you get to the new church you will find factors which are unsatisfactory just as sure as those you have listed here.

Truly, I wish you good luck on your journey and hope the journey inside you is as meaningful as the exterior changes you will be making.

Pax
 
Techno2000, read a few lines down, and the page clearly states and I quote **“Now of course, no valid dogmatic proof can be had from private revelations”. **

My parish priest and my Bishop for that matter stated that a Roman Catholic cannot switch rites and that you must be born or convert only to and remain in that rite of Catholicism. They both state that they aren’t as full or true as the Roman Catholic Rite (Latin).

ChurchSolider, thank you for your well wishes, you seem to be one of the few with a positive outlook on this matter, I am just so done arguing with everyone and I regret ever posting about my personal faith journey.

Everyone else, thank you for your (name removed by moderator)ut and advice however I will do what Christ wants me do and I ask for all of your prayers in my journey.

PJM, I have replied to your email.
 
Well, you might as well become a Protestant because you are acting like one. It’s nothing more than private interpretation and subjectivism.
 
Yeah, I agree with the above posters.

Eastern Catholic Rites. Research them.

Here’s a good post from another thread on this subject:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7510519&postcount=5

There are the 23 Rites of the Catholic Church, then all of these other “subrites” or uses of the Roman Rite which that post lists very well.

Yeah, there’s more there than I can even wrap my head around. But yeah, basically you should definitely talk to your local priests about this. And ask about the Eastern Catholic Churches. And Catholic, no matter what their stripe, can change Rites, though I’m not an expert on if they can do so more than 1 time.

Anyways, you are a Baptized and Confirmed Catholic, and you should explore this option first. Those Sacraments have left an indelible mark on your soul. So one last time: do check out Eastern Catholic Churches before doing anything too drastic.
I agree, I am a Byzantine Catholic and like it so much better than the Roman rite, although at times it is necessary to attend a Roman Rite mass to satisfy our obligation to attend Mass on a Sunday or a Holy Day. the Eastern Rite is a lot like the Orthodox church but is under the Pope. You should check it out.
 
I am thinking of joining the Antiochian Orthodox Church.my reasons are many, however an interesting fact is that in the New Testament, the followers of Christ were first referred to as Christians.

The Holy Spirit resolves the conflicts when all Bishops are equal through the action of Ecumenical councils.

Unfortunately, there is only one Tridentine mass celebrated in my diocese that has been approved by the bishop and it is located very far away from my home and I don’t have the funds to keep driving there all of the time. I have been to a church run by a very odd group who are very traditional however they are Sede-vacantist and reject the current pope. I have also explored the option of Eastern Catholic churches, however all services are in ethnic languages and they are all very ethnically based and didn’t seem very friendly or welcoming to me. there are only two Eastern Catholic Churches in my city and one speaks Greek and the other Ukrainian. I just feel so spiritually depleted, I had a spiritual director but he was not accessible and gave me poor advice about prayer and how to live my life in Christ. I am currently reading several books on Orthodoxy and things are becoming more clearer to me based on what they believe. Thank you for your assistance and (name removed by moderator)ut, it is most helpful!!!
I think it is normal for us converts to Catholicism to become interested in EO at some time. I too became interested in learning more about EO and I can only tell you what I concluded form it.

It is clear, to me, from the writings of early church fathers such as Ignatius of antioch, Ireneas, Agustine, etc. that the Bishop of Rome was in charge in the early church.

Ireneas describes the church of Rome as the church that all other churches must agree with.
And indeed the EO admit that the Bishop of Rome was the Prime Patriarch and settled disputes.
So how can the EO get into a dispute with the guy who settles disputes and believe they are in the right? That one I just can’t get passed.
I have heard answers like " Since the dispute involved him he couldn’t settle it and it would go to the Ecumenical Patriarch to settle" The problem is the other party in the dispute was the Ecumenical patriarch. Somehow he can?

The problems the EO have with us just seem petty to me, they have more to do with hurt feelings over things that happened ,literally, hundreds of years ago then theology. Get over it.

The Roman Catholic church recognizes the legitimacy of Orthodoxy yet they do not recognize our legitimacy even though we have the Prime patriarch that everyone is supposed to be in agreement with (I can’t get passed that one).

In the Roman Catholic church you have great acts of charity performed by greats such as Mother Theresa and many others. While Orthodoxy seems to be obsessed with ethnicity.

Anyway that’s my conclusion.
 
Jesus said, “By this all men will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.”

braeden mackay, if I were you, I would just stick with the basics of Christianity. What did Jesus command us to do? Love God, love one another, care for the needy and the children, reconcile with our brother, love our enemies, avoid attachment to (and not worry about) wealth and goods, pray, have faith, … I’ve probably left out a few. Then too the Beatitudes and the Greatest Commandment.

Don’t get too wrapped up in the details of the liturgy, because that is not the core of our faith.

You seem like a very intelligent and conscientious Christian, and so I am sure you will figure it out.

May the Holy Spirit assist and guide you always toward faith and love.
 
I use to see things like that, but after going to religious education in a Catholic School, I realized it was the West (Rome) who broke away from the East, and not the other way around.
This is untrue, i.e., Rome and Constantinople (the other sees were not involved and were moreover under the influence of Constantinople) both attributed to the schism, however, there was reunification at the council of Florence for a short while, but that failed when the Orthodox bishops who participated could not engage the support of the laity back home (this is a generalization, i.e., I’m not getting into the particulars). If you wish to read a good article written by an Orthodox convert about his journey to Orthodoxy, please read this article, I think you will find it enlightening: An Eastern Orthodox Christian Looks West

devinrose.heroicvirtuecreations.com/blog/2012/11/26/an-eastern-orthodox-christian-looks-west/comment-page-1/
 
I am thinking of joining the Antiochian Orthodox Church.my reasons are many, however an interesting fact is that in the New Testament, the followers of Christ were first referred to as Christians.

The Holy Spirit resolves the conflicts when all Bishops are equal through the action of Ecumenical councils.

Unfortunately, there is only one Tridentine mass celebrated in my diocese that has been approved by the bishop and it is located very far away from my home and I don’t have the funds to keep driving there all of the time. I have been to a church run by a very odd group who are very traditional however they are Sede-vacantist and reject the current pope. I have also explored the option of Eastern Catholic churches, however all services are in ethnic languages and they are all very ethnically based and didn’t seem very friendly or welcoming to me. there are only two Eastern Catholic Churches in my city and one speaks Greek and the other Ukrainian. I just feel so spiritually depleted, I had a spiritual director but he was not accessible and gave me poor advice about prayer and how to live my life in Christ. I am currently reading several books on Orthodoxy and things are becoming more clearer to me based on what they believe. Thank you for your assistance and (name removed by moderator)ut, it is most helpful!!!
If you’ve just become Catholic don’t think you should give yourself time to adjust and settle in, i.e., how much do you really know about Catholicism (I’m a cradle Catholic and I’m still learning)? I ask because you don’t want to make any rash decisions because you “feel” spiritually depleted, i.e., we all have felt that from time to time. Moreover, reading Orthodox books is fine but do not use them in order to judge Catholic doctrine, i.e., you need to read Catholic resources concerning Catholic teaching. In order for you to understand this, let me quote an excerpt from a convert to Orthodoxy highlighting some key issues of his conversion:
Blinded by such passions (I had no idea about any of this at the time), I, like many Protestant converts to Orthodoxy in English-speaking lands, never bothered to truly understand Roman Catholicism before I rejected it. The very word “pope” was like a counter-argument in itself—its refutation was a fait accompli to a soul prostituted to the wicked man. I did not evaluate this according to Christian wisdom (even though I thought I had committed myself to the wise). I did not search the Church Fathers to confirm or deny the assertions of these Orthodox polemics. A few quotations was good enough for me, and good enough for my sinful nature—I could submit to wise men of the past, and selectively choose which wise men to listen to (which patristic interpretation), but I sure as hell wasn’t going to be under the pope! I became an Orthodox apologist and polemicist, proving to everyone that the Orthodox Church was the one true Church, and that everything else was an impious derivation therefrom. I saw myself as a pious freedom fighter, liberating others from the tyranny of division, ushering them into the light of Orthodoxy. I was overjoyed to finally have the answer to the division in the Church.
devinrose.heroicvirtuecreations.com/blog/2012/11/26/an-eastern-orthodox-christian-looks-west/comment-page-1/
 
Yeah, I agree with the above posters.

Eastern Catholic Rites. Research them.

Here’s a good post from another thread on this subject:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=7510519&postcount=5

There are the 23 Rites of the Catholic Church, then all of these other “subrites” or uses of the Roman Rite which that post lists very well.

Yeah, there’s more there than I can even wrap my head around. But yeah, basically you should definitely talk to your local priests about this. And ask about the Eastern Catholic Churches. And Catholic, no matter what their stripe, can change Rites, though I’m not an expert on if they can do so more than 1 time.

Anyways, you are a Baptized and Confirmed Catholic, and you should explore this option first. Those Sacraments have left an indelible mark on your soul. So one last time: do check out Eastern Catholic Churches before doing anything too drastic.
You should refer to them as sui iuris churches, i.e., 23 particular Catholic churches all in communion with each other, but more specifically with the bishop of Rome (the rite is in reference to what liturgy they use).
 
Hello All,

I was received into the Roman Catholic Church this past Easter (March 30 2013). I enjoyed the RCIA program, however I was quite dissatisfied. I have been doing a lot of research and prayer over the past month or so and I have come to conclusion that It is highly likely I will convert to Orthodox Christianity. However, I feel lost and I don’t know where to go, I am still young but I want to find my place early in my life and not later, I want to do Gods will and I feel that He is pulling me towards Orthodoxy. I love Roman Catholicism but I just cannot get over the changes that Vatican II made to the Church. How will I tell the Catholic Priests that I know, that I wish to convert? How should I go about this? Can anyone offer me any advice? Thank you so much for your time and assistance!!!
There is a poster on CAF, his name is Marduk, I think he would be able to help you, i.e., he is an “Orthodox in communion with Rome”. Read up on his posts, i.e., you can read about his conversion into the Catholic Church. He’s really knowledgeable.

p.s. Give yourself time to think this through because there can only be one Church of Christ, which contains the fullness of Truth.
 
Hello All,

I was received into the Roman Catholic Church this past Easter (March 30 2013). I enjoyed the RCIA program, however I was quite dissatisfied. I have been doing a lot of research and prayer over the past month or so and I have come to conclusion that It is highly likely I will convert to Orthodox Christianity. However, I feel lost and I don’t know where to go, I am still young but I want to find my place early in my life and not later, I want to do Gods will and I feel that He is pulling me towards Orthodoxy. I love Roman Catholicism but I just cannot get over the changes that Vatican II made to the Church. How will I tell the Catholic Priests that I know, that I wish to convert? How should I go about this? Can anyone offer me any advice? Thank you so much for your time and assistance!!!
Something to soothe your soul, his name is Friar Alessandro, and his voice is like nothing I’ve ever heard before:

youtube.com/watch?v=vZjjLYa8o4I

God bless, I’m praying for you!
 
This is untrue, i.e., Rome and Constantinople (the other sees were not involved and were moreover under the influence of Constantinople) both attributed to the schism, however, there was reunification at the council of Florence for a short while, but that failed when the Orthodox bishops who participated could not engage the support of the laity back home (this is a generalization, i.e., I’m not getting into the particulars). If you wish to read a good article written by an Orthodox convert about his journey to Orthodoxy, please read this article, I think you will find it enlightening: An Eastern Orthodox Christian Looks West

devinrose.heroicvirtuecreations.com/blog/2012/11/26/an-eastern-orthodox-christian-looks-west/comment-page-1/
I should not have written Rome per se, but Latins, i.e., the See of Peter was not involved in the altercation between Cardinal Humbert and Patriarch Cerulius of Constantinople, nor was the bishop of Rome involved in the sacking of Constantinople in 1204 (in fact he excommunicated those who were involved). The history of our churches is riddled with wrongs on both sides (the Massacre of the Latins in Constantinople in 1182), and we need to take ownership of that (Pope John Paul II publicly apologized for the misdeeds of Catholics in the past).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top