Some polls on the Charlottesville Situation

  • Thread starter Thread starter AFerri48
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
pbs.org/newshour/rundown/new-poll-majority-americans-unhappy-trumps-response-charlottesville/

52% think Trump’s response wasn’t strong enough.

67% think the car crash should be considered domestic terrorism.

62% think the confederate statues should remain in place as historical symbols.
I would think that the car crash percentage would be higher. I remembered when the incident happened, many here on CAF posted that the incident was domestic terrorism.

To me based on the kids history, where he was at and the things that were happening should be terrorism.

Same if anybody gets caught beating someone else, that also should be terrorism whether it’s a black or white or hispanic person. Hate is hate and it needs to be seen as terrorism.
 
I would think that the car crash percentage would be higher. I remembered when the incident happened, many here on CAF posted that the incident was domestic terrorism.
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act. Some even have claimed ALL car drivers have been tempted to run people over, and so we shouldn’t judge Mr. Fields too harshly. :rolleyes:

So I wouldn’t exactly take the responses on CAF as at all indicative of larger society. I think World News has been mostly given over to the extreme partisans on both sides, those with moderate opinions have mostly walked away and shaken the dust from their feet.

Interesting though that the percentage who think the crash was terrorism, and the percentage that actually agrees with the main point of the “Unite the Right” rally, that the Confederate statues should NOT come down, is about the same.

So apparently, people in the Real World actually ARE capable of holding to a certain opinion on a political topic, yet NOT find themselves obligated to defend the actions of every other person who holds that same opinion.

Sadly, some on CAF seem to think that it’s impossible to do that, to actually criticize the actions of those “on my side”, without spontaneously combusting. So they will defend the indefensible, or at least claim mitigating circumstances, or that “well their side is no better, so don’t judge my side so harshly”. As another poster has said, I doubt this “but what about THEIR sins, they’re just as bad as mine” strategy will work on Judgment Day. But what do I know, I’m just a wishy-washy moderate, who will be joining the goats too for being “lukewarm”. 🤷
 
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act. Some even have claimed ALL car drivers have been tempted to run people over, and so we shouldn’t judge Mr. Fields too harshly. :rolleyes:

:
Sine he used a car to run her over…maybe that will turn into hatred for cars, roving gangs out defacing cars, people calling for cars to be banned or heavily regulated, going after companies who manufacture, sell cars (they are part of the problem too)!!
 
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act. Some even have claimed ALL car drivers have been tempted to run people over, and so we shouldn’t judge Mr. Fields too harshly. :rolleyes:
He was attacked first from the video I’ve seen. Other things may have happened to him prior to what we did see that caused him to fear for his life. But he may have also intended the act. We don’t know. If justice is just what a majority of people think based on news reports then I don’t have to tell you what that is… it’s a lynch mob.
 
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act.
Can you point me to posts that claim this? I’m not saying it did not happen, I have just not seen them. I don’t have time to keep up with the pages upon pages of posts in all the threads related to Charlottesville
So I wouldn’t exactly take the responses on CAF as at all indicative of larger society.
Agree
 
Are we still listening to these people who told us Hillary was to be president?!
 
Sadly, some on CAF seem to think that it’s impossible to do that, to actually criticize the actions of those “on my side”, without spontaneously combusting. So they will defend the indefensible, or at least claim mitigating circumstances, or that “well their side is no better, so don’t judge my side so harshly”. As another poster has said, I doubt this “but what about THEIR sins, they’re just as bad as mine” strategy will work on Judgment Day. But what do I know, I’m just a wishy-washy moderate, who will be joining the goats too for being “lukewarm”. 🤷
I don’t think you need to worry about being a goat. 😃

As the Pope’s advisors state:

At times this mingling of politics, morals and religion has taken on a Manichaean language that divides reality between absolute Good and absolute Evil. In fact, after President George W. Bush spoke in his day about challenging the “axis of evil” and stated it was the USA’s duty to “free the world from evil” following the events of September 11, 2001. Today President Trump steers the fight against a wider, generic collective entity of the “bad” or even the “very bad.” Sometimes the tones used by his supporters in some campaigns take on meanings that we could define as “epic.”

These stances are based on Christian-Evangelical fundamentalist principles dating from the beginning of the 20th Century that have been gradually radicalized. These have moved on from a rejection of all that is mundane – as politics was considered – to bringing a strong and determined religious-moral influence to bear on democratic processes and their results.

Evangelical Fundamentalism and Catholic Integralism: A surprising ecumenism by Antonio Spadaro - Marcelo Figueroa* laciviltacattolica.it/articolo/evangelical-fundamentalism-and-catholic-integralism-in-the-usa-a-surprising-ecumenism/

Every Catholic should read that article, which was vetted and approved by the Vatican as accurately reflecting the Pope’s views on American politics.

Manichean dualism is an ancient heresy that was denounced by the Church in late antiquity. But that doesn’t mean it doesn’t keep coming back.

CAF has allowed itself to become a platform for this sort of thinking, which gives the false impression that it represents a legitimate Catholic world view. It does not.
 
Can you point me to posts that claim this? I’m not saying it did not happen, I have just not seen them. I don’t have time to keep up with the pages upon pages of posts in all the threads related to Charlottesville

Agree
the post above yours…?
 
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act.
Can you point me to posts that claim this? I’m not saying it did not happen, I have just not seen them. I don’t have time to keep up with the pages upon pages of posts in all the threads related to Charlottesville.
Uh, there was one right above yours, but here it is again.
He was attacked first from the video I’ve seen. Other things may have happened to him prior to what we did see that caused him to fear for his life. But he may have also intended the act. We don’t know. If justice is just what a majority of people think based on news reports then I don’t have to tell you what that is… it’s a lynch mob.
To be fair most such as this poster, are claiming “it COULD have been self defense” not that it definitely was.

I’m actually not totally convinced that Fields came to the rally premeditating an attack on counter-protestors, it could have been an impulsive act, as well. So I hesitate to label it “terrorism”.

Also while many people think a claim of “self-defense” automatically makes all violent behavior justified, I don’t. I think the concept of proportionality still applies.
 
To be fair most such as this poster, are claiming “it COULD have been self defense” not that it definitely was.
To be fair isn’t it fair to not form an opinion without all the facts? Isn’t it fair to allow the man to defend his actions? I actually saw a video where the guys car was swung at as he drove. Now, if the guy had set up shop with a rifle in a building then I would think it pretty hard to imagine any justification for his actions.
 
To be fair isn’t it fair to not form an opinion without all the facts? Isn’t it fair to allow the man to defend his actions? I actually saw a video where the guys car was swung at as he drove. Now, if the guy had set up shop with a rifle in a building then I would think it pretty hard to imagine any justification for his actions.
But is Fields even claiming self-defense here?

In any case, why do I get the feeling you’d be singing a quite different tune if it had been some guy had driven a Subaru festooned with Clinton and Obama into the rightist protestors?

I humbly apologize if I am wrong about that.

Manicheanism, indeed.
 
But is Fields even claiming self-defense here?

In any case, why do I get the feeling you’d be singing a quite different tune if it had been some guy had driven a Subaru festooned with Clinton and Obama into the rightist protestors?

I humbly apologize if I am wrong about that.

Manicheanism, indeed.
I have no idea what the guy is claiming. If he is smart he’d be claiming nothing right now. He’d be saying nothing. He would wait until he knows what evidence the state has against him. He would wait until his court case to say anything. Because it isn’t like a self defense claim is going to get him out of a court case.

I don’t know why you’d have any feelings about me.
 
To my understanding, “terrorism” is properly understood as an act which might or might not be violent, or a communication, the objective of which is to create extreme fear, in order to accomplish political objectives.

It’s possible the driver was doing that. It’s also possible he just wanted to kill someone he hated. At present those seem the only two possibilities most are positing. But I don’t think we’ll actually know until law enforcement finishes its investigation.

Personally, my speculation is that it was a “hate crime” murder or manslaughter, combined with attempted murder or manslaughter and any number of criminal assaults. For it to be “terrorism” properly speaking, I don’t think we know enough yet to say it.

I think I understand there is a political purpose in some of the people wanting it designated as “terrorism”, but I don’t think it’s appropriate at this time to call it that when it might simply be a series of criminal acts.
 
I don’t think you need to worry about being a goat. 😃

As the Pope’s advisors state:

At times this mingling of politics, morals and religion has taken on a Manichaean language that divides reality between absolute Good and absolute Evil. In fact, after President George W. Bush spoke in his day about challenging the “axis of evil” and stated it was the USA’s duty to “free the world from evil” following the events of September 11, 2001. Today President Trump steers the fight against a wider, generic collective entity of the “bad” or even the “very bad.” Sometimes the tones used by his supporters in some campaigns take on meanings that we could define as “epic.”

These stances are based on Christian-Evangelical fundamentalist principles dating from the beginning of the 20th Century that have been gradually radicalized. These have moved on from a rejection of all that is mundane – as politics was considered – to bringing a strong and determined religious-moral influence to bear on democratic processes and their results.

Evangelical Fundamentalism and Catholic Integralism: A surprising ecumenism by Antonio Spadaro - Marcelo Figueroa* laciviltacattolica.it/articolo/evangelical-fundamentalism-and-catholic-integralism-in-the-usa-a-surprising-ecumenism/

Every Catholic should read that article, which was vetted and approved by the Vatican as accurately reflecting the Pope’s views on American politics.

Manichean dualism is an ancient heresy that was denounced by the Church in late antiquity. But that doesn’t mean it doesn’t keep coming back.

CAF has allowed itself to become a platform for this sort of thinking, which gives the false impression that it represents a legitimate Catholic world view. It does not.
I don’t know anything about these particular “Pope’s advisors” or what they know about American politics. But I don’t see this as “Manichaean”. What’s “good” or even “gray” about ISIS, for example? What’s “good” or “gray” about true racism or “racial supremacy”, for that matter? What’s “good” or “gray” about abortion on demand?

Some things really are good and some really are bad. But being persuaded of the morality or immorality of a particular thing does not make one a “Manichaean”.
 
I think you are intentionally conflating posts here.

Yes people have said you should defend yourself when someone is swinging a club at you. However, nobody has said the car driver was justified and defending himself by running people over.

I really don’t care if his act was premeditated, it’s still wrong and the court will sort that out at trial.
And many on CAF are actually claiming “it was self defense, he was attacked first” or at least aren’t convinced the car crash was a premeditated act. Some even have claimed ALL car drivers have been tempted to run people over, and so we shouldn’t judge Mr. Fields too harshly. :rolleyes:

So I wouldn’t exactly take the responses on CAF as at all indicative of larger society. I think World News has been mostly given over to the extreme partisans on both sides, those with moderate opinions have mostly walked away and shaken the dust from their feet.

Interesting though that the percentage who think the crash was terrorism, and the percentage that actually agrees with the main point of the “Unite the Right” rally, that the Confederate statues should NOT come down, is about the same.

So apparently, people in the Real World actually ARE capable of holding to a certain opinion on a political topic, yet NOT find themselves obligated to defend the actions of every other person who holds that same opinion.

Sadly, some on CAF seem to think that it’s impossible to do that, to actually criticize the actions of those “on my side”, without spontaneously combusting. So they will defend the indefensible, or at least claim mitigating circumstances, or that “well their side is no better, so don’t judge my side so harshly”. As another poster has said, I doubt this “but what about THEIR sins, they’re just as bad as mine” strategy will work on Judgment Day. But what do I know, I’m just a wishy-washy moderate, who will be joining the goats too for being “lukewarm”. 🤷
 
I don’t know anything about these particular “Pope’s advisors” or what they know about American politics. But I don’t see this as “Manichaean”. What’s “good” or even “gray” about ISIS, for example? What’s “good” or “gray” about true racism or “racial supremacy”, for that matter? What’s “good” or “gray” about abortion on demand?

Some things really are good and some really are bad. But being persuaded of the morality or immorality of a particular thing does not make one a “Manichaean”.
The problem I have seen happening is not really about political opinions, but how many people are quick to assume that everyone who holds a particular political belief is “good” and that everyone who hold a particular political belief is " bad". And if someone is “bad” then it’s okay to treat them badly because they “deserve” it.

Maybe Fields truly believed “all those Antifa protestors are evil and trying to take over the country I love and turn into a godless Communist hellhole” and hence that meant “they deserve to be run over”.

If so, does that therefore justify his actions?

BTW, what is your definition of “true racism”?
 
I think you are intentionally conflating posts here.

Yes people have said you should defend yourself when someone is swinging a club at you. However, nobody has said the car driver was justified and defending himself by running people over.

I really don’t care if his act was premeditated, it’s still wrong and the court will sort that out at trial.
I admit to paraphrasing, but not “intentionally conflating” if you are insinuating some nefarious motive on my part.

I concede that nobody has said the car driver definitely WAS justified, but some have suggested he MAY have been justified. One has done so in this very topic.
 
I concede that nobody has said the car driver definitely WAS justified, but some have suggested he MAY have been justified. One has done so in this very topic.
I’ve not said he may have been justified. I’ve said it may not have been an intentional act. It could be manslaughter. It is conceivable he was frightened and tried to escape. Even if that is so he’d still be guilty of a crime.
 
I’ve not said he may have been justified. I’ve said it may not have been an intentional act. It could be manslaughter. It is conceivable he was frightened and tried to escape. Even if that is so he’d still be guilty of a crime.
Thanks for the clarification.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top