I have a lot of thoughts on ROTC, although it appears we’re talking about JROTC.
I echo sentiments that scouting is more important.
Now, some ruminations:
- The military is a major commitment and is not undertaken lightly. I have the utmost respect for the military. That said, a former drill sergeant I know used to give the advice that if you had anything on the ball and wanted to join the military, join as an officer. Enlisted face low pay, many demands, and many join from a lack of other real opportunities where they live. There are some who join up as enlisted because they basically need or want to be essentially told “where to go, where to stand, what to do, and how to dress.”
- ROTC does in fact essentially pay for college but should you reverse yourself and not join, I believe you then owe the cost of the education you received…so by joining ROTC you “sort of, but not quite” obligate yourself.
- I personally suspect most 8th grade boys go thru a phase where they want to join the army. The more relevant questions are i) if do they still feel that way at 18, or 22, and ii) WHY do they feel this way.
- For that matter, we are talking about army ROTC, are we? Why is OP’s son interested in that branch? Navy? Air Force? What about those services are interesting to OP’s son?
Final analysis IMHO: 8th grade is WAY TOO YOUNG to make life altering decisions. Have son join boy scouts…
…and first explain WHY he wants to join JROTC. Does he want to “join the army & see the world?” Jump out of planes? Learn a skill, i.e., radar, radio, whatever? Does he want to drive M-1 tanks? Be an MP? What sort of enlistment period will he face?..
…and he needs to keep 2 things in mind.
First, the entire goal of the military is to fight wars. Not to teach a skill, or perform humanitarian missions. It is to fight wars. He BETTER be okay with that.
Second. the military is a HIGHLY, HUGELY STRUCTURED environment. He can expect – even as an officer – to follow orders completely; to follow procedures completely; to use a particular form to requisition a certain type of spare part; to be at a particular place at exactly 0730 hours (not 0725, or 0735); to behave in a certain way, all the time, around enlisted personnel (officers are leaders); etc.
Sorry to run on. Just want the lad to know what he’s getting into…