Son wants to do ROTC

  • Thread starter Thread starter rdscheirer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

rdscheirer

Guest
My son is in 8th grade at a great Catholic school. He wants to go ROTC in High School. Local Catholic High School doesn’t have ROTC. He would attend the same public school as my daughter (now Sr) elected to attend because the opportunities for her in the artistic fields were so much greater ( art, photography and creative writing). She is brilliant- he struggles to make B’s. She gets A’s in all the courses except math and science but still gets B’s in those. There is no way logistically (transportation wise) that we could get him from Catholic High School to the Public School for ROTC. There have been families in our Parish who have been able to do it. Daughter has pretty much been able to weather the storm of the Baptists who dominate the school (we’re in the South)- not so sure my son would be able to defend the Faith. Daughter has related that since her first day she has been evengelized by the Baptists in her classes- discretely of course as this is a government school.
Advice or comments please!
 
My son is in 8th grade at a great Catholic school. He wants to go ROTC in High School. Local Catholic High School doesn’t have ROTC. He would attend the same public school as my daughter (now Sr) elected to attend because the opportunities for her in the artistic fields were so much greater ( art, photography and creative writing). She is brilliant- he struggles to make B’s. She gets A’s in all the courses except math and science but still gets B’s in those. There is no way logistically (transportation wise) that we could get him from Catholic High School to the Public School for ROTC. There have been families in our Parish who have been able to do it. Daughter has pretty much been able to weather the storm of the Baptists who dominate the school (we’re in the South)- not so sure my son would be able to defend the Faith. Daughter has related that since her first day she has been evengelized by the Baptists in her classes- discretely of course as this is a government school.
Advice or comments please!
Is it ROTC in high school, or JROTC?

If its just JROTC, tell him to work harder to get his Bs or higher, and get into a college ROTC program. That’s where the real fun begins, and the military assigns slightly higher E-# ranks based on college credit earned, if nothing else.

In any case, I’d recommend you get this kid into the Boy Scouts if he isn’t already. There’s a reason the military looks so favorably (especially in the officer-selection process) on young men who have achieved advanced rank in the Boy Scouts. This–far more than JROTC–would set him up for success in the military, and beyond.
 
I have a lot of thoughts on ROTC, although it appears we’re talking about JROTC.

I echo sentiments that scouting is more important.

Now, some ruminations:
  1. The military is a major commitment and is not undertaken lightly. I have the utmost respect for the military. That said, a former drill sergeant I know used to give the advice that if you had anything on the ball and wanted to join the military, join as an officer. Enlisted face low pay, many demands, and many join from a lack of other real opportunities where they live. There are some who join up as enlisted because they basically need or want to be essentially told “where to go, where to stand, what to do, and how to dress.”
  2. ROTC does in fact essentially pay for college but should you reverse yourself and not join, I believe you then owe the cost of the education you received…so by joining ROTC you “sort of, but not quite” obligate yourself.
  3. I personally suspect most 8th grade boys go thru a phase where they want to join the army. The more relevant questions are i) if do they still feel that way at 18, or 22, and ii) WHY do they feel this way.
  4. For that matter, we are talking about army ROTC, are we? Why is OP’s son interested in that branch? Navy? Air Force? What about those services are interesting to OP’s son?
Final analysis IMHO: 8th grade is WAY TOO YOUNG to make life altering decisions. Have son join boy scouts…

…and first explain WHY he wants to join JROTC. Does he want to “join the army & see the world?” Jump out of planes? Learn a skill, i.e., radar, radio, whatever? Does he want to drive M-1 tanks? Be an MP? What sort of enlistment period will he face?..

…and he needs to keep 2 things in mind.

First, the entire goal of the military is to fight wars. Not to teach a skill, or perform humanitarian missions. It is to fight wars. He BETTER be okay with that.

Second. the military is a HIGHLY, HUGELY STRUCTURED environment. He can expect – even as an officer – to follow orders completely; to follow procedures completely; to use a particular form to requisition a certain type of spare part; to be at a particular place at exactly 0730 hours (not 0725, or 0735); to behave in a certain way, all the time, around enlisted personnel (officers are leaders); etc.

Sorry to run on. Just want the lad to know what he’s getting into…
 
Ah, well-met! The ol’ ‘be-careful-what-you-sign’ lecture. Tsk, tsk, where do I begin…

Men old enough to be inducted into military service should be able to (1) read their contracts, (2) research what personal obligations the terms of their contract entail, and (3) uphold those obligations.

To give this classic FOG lecture does three things: (a) it makes the person listening to it feel like an illiterate peasant, and (b) presents military service like its somehow unworthy of the average nose-picking American teenager or 20-something. Since not every SOB with a baccalaureate is poised to be the next Steve Jobs, I really feel like the tone is overkill, don’t you? Anywho, ironically the most irritating thing about this FOG lecture is: (c) many of the people delivering it aren’t a FOG or BTDT, and therefore have no idea what they’re talking about. But whatever, water under the bridge. 🙂

If the person has even the most basic critical reading and career-planning skills, they should be able to navigate the enlistment or commissioning process alright. If they don’t–well, hey, maybe its a blessing for them that they get a job doing pushups as an 11b, than wandering around civil society signing themselves into stuff they can’t understand and planning poorly! Am I right!? 😃
 
I did both Boy Scouts and JROTC, and let me say with certainty, I learned far more in JROTC than I did in Scouting.

8th and 9th grade is too old to begin Boy Scouts. He should have joined in the 6th grade. He will be two or three years older than everyone else his rank, and boys his age will be far ahead of him. This makes a difference, especially at that age.

As much as I appreciate the skills I learned, I left scouting when I joined JROTC. I madedid Life, no Eagle for me, but even if I had earned it, I would have walked away. I stayed in all four years of high school, and I was the school’s battalion commander my senior year. I learned far more in that class and all the extra activities than I did in my years of scouting.

After high school, I earned an advanced promotion to PFC/E-3 when I joined the Army. I breezed through basic with flying colors. However, plenty of my classmates did not enlist. I turned down college, but other used their JROTC to gain enrollment into higher learning. It looks great on paper, especially if you go the distance.

Let him go. JROTC is not about recruiting. The mission statement is “to motivate young people to become better Americans”. There are some schools where the class is mandatory. It will be a good experience for him.

Keep and eye on his faith, but it may be better to test him now than to wait until after he has left your authority and guidance.
 
Don’t be concerned. JROTC is not a recruiting mechanicism for the military. It is a leadership dveleopment course. The curriculum meets the nattional education standards and crosses all of the core subjects. The program is designed to equip young people with the necessary critical thinking and communications skills to ensure their success. In 10 years working in JROTC I have helped far more young people get into college than into the military. And I work in the inner city. JROTC is a great program.🙂
 
I did JROTC. Yes, as a girl who skipped grades I started as a shy 12 year-old 96 pound 4’11" gal. Best time I had in high school. I gained confidence and upper body strength!

JROTC is a great program. I pray whatever is the better choice for your child is what happens. :hug1:
 
My best friend from High School went ROTC in the late 70’s and is now a pilot with a major airline- his older brother did the same and became an Army Ranger- very similar to the Navy Seals. In fact talking with him I would rather have a Ranger protecting me than a Seal.- No offense to the Seals but the Rangers have a different approach to freedom according to him.
 
My best friend from High School went ROTC in the late 70’s and is now a pilot with a major airline- his older brother did the same and became an Army Ranger- very similar to the Navy Seals. In fact talking with him I would rather have a Ranger protecting me than a Seal.- No offense to the Seals but the Rangers have a different approach to freedom according to him.
Can you go into detail? That’s interesting .
 
He said that the Rangers are sworn in to uphold the Constitution and the Seals are not. This was in the late 70’s early 80’s. Has it changed?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top