SOPA and PIPA postponed indefinitely after protests

  • Thread starter Thread starter LemonAndLime
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

LemonAndLime

Guest
When the entire Internet gets angry, Congress takes notice. Both the House and the Senate on Friday backed away from a pair of controversial anti-piracy bills, tossing them into limbo and throwing doubt on their future viability.

The Senate had been scheduled to hold a proceedural vote next week on whether to take up the Protect IP Act (PIPA) – a bill that once had widespread, bipartisan support. But on Friday, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said he was postponing the vote “in light of recent events.”

Meanwhile, the House of Representatives said it is putting on hold its version of the bill, the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). The House will “postpone consideration of the legislation until there is wider agreement on a solution,” House Judiciary Committee Chairman Lamar Smith said in a written statement.

The moves came after several lawmakers flipped their position on the bills in the wake of widespread online and offline protests against them.

money.cnn.com/2012/01/20/technology/SOPA_PIPA_postponed/index.htm
 
They need to redefine their strategies. A few tweaks to the law and they’ll be at it pretty soon again. Next time they may succeed. Usually first draft legislation is pretty extreme, when people protest the politicos tame it a little and then it gets passed - “You see we listened to you!”
 
Yes! When the net gets angry they do indeed listen. (Now if we could only do the same for right to life!)
 
People are usually too busy on YouTube and Facebook to bother to vote. But if those sites shut down then they’ll have time on their hands to take it out on those who voted for the bill. 😛
 
The biggest idiocy was the following procedure:
  1. copyright holder spots something he doesn’t like
  2. without needing to go to court, he gives notice to advertisers etc. to stop providing services to the website
  3. website can provide counter-notice but service providers do not need to comply
  4. website can’t sue for damages unless the holder knowingly and materially misrepresented the suspected violation.
That’s a clear case of lobbying tinkering with liability.

When Microsoft opposes a pro-copyright bill, you know something’s really wrong about it.
 
The biggest idiocy was the following procedure:
  1. copyright holder spots something he doesn’t like
  2. without needing to go to court, he gives notice to advertisers etc. to stop providing services to the website
  3. website can provide counter-notice but service providers do not need to comply
  4. website can’t sue for damages unless the holder knowingly and materially misrepresented the suspected violation.
That’s a clear case of lobbying tinkering with liability.

When Microsoft opposes a pro-copyright bill, you know something’s really wrong about it.
Another thing I had heard – this is at second hand, but sounds like it might be true as Congress/Hollywood tried these same shenanigans before* – is that the bills mandated that all siezed domain names were to be given to GoDaddy.com, who, completely coincidentally (wink, wink) was a major supporter of SOPA/PIPA in defiance of pretty much every other Internet company until the wrath of teh Interwebs fell upon them.

*In 1999, when DCMA was written, they inerted provisions making Macrovision copy-protection all but mandatory by name on DVD players. The physical discs could be protected or not at will, but all DVD player manufacturers were, and are, forced explicitly to support Macrovision CSS or run afoul of the law. Guess who was a supporter of the bill? (No points for a correct guess 😉 )
 
The current bills are effectively dead. Still, someone is going to have to figure out how to stop piracy of content. Here are the words of independent film maker Ellen Seidler:

“For these pirate entrepreneurs, and companies that indirectly facilitate their operation, it’s a no-risk proposition. Steal content, post it on a website, drive traffic to the website and earn revenue. In this equation, the pirate website operators make money, credit card companies make money, ad providers make money and advertisers attract new customers. Who is left out? The artists who actually create the content.”

Independent filmmaker Ellen Seidler

Source: rollcall.com/news/-200779-1.html
 
The current bills are effectively dead. Still, someone is going to have to figure out how to stop piracy of content. Here are the words of independent film maker Ellen Seidler:

“For these pirate entrepreneurs, and companies that indirectly facilitate their operation, it’s a no-risk proposition. Steal content, post it on a website, drive traffic to the website and earn revenue. In this equation, the pirate website operators make money, credit card companies make money, ad providers make money and advertisers attract new customers. Who is left out? The artists who actually create the content.”

Independent filmmaker Ellen Seidler

Source: rollcall.com/news/-200779-1.html
DMCA take down notice. And if that fails appeal to copyright body in country where stuff is uploaded.

BTW those companies also include such companies as Google, Yahoo, MSN etc, since they all index links.

I tried that once with Rapid Share. They hosted an anti-John Paul II book. But RS wanted proof that I was the copyright holder. Arbitrary people can’t report content.
It can be done by copyright holders. RS is a German site so it works outside of DMCA too.
 
DMCA take down notice. And if that fails appeal to copyright body in country where stuff is uploaded.

BTW those companies also include such companies as Google, Yahoo, MSN etc, since they all index links.

I tried that once with Rapid Share. They hosted an anti-John Paul II book. But RS wanted proof that I was the copyright holder. Arbitrary people can’t report content.
It can be done by copyright holders. RS is a German site so it works outside of DMCA too.
I have no copyrighted work online so it doesn’t affect me personally. And if DMCA works, that’s good. But this is the same filmmaker who says she has filed numerous DMCA complaints without much effect. She’s also said, with respect to the piracy sites, that even when they take down one link because of a DMCA complaint, another link immediately goes up.
 
I took down my personal blog and my writing blog as part of the protest on Wednesday: glad to see it worked. Congress seems to have realized that they’d started tangling with a dragon that they shouldn’t have woken up in the first place, and I hope they learn from this. Maybe they realized they were making the same mistake that was made when the 18th Amendment was ratified.
 
She’s also said, with respect to the piracy sites, that even when they take down one link because of a DMCA complaint, another link immediately goes up.
That links go up does not mean that whole sites must be shut down. If you imply that, you imply that other business owners must babysit the business of the film makers.
Look at it like this, if some guy is selling CDs with your work on some streetcorner in Thailand, what are you going to do about it? Nothing. At least with the internet you can take down the links and hopefully sites will take down repeat offenders. It’s actually easier to fix copyright problems on the internet than on the streets in far off countries.
 
What about sites whose entire business model consists of making copyrighted material available to anyone for free, and making money from site ads. Those providing the ads, like Google, make money as well.

From what I’m hearing, it sounds as though we’re being told that we must simply accomodate wholesale theft. That’s sad.
 
What about sites whose entire business model consists of making copyrighted material available to anyone for free, and making money from site ads. Those providing the ads, like Google, make money as well.
Well the authorities have been going after The Pirate Bay for a while. They’ve also shut down Napster. They shut down pirate websites frequently. It does happen.

Maybe someone should complain to the advertiser that their ads support distribution of works? It’s possible I guess. And if they ignore it, write to the papers. If VISA is advertising it’s cards on a warez site, take a screenshot, URL and email it to VISA. If they don’t respond, get it to the papers. I think it’s also possible to report some sites directly to different police organisations.
From what I’m hearing, it sounds as though we’re being told that we must simply accomodate wholesale theft. That’s sad.
Do you police street corners looking for illegal CDs being sold?
Do you police what McDonald’s puts in their burgers?
Do you police that other drivers don’t drive under the influence of alcohol?
Well I doubt it. Think of the context. The offenses are easier to find on the internet but crimes occur everywhere and no-one laments them there.

You have made valid points but the issue is that there are tools to help take down offensive sites/links. The internet makes piracy easier, but also makes sales and distribution as well as advertising easier. It’s a double edged sword. If we all had 56k modems only then no movies would be shared, but then your director friend would not be able to distribute her work either.

Plus it’s also an issue with people themselves. People find it ethical to copy the works of major studios because they see these actors snorting coke from prostitutes’ bodies, owning wealth on the order of 100-1000x what they make, they see people behave badly and so on. In fact many of the movies themselves promote this type of attitude. When have you seen a film expound decent morals? Very few of those. Maybe the society needs fixing in other ways. Most people believe in hook ups and free sex, contraception, abortion and euthanasia.
 
Yes, I saw that site previously, but wasn’t able to clearly follow the argument, if there was one. He seems to have something against CNET. I’m not sure. I still don’t see how any of that is a justification for theft by Internet.
 
Yes, I saw that site previously, but wasn’t able to clearly follow the argument, if there was one. He seems to have something against CNET. I’m not sure. I still don’t see how any of that is a justification for theft by Internet.
He’s saying (and he’s proving it) that CNET and affiliates, promoted piracy and promoted file sharing programs. One of the execs there was even a member of MPAA or RIAA.
Programs like Kazaa were not sued because they’re owned by the big boys yet they were sold for file sharing.

How is it justified? If major trusted companies promote something, you’re still asking how it’s justified? He’s a summary video: youtube.com/watch?v=WJIuYgIvKsc&NR=1&feature=endscreen
Please watch it and let me know what you think.

When you tell kids something is OK, they will believe you. I’m just trying you to see something bigger here. And of course your own link highlights some of it, but does not go far enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top