Spiritual Director

  • Thread starter Thread starter Carmelite1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
An alternative that I saw in Dan Burke’s book Navigating the Interior Life is that some lay organizations have spiritual direction as a component of belonging to that group. In my case I belong to the Legion of Mary and we have a Spiritual Director and weekly spiritual direction as a group is part of our meetings. He is also my regular confessor so I feel I have been able to patch together a system of spiritual direction that fits with my busy lifestyle. I am a convert so I tend to use the Sacrament of Reconciliation for spiritual direction in that I confess whatever the Lord has “put on my heart” in my old evangelical parlance to stay accountable and to reverse my venial sins which if not kept up with could lead me to trouble. I believe with all my heart what is in the Diary of St. Faustina that it is the Lord Himself who I am confessing to and I always come out better for having gone in even though my cradle Catholic husband thinks I am not quite getting the sacrament:) I have not tried to pursue individual direction yet as my life is busy but using Dan Burke’s book and other spiritual classics as guides (love Intro to the Devout Life) I have developed a plan of life which includes daily Mass if I can get there, Morning Prayer and Bible Study typically using the Magnificat and daily Mass Readings as well as a Morning Offering Prayer and 33 days to Morning Glory short version consecration prayer to Jesus through Mary, Rosary usually when I am walking for exercise following Mass, Divine Mercy Chaplet at 3 PM if work allows which gives me a good chance to review the day so far, Legion of Mary Prayers in the evening and Night Prayer using Magnificat with Examination of Conscience and some spiritual classic or scripture study to fall asleep to:) Most of my resources are on my iphone or ipad so sometimes I am reading and praying as I go with work travel or busy schedule but it keeps me connected to the Vine.

Blessings,

Val
 
Priests are paid a salary. I don’t know where you get that you’d have to pay a priest for spiritual direction. Ask your pastor if you can schedule a meeting once a month or so for spiritual direction, tell him what kind of things you’d like to discuss. If he won’t be available to you, find another priest in another parish. It’s not all that complicated, really.

-ACEGC
My SD is a sister (nun) and has a sliding scale fee.
 
I would have thought you could get a type of spiritual.direction just by having a regular confessor - would that be the same thing?
Not really.

At least two things come to mind.

One is that going to confession has a purpose. You confess your sins and receive absolution. Spiritual direction has a different purpose: seeing the movement of the Holy Spirit in your life. Let’s say something has come up during your prayer. That would be appropriate to talk about with your spiritual director, but really has nothing to do with confessing your sins. If there’s no one waiting in line for confession, perhaps you can ask your prayer question, but your overall meeting isn’t going to focus on prayer.

The second thing is the length of time you meet. A typical meeting for spiritual direction lasts about an hour. There’s time set aside to fully discuss an issue. Confession is typically much shorter and there’s an awareness that other people are waiting so you can’t take up too much of the priest’s time.
 
I’d agree with that. Those seriously discerning a vocation do need specific directing, as though those already ordained.

The trouble with lay-people (who aren’t discerning a vocation) seeking a spiritual director is that it can be seen as some sort of ‘spiritual therapy’. I think it’s a product of a culture where people feel they need therapists, when what is going on in their lives (secularly and spiritually) is nothing more than the ordinary, ups and downs, troubles and woes, that have been going on in the lives of most people since man first walked on the earth. Talk to God, talk to your spouse, talk to your family, talk to your friends, talk to yourself, that’s what people have been doing for thousands of years.
I think you’re onto something. Our priest is especially weary of married women coming to him for spiritual direction because he’s a man who will listen. Often what happens to him is that married women are having issues, but rather than talk to their husbands, they come to him and dump all their problems (particularly marital issues pertaining to their husband) on him and don’t actually want help in their spiritual life, but rather want a man to listen to them.

When I read descriptions of spiritual direction that are online and then compare it to what my spiritual direction is like, they’re two completely different experiences. I read about spiritual journeys and spiritual direction being some type of journey and your SD helps you to see where God is working in your life. Something that sounds like fluffy clouds and warm fuzzies. Mine’s like a long term spiritual bootcamp with my SD director more like a drill sergeant trying to push my limits to their spiritual breaking point. Though, I think if people’s spiritual direction was more like mine, they wouldn’t all be wanting a spiritual director. Mine’s kinda scary.
 
If there is 1 priest to every 1000 Catholics then why do some lay people feel that their case is particularly special that they require a spiritual director, when this is clearly something that cannot be offered to all? It is a different case with regards to the clergy as they have specific, complex requirements that laity do not (thankfully) share.

We have the teachings of the Church, we have the Bible, and we have the Holy Spirit working in each of our lives. Surely the Holy Spirit is the best spiritual director of all (and you don’t even have to book an appointment)?
 
We have the teachings of the Church, we have the Bible, and we have the Holy Spirit working in each of our lives. Surely the Holy Spirit is the best spiritual director of all (and you don’t even have to book an appointment)?
From the Catholic Encyclopedia:
newadvent.org/cathen/05024a.htm
II. Still more frequently is spiritual direction required in the lives of Christians who aim at the attainment of perfection (see PERFECTION). All religious are obliged to do so by their profession; and many of the faithful, married and unmarried, who live amidst worldly cares aspire to such perfection as is attainable in their states of life. This striving after Christian perfection means the cultivation of certain virtues and watchfulness against faults and spiritual dangers. The knowledge of this constitutes the science of asceticism. The spiritual director must be well versed in this difficult science, as his advice is very necessary for such souls. For, as Cassian writes, “by no vice does the devil draw a monk headlong and bring him to death sooner than by persuading him to neglect the counsel of the Elders and trust to his own judgment and determination” (Conf. of Abbot Moses).
From an Eastern Christian perspective, where a Spiritual Director is known as a Spiritual Father:
One who climbs a mountain for the first time needs to follow a known route; and he needs to have with him, as companion and guide, someone who has been up before and is familiar with the way. To serve as such a companion and guide is precisely the role of the “Abba” or spiritual father—whom the Greeks call “Geron” and the Russians “Starets”, a title which in both languages means “old man” or “elder”. [1]
 
I’m going to re-post what I originally wrote about this.
Sure they would, just as I would do well to have my own personal trainer. That said, I don’t need a personal trainer to get in shape. Most Catholics don’t need a regular spiritual director. They would do good with making frequent use of the sacraments, especially frequent confession (ie: weekly), good spiritual reading from the saints (ie: intro to the devout life), a real commitment to avoid committing ALL sins, and taking their prayer life seriously with not just vocal prayer, but mental prayer as well, and maybe the odd (like once a year) meeting with their priest to make sure they’re on the right path.

While it would be nice for us to all have our own personal spiritual director, there just aren’t enough good ones to go around. Having a bad spiritual director is only going to make things worse.
 
If a person strives to be holy and grow in spiritually a spiritual director or advisor is needed. Sadly not every priest are trained in spiritual direction, though I understand that that might be changing. I have had three very good spiritual directors and that helped me a lot. Spiritual direction is not therapy, but a means in understanding how one can grow spiritually. I have had priest who I asked during confession advice in how to grow spiritually and most try to help. As for paying for spiritual direction it depends, which is to say lay people or nuns may or may not ask for a small sum, however, most priests do not ask for monies for doing what they as priests do as a matter of their calling. I am not opposed to paying a small sum of money to a priest if the request it ,especially if needed for the Church rather than for themselves.
 
If a person strives to be holy and grow in spiritually a spiritual director or advisor is needed. Sadly not every priest are trained in spiritual direction, though I understand that that might be changing. I have had three very good spiritual directors and that helped me a lot. Spiritual direction is not therapy, but a means in understanding how one can grow spiritually. I have had priest who I asked during confession advice in how to grow spiritually and most try to help. As for paying for spiritual direction it depends, which is to say lay people or nuns may or may not ask for a small sum, however, most priests do not ask for monies for doing what they as priests do as a matter of their calling. I am not opposed to paying a small sum of money to a priest if the request it ,especially if needed for the Church rather than for themselves.
Most people can do just fine without a spiritual director simply by reading good holy spiritual books, frequenting the sacraments, and seriously striving to root out sin and get their faculties in order. Once they get through that, a spiritual director is needed because people will start going through the dark night of the sense and will need someone who can see to guide them through the darkness. Until then, a spiritual director is more of a luxury.
 
I asked my fiancée’s parish Priest if I could seek a spiritual director before finishing RCIA. He said absolutely. I said, “But, Father, aren’t Priest really busy?” He said yes, but spiritual direction is part of our job. If every Catholic suddenly decided they needed a spiritual director, there would be a problem. But, given that very few are seeking directors, it seems to me that we should not be afraid to ask a priest.
 
You don’t have to be seeking a vocation to go for spiritual direction.

You can go if you feel that you need help with your spiritual life, in some way. It is open to anyone who is seeking help and guidance with their spiritual life. Again, that is the reason “why” I personally decided to go, at the times that I went.

Personally, I think perhaps that people might be confusing spiritual direction with personal counseling, if they are not familiar with it. It is not the same thing as personal counseling that you might also seek from your pastor.

Also, as I already mentioned, a spiritual director doesn’t have to be your pastor, although it can be. It can be a Nun, or as others have mentioned on other threads here on the forum, it can also be a Deacon or even a lay person.
 
Code:
				Originally Posted by **Deo Gratias42** 					[forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons_khaki/viewpost.gif](http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=10367373#post10367373) 				
			*Sure they would, just as I would do  well to have my own personal trainer. That said, I don't need a personal  trainer to get in shape. Most Catholics don't need a regular spiritual  director. They would do good with making frequent use of the sacraments,  especially frequent confession (ie: weekly),** good spiritual reading  from the saints (ie: intro to the devout life***), a real commitment to  avoid committing ALL sins, and taking their prayer life seriously with  not just vocal prayer, but mental prayer as well, and maybe the odd  (like once a year) meeting with their priest to make sure they're on the  right path.
While it would be nice for us to all have our own personal spiritual director, there just aren’t enough good ones to go around. Having a bad spiritual director is only going to make things worse.
It is good that you refer people to Introduction to the Devout Life. I refer you to the St. Francies de Sales’ own words in this classic:
WHEN Tobias was bidden to go to Rages, he was willing to obey his father, but he objected that he knew not the way;—to which Tobit answered, “Seek thee a man which may go with thee:" and even so, daughter, I say to you, If you would really tread the paths of the devout life, seek some holy man to guide and conduct you. This is the precept of precepts, says the devout Avila,—seek as you will you can never so surely discover God’s Will as through the channel of humble obedience so universally taught and practised by all the Saints of olden time.

I think that what you have recommended is true for all as a beginning step. We need to cultivate a strong prayer and sacramental life. But, say the saints, if we desire perfection (as we all should), we will need a spiritual guide to get us there. Studying the lives of the saints and emulating them is a beginning. I don’t think priests need worry about us taking up too much of their time. Most of us aren’t there yet. :)🙂 I would say, though, that a good regular confessor can serve in the role of spiritual director for many, if not most, people. So often I have read on these forums that confession is not spiritual direction, but there is much that overlaps between the two. The Vatican published an interesting document a couple of years ago, in order to guide priests in this area. It can be found here: clerus.org/clerus/dati/2011-08/08-13/sussidio_per_confessori_en.pdf
 
Most people can do just fine without a spiritual director simply by reading good holy spiritual books, frequenting the sacraments, and seriously striving to root out sin and get their faculties in order. Once they get through that, a spiritual director is needed because people will start going through the dark night of the sense and will need someone who can see to guide them through the darkness. Until then, a spiritual director is more of a luxury.
I do not know if people do just fine or not without a spiritual director. reading spiritual books are fine up to a point and the frequenting the Sacraments and striving to root out sin is always good. I think most do not really understand what a spiritual director is or does and many might be confused about and also many may not even know about spiritual direction, many may feel that they do not need one. Yet, there are always questions one has where spiritual direction would be of some small help in understanding where one is in their spiritual life. Not everyone goes through a dark night of the senses etc… some need encouragement, others need advice, and others need a pathway that leads to holiness and spiritual growth.
 
and others need a pathway that leads to holiness and spiritual growth.
That pathway will not come from a spiritual director (or any other person) that pathway will only come from the Holy Spirit. We won’t find a ‘shortcut’ to accessing that pathway by talking to another flawed, human, sinner. God has a pathway for us all; we need to stop and listen, and if we don’t hear we need to keep on stopping and listening.
 
That pathway will not come from a spiritual director (or any other person) that pathway will only come from the Holy Spirit. We won’t find a ‘shortcut’ to accessing that pathway by talking to another flawed, human, sinner. God has a pathway for us all; we need to stop and listen, and if we don’t hear we need to keep on stopping and listening.
Brendan 64: Are you that sure that the pathway I spoke of will not come from a spiritual director? It seems to me that you either have no faith in spiritual direction or that you do not believe one has any need of one. I do not know if you have ever tried spiritual direction or not but it appear that you have no use for it.
 
Brendan 64: Are you that sure that the pathway I spoke of will not come from a spiritual director?
I am sure that one’s spiritual direction will come from the Holy Spirit and not through a fellow, flawed, human sinner.
It seems to me that you either have no faith in spiritual direction or that you do not believe one has any need of one.
Those that are discerning the priesthood, or those that are ordained have more complex needs, and would benefit from having someone to talk things through with.
I do not know if you have ever tried spiritual direction or not but it appear that you have no use for it.
I have spiritual direction, and it is given to be by the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is my spiritual director, and is available 24 hours a day without the need to make an appointment. If you trust in the Holy Spirit and listen carefully, you do not need any human to direct you.
 
I am sure that one’s spiritual direction will come from the Holy Spirit and not through a fellow, flawed, human sinner.

Those that are discerning the priesthood, or those that are ordained have more complex needs, and would benefit from having someone to talk things through with.

I have spiritual direction, and it is given to be by the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is my spiritual director, and is available 24 hours a day without the need to make an appointment. If you trust in the Holy Spirit and listen carefully, you do not need any human to direct you.
I see that we see spiritual direction very differently from each other.
 
I see that we see spiritual direction very differently from each other.
Our spiritual direction comes from God. I just don’t see the need to have a human intermediary involved in the equation. All you need to do is stop and listen, it’s really not that complicated. You’re directed to do certain things and move your life in certain specific directions, but you’re not told why. You sometimes get a vague clue about why you are being asked to act or move your life in a particular direction, but it’s never clear. I have developed hugely in terms of my own spirituality through listening and following the directions I’m pointed in, most often without understanding why. To me that is spiritual direction.
 
Our spiritual direction comes from God. I just don’t see the need to have a human intermediary involved in the equation. All you need to do is stop and listen, it’s really not that complicated. You’re directed to do certain things and move your life in certain specific directions, but you’re not told why. You sometimes get a vague clue about why you are being asked to act or move your life in a particular direction, but it’s never clear. I have developed hugely in terms of my own spirituality through listening and following the directions I’m pointed in, most often without understanding why. To me that is spiritual direction.
And it’s great that it works that way FOR YOU. But not everyone can wear the same size shoe – and some DO need to speak to someone who has more experience in the spiritual life. You sound utterly certain that no priest, deacon, or sister could give you good counsel.

“Pride goeth before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall…” Proverbs 16:18
 
And it’s great that it works that way FOR YOU. But not everyone can wear the same size shoe – and some DO need to speak to someone who has more experience in the spiritual life. You sound utterly certain that no priest, deacon, or sister could give you good counsel.

“Pride goeth before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall…” Proverbs 16:18
I’m not being prideful, I’m simply saying how I see it.

Good counsel is very different from spiritual direction.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top