Spirituality of religious orders in Catholic tradition

  • Thread starter Thread starter Melchior_1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a seriously flawed quiz as the only options are the 6 you have listed.

😛 I am offended that Carmelite is not an option. 😛
Carmelites? I’ve heard of them, but where? :rotfl:

I disagree Brother. Look at my results.


  1. *]Franciscan
    *] Jesuit
    *] Missionaries of Charity
    *] Dominican
    *] Benedictine
    *] Opus Dei

    That was right on the money. If I were to rank these communities in order of attraction, that would be my list.

    Fraternally,

    Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
This is a seriously flawed quiz as the only options are the 6 you have listed.

😛 I am offended that Carmelite is not an option. 😛
I remember Fr. Jon-Benedict Weber O.Carm. comparing orders to trains, each one on the way to a common destination. He remarked on how small our train was compared to the Franciscans as an example. Maybe we are the “little engine that could!”
 
Carmelites? I’ve heard of them, but where? :rotfl:

I disagree Brother. Look at my results.


  1. *]Franciscan
    *] Jesuit
    *] Missionaries of Charity
    *] Dominican
    *] Benedictine
    *] Opus Dei

    That was right on the money. If I were to rank these communities in order of attraction, that would be my list.

    Fraternally,

    Br. JR, OSF 🙂

  1. I took the test before I realized that Carmelite was not an option.

    I tested out as Franciscan with Dominican as second. At least the first two are mendicants.
 
OK, so this is just awesome!

saltandlighttv.org/witness/vianney.php

I debated putting this in the Religious after Vatican II thread. There is some really interesting discussion on how religious life changed and the struggles their community went through afterwards but I decided that it best fit in this thread overall.

Enjoy,
 
Could somebody please post the link for the quiz again?
When I tried the linke given upthread, I ended up on a very confused and confusing page and could not find said quiz.
 
Carmelites? I’ve heard of them, but where? :rotfl:

I disagree Brother. Look at my results.


  1. *]Franciscan
    *] Jesuit
    *] Missionaries of Charity
    *] Dominican
    *] Benedictine
    *] Opus Dei

    That was right on the money. If I were to rank these communities in order of attraction, that would be my list.

    Fraternally,

    Br. JR, OSF 🙂

  1. My list was all over the place for some reason. My absolute top two Orders are Dominican and Franciscan, and yet Franciscan was second (If I remember correctly), and I never even got a score on the Dominicans. My number three was Opus Dei (Which I didn’t even know was an Order), and my number one was Jesuit, which, according to my unofficial Spiritual Adviser Father Pascal, would be my absolute nightmare. Sixteen years of college… It’s scary to just think about… 😃

    However, I agree with Brother David. It didn’t have many of the biggest Orders on there. I can’t remember any other than Carmelite since I’m tired and my brain isn’t working that well, but I do know that there are a few missing from that list. Some of which I would be appalled for if I was able to think. 😛
 
Dang it! I couldn’t get Dominican/Franciscan even when I purposefully chose all of the Dominican/Franciscan ones! This quiz is stupid. 😛
 
Here’s a Catholic Spirituality Selector quiz for fun. 😃

Here are my results.
Code:
           1. Benedictine   	
       2. Franciscan   	
           3.Missionaries of Charity   	
           4.Dominican   	
           5. Opus Dei   	
           6.Jesuit
Hi Gracesophia: here is the quote with the link; just click and go for it. Very interesting result for me: Benedictine came in first, Dominican second. For an Orthodox,the rule of St. Benedict fits right in with Orthodox spirituality, and most of our monks would feel right at home in a Benedictine life. Makes sense, as St.'s John Climacus and Pachomius brought the idea of a Rule of common life to the West from the East. God bless all.
 
Quiz:

Oops!! 😃 — I came out as -

Dominican
Jesuit
Missionaries of Charity
Benedictine
Franciscan
Opus Dei

I know this can’t be right!!! I’ve got some strange looks from Dominican Friars that I met at a small Franciscan chapel when I slipped off my sandals at the chapel’s door. :cool: (I do have great affection for them.)
 
Hi Gracesophia: here is the quote with the link; just click and go for it.
Thanks. For some reason, I ended up on a different page before. But it worked now… okay let’s see what I get …

1.Benedictine
2.Dominican
3.Franciscan
4.Jesuit
5. Missionaries of Charity
6. Opus Dei
 
Thanks. For some reason, I ended up on a different page before. But it worked now… okay let’s see what I get …

1.Benedictine
2.Dominican
3.Franciscan
4.Jesuit
5. Missionaries of Charity
6. Opus Dei
Don’t forget the sliders. I didn’t even see them the first time I tried this, and apparently they do make quite a bit of difference.
 
They and their two families have always constituted an incredible team. There is a third figure who is rarely mentioned, but who was also brought into the circle, because of his great love for Francis. That was St. John de Matha, the founder of the Order of the Most Holy Trinity (Trinitarian Brothers).

At the mother house of the Trinitarians there is a big stained glass window of St. John washing Francis’ feet. The Trinitarians refer to Francis as “The Holy Father”.

Dominicans and Franciscans call him and Dominic, Our Holy Fathers. The Trinitarians call Francis, The Holy Father. They do not refer to St. John as the father, but as the founder.

The 7 Holy Founders of the Servite Friars also refer to Francis as “Our Holy Father Francis.”

The Mendicant Orders are a strong part of the tradition of the Church. Together with the monastic orders, they have upheld Catholicism through it’s worse times.

They are:

Franciscans (Friars Minor, commonly known as the Grey Friars), founded 1209

Carmelites, (Brothers of the Blessed Virgin Mary of Carmel, commonly known as the White Friars), founded 1206–1214

Dominicans (Order of Preachers, commonly called the Black Friars), founded 1215

Servites (Order of Servants of Mary), founded 1233 by the Seven Holy Men of Florence, Italy.

Augustinians (Hermits of St. Augustine, commonly called the Austin Friars), founded 1244 - 1256

We have to clarify here that the Dominican Friars, even though they are referred to as the First Order of the Dominican family are not truly the first order. The nuns were founded first around 1206 - 1208. The friars were founded second around 1215 - 1216. The friars did not like being called the second order, because in the Franciscan and Benedictine traditions the second order was the order for women. The Dominicans changed it. They refer to the friars as the First Order.

It was kind of a silly thing of the later Middle Ages. Today, no one pays any attention to such things. Mother Teresa founded a congregation of women first, then a congregation of men. Big deal! As long as they got founded. I guess in those days, the whole male female thing was important.

My guess is that there was the whole issue of clericalism. The Dominicans are an order of priests. In those days, priests occuppied the place of honor in many religious houses. Even the Carmelites and Franciscans, who were not originally priests, fell into clericalism.

Franciscan historians always blame it on the laity. That’s a very interesting debate. Many laymen argue that it was not their fault. I often wonder, does it matter whose fault it was? What matters is that we recover the vision and traditions of these great movements.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF :christmastree1:
 
Brother, can you remind us again, which was the last order that was founded? The question popped up again somewhere about orders verses congregations and there was a disagreement about which was the last order founded.
 
Brother, can you remind us again, which was the last order that was founded? The question popped up again somewhere about orders verses congregations and there was a disagreement about which was the last order founded.
I know you asked Brother but I am about 99.9% sure it was the Society of Jesus.
 
I know you asked Brother but I am about 99.9% sure it was the Society of Jesus.
BINGO

GIVE THE MAN $200.00 😃

The Discalced Carmelites don’t count, because even though they’re younger than the Jesuits, they really began as a reform of the Carmelites. Later, they became a province and finally got their autonomy, as did the Capuchins and the Franciscans (OFM). These were all reforms of orders that existed.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF :christmastree1:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top