SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well…you believe you are anyway. 😃 😛
That’s just the thing Wind, we do believe we are, but not by our own authority. You believe you’re right, but who tells you you’re right? Just you? You can’t say the Bible does, b/c the Bible doesn’t TELL anyone anything, we READ the Bible. So is everyone who has their own interpretation right?
 
If it was so simple as to just read a book and the Holy Spirit would guide everybody to the truth, why didn’t Jesus just write the Bible Himself and tell His apostles to distribute them (ala JW with the Watchtower method) instead of telling them to go and “TEACH”?

And according to some beliefs, all that Jesus would have needed to write n His book was “Believe and you are saved.”

If just reading a book is so simple, why cant I buy a medical dictionary and go perform brain surgery. Will I be able to recognize a cancer sore from an infected pimple?

Our souls are more important wouldn’t you think?
 
I was out for a while and just came back and trying to catch up on this thread but something popped out - I dont remember if it was WG or G2 that
p.s. what you see as authority figures and what I see are two different things. Also the apostle Paul said to follow him AS HE FOLLOWED CHRIST. What if he ceased to follow Christ? Or began to teach heresy. We don’t follow authority blindly. They’re subject to the same Scriptures we are. They depart from them and the authority departs. That’s my belief, you don’t have to agree.
Hmm… What version of the KJV was St. Paul subject to? How does anybody know that they can tell that St. Paul departed from the scriptures and they themselves are correct?

Also
Code:
**Any of these supposed extra biblical teachings that supposedly are from the apostles must agree with the Bible or they didn't come from the apostles.** And we know that Catholics and non Catholics will not agree on whether or not something is compatible with the Bible.
Code:
This statement is bassackwards,  The Teachings of the CC came before the Bible.  Do a little research as to when the first bible was canonized.  What bible were the apostles subject to?
Correction, Catoliolics agree that the Bible is compatible with the teachings of the Church.
 
Yes and no. I used to think that, but I read a book by Dubay about choosing a spiritual director, and he said that Confession should be brief. The penitent should go through their sins without a lot of detail except for mortal sins, when the Confessor asks for the details. (For example: "I took the Lord’s name in vain inadvertantly, I gossiped, I was angry with my spouse, etc…) Similarly, the Confessor should give brief instruction for mortal sins. The rest is proper to spiritual direction, not Confession.

Which is better? Really “good” Confession for 10 people and 10 turned away, unable to receive absolution for their sins (perhaps a couple of them in serious moral sin)? Or, efficiently done Confession for 20 people, placing them all in a state of grace?
My confession was brief, but who knows maybe some of the others were asking questions of the priests about their sins etc. The priest did not ask me to go into detail about my sins. You Know people are impatient, & we all have to wait our turn, I see this behavior in a lot of other realms.
 
I read the Bible. It’s the only infallible history book there is.
Book Chapter and verse please that says “This is the bible and it is infallible”
How does anybody know the Bible is infallible (which it is not- its innerant)simply by reading it? And if its innerant, where does it say that in the Bible?
 
Randy Carson
Code:
 FWIW, I did print out and read the article which attempted to offer explanations as to why Christians have so many different interpretations of scripture. To summarize, the excuses...er, reasons, offered are:
  1. Unbelief
  2. Lack of training
  3. Poor hermeneutics
  4. Ignorance of the whole word of God
  5. Selfishness and pride
  6. Failure to mature
  7. Undue emphasis on tradition
Code:
 This is,,,,,, how would you put it,,,,, funny in a sense.  Who is to say which of the thousands of denominations fall into any of these categories? And how does this dude know he isn’t a #3, 4, or 5.  Who can accuse who of # 1, or # 2, or # 3, etc. etc.?  Can a Baptist tell a Methodist they are #4, and can a Methodist tell a Presbyterian they are a #6, etc.?
Good post Randy.
 
My confession was brief, but who knows maybe some of the others were asking questions of the priests about their sins etc. The priest did not ask me to go into detail about my sins. You Know people are impatient, & we all have to wait our turn, I see this behavior in a lot of other realms.
I agree…patience is a virtue. 👍 But, thinking of others when we are in Confession (i.e. keeping it brief) is also a virtue. I waited an hour and 15 minutes one time, only to be turned away. Last time I almost didn’t make it because of a short Confession time, and the woman in front of me said “well, if I can’t make it, I’ll come back for the later session.” I explained to her that it wasn’t an option for me, and I wouldn’t be able to receive the Eucharist the next day. She was very nice and let me go.

I have noticed that our new pastor is very long in the Confessional. The reaction from many has been “oh he is so wonderful because he takes his time with us,” but others who have been turned away one too many times are going elsewhere for Confession. I am fortunate that one of the key areas I travel to for business on a regular basis has Confession before every Mass (3x per day during the week). I usually take care of Confession on those trips, rather than wait for the possibility of maybe getting into Confession at home. For my kids, I take them to a neighboring parish, so they don’t have to wait an hour. It’s difficult enough to get kids to Confession…let alone taking them only to be turned away.
 
I agree…patience is a virtue. 👍 But, thinking of others when we are in Confession (i.e. keeping it brief) is also a virtue. I waited an hour and 15 minutes one time, only to be turned away. Last time I almost didn’t make it because of a short Confession time, and the woman in front of me said “well, if I can’t make it, I’ll come back for the later session.” I explained to her that it wasn’t an option for me, and I wouldn’t be able to receive the Eucharist the next day. She was very nice and let me go.

I have noticed that our new pastor is very long in the Confessional. The reaction from many has been “oh he is so wonderful because he takes his time with us,” but others who have been turned away one too many times are going elsewhere for Confession. I am fortunate that one of the key areas I travel to for business on a regular basis has Confession before every Mass (3x per day during the week). I usually take care of Confession on those trips, rather than wait for the possibility of maybe getting into Confession at home. For my kids, I take them to a neighboring parish, so they don’t have to wait an hour. It’s difficult enough to get kids to Confession…let alone taking them only to be turned away.
I have never in My life been turned away from confession by a priest, I personally think that if a priest would turn someone away, especially from confession, I wouldnt think much of him as a priest
 
I have never in My life been turned away from confession by a priest, I personally think that if a priest would turn someone away, especially from confession, I wouldnt think much of him as a priest
Sorry if I wasn’t clear. It was not a personal thing…it’s a time thing. If you only have one priest and the Confession time is 3:30PM - 4:30PM with Mass at 5PM, then people will be turned away when they run out of time. You can arrange a special time, of course, but most people prefer “anonymous” private Confession.

If you are only confessing venial sins, it isn’t as big a problem because you can come next time. If you are confessing a mortal sin, it is an issue since you need to receive absolution to be in a state of grace, in order to receive. And, as I said, getting your kids to wait an hour and possibly not get into the confessional just makes getting them to Confession that much harder the next time.
 
Sorry if I wasn’t clear. It was not a personal thing…it’s a time thing. If you only have one priest and the Confession time is 3:30PM - 4:30PM with Mass at 5PM, then people will be turned away when they run out of time. You can arrange a special time, of course, but most people prefer “anonymous” private Confession.

If you are only confessing venial sins, it isn’t as big a problem because you can come next time. If you are confessing a mortal sin, it is an issue since you need to receive absolution to be in a state of grace, in order to receive. And, as I said, getting your kids to wait an hour and possibly not get into the confessional just makes getting them to Confession that much harder the next time.
One time, just before mass was going to be starting, I ran to the sacristy & asked father if He could hear my confession, else like, You I wouldnt be able to receive the Eucharist if in mortal sin, well he locked the door with all the chaos going on choir members trying to get in, etc, but he heard my confession, I was very thankful, never did that again tho cause of the chaos it caused
 
As far as been turned away at the confessional it depends on the circumstances. As was stated short on time and Mass is about to begin. But lets say for example if somebody goes to confess that he is living with his girlfriend and having sexual relations. The priest of course is going to tell him that he has to move out. If the guy says he does not want to and wants to keep living in that state because he “feels” its OK and he loves her and does not think its wrong to express his love to her and is not repentant, then the priest will refuse to give him absolution because the guy has just revealed what is in his heart so the priest knows he has no intent of repenting and stop living in sin. The priest has no choice but to retain that sin.

If a non-catholic is in that same situation and goes and speaks only to God and “feels” God has forgiven because its OK to express his love to his girlfriend is he forgiven even though he knows its wrong?

Big difference I would say…
 
As far as been turned away at the confessional it depends on the circumstances. As was stated short on time and Mass is about to begin. But lets say for example if somebody goes to confess that he is living with his girlfriend and having sexual relations. The priest of course is going to tell him that he has to move out. If the guy says he does not want to and wants to keep living in that state because he “feels” its OK and he loves her and does not think its wrong to express his love to her and is not repentant, then the priest will refuse to give him absolution because the guy has just revealed what is in his heart so the priest knows he has no intent of repenting and stop living in sin. The priest has no choice but to retain that sin.

If a non-catholic is in that same situation and goes and speaks only to God and “feels” God has forgiven because its OK to express his love to his girlfriend is he forgiven even though he knows its wrong?

Big difference I would say…
I think so, we cant all be catholic, & God alone knows our hearts
 
** You won’t agree with me.** The veil was to hide or block he way into the holy of holies in the temple. Where the ark and mercy seat was.
Its not a matter of agreeing with you. Error, needs some measure of truth to be believeable. Yo’ve posted half. Don’t forget that as "the veil of the temple was rent " the "the earth quaked, and “the rocks were rent.” Do these other mini-events have signifance as well?
The priest only went in once a year I believe. **We now have no need of any human priest going into the temple and continuing to offer animal sacrfices **
Nor do you see Catholic priests, offering animal sacrifices today. lol. Not sure what your point is
because we now have a permanent, eternal high Priest that ever lives to make intercession for us before the Father. I have direct access to the Father any time, any where becaues of Christ.
You only post this because it makes you feel better as a protestant, but its only half of the truth, as i said above
That Christ is ever presented as the Lamb in from of the Father, does not negate the individual priesthood.
If individual priesthood is not longer need, then you might as well accuse Christ of making a superflous statement(after the resurrection), when he said:
“Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained”

You’ve so far created for yourself a temporary magisterium to tell you what think on this matter, even though the Bible that you claim to hold to, is telling you otherwise.
 
I have never in My life been turned away from confession by a priest, I personally think that if a priest would turn someone away, especially from confession, I wouldnt think much of him as a priest
I have never been turned away or known anyone turned away, but I do know of a woman who was refused absolution, because the priest did not think she was contrite enough (her words, don’t know his…wasn’t allowed in the confessional).
 
In the first link it jumped out at me when it said priests reconcile people to God. I disagree. Christ reconciles people to God. You believe He does it through Catholic priests, obviously, and non Catholics do not.
JL: 2Cor5:18 All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ **and gave us **the ministry of reconciliation:
 
I have never been turned away or known anyone turned away, but I do know of a woman who was refused absolution, because the priest did not think she was contrite enough (her words, don’t know his…wasn’t allowed in the confessional).
well, a priest can absolve your sins thru Christ or he can retain them acording to what the circumstances are. When U go to confesion, You are supposed to have a firm purpose of ammendment, it doesnt mean U wont sin again, but at the time of confession the firm purpose was there. Maybe she didnt have it. Also, some sins I think, according to the gravity of them may have to go to the Bishop, dont quote me on that one tho
 
Yipee! Went to confession finally. That was probably the first time in - wow, I don’t know how long - maybe years… - that I’ve been away from my family for just a few hours. I had to go out of town. Our parish priest only does confessions for 1/2 an hour and there is never enough time for everyone - so I went to a nearby shrine for Our Lady of LaSalette. I never realized how little time I have had for just me and the Lord. I know I meet Him in my family and others presented to me in my daily life, but there is something special about dedicating solitude to Him. I can’t believe I used to do this every day (not confession, but time alone at church). No wonder my faith has gotten so messed up these past few years… I went to Mass afterwards and received communion. It was our parish’s feast day (vigil) - The Holy Family.

Confession was very quick - not b/c I didn’t have enough to say :rolleyes: , but b/c the priest only seemed interested in hearing my introduction (about questioning the faith, etc…). He didn’t give me a chance to give my “laundry list” of sins (some of which I really should have told him) b/c he immediately gave me a penance and absolved me. I didn’t have a chance to interrupt nicely. Guess I’ll save the list for next time. Not going to get scrupulous about it. Maybe this was God’s way of making sure I’d take the time again real soon 😉

Peace~
 
Yipee! Went to confession finally. That was probably the first time in - wow, I don’t know how long - maybe years… - that I’ve been away from my family for just a few hours. I had to go out of town. Our parish priest only does confessions for 1/2 an hour and there is never enough time for everyone - so I went to a nearby shrine for Our Lady of LaSalette. I never realized how little time I have had for just me and the Lord. I know I meet Him in my family and others presented to me in my daily life, but there is something special about dedicating solitude to Him. I can’t believe I used to do this every day (not confession, but time alone at church). No wonder my faith has gotten so messed up these past few years… I went to Mass afterwards and received communion. It was our parish’s feast day (vigil) - The Holy Family.

Confession was very quick - not b/c I didn’t have enough to say :rolleyes: , but b/c the priest only seemed interested in hearing my introduction (about questioning the faith, etc…). He didn’t give me a chance to give my “laundry list” of sins (some of which I really should have told him) b/c he immediately gave me a penance and absolved me. I didn’t have a chance to interrupt nicely. Guess I’ll save the list for next time. Not going to get scrupulous about it. Maybe this was God’s way of making sure I’d take the time again real soon 😉

Peace~
Glad to hear! 👍
 
i agree we are to confess our sins to one another - it says so in the Bible.
Good so far…
What I disagree with is a priest being able to forgive sins as God does. It contradicts Scriptures, therefore, your interpretation is wrong.
In your not so objective opinion perhaps, however, you seem to be trying to ignore that your opinion disagrees with the Word of God and that you offer no scriptural alternative to my point that if Our Lord did not intend that that apostolic authority to be passed down to the presbyters/elders/priests of the church then what else does it mean?

If you disagree as you say you do, then provide a scripturally sound and viable meaning for John 20:21-23, or else admit that you just don’t like it because it’s too Catholic and you are unwilling to obey the Word of God anywhere where it teaches something that has been Catholic teaching and practice for 2,000 years.
 
Good so far…In your not so objective opinion perhaps, however, you seem to be trying to ignore that your opinion disagrees with the Word of God and that you offer no scriptural alternative to my point that if Our Lord did not intend that that apostolic authority to be passed down to the presbyters/elders/priests of the church then what else does it mean?

If you disagree as you say you do, then provide a scripturally sound and viable meaning for John 20:21-23, or else admit that you just don’t like it because it’s too Catholic and you are unwilling to obey the Word of God anywhere where it teaches something that has been Catholic teaching and practice for 2,000 years.
This is a point always bring up in conversations with my non-Catholic friends. It would be illogical for Jesus to give the power of binding and loosing to the Apostles with no plan to pass that authority down.

If Jesus’ intended message was to confess directly to God without a priest, then he would have sent the Apostles out to teach people to confess directly to God…not bind and loose. 🤷

The only argument from Scripture I’ve ever been given is 1 John 1:9, but all it says is “He will forgive our sins” if we confess. It doesn’t preclude confession through a priest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top